arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Law

Pornography and the Limits of Speech Act Analysis

Kate Greasley

See on the map

Abstract

Abstract Some feminist philosophers have argued that harmful pornography is not mere speech, but that, in the right conditions, it could constitute the speech act of subordinating women. This chapter considers the ramifications of this speech act analysis for the argument over pornography’s legal protection as free speech. It asks what normative and political importance attaches to the prospect that some pornography is a harmful speech act, and not just speech with harmful consequences. It explores the possibility that pornography’s speech act analysis might itself accede to, or further entrench, the double standard under which pornography, but not some other harmful speech, is legally assimilated with its expressive content. It argues, ultimately, that the speech act analysis can bolster the feminist critique of pornography’s protection, in legal and political terms, by placing the double standard of that protection into sharper resolution.

More like this