Abstract
Sir, – I had intended to take farewell of this controversy some time ago; let me take farewell of it now, though I am somewhat belated, with the conviction that many people must feel, with me, the general conviction of the great debt which we owe to Dr. Clifford. I am very keenly sensible, amongst other things, of the courtesy that he has extended to me personally, for I hope I know enough of human nature to know that to him, and to a certain degree even to you, my interposition must have seemed a mere piece of meddling, a distortion of the issue. I hope that the personal sincerity of my opponents will provide them with some key to mine. Dr. Clifford's last letter 1 is very pleasant and profitable to read. It is a pleasure to conduct a controversy with Dr. Clifford, for this reason, that in most controversies the issue becomes more and more clouded, whereas in this controversy it has, upon the whole, become more and more clear. Dr. Clifford's position, according to his last letter, is that apart from every theological position, ignoring every ecclesiastical theory, a nation has a right to resist the political impositions of a certain profession. If that is all Dr. Clifford means or has meant, I thoroughly agree with him and he thoroughly agrees with me. That is all satisfactory and reconciled. The only doubt I have is whether Dr. Clifford will be able, in this liberal mood, to agree with his own original letter. 2