Social Sciences · Law
Reorientation of the Indonesian Penal System Based on the Philosophy of Pancasila
Alda Dewi Alawiyah, Teddy Lesmana
See on the mapAbstract
The imposition of suffering or criminal sanctions has been a longstanding practice considered painful by any society.Given the facts of criminal law, society cannot function without the intervention of criminal law.Sentencing is not a pleasant experience for the convicted individual and incurs substantial costs, including court proceedings, prisons, parole, consultation centers, and fines.According to utilitarian theory, punishment is a necessary evil that can only be justified if it prevents greater harm than it inflicts on the perpetrator.The evolving sense of justice in sentencing has led to various sentencing objectives that have developed over time, moving towards a more rational approach.Starting with the theory of retribution, which aims to satisfy all parties, the concept of criminal law retaliation is primitive but continues to influence modern practices due to its deep-rooted nature.Unlike other branches of law, the objective here is seen as ancient, focusing on expiation or retribution.Criminal suffering is viewed as penance for the perpetrator's sins, restoring balance within the individual, and is considered a fundamental requirement of our moral nature.By the end of the eighteenth century, criminal law practice was still influenced by the idea of retribution, combined with the aim of deterrence.Since classical times, the purpose of punishment has been a subject of debate.Simons, following Immanuel Kant's perspective, posits that unlawful acts warrant retribution.Similarly, Hegel argues that breaking the law is an inhuman act that deserves punishment.