arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Julia Stapleton

125 papers · 1991–2024

1991: 11992: 01993: 01994: 81995: 11996: 01997: 01998: 01999: 32000: 12001: 12002: 12003: 02004: 22005: 02006: 22007: 22008: 12009: 12010: 12011: 12012: 02013: 02014: 22015: 02016: 12017: 12018: 02019: 12020: 02021: 12022: 12023: 02024: 92
1991peak 92 in 20242024

Papers

showing 1–25 of 125 RSS

British idealism and political theory

Julia Stapleton

Political Science and International Relations · History of European Ideas · · cited 115× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This stimulating and illuminating book is the product of long-standing collaboration between two prominent interpreters of philosophical Idealism in Britain. It marks the launch of the new Collingw...

Political thought and national identity in Britain, 1850–1950

Julia Stapleton

Sociology and Political Science · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 24× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Historians continue to find rich pickings in British political thought in the decades enclosing the turn of the nineteenth century. As a result, the forces which invigorated it and the characteristics it assumed have become increasingly clear. A key factor was the growth of government intervention in spheres of society that had been ordered on a largely spontaneous basis hitherto. This provoked much dispute on the merits of such action. Correspondingly, interest in the concept of the state itself was greatly enhanced, particularly the moral purposes of which it was thought to be the highest expression. Political speculation was intensified further by successive extensions of the franchise. These concentrated the minds of political thinkers on the rights and duties associated with citizenship, the social conditions with which its 'spiritual' foundations would best accord, and the role of…

James Fitzjames Stephen: Liberalism, Patriotism, and English Liberty

Julia Stapleton

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 17× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

James Fitzjames Stephen (1829-94) is chiefly known as John Stuart Mill's most scathing critic. Author of Liberty, Equality, Fraternity (1873), Stephen savaged all the ascendant doctrines of the midnineteenth century which seemed to have crystallized in Mill's later writings. Yet Stephen's legacy was not purely negative and destructive. In particular, he passionately defended the cause of a non-doctrinaire form of liberalism which bore more than a merely superficial resemblance to the political ideas of Edmund Burke (Francis and Morrow 264). This defense entailed a considerable reorientation of mid-Victorian liberalism away from its epicenter in the various tributaries of radicalism. The chief impetus behind the project was Stephen's deep attachment to his country--a country which he considered to be unduly despised by the educated classes and popular leaders alike, and nowhere more so…

English Pluralism as Cultural Definition: The Social and Political Thought of George Unwin

Julia Stapleton

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of the History of Ideas · · cited 17× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The pluralist movement in British political thought at the beginning of the twentieth century was marked by considerable internal tension.* Nevertheless, a salient common goal among its diverse adherents was to elevate society-conceived as an intricate web of voluntary organizations-against liberal individualism on the one hand and state collectivism on the other. Against claims as to the sovereignty of the individual in the first perspective and the state in the second, pluralist writers like F. W. Maitland, J. N. Figgis, H. J. Laski, and G. D. H. Cole emphasized the equal importance of group life to human fulfillment and social cohesion. Groups, they maintained, possessed their own corporate existence, irreducible to both their members and the concession of the state. As such, small associations must be regarded as the subject of inherent rights. In the light of these insistences…

Dicey and his legacy

Julia Stapleton

Political Science and International Relations · History of Political Thought · · cited 11× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

The article begins by examining the beliefs about the English nation which informed the elevation of English law to a central position in the political thought of Dicey's time. Second, it identifies similar cultural ideals in the work of some influential political thinkers in Britain in the twentieth century, particularly Ernest Barker and Michael Oakeshott. In this way the article explores the various sympathies and antipathies which amplified a conception of the political world in England as vitally related to the fabric of English law and only comprehensible through the categories of the latter.

POLITICAL THOUGHT, ELITES, AND THE STATE IN MODERN BRITAIN

Julia Stapleton

Sociology and Political Science · The Historical Journal · · cited 8× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In general it seems to me a primary condition of national health that there shall be free and abundant contact between the most advanced culture and the masses, that due pains shall be taken ‘to marshall well the ranks behind’, and keep the whole army together. Where there is a great residuum of ignorance and stupidity, everything is dragged down... But if ever this contact was needful it is now and here; for evidently what has put the finishing touch to our confusion is the fact that the residuum of ignorance and stupidity has become our master and our judge... Just when the religious tradition had been dethroned by scepticism, and the constitutional tradition by radicalism, a new sovereign was crowned who knew nothing of either. Ignorance was proclaimed king, and an authority set up. Before whose fell approach and secret might Art after art goes out, and all is night! It is well worth…

The Classicist as Liberal Intellectual: Gilbert Murray and Alfred Eckhard Zimmern

Julia Stapleton

Anthropology · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter considers Murray's conception of Hellenism in relation to the vicissitudes of 20th-century liberalism, both political and intellectual, and explores his tireless work on its behalf. It examines his early influence on classical scholarship at Oxford, and the wider pursuit of cultural and political improvement to which he believed Classics was inextricably tied. The chapter analyses the quarters of society in which Murray and Zimmern sought to spread the Hellenist message as they understood it, and the extent of their success. It further emphasizes Murray's growing attachment to the historic English nation as an example of his later conservatism which has often been overlooked. Finally, it sets Murray's enhanced cultural pessimism during the interwar period in the context of the decline of a particular type of ‘public intellectual’ in Britain: the liberal…

T.E. Utley and renewal of conservatism in post-war Britain

Julia Stapleton

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Political Ideologies · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article examines the writings of T.E. Utley (1921–1988), a prominent contributor to the Conservative press in the post-war period. It does so in the context of Maurice Cowling's concept of ‘public doctrine.’ While attention is increasingly given to the ideas that shaped the Conservative Party in the 20th century, it has fallen short of investigating the broad foundations of Conservative ideology and their authoritative status expressed in Cowling's term. Yet Utley's thought underlines the importance of inquiry at this level, especially in distinguishing Conservatism from rival ideologies after 1945. His concern to ground Conservatism in a theory of moral and political obligation is crucial here; it was targeted against diffuse forms of secular liberalism that conceived ‘happiness’ as the end of human life. The article focuses on the shift in his allegiance from the post-war…

Sir Arthur Bryant as a 20th-century Victorian

Julia Stapleton

Sociology and Political Science · History of European Ideas · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article considers some of the late-Victorian and Edwardian influences on the popular historian, Sir Arthur Bryant (1899–1985) in the 20th century. It emphasises Bryant's role in strengthening patriotism and English national identity in the unpropitious circumstances of interwar and postwar Britain. The article examines his conservative cast of mind, one he communicated through best-selling histories and prolific journalism. It emphasises his increasing distance from organised Conservatism after the Second World War and the sympathy he attracted in some quarters of the Labour movement at the end of his life, as well as earlier on. However, it concludes that Bryant is a vital link between the late-19th century ‘moment’ of Englishness and its recent revival among Conservative thinkers, publicists and politicians. 
\n

Ernest Barker: Classics, England-Britain, and Europe, 1906–1960

Julia Stapleton

Sociology and Political Science · Polis The Journal for Ancient Greek and Roman Political Thought · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Ernest Barker’s contributions to the study of classical political thought have remained a benchmark in that field for much of the twentieth century. This introduction seeks to place his output in historical context, examining the professional, political and personal factors which underpinned his success as an interpreter of Plato and Aristotle, especially. It considers his education, the popular nature of his work, his ambiguous relationship to the establishment, his English-British patriotism, his European connections and perspective, his dual career as a scholar and journalist, and his liberalism as central to the cultural authority he acquired in the first half of the twentieth- century. The introduction emphasises the close relationship between Barker’s ‘national’ status as a classical scholar, the methodological, democratic, and religious sensibilities that informed his work, and…

British Intellectuals: Identity, Diversity and Change

Julia Stapleton

Political Science and International Relations · Twentieth Century British History · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The vibrancy of British intellectual life has never been in doubt, and has been recognized as such in the award of some of the nation's highest honours. But the concept of the intellectual has consistently suffered from a bad press, not least from intellectuals themselves, throughout much of the twentieth century. In emphasizing this cultural blind-spot, Absent Minds is the often depressing sequel to the author's previous work, Public Moralists: Political Thought and Intellectual Life in Britain, 1850–1930 (Clarendon Press, 1991), which explored the high prestige and authority enjoyed by the intellectual elite in late-nineteenth-century Britain. It is nonetheless a brilliant book, exhaustive, penetrating, full of rich subtlety, nuance and caustic humour. It explores every conceivable avenue of the above paradox, employing some neat detective work, and setting the ‘question of…

Herbert Hensley Henson, J. N. Figgis and the Archbishops’ Committee on Church and State, 1913–1916: Two Competing Visions of the Church of England

Julia Stapleton

Political Science and International Relations · The Journal of Ecclesiastical History · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article brings fresh perspective to the Archbishops’ Committee on Church and State that sat from 1913 to 1916, emphasising the divisions in the Church that it both reflected and reinforced. The article focuses on the shadow that two competing legacies cast over the committee's appointment and recommendations, and the reception of its report. This is evident in the work of two prominent figures of the early twentieth-century Church: Herbert Hensley Henson (1863–1947) and J. N. Figgis (1866–1919). While Henson appealed to Hooker's legacy in upholding a national Church, Figgis drew on Tractarianism in defending a narrower, denominational ideal.

Englishness, Britishness, and Patriotism in Recent Political Thought and Historiography

Julia Stapleton

Sociology and Political Science · The British Journal of Politics and International Relations · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Maurizio Viroli, For Love of Country: An Essay on Patriotismand Nationalism Geoffrey Elton, The English Eugenio F. Biagini (ed.), Citizenship and Community: Liberals, Radicalsand Collective Identities in the British Isles, 1865-1931 Caryl Phillips (ed.), Extravagant Strangers: A Literature of Belonging

Introduction: The ‘national character’ of Barker's thought

Julia Stapleton

Geography, Planning and Development · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

On 24 May 1948, Ernest Barker (1874–1960) dined at the Athenaeum with Sir Edward Bridges, Permanent Secretary of the Treasury and Official Head of the Civil Service. He was there to discuss how Bridges might resolve a feud which had arisen between Bridges and the Foreign Office over that part of Bridges' title which referred to his ‘headship’ of the Civil Service. Bridges had inherited this role from one of his predecessors, Sir Warren Fisher, who had revived its association with the Treasury in 1919. But the dust of the constitutional wrangling at that time had never settled, a certain Sir Walford Selby in the Foreign Office persistently alleging that the Treasury's possession of the headship had effectively ‘paralysed’ his department, and wreaked much other havoc in British government besides. The latest figure whom Selby had sought to recruit to his cause was Barker, evidently…

Conclusion: A late-Victorian liberal-conservative

Julia Stapleton

Political Science and International Relations · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

On the twenty-fifth anniversary of the Political Studies Association (PSA) in 1975, Wilfred Harrison found it necessary to explain to younger members of the profession why articles by Ernest Barker and G.D.H. Cole had been included in the first edition of Political Studies (1953). ‘Odd’ though those pieces now seemed, Harrison stressed that at the time Barker and Cole had been two ‘leading scholars’. Moreover, for those who required further retrospective justification, he added that references had been made to the two authors in recent works of political theory, this being evidence of sustained interest in their writings.

October 30, 1902. A NEGLECTED ORIGINALITY.1

Julia Stapleton

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A very interesting branch of mental science might be found in the study of the things which we think we know and do not know. At first sight it seems a somewhat wild proposition to say that we can think we know anything, since knowledge implies certainty and sincerity. It is hard to believe that a sane man can think he knows Arabic when he does not; it is hard to believe that he can be profoundly convinced that he has counted the steps up to St. Paul's Cathedral when as a matter of fact he has no idea whether there are ninety or fift een. But that is the real and genuine state of affairs. People think, for instance, that they have read the English Church Prayer Book; they are sure they have read it; they love it and pore over it as the essential heritage of Englishmen. You quote a passage out of the actual text of the Articles or the Rubrics, and they nearly jump out of their boots and…

October 4, 1902. THE CLIFFORD—CHESTERTON CONTROVERSY.

Julia Stapleton

Law · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Sir, – I had intended to take farewell of this controversy some time ago; let me take farewell of it now, though I am somewhat belated, with the conviction that many people must feel, with me, the general conviction of the great debt which we owe to Dr. Clifford. I am very keenly sensible, amongst other things, of the courtesy that he has extended to me personally, for I hope I know enough of human nature to know that to him, and to a certain degree even to you, my interposition must have seemed a mere piece of meddling, a distortion of the issue. I hope that the personal sincerity of my opponents will provide them with some key to mine. Dr. Clifford's last letter 1 is very pleasant and profitable to read. It is a pleasure to conduct a controversy with Dr. Clifford, for this reason, that in most controversies the issue becomes more and more clouded, whereas in this controversy it has…

September 19, 1902. SOME FORMS OF ADDRESS.

Julia Stapleton

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A drift of reflections on the elementary qualities involved in titles and forms of address has passed across my mind in consequence of my having studied, by accident, but with some attention, a sheaf of Socialist papers from America. In them, I notice, everyone calls everyone else ‘comrade’, including the editor; and I was much moved at this first impression of a little Eden of beautiful civic friendships. On reading in a more detailed manner, however, this luminous sentiment began in some degree to wear off: I regret to say that it became gradually apparent that one comrade was commonly employed in emphatically inquiring what another comrade had done with some portion of the funds, or whether a third comrade had any moral or political right to call himself a comrade at all. These squabbles are not, of course, in any way peculiar to the American Labour parties; they exist in all…

September 26, 1902. FIGHT FOR THE SCHOOLS.

Julia Stapleton

Education · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Sir, – Mr. Chesterton makes two mistakes in his letter of Saturday. 1 He pleads that our opposition to the Education Bill should be broad based on the principles of Liberalism, and then states that Dr. Clifford is making a blunder in ‘basing our case’ upon the position that to be a Catholic in the English Church Union sense is to be Papistical. Now I venture to say that Dr. Clifford does not base our case on any such foundation. His last letter is one of a long series, and as I have read them I have been impressed with the fact that he has ‘based our case’ on the broad ground of citizenship. In winding up the series he may have appealed with more than usual fervour to his fellow-Nonconformists, but seeing he had dealt exhaustively with every important phase of the question, it seems unjust to charge him with the tactical error of basing our case for a truly national system on the…

28 October, 1901. THE PHILOSOPHY OF ROBERT BUCHANAN*

Julia Stapleton

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The complete edition of the Poems of Robert Buchanan 1 form a very massive piece of poetical luggage indeed. In bulk they amount to as much, or more, than the collected poems of Browning, 2 who is commonly reckoned one of the most prolific of our English poets. But the difference between two impressions of bulk is very great. Every one of Browning's poems is a finished work of art in a particular style; the common statement that Browning was indifferent to form is precisely the most absurd thing that could possibly be said, for he cared a great deal more for form than any other English poet. Wordsworth 3 and Tennyson 4 were content with old forms, so long as they had new thoughts. Browning invented a new style for every poem, and generally a new metre. Robert Buchanan has something of his richness, his daring and prodigality, and something also of his love of the grotesque and the…

December 17, 1902. A PLEA FOR PARTIAL HISTORIANS.1

Julia Stapleton

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

All reputations, except those of the utterly imbecile, dwindle and rise again; capable men are praised twice, first for the wrong reasons and then again, after a cycle of obloquy, for the right. Thus, Dr. Johnson 2 was admired in his own time as an awful judge, and is admired now as a humorous, extravagant, and delightful partisan; thus Byron was admired by the young in his own time as a type of age and weariness, and is admired now by the aged (such, that is, as the present writer) as a type of romantic youth. Among these great reputations, which are bound to return, may be ranked Macaulay, the historian, whose resurrection I unhesitatingly predict and await with a profound joy. 3 But when Macaulay rises again, we shall have the same liberty in praising him that we have in the case of Johnson and Byron. We do not think it necessary to pretend that Johnson was right on the American War…

June 16, 1901. THE CONVERSION OF THE POETS.1

Julia Stapleton

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The more anarchic poets of the early part of the century2 devoted themselves largely to the exhilarating task of attacking the supernatural wholesale. With Mr. Swinburne 3 at their head, they quoted whole passages of the Old Testament, with negatives and irreverent applications interspersed, and by this commodious method succeeded in combining the advantages of being original and profane with the advantages of drawing on an old and excellent stock of literary images. Like Mr. Swinburne, they set Paganism against Christianity: like him they could not tolerate a single Deity, but seemed, for some singular reason, to get on very comfortably with a great many. The same remarkable idiosyncracy [sic] was to be remarked in their attitude towards the ladies whom they tragically and ecstatically adored. But the dominant note of Swinburnianism, beyond all question, was the attack upon religion…

January 16, 1901. A HISTORY OF CHINESE LITERATURE.*

Julia Stapleton

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The critic who does not happen to count an acquaintance with the Chinese language and literature among his accomplishments must be content to sit at the feet of Dr. Herbert Giles; 1 but he will be at liberty at least to certify to the fact that the Professor of Chinese in the University of Cambridge has, in this volume, furnished one of the most interesting of the series of short histories of literatures of the World now publishing, under the editorship of Mr. Edmund Gosse. 2 The field is an enormous one, and we are reminded that he who ventures upon it can calculate upon no assistance from any predecessor, this being the first attempt made in any language, Chinese not excepted, to produce a work of this kind, though Professor Giles acknowledges his obligations to the late Dr. James Legge's 3 ‘Chinese Classics’. A prominent feature of the book which the reader is likely to appreciate is…

November 13, 1901. IS THERE A SCHOOL OF WALT WHITMAN?*

Julia Stapleton

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A book lies before me which raises the interesting question whether Walt Whitman will succeed in founding a school of poetry. No rational person will deny that his personality was great enough to do it. It is absurd to attempt to curse a man whose blessing would include everything, even the curse. He is secure of victory, for his is the truce which conquers more terribly than war.

October 7, 1901. FABIAN FUTILITIES.

Julia Stapleton

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Sir, – I think perhaps it is time that C. E. C. and I made a fencing salute 1 and retired with that magnanimous courtesy which is the prerogative of two combatants each of whom is firmly convinced that he has annihilated the other. I shall not, therefore, say much more in a highly controversial vein, but confine myself to clearing up one or two points that have arisen elsewhere in the controversy. I desire particularly to dissociate myself from any suggestion that I intended to speak in a scornful or hostile spirit about Fabianism, or to deny the right of Fabians to combine Socialism with approval of the war. What I maintained was not that it was logically impossible for a Socialist to be an Imperialist, but simply that it was exceedingly foolish of him to be one, because Imperialism encourages a moral atmosphere in which all social idealism has been stifled and will always continue to…