arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

Criminalizing Support for Terrorism: A Comparative Perspective

Adam Tomkins

· Duke journal of constitutional law & public policy

See on the map

Abstract

In Holder v. Humanitarian Law Project the U.S. Supreme Court held, six to three, that the federal crime of knowingly providing “material support or resources to a foreign terrorist organization” is constitutional, at least as applied to the particular forms of support that the plaintiffs sought to provide. This essay examines the legal and constitutional issues arising in Holder v. Humanitarian Law Project from a comparative perspective and, in particular, in light of developments in the United Kingdom and in European law. Part I begins with a brief overview of counter-terrorism law in the UK. Part II examines the role played specifically by criminal law in the UK’s struggle against terrorism. Part III examines the aspects of UK and European counter-terrorism law, which most sharply reflect on the issues arising in Holder. The Holder plaintiffs, two U.S. citizens and six domestic organizations, wished to support the lawful and nonviolent activities of two groups that the Secretary of State had designated as “foreign terrorist organizations”: namely, the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) and the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE). These groups aim to establish independent states, respectively, for Kurds in Turkey and for Tamils in Sri Lanka. Both groups engage in political and humanitarian activities, but both groups also have committed terrorist attacks, some of which have harmed U.S. citizens.

More like this