arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science

The Contraction of Crime in Hegel’s <i>Rechtsphilosophie</i>

Alan Brudner

See on the map

Abstract

Abstract This chapter presents Hegel’s account of crime and punishment as an uncompromising version of the kind of criminal law appropriate for autonomous agents. Specifically, it reads Hegel as purifying the category of crime of all reference to human threats and as purifying the idea of punishment of all reference to the management of such threats. The consequence of this refinement, the author argues, is both a radical contraction of crime as a legal category and a largely symbolic role for punishment. As the idea of crime acquires analytical precision, it recedes to a corner of wrongdoing much narrower than the one it occupies in Anglo-American law. Correspondingly, punishment assumes an expressive function far more modest than the militantly prophylactic one assigned to it by existing legal systems. The upshot is a categorical separation (contrasting with the contemporary conflation) of criminal justice and criminal policy, the former defining the bounds within which the latter may operate.

More like this