arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Adam Tomkins

66 papers · 1992–2023

1992: 11993: 11994: 01995: 01996: 21997: 11998: 81999: 22000: 02001: 22002: 02003: 62004: 12005: 22006: 02007: 212008: 02009: 22010: 32011: 62012: 02013: 12014: 22015: 12016: 12017: 02018: 02019: 12020: 02021: 02022: 02023: 2
1992peak 21 in 20072023

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 66 RSS

THE ROLE OF THE COURTS IN THE POLITICAL CONSTITUTION

Adam Tomkins

Law · University of Toronto Law Journal · · cited 46× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The article sketches the beginnings of a theory of what the courts should do in the political constitution. As such, it differs from most of the literature on political constitutionalism (which tends to say more about what courts should not do) and most of the literature about what courts should do in constitutional law (which tends to be framed in a legal constitutionalist perspective). First, arguments are presented about how a political constitutionalist might distinguish between rights which are best left to political institutions and those which better lend themselves to judicial enforcement. Second, the argument is made that in constitutional litigation the courts should focus as much (if not more) on powers and evidence as on rights. The article closes with brief consideration of the legislature's role in the political constitution and of the courts' role in supporting the…

What's Left of the Political Constitution?

Adam Tomkins

Sociology and Political Science · German Law Journal · · cited 35× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper argues that we should move on from what has become a rather outdated contrast between the political constitution and the legal constitution. Taking as its focus the constitution of the United Kingdom, the paper analyzes the contemporary constitutional order as a mixed system of politics and law combined. It argues that such a mix may be a more compelling and attractive system than either the model of the political constitution or that of the legal constitution.

Scotland's choice, Britain's future

Adam Tomkins

Political Science and International Relations · ENLIGHTEN (Jurnal Bimbingan dan Konseling Islam) · · cited 18× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Analyses the legal and constitutional implications of the referendum on Scottish independence on September 18, 2014 for the UK as a whole, taking account of both its possible outcomes. Outlines the historical and political background to the referendum. Discusses the controversy over the proposed inclusion of a second question in the referendum concerning an extended form of Scottish devolution. Considers the main points of contention between the Scottish and UK Governments on the consequences of a "yes" vote.

National Security and the Due Process of Law

Adam Tomkins

Political Science and International Relations · Current Legal Problems · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article focuses on the ways in which English law struggles to accommodate security concerns within its framework of procedural fairness; insights drawn from EU law, which is rapidly gaining in importance in this field, are also briefly examined. The argument opens with a brief consideration of the use of special advocates and of closed material before turning to examine three recent ‘litigation sagas’ from the English courts which sharply illuminate the difficulties the law faces: Binyam Mohamed on intelligence sharing and obligations of disclosure; Al Sweady on public interest immunity and the Ministry of Defence; and Al Rawi on UK complicity in torture.

Introduction: On Being Sceptical about Human Rights

Adam Tomkins

Law · · cited 8× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Over the past two decades, human rights have come to enjoy an ever more dominant position in national constitutional or public law. This has been as true for Canada and New Zealand as it has been for Poland and Hungary. One of the last countries in the common law world, and one of the last countries in Europe, to allow its domestic legal system to embrace human rights is the United Kingdom, whose Parliament passed the Human Rights Act 1998. The Human Rights Act 1998, which came into effect in October 2000, was one of the most widely celebrated statutes to have been passed by the UK Parliament in many years. This book examines both the global phenomenon of human rights and the UK's participation in it, focusing on legislation in communist eastern Europe to South Africa via North America and Australasia. It deals with the general issue of the various reasons why we might be…

The rule of law in Blair's Britain

Adam Tomkins

Political Science and International Relations · ENLIGHTEN (Jurnal Bimbingan dan Konseling Islam) · · cited 7× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Blair's Britain came to an end in June 2007 when, after ten years and one month, Tony Blair stepped down as Prime Minister. His decade in office will be remembered for many things: for ending eighteen years of electoral wilderness for the Labour party, albeit only by re-branding it as 'New Labour'; for delivering unprecedented Labour majorities in the House of Commons; for the ruinous foreign policy misadventure in Iraq; for a curious and from no point of view altogether satisfactory combination of continuity and change in domestic public service reform; and for historic constitutional change. It is with this last feature that the present paper is concerned. Blair never wanted his legacy to be constitutional reform. He was never much interested in it and he inherited Labour's commitment to deliver important parts of it from his (Scottish) predecessor, John Smith. Had Blair felt able to…

Parliament, Human Rights, and Counter-Terrorism

Adam Tomkins

Political Science and International Relations · ENLIGHTEN (Jurnal Bimbingan dan Konseling Islam) · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter contributes to the debate between legal constitutionalists and political constitutionalists. It is in three parts. The first summarizes the leading UK case law on rights, liberty, and security since the Belmarsh decision. Arguing that Belmarsh already looks like an exception rather than a new beginning in public law, it outlines the illiberal nature of a range of decisions. Secondly, this case law is used to challenge the workability/desirability of David Dyzenhaus's model of rule-of-law protection in times of crisis. Thirdly, the chapter examines Parliament's recent record at scrutinizing various government claims as to what it is necessary to do in the interests of national security, focussing on the debate of the Terrorism Act 2006, and the role of the Joint Committee on Human Rights. This is used to show that that a weak judicial decision that legitimates an…

Tracking visual engagement in mixed reality : a framework for analysing interaction with digital models

Adam Tomkins, Sigrid Hehl‐Lange, Eckart Lange

Human-Computer Interaction · White Rose Research Online (University of Leeds, The University of Sheffield, University of York) · · cited 4× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Due to technological advances, affordable mixed reality devices, including both virtualreality and augmented reality, are beginning to be used to support participatory planning to better inform stakeholders of design interventions. Stakeholder participation and perception studies often utilize both qualitative interviews and quantitative techniques to gauge how a model can effectively communicate design intentions. In this paper, we examine how mixed reality enables new methods of investigating how users interact with digital models, enhancing existing techniques. We introduce a non-invasive perspective tracking system, to track how a participant explores a 3D model of a landscape intervention through the perspective of their mixed reality device. Our software provides a supplementary technique to better analyse user interaction patterns with digital models, allowing a data-driven…

Justice and Security in the United Kingdom

Adam Tomkins

Political Science and International Relations · Israel Law Review · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article outlines the ways in which the United Kingdom manages civil litigation concerning sensitive national security material. These are: (i) the common law of public interest immunity; (ii) the use of a closed material procedure and special advocates; and (iii) the secret hearings of the Investigatory Powers Tribunal. With these existing alternatives in mind the article analyses the background to, the reasons for, and the controversies associated with the Justice and Security Act 2013, enacted in the wake of the UK Supreme Court's 2011 ruling in Al Rawi v Security Service.

The Struggle to Delimit Executive Power in Britain

Adam Tomkins

Political Science and International Relations · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The theme that recurs throughout this chapter is the intermittent presence of law in the regulation of executive power in Britain. This chapter also discusses the tension between the structure of executive power (which, despite devolution, is largely centripetal) and the accountability of executive power in Britain (which is often centrifugal). Furthermore, it throws some light on the patchy, intermittent legal regulation of British government. Thus, this chapter provides three main conclusions. The first is that, in the British constitution, law plays only an intermittent role in delimiting executive power and in holding its exercise to account. The second is the tension, alluded to in the introductory section, between power and accountability. A final observation is that the British constitution has done considerably more to create mechanisms and institutions of executive…

‘Talking in Fictions’: Jennings on Parliament

Adam Tomkins

Political Science and International Relations · Modern Law Review · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Sir Ivor Jennings made many ground‐breaking contributions to the study of Parliament. Among them are two books written in the 1930s, while Jennings was at the peak of his powers: Parliamentary Reform in 1934, 1 and Parliament in 1939. 2 This essay offers an assessment of Jennings' scholarship on Parliament. It commences with some observations on his method, and this is followed by an outline of the argument in Parliament and an appraisal of the book's originality and ongoing significance. The essay closes with some brief remarks concerning Jennings' Parliamentary Reform .

Of Institutions and Individuals: The Enforcement of EC Law

Adam Tomkins

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract One of Carol Harlow’s principal contributions to English administrative law was the famous metaphor she and Richard Rawlings adopted to explain to generations of students the two essential schools of thought which dominated English administrative law scholarship throughout the twentieth century.

Political Accountability

Adam Tomkins

Law · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract In both the political and the legal contexts, it is with the accountability of the Crown’s government that we are primarily concerned. This is not to say that public law is not also concerned with questions of the account- ability of other constitutional actors. The accountability of Parliament, of the armed forces, of the police, and of the security and secret intelligence services, among others, are all weighty topics within public law, and our focus on governmental accountability is not meant to deny the importance of these issues. To concentrate on the accountability of the executive may be justified in three ways. First, the sheer centrality to public law of executive accountability makes it an essential component of any account of the subject.

On Republican Constitutionalism in the Age of Commerce: Reflections from the Scottish Enlightenment

Adam Tomkins

Law · ENLIGHTEN (Jurnal Bimbingan dan Konseling Islam) · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter presents a vision of republican constitutionalism that emanates from the political conflicts of 17th-century England. It explores the tension between the values of republican constitutionalism and those of commercial society by revisiting the work of those who were among the first to identify this tension as a problem for the modern world: namely, the thinkers of the Scottish Enlightenment. An exploration of the relationship between law, the constitution, government, and commerce was a core concern of the Scots of the Enlightenment. The chapter focuses on the work of John Millar, who wrote about these themes from the perspective of a lawyer: Millar was Regius Professor of Law in the University of Glasgow for forty years (1761-1801) and, among his many legal interests, was an abiding fascination with constitutional law. It is argued that his work and that of his…

Preface

Colin Turpin, Adam Tomkins

Law · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This book is concerned with the organisation, powers and accountability of government in the British constitution. It has been written from a lawyer's perspective, modified by an awareness that the British constitution is far from being exclusively the handiwork of lawyers. Judges and other practitioners of the discipline of law have made a notable contribution to it, but so have political philosophers, controversialists of many hues, party organisations, peers, rebels in and out of Parliament and the legions of special interests. Yet lawyers sometimes pretend that the constitution is theirs, teaching and writing about it in myopic isolation.

Parliament

Adam Tomkins

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Parliament, after the Crown, is the second of the two sovereign authorities known to English public law. This chapter considers the public law powers of Parliament, just as the previous one considered the public law powers of the Crown. This chapter is in four sections: first we consider the three functions of Parliament and their historical development; secondly we discuss the composition of the two Houses of Parliament; thirdly we consider the so-called ‘sovereignty of Parliament’, more accurately the notion that in English law Acts of Parliament enjoy legislative supremacy; and finally we turn to the revealing, but often overlooked, topic of the privileges of Parliament.

Inventing human rights law and scholarship

Adam Tomkins

Sociology and Political Science · Oxford Journal of Legal Studies · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Inventing Human Rights Law and Scholarship Get access ADAM TOMKINS ADAM TOMKINS *School of Law, King's College London. I would like to thank Lionel Bendy, Sionaidh Douglas-Scott and Andrew Ashworth for their comments and criticisms on an earlier draft. Search for other works by this author on: Oxford Academic Google Scholar Oxford Journal of Legal Studies, Volume 16, Issue 1, Spring 1996, Pages 153–160, https://doi.org/10.1093/ojls/16.1.153 Published: 01 March 1996

Parliament and the responsibility of government

Colin Turpin, Adam Tomkins

Political Science and International Relations · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Our constitutional system is one of ‘responsible government’. The idea of political (or constitutional) responsibility is wide enough to include a number of values (no fewer than twelve are identified by Gilbert, ‘The framework of administrative responsibility’ (1959) 21 Journal of Politics 373), but in the present context two are of particular importance. The first is indicated by AH Birch, Representative and Responsible Government (1964), pp 17–18, in saying that ‘the term “responsible” is commonly used to describe a system of government in which the administration is responsive to public demands and movements of public opinion’. The responsibility of government in this sense implies that it is responsive to (takes heed of, defers to) demands, pressure or influence exerted by the public, or on its behalf by institutions or organisations that have an acknowledged place in the…

The courts

Colin Turpin, Adam Tomkins

Law · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The decision of a minister, local authority or other public officer or body may be challenged in court by recourse to the machinery of judicial review. Judicial review is to be distinguished from appeal, which is sometimes available as a means of contesting an administrative decision. Judicial review is the exercise of an ancient and inherent supervisory jurisdiction of the court, by which excess or abuse of public power may be restrained or remedied. On the other hand, appeal to a court against an administrative act is possible only where provision for it is made by statute. Take, for instance, Quigly v Chief Land Registrar [1993] 1 WLR 1435. Quigly sought to appeal against an administrative decision of the Chief Land Registrar, but the court ruled that it had no jurisdiction to hear an appeal from such a decision. This ruling was upheld by the Court of Appeal. Hoffmann LJ remarked…

Constitutionalism

Adam Tomkins

Law · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article reviews the nature of the British constitution, exploring its unusual ‘unwritten’ form, and presenting an account of its main substantive components. It also addresses a range of challenges which the contemporary constitution faces and argues throughout that the constitution is currently undergoing a profound transformation from being a largely parliamentary or political constitution to being a mainly legal or juridical order in which the courts will play a markedly expanded role, unprecedented in British constitutional history. It specifically outlines ‘Europe’ and New Labour's constitutional reforms. The present time is one of rapid and in many cases significant constitutional change in Britain, change which in some instances the Blair/Brown New Labour governments either caused or contributed to but which in other instances stems from different sources not…

Criminalizing Support for Terrorism: A Comparative Perspective

Adam Tomkins

Political Science and International Relations · Duke journal of constitutional law & public policy · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In Holder v. Humanitarian Law Project the U.S. Supreme Court held, six to three, that the federal crime of knowingly providing “material support or resources to a foreign terrorist organization” is constitutional, at least as applied to the particular forms of support that the plaintiffs sought to provide. This essay examines the legal and constitutional issues arising in Holder v. Humanitarian Law Project from a comparative perspective and, in particular, in light of developments in the United Kingdom and in European law. Part I begins with a brief overview of counter-terrorism law in the UK. Part II examines the role played specifically by criminal law in the UK’s struggle against terrorism. Part III examines the aspects of UK and European counter-terrorism law, which most sharply reflect on the issues arising in Holder. The Holder plaintiffs, two U.S. citizens and six domestic…

Community law-making

Damian Chalmers, Adam Tomkins

Political Science and International Relations · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The European Union has no general law-making power. Instead, its legislative powers are to be found in specific Treaty provisions which authorise it to make laws in certain fields. This system enabled the designers of the Treaty to strike a delicate balance between the EU institutions and the Member States, with the types of instrument and legal procedure varying according to the field in question. As the Treaty has expanded, both in terms of its competencies and its institutions, so the number of legal bases has become ever more voluminous and the institutional settlement ever more complex. All this raises a question about the coherence of Community law-making, namely whether the principles for determining which procedure is used and which type of law is adopted strike an appropriate balance between the different fields of Community activity, respect the prerogatives of the different…

Judicial relations in the European Union

Damian Chalmers, Adam Tomkins

Political Science and International Relations · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Granting the possibility for individuals to assert EC legal provisions in national courts in Van Gend en Loos transformed the EC legal settlement. The Court of Justice became the guardian of a sovereign legal order, which created new legal subjects and new principles, and was enforceable in domestic courts. The subjects of EC law were also provided with new litigation opportunities. At the apex of all this was the domestic court, for Van Gend en Loos was, above all, a judgment about the responsibilities of national courts. These were responsible for the application of EC law and were required by that judgment to provide standing to any individual that asserted directly effective EC rights before them and to disapply any national measures that conflicted with these. Without their cooperation, the whole edifice collapses. This begged the question of why national courts should comply with…

Introduction

Paul Craig, Adam Tomkins

Law · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This book was inspired by the desire of British public lawyers to learn something more about how executive power may be conceived. The public law regimes of all the jurisdictions considered in this book find executive power to be a difficult and testing matter. An uneasy ambivalence about executive power is detected in all of the chapters — a recognition, perhaps, that on the one hand the government must be allowed to govern but that on the other it is the role of public law to find ways of delimiting the government's reach and of holding the government's exercise of its power to account. The inadequacy of formal, constitutional definitions of executive power is a widely shared phenomenon. All of the constitutions considered in this book provide comprehensive definitions of executive power.

The Crown

Adam Tomkins

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter will consider the public law powers of the Crown. The analysis will be divided into ve sections. First, we shall consider the position of the monarch herself. Secondly, we shall discuss the institutions of central government — Prime Minister, Cabinet, civil service, and so forth. The following two sections then address questions of the nature and exercise of royal prerogative power, and of the compatibility of the prerogative with the constitutional doctrine of the rule of law. In the final section of the chapter we shall step back a little from the more detailed discussion of the preceding sections and consider the broader question of what problems are caused for modern public law by its continuing reliance on the power and authority of the Crown.