Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science
September 27, 1902. DR. CLIFFORD AND THE 'NO POPERY' CRY.
See on the mapAbstract
Sir, – Dr. Clifford, and most of those who have supported him, seem, as far as I can make out, to be under the impression that a statement is not theologically provocative so long as you make it from a civic motive. Surely the question of party tact and decency is not a question of motive, but a question of effect. Suppose, for instance, Mr. John Morley, 1 in the course of addressing a vast meeting of Liberals at a General Election, were to say that the chief enemy of citizenship was the belief in a God. Is it not quite obvious that Mr. Morley might go on saying till he dropped dead that he stood outside religions, and spoke only as a citizen? And his statement would still be religious, for the simple reason that it raised a religious problem and outraged religious sensibilities. The Catholic priesthood may be quite as invalid to Dr. Clifford as the Christian God is to Mr. Morley. But that is not the point. The point is that the Catholic priesthood is quite as valid to Canon McColl as the Christian God is to Dr. Clifford. And what is the real test in such a matter? Surely it is this, that though Mr. Morley might, in a sentence of political oratory, sweep away God, yet to answer him, to differ from that immense elimination, it would be necessary to go into huge questions of primal reason and intuition, into optimism and pessimism, into evolution and design. And so it is precisely with Dr. Clifford and his school. Because they can sweep away priests and churches and Catholic reunion in a purely political sentence, they seem to forget that in order that other Liberals who do not agree with them should answer their sentences they would have to go into huge questions of inspiration and sin, of the nature of the priesthood of Melchisedec 2 and the nature of the charge to Peter. 3 As it happens, I can give a rather amusing example of the fact from this correspondence. Mr. F. A. Channing, 4 in a very moderate letter, which I do not think for a moment he intended to be sectarian or dogmatic, says that we are not concerned with the historic claims of churches, but must take count of certain peculiar qualities in ‘the Roman Catholic and his Anglican imitator’. Mr. Channing, as I say, is rather a peace-maker than anything else. But is it possible that Mr. Channing does not know that in merely using the phrase ‘his Anglican imitator’ he is begging an enormous disputed question of a purely ecclesiastical kind? Is it possible that he does not know that the Anglo-Catholic asserts that he is not imitating anybody, but simply obeying the rubrics of his own Church? This is typical of the whole affair. It is easy enough, in an off-hand sentence or so, to bring in a vast and different question, or rather a vast and different science, like Church history. But if a man brings in a question, it should be thrashed out, and then it must become entirely technical. I can illustrate my whole meaning in a plain parallel. If Dr. Clifford said, even in a short sentence, that this Bill gave less public control than any educational scheme in Europe, it would be a political statement which might deserve exhaustive examination. No one would complain if you devoted two columns of your paper to a discussion of it, with any number of details from France and Sweden, from German kindergartens, and Russian villages. The whole would be political. But if you took Dr. Clifford's statement that the Anglican Ritualists ‘gyrate in Roman garments’, would you then be prepared to give two columns to the Rev. Percy Dearmer, 5 in order that he might have a chance of showing that the Anglican ecclesiastical colour-scheme has always been distinct from the Roman? But the latter is quite as fair comment on Dr. Clifford's remark on Roman garments as the former would be on his hypothetical remark on European education. Do my critics see that the whole point is that if you once let in theology, like any other elaborate science, you must let it in altogether. It is fair to leave it all