arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Adam Perry

46 papers · 2007–2026

2007: 12008: 02009: 12010: 02011: 12012: 32013: 12014: 32015: 02016: 12017: 32018: 32019: 32020: 22021: 12022: 12023: 62024: 02025: 102026: 6
2007peak 10 in 20252026

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 46 RSS

Mercy and caprice under the Indian constitution

Adam Perry

Law · Indian Law Review · · cited 20× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Indian Constitution gives the executive the power to pardon offenders. The Supreme Court of India has repeatedly held that the executive must not grant or refuse pardons capriciously or arbitrarily. I raise two worries about this line of authority. The executive has its pardon powers in part so that it can show mercy. In one sense, mercy is about doing justice despite what the law requires. Were mercy in this sense shown consistently, it would imperil the rule of law. Caprice is the price of containing that threat. In another sense, mercy is about showing compassion despite what justice requires. Mercy in this sense is an act of grace, and caprice is the price of it being possible at all. By seeking to eliminate caprice, the Court has risked undermining the rule of law, and frustrating one of the aims of the Constitution.

THE COHERENCE OF THE DOCTRINE OF LEGITIMATE EXPECTATIONS

Farrah Ahmed, Adam Perry

Law · The Cambridge Law Journal · · cited 19× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The doctrine of legitimate expectations is a developing area of administrative law, and many issues remain outstanding. Promises, practices, and policies generate legitimate expectations, but what is special about them? Why do they and only they generate legitimate expectations? The lack of an obvious answer has led some commentators to claim that the doctrine is ultimately incoherent and should be disaggregated. In this paper, we challenge this claim by arguing, first, that promises, practices, and policies each comprise or make applicable a certain type of rule, and second, that having a legitimate expectation is a matter of such a rule binding a public body to act in some way. This rule-based account gives the doctrine of legitimate expectations both coherence and distinctiveness.

Judging constitutional conventions

Farrah Ahmed, Richard Albert, Adam Perry

Law · International Journal of Constitutional Law · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The study of constitutional conventions is anchored in three assumptions that have so far remained largely unchallenged: that there is a shared “Commonwealth approach” to constitutional conventions; that Commonwealth courts will recognize and employ conventions but never enforce them; and that conventions are always distinguishable from rules of law. After setting out a new taxonomy of modes of judicial engagement with constitutional conventions, we overturn each of these assumptions. We draw on recent case law from Canada, India, and the United Kingdom to show that there is no shared “Commonwealth approach” to the treatment of constitutional conventions. We show that some Commonwealth courts do, in fact, enforce conventions. Finally, we show that at least some constitutional conventions have crystallized into law. These insights disrupt much of what is foundational in the…

THE QUASI-ENTRENCHMENT OF CONSTITUTIONAL STATUTES

Farrah Ahmed, Adam Perry

Law · The Cambridge Law Journal · · cited 15× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The British constitution is famously unentrenched: constitutional laws are not intrinsically more difficult to override than ordinary laws. However, in the largely overlooked 2012 case of H v Lord Advocate , the Supreme Court said that the Scotland Act 1998 cannot be impliedly repealed due to its “fundamental constitutional” status. Unless judicial thinking changes, courts in the future may treat constitutional statutes, like the Scotland Act, as capable only of express repeal, making such statutes “quasi-entrenched”. In this article, we argue that, as a judicial innovation, the quasi-entrenchment of constitutional statutes lacks a sound legal basis. Parliament can make its intention to repeal a constitutional statute clear without making it express, and judges cannot, on their own initiative, ignore Parliament's clear decision to repeal even a constitutional statute.

Constitutional Statutes

Farrah Ahmed, Adam Perry

Law · Oxford Journal of Legal Studies · · cited 13× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract In recent years, British courts have treated constitutional statutes differently from ordinary statutes. This article sets outs to explain: (i) how courts have treated constitutional statutes differently from ordinary statutes; (ii) what a constitutional statute is; and (iii) why constitutional statutes should be treated differently from ordinary statutes. Courts have made it harder for ordinary statutes to repeal constitutional statutes by implication, and easier for constitutional statutes to repeal ordinary statutes by implication. A constitutional statute is a statute which regulates state institutions, and which possesses importance of a particular type that we describe. The nature of a constitutional statute largely—but not entirely—justifies the special treatment they have been given. These conclusions have wider implications, including for proposals to codify the…

Measuring What Counts to Advance Indigenous Self-Determination: A Case Study of the Nisga’a Lisims Government’s Quality of Life Framework and Survey

Karen Bouchard, Adam Perry, Shannon West-Johnson +2 more

Health · International Journal of Community Well-Being · · cited 8× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Modern Treaties are presented as a means for improving the lives of First Nations, Inuit, and Métis peoples in Canada by providing specific rights, and negotiated benefits. However, the positive impacts of Modern Treaties on Indigenous well-being are contested (Borrows and Coyle 2017; Coulthard 2014; Guimond et al. 2013; Miller 2009; Poelzer and Coates 2015). Developing a more transparent, consistent, collaborative and contextual way of measuring well-being relevant to the cultural realities of Modern Treaty beneficiaries is an important step for generating comparative methods that could systematically demonstrate whether, and under what conditions, such agreements can effectively reduce socio-economic disparities and improve the quality of life of Indigenous communities. The authors first examine previous attempts at measuring Indigenous well-being, then reflect on well-being in…

Ethnographic insights on rural sustainability; homestead design and permaculture of Eastern Cape settlements in South Africa

Adam Perry

Sociology and Political Science · Africanus Journal of Development Studies · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article considers the prevalence of sustained agricultural practices (particularly large scale gardens of the homestead) and questions current public debate that permaculture strategy is foreign to South Africa. The paper speaks on recent ethnographic work by the author in rural parts of the Eastern Cape, or the former Transkei. The article makes comparisons to some of the founding principles of permaculture theory and practice to suggest that current agricultural practices and homestead (umzi, plural imizi) settlement patterns follow closely to "permaculture ideals" in theory and practice. An argument is made that the rural Xhosa homestead has developed much more to the tune of achieving sustainability for its occupants, as many continue to build to accommodate subsistence agriculture. Natural resources of the area also continue to be utilized and collectively shared. Whilst, the…

THE FLEXIBILITY RULE IN ADMINISTRATIVE LAW

Adam Perry

Law · The Cambridge Law Journal · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Administrative officials are permitted to have policies as to the exercise of their discretionary powers, but those policies must be flexible, not rigid. The “flexibility rule”, as I call it here, is nearly a century old. Over time, it has become part of the furniture of judicial review: often used, rarely examined. That neglect has led to confusion, on display in recent cases. In this article I try to put the flexibility rule back on a sound footing. I argue, first, that the flexibility rule requires authorities to treat policies merely as rules of thumb. Second, the primary justification for the flexibility rule is neither legislative intent (as courts have said), nor the avoidance of error (as commentators tend to assume); it is the value of participation. Third, and as a result, the flexibility rule ought to apply to policies governing the use of prerogative and other…

Enforcing constitutional conventions

Farrah Ahmed, Richard Albert, Adam Perry

Law · International Journal of Constitutional Law · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract In an earlier article, we disproved the three claims central to the dominant view in the study of constitutional conventions: that there is a shared “Commonwealth approach” to constitutional conventions; that Commonwealth courts will recognize and employ conventions but never enforce them; and that conventions are sharply distinguishable from rules of law. We drew from Canada, India, and the United Kingdom to demonstrate that Commonwealth courts have recognized, employed, and indeed also enforced conventions. In this article, we turn from the descriptive to the normative, arguing, again in contrast with the dominant view, that Commonwealth courts sometimes should enforce conventions. We argue that courts should act as executors of the will and judgment of constitutional actors, and limit themselves to enforcing only power-shifting conventions: conventions which transfer power…

According to law

Adam Perry

Law · Analysis · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Legal discourse consists largely of legal claims. These are claims that there is a legal obligation, legal right, or other legal incident. What is the meaning of “legal obligation”, “legal right” and so on in legal claims? The standard view among philosophers of law is that “legal” indicates that, according to law, there is a moral obligation, moral right or other moral incident. Here I set out a new objection to the standard view. The objection is that the standard view is unable to account for the use of legal claims in some common forms of logically complex arguments.

Top‐Down Constitutional Conventions

Adam Perry, Adam Tucker

Law · Modern Law Review · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Many scholars think that all conventions of the constitution emerge from the bottom up, out of the practices of constitutional actors. Here we develop the first systematic account of conventions that are imposed from the top down, through prescriptions by constitutional actors. We show that ‘top‐down conventions’ (as we term them) can be created through the use of normative rule‐making powers; that powers of the right kind are sometimes conferred by ‘bottom‐up conventions’; that these powers are often exercised; and, as a result, that top‐down conventions are increasingly common. We show, too, that as the formal, systematic, and intentional products of a small number of constitutional actors, top‐down conventions are a potentially illegitimate form of constitutional regulation.

Precedent and Fairness

Adam Perry

Law · Legal Theory · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Courts in common law systems decide cases as they decided like cases in the past—even if they believe they decided those past cases wrongly. What, if anything, justifies this practice? I defend two main claims. The first is that fairness favors treating like cases alike if that means treating them correctly. The second is that, in general, a court is as likely to decide an instant case correctly as it was to decide a previous and like case correctly. Together, these claims tell us that departing from and following precedent are equally likely to yield a correct decision, whereas following precedent may also yield a fair decision. Adhering to precedent is the dominant alternative, as a result. Fairness therefore justifies the practice of precedent. While this conclusion is not original, my argument for it is.

Symposium on Containing Diversity: Canada and the Politics of Immigration in the 21st Century (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2023)

Yasmeen Abu‐Laban, Ethel Tungohan, Christina Gabriel +5 more

Political Science and International Relations · Canadian ethnic studies · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this Symposium, scholars across disciplines discuss the key themes of the volume and questions that arise from Containing Diversity: Canada and the Politics of Immigration in the 21st Century. The book's authors, Yasmeen Abu-Laban, Ethel Tungohan and Christina Gabriel document and analyze the shifts that marked Canadian immigration, citizenship and multiculturalism in the period 2001-2021. They argue that these policy changes can be understood through the dynamic of containing diversity–a process involving the racialization and control of specific groups, alongside contradictory impulses exhibited in all these policies between closure to threatening outsiders and openness to valued workers and citizens. This symposium further advances the discussion of shifts within immigration, citizenship and multiculturalism policy by featuring the responses of Alexandra Dobrowolsky, Shanti…

Sustainable and informal: A case study in the shadows of housing policy in Masiphumelele, Cape Town, South Africa

Adam Perry

Urban Studies · Indilinga African Journal of Indigenous Knowledge Systems · · cited 2× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

The article reflects on how South African housing policy explores alternatives in low-income housing through a pilot project carried out at Site Five or Masiphumelele, Cape Town. The potential of the project to speak of 'sustainable' solutions in housing may have been undermined in its goal to showcase an alternative in low-income housing because it pushed the envelope by building beyond building codes. By tracing the building process and the ethnographic fieldwork of the author, building practices reveal that in South Africa there are distinct categories between formal and informal ways to construct houses. During construction, the use of earth, a locally sourced material and typically a rural methodology, challenged regional building codes, but was viewed as acceptable by local residents, architects, engineers, and foreign volunteers who participated to build a more sustainable…

Law's Boundaries

Adam Perry

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

The norms of a legal system are relevant in deciding on what rights and duties people have within that system. But many norms which are not part of a legal system will also be relevant within it. These other norms may include the norms of foreign legal systems, games, clubs, contracts, grammar, arithmetic, unions, universities, and so on. What distinguishes norms which are part of a legal system (“local norms”) from norms merely relevant within it (“adopted norms”)? Where, in other words, are the law’s boundaries? There are three main answers in the literature. Matthew Kramer claims that adopted norms are under the control of non-local actors, whereas local norms are not. Scott Shapiro flips that idea on its head. Adopted norms are not created through the exercise of local powers, he says, whereas local norms are. Joseph Raz, meanwhile, distinguishes adopted and local norms based on the…

Expertise, Deference and Giving Reasons

Farrah Ahmed, Adam Perry

Law · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

There is a consensus among courts and commentators on the grounds for a duty to give reasons in administrative law. Traditionally, the duty has been justified as a way to promote good decision-making, show respect for the parties, and reveal potential grounds for a challenge to the decision. We argue that this traditional picture is incomplete, because it omits two important considerations that favour giving reasons. Giving reasons can provide evidence that a decision-maker is a relative expert, and thus provide evidence of a reason to defer to the decision-maker. Giving reasons can also indicate a decision-maker’s findings on specific issues, making it possible for an appellate or reviewing body to selectively defer to it. Together these points show that concerns of deference are relevant to when administrative decision-makers should give reasons.

JUDICIAL REVIEW AND CIVIL APPEALS: COMMON GROUNDS

Adam Perry

Law · The Cambridge Law Journal · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract A civil appeal from a judicial decision is different from a judicial review of an administrative decision. But how are they different, exactly? One common view is that the grounds of appeal are more extensive than the common law grounds of judicial review. Specifically, appeal concerns the merits of a decision whereas review concerns only its legality. I argue that this common view is false. All the grounds of appeal are, in fact, also grounds of review. The implication is that review concerns the merits of a decision at least as much as appeal does.

Abductive Principles of the British Constitution

Adam Perry

Law · Oxford Journal of Legal Studies · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article investigates how principles such as responsible government and democracy enter the British constitution. Principles do not enter the British constitution by being enacted in statute or laid down in judicial decisions. Nor do they become part of the constitution by being accepted and followed by constitutional actors. Instead, principles enter the constitution by figuring in the best explanation for constitutional rules and practices. So understood, British constitutional principles are stated in the conclusion of an abductive argument, also known as an inference to the best explanation. As well as correctly diagnosing which principles are part of the constitution, the abductive account can resolve several puzzles about constitutional principles, including why they resist deliberate change.

Learning to stay or learning to go? Lived citizenship learning and young adults’ mobility decisions in a peripheral region

J. Adam Perry

Sociology and Political Science · International Journal of Lifelong Education · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article examines how young adults’ geographic mobility decisions function as processes of lived citizenship learning in Atlantic Canada, a peripherally economic region with long histories of youth outmigration and demographic change. Drawing on survey data and qualitative interviews with domestic and international students in Nova Scotia, Canada, the analysis explores how caregiving obligations, peer networks, immigration uncertainty, and experiences of racism shape uneven opportunities for belonging beyond formal educational settings. To conceptualise these dynamics, the article develops the notion of lived citizenship learning: the informal, everyday processes through which young adults learn what it means to belong, to be excluded, and to navigate disjunctural moments of decision-making. Findings suggest that mobility decisions are inseparable from broader solidarities and…

Editorial

J. Adam Perry, Robin` Neustaeter, Myriam Zaidi

Education · Canadian Journal for the Study of Adult Education · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

As we share this Fall 2025 issue of the Canadian Journal for the Study of Adult Education, we find ourselves reflecting on the tensions, possibilities, and everyday practices that continue to define adult education in a moment marked by global displacement, ideological polarization, ecological urgency, and ongoing questions of social justice. As always, the journal’s vitality rests not only on scholarly contribution but also on collective commitments to care, reflexivity, and to the diverse learning worlds that adults inhabit. This issue showcases those commitments through research and reflection stretching across communities and sectors.

Judicial Review: Substance and Procedure

Adam Perry, Angelo Ryu

Law · Modern Law Review · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this article we distinguish two questions about judicial review. First, substance: what acts or decisions are properly subject to the grounds of review? Second, procedure: what acts or decisions are properly reviewable through the judicial review procedure? Then we settle both. Our answer to substance is that two principles determine the scope of the grounds of review, the first a principle of regularity, the second a principle of non‐arbitrariness. Our answer to procedure is that acts or decisions are amenable to judicial review when two conditions are met, the first that the grounds of review apply, the second that no alternative procedure adequately enforces those grounds.

Introduction

Adam Perry

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The conventional constitution helps to make the UK government more effective, accountable, and democratic. Despite its importance, the conventional constitution is not well understood, partly because it is neglected as a subject of study (section I). Section II sets out the main aims of the book: (1) to define a constitutional convention; (2) to determine the difference between conventions and laws; (3) to identify every convention, state each precisely, and arrange them in an orderly way; and (4) to resolve the major normative questions regarding conventions, including whether the constitution should include them. Section III outlines the main claims with respect to each aim. Section IV summarizes the other chapters, and Section V explains that the book presupposes a basic familiarity with the UK constitution.

Conventions of Good Government

Adam Perry

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The previous chapter distinguished justified from unjustified conventions. This chapter discusses conventions that are justified by their contribution to good government. Section I explains that conventions of good government either improve decision-making or facilitate coordination. Conventions that improve decision-making do so mainly by securing the independence of bodies like the Speaker (section II), managing the flow of information (sections III and V), and involving experts (section IV). The longest section in this chapter is section VI, which is about whether ministers are required to resign for misconduct. Based on a survey of resignations and non-resignations, set out in Appendix 2, it is concluded that there is no resignation convention. Section VII discusses conventions that help to coordinate activity within Parliament and within an administration.

Obedience

Adam Perry

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter addresses a set of issues about obedience to conventions. One issue is why officials so often obey conventions. Section II suggests a range of possible reasons, including habit, fear, strategic calculation, and moral conviction. Section III argues that officials have a moral duty to obey the constitution, including its conventions. That duty has two bases: consent and fair play. Section IV considers whether judges should enforce obedience to conventions. By enforcing conventions, judges might help officials comply with their moral duties. But, since we don’t know exactly why officials obey conventions, judicial intervention risks doing more harm than good.