Abstract
I. INTRODUCTION The Human Act of 1998,1 which came into full force in the United Kingdom2 on October 2, 2000,3 will have an uncertain but undoubtedly significant impact on British constitutional law. The Act represents the culmination of a long-running constitutional debate in the United Kingdom over whether to adopt a of Rights.4 By incorporating most of the substantive provisions of the European Convention on Human (European Convention)5 into the domestic law of the United Kingdom, the Human Act marks a dramatic shift in how individual rights are conceptualized under British law. Traditionally, civil liberties-including fundamental ones such as freedom of expression, freedom of religion, and the right to privacy-were seen as in nature: [T]hey are the residue of freedom left behind after the legal restrictions have been defined by legislation or the common law.6 The British constitution has traditionally eschewed broadly worded textual pronouncements of fundamental rights, preferring, instead, to rely on the democratic process, the rule of law, and the United Kingdom's complex system of checks and balances to safeguard civil liberties. This approach has been repeatedly questioned over the past two decades.8 The Human Act, which puts courts and other public authorities under a positive duty to give[] to the rights enumerated in the European Convention in their day-to-day activities,9 marks a shift in the perception of civil liberties from residual freedoms to positive rights. Nonetheless, at first glance this British Bill of Rights seems rather toothless, particularly if judged by the standards of U.S. constitutionalism. In most countries with an effective charter of rights, the theory has been that citizens can never be assured of the safety of their liberties unless those liberties are insulated from the vagaries of democratic decision-making.10 Fundamental rights must be entrenched-enshrined in some constitutional instrument in a way that makes it difficult or even impossible for later generations to modify or abolish those rights-if they are to be preserved. The Human Act does not entrench rights in this way. The Act is given no special legal status, and, like any act of Parliament, it can be repealed by a simple majority vote in the House of Commons. Indeed, in a way the Human Act is even weaker than an ordinary act of Parliament because it does not automatically override inconsistent pre-existing acts,12 but its provisions can still be overridden by subsequent inconsistent acts.13 Finally, courts are not given the power to invalidate acts of Parliament that are incompatible with the rights listed in the European Convention, but may only issue a declaration of incompatibility, which does not itself affect the validity or enforceability of an incompatible act.14 Notwithstanding these limitations, however, there is good reason to believe that the Human Act will have a substantial impact on British constitutional law. To understand why this might be, and to understand why the Human Act was enacted in the way it was, it is necessary to examine the nature of the U.K. constitution. In the section immediately following, the nature and sources of the British constitution are discussed. While it is not possible to do justice to the intricacy of the British system in a short article, it is hoped that at least a sense of the complexity of British constitutionalism is conveyed. The article then addresses the status of individual rights within the United Kingdom's constitutional order before the Human Act came into force. The discussion then turns to the Act itself and an assessment of its potential effect on U.K. constitutional law. 11. THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED KINGDOM The constitution of the United Kingdom is, to say the least, unique. 15 Some scholars have questioned whether a U. …