arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

The doctrine of the purpose of criminal punishment in modern European political and legal thought

V. Tymoshenko

· Uzhhorod National University Herald Series Law

See on the map

Abstract

The doctrines on the purpose of punishment in the political and legal thought of the New Age are considered. Attention is focused on the essence of punishment in the works of contemporary thinkers, its properties and the appropriateness of certain types of punishment.
 It is stated that the call for humane treatment of criminals and condemnation of cruel punishments was made in the early XVI century. In addition, the ideas of natural law doctrine influenced criminal law theories, including the theory of punishment. In modern times, the absolute and relative theory of punishment have gained popularity. In this regard, the views on the purpose of punishment are briefly characterized by the following scholars: I. Kant, G.W.F. Hegel, C. Lombroso, E. Ferry, R. Garofalo, I. Bentham, P.Y.A. Feuerbach, O.F. Kistyakivskii, J. Howard, I.Ya. Foynitsky and others. It is established that from the point of view of absolute theory, a criminal should be punished only because he committed a crime. In other words, the criminal should be punished for the triumph of the absolute idea. Any other purpose of punishment does not matter. It should be inevitable, fair, and commensurate with the crime. Representatives of relative theories of punishment found justification and purpose not in the punishment itself, but in the results that should be achieved by it. These results include intimidation, psychological coercion, correction, prevention of other crimes, and so on. Punishment is considered as a way to influence the consciousness of the offender. It should eliminate the criminal will of the offender. In addition, thinkers of the past considered punishment as a criminal form of resolving social contradictions, and antagonism between society and the state, between society and the individual.
 Today the socio-political situation indicates a growing need for criminal repression and requires careful theoretical understanding and legislative consolidation of the concept, nature of punishment, the system of punishment, as well as the development of principles and legal mechanism for sentencing and execution. In this regard, the experience of our predecessors on the general theoretical problems of punishment can be useful and instructive.

More like this