arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Kate Greasley

15 papers · 2010–2026

2010: 12011: 02012: 02013: 02014: 02015: 12016: 02017: 42018: 02019: 02020: 22021: 22022: 02023: 22024: 12025: 12026: 1
2010peak 4 in 20172026

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–15 of 15 RSS

Sex, Reasons, Pro Tanto Wronging, and the Structure of Rape Liability

Kate Greasley

Law · Criminal Law and Philosophy · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Some recent scholarship in the philosophy of criminal law has claimed that sexual penetration ‘per se’—meaning, consensual or otherwise—is pro tanto morally wrong, or that there exist ‘general reasons’ against it. On such a view, penetrative sex is only ever at best justified wrongdoing. When paired with an influential view about the theoretical basis of the offence-defence distinction in criminal law, the apparent implication is that sexual penetration alone ought to constitute the actus reus of rape, with the question of consent relegated to a defence matter. This article firstly sets out some of the difficult upshots of considering all sexual penetration to be pro tanto wrong, particularly when one attends to the full moral entailments of justified wrongdoing. Assuming, arguendo, that sexual penetration is pro tanto wrong, it is also far from clear, I suggest, that consent…

R(Purdy) v DPP and the Case for Wilful Blindness

Kate Greasley

Law · Oxford Journal of Legal Studies · · cited 8× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Journal Article R(Purdy) v DPP and the Case for Wilful Blindness Get access Kate Greasley Kate Greasley **New College, Oxford. E-mail: kate.greasley@law.ox.ac.uk. Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic Google Scholar Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, Volume 30, Issue 2, Summer 2010, Pages 301–326, https://doi.org/10.1093/ojls/gqq010 Published: 15 March 2010

Is Sex-Selective Abortion against the Law?

Kate Greasley

Gender Studies · Oxford Journal of Legal Studies · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The article addresses the legal status of ‘sex-selective’ abortion in British law. It argues, firstly, that abortions for which knowledge of fetal sex is a ‘but-for’ cause <it>can</it> be lawful under the terms of the Abortion Act 1967, so long as one of the physical or mental health grounds in section 1 of the Act is attested to in good faith by two medical professionals. The failure of governmental and health bodies to correctly state the law pertaining to sex-selective abortion in recent years owes in part to the failure to distinguish the legal <it>grounds</it> for abortion from the factual <it>explanations</it> for abortion, a distinction which, I argue, is essential for understanding the structure of Britain’s abortion law. The article also considers the claim that abortions carried out partly for reasons of fetal sex are unlawful, or, if not…

Rape Trauma and Rape’s Wrongness

Kate Greasley

Gender Studies · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract In a widely discussed article co-authored with Stephen Shute, John Gardner offered a persuasive argument to the effect that the core wrongness of rape is not, as it seems, a function of the harmfulness of rape, but of something else: the rapist’s sheer sexual use of the victim, which is potentially harmless. In subsequent writing, partly in response to criticisms, Gardner sought to restate and clarify his view about the role of rape trauma in rape’s wrongness. A guiding thought in both his earlier and his later work is that the reasonableness of distress and anguish as a response to rape suggests that those reactions respond to and evaluate a prior, harm-independent wrong, thus revealed as the more basic wrong of rape. More strongly, he argued, we must agree that rape trauma is only epiphenomenal to, or derivative of, rape’s basic wrongness, if we are to affirm the rationality…

Review of David Boonin, Beyond Roe: Why Abortion Should be Legal Even if the Fetus is a Person (Oxford University Press, 2019)

Kate Greasley

Sociology and Political Science · Criminal Law and Philosophy · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Should abortion be legal even if the human fetus is a person? "Person" is intended here in its philosophical sense, to mean a being possessed of equal moral standing and rights as you and me. Most importantly of all, a person is a being with the fundamental right to life. The question about what follows morally and legally when fetal personhood is presumed has occupied a sizeable part of abortion ethics for some time. Far and away the most influential reflection on that question was the philosopher Judith Thomson's "violinist analogy argument" in defence of abortion rights. 1 There, Thomson argued that abortion is morally defensible even if it is true that the fetus is a rights-holding person. Her argument rested on a view of pregnancy as supererogatory, and, conversely, of abortion as the mere refusal to be a good Samaritan. Though it might be laudable to do so, no one is morally…

Mistaken Consent and Socially Reasonable Beliefs

Kate Greasley

Gender Studies · Law and Philosophy · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article examines the philosophical underpinnings of reasonable belief about consent to sexual activity, in the context of rape liability. I argue that scholars are correct to underscore the centrality of social conventions around consent in every assessment of reasonable belief. Despite this, I argue that what makes for a reasonable belief by A that B consents to sexual activity is not merely determined by social conventions. Against one intuitive view about how social consent norms interact with reasonable belief, I argue that the fault element in rape can be present where one person’s belief that another person consents to sex is predicated on, and in line with, prevailing social codes. Consequently, the reasonable belief standard is not socially relative all the way down. A long-standing debate about hypothetical social consent conventions involving ‘token refusal’ is…

Using Law to Improve Sexual Morality

Kate Greasley

Gender Studies · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Leslie Green has argued that law can be an efficacious and warranted means of improving social morality, bringing it better into line with critical (ie ideal or correct) morality. Social sexual morality is a key site, Green says, where the law can effect positive change. This chapter further takes up the question of when and how the law can legitimately use its power to improve social sexual morality. After specifying some candidates for improvement by law, the chapter contemplate one putatively distinct reason for the law to prescind from interfering with sexual morality beyond strict limits, that having to do with the importance of authenticity and self-expression to the value of sexual intimacy. I argue that law is nonetheless justified in using its power to change sexual mores for the better, and that law’s interference might not impede, and can even enhance, sexual freedom…

Pornography and the Limits of Speech Act Analysis

Kate Greasley

Law · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Some feminist philosophers have argued that harmful pornography is not mere speech, but that, in the right conditions, it could constitute the speech act of subordinating women. This chapter considers the ramifications of this speech act analysis for the argument over pornography’s legal protection as free speech. It asks what normative and political importance attaches to the prospect that some pornography is a harmful speech act, and not just speech with harmful consequences. It explores the possibility that pornography’s speech act analysis might itself accede to, or further entrench, the double standard under which pornography, but not some other harmful speech, is legally assimilated with its expressive content. It argues, ultimately, that the speech act analysis can bolster the feminist critique of pornography’s protection, in legal and political terms, by placing the…

Conclusion to 'Persons, Parts and Property'

Imogen Goold, Kate Greasley, Jonathan Herring +1 more

Law · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In this concluding chapter we will not seek to summarise all the points made throughout the volume. Rather we bring out from these discussions some practical proposals for how the law might move forward. Three models for reform will be outlined: – The law should recognise that human bodily material is subject to the laws of property that apply to other ‘things’. The tissue could then be owned, sold, stolen, commercially exploited, given away, and so on and these dealings would be governed by the developed principles of property, tort, criminal and other areas of law relevant to property. We shall call this the ‘property model’. – Parliament should pass a statute governing the storage, use and control of bodily material, reflecting a balance between individual and communal interests in different contexts. We shall call this the ‘statutory model’. – The courts should develop an…

Silencing Without Uptake

Kate Greasley

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In the argument over pornography’s censorship, feminist theorists of certain stripes have argued that one of the ways pornography might harm women is by silencing them. First suggested by Catharine MacKinnon, the silencing claim has since been considerably developed, most notably by Rae Langton and Jennifer Hornsby. Taking their cue from J.L. Austin’s speech act theory, these scholars have argued that pornography is capable, in principle, of silencing women in the ‘illocutionary’ sense, that is, by robbing them of a speech act power — as a case in point, the power of sexual refusal. Langton refers to this as the silencing of ‘illocutionary disablement’. The illocutionary disablement claim has met with plenty of resistance, especially concerning its reliance on an ‘uptake’ condition for illocutionary success, also attributed to Austin. Pursuant to this uptake condition, certain speech…

Gestation as Good Samaritanism

Kate Greasley

Sociology and Political Science · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter discusses the possibility that abortion is clearly permissible in almost all cases whether or not the fetus is a person, because abortion is not, in truth, an act of killing, but only the refusal by a pregnant woman to be a Good Samaritan. It presents and criticizes Judith Jarvis Thomson’s famous ‘violinist analogy’ argument in defence of the ‘Good Samaritan Thesis’ that continued pregnancy is a form of non-obligatory assistance to another, if the fetus is a person. Against this thesis, I argue that the problem of abortion, if fetal personhood is presumed, is not a question of positive duties to rescue others, but of the negative duty to refrain from killing them. Given that this is the case, the Good Samaritan Thesis fails.

Human Equality and the Significance of Birth

Kate Greasley

Political Science and International Relations · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter addresses two prominent issues in the abortion ethics literature: the human equality problem and the difference between abortion and infanticide. The human equality problem asserts that any theoretical account which takes personhood status to supervene on developmentally acquired attributes, such as self-consciousness or rationality, is inconsistent with a commitment to basic human equality, since those same attributes are possessed in greater and lesser degrees by human beings post-birth. The argument defends a ‘range property’ analysis of personhood, according to which personhood status, is equally possessed by all human beings past a certain minimum threshold. It suggests, moreover, that there are good reasons for the law to set that minimum threshold at live birth. However, it does call into question the conventional philosophical view that there is no morally…

Analogical Arguments and Sex Equality

Kate Greasley

Political Science and International Relations · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter analyses the view that considerations of sex equality relegate the personhood question to irrelevancy in the abortion debate. That is, sex equality is a sound basis for abortion rights whether or not the fetus is a person. It argues that the sex equality interest in reproductive control is not sufficient to justify abortion philosophically. Other things must also be true—namely, that the fetus is not a person, certainly not in the fullest sense. If the interest in sex equality justifies abortion rights, this can only be because the fetus is something less than a person, since the furtherance of sex equality is not a justification for homicide.

Dualism, Substantial Identity, and the Precautionary Principle

Kate Greasley

Sociology and Political Science · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter considers and rejects some further arguments for embracing the punctualist thesis and for the view that complete persons have come into being by the completion of conception. These arguments include ones that derive from the concept of dualism, which is the belief that personhood consists in something supernatural (in the literal sense of being beyond and outside of physical events); the substantial identity argument, which is in large part an argument about the possibility of substantial change: the possibility that an object or an individual can change in respect of a substantial—meaning, an essential—characteristic, and still remain the same basic thing; and the precautionary principle of assuming personhood at conception.