arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Alice Donald

41 papers · 2008–2025

2008: 22009: 22010: 22011: 02012: 12013: 42014: 32015: 22016: 82017: 02018: 22019: 12020: 62021: 22022: 22023: 22024: 12025: 1
2008peak 8 in 20162025

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 41 RSS

The European Court of Human Rights’ Remedial Practice and its Impact on the Execution of Judgments

Alice Donald, Anne-Katrin Speck

Political Science and International Relations · Human Rights Law Review · · cited 45× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article analyses the developing approach of the European Court of Human Rights to the indication of specific non-monetary individual or general remedies and the impact of this practice on the execution of its judgments. It draws on interviews with Judges of the Court and officials in Council of Europe institutions, and a statistical analysis of pilot judgments and judgments that invoke Article 46 of the European Convention of Human Rights delivered between 2004 and 2016. The article argues that the Court’s remedial practice is fluid and pragmatic, with differences of perspective between Judges. It discusses the factors that influence judicial decision-making, and examines the implications of the Court’s remedial approach both for its ‘horizontal’ relationship with the Committee of Ministers and its ‘vertical’ relationship with states. It concludes that, from both these…

Identifying and Assessing the Implementation of Human Rights Decisions

Alice Donald, Debra Long, Anne-Katrin Speck

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Human Rights Practice · · cited 27× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Assessing the extent to which states have implemented the decisions of supranational human rights bodies is a challenging task. It requires supranational bodies—be they judicial, quasi-judicial or political—to create an evidence-based public record of the status quo of implementation at any point in time and determine whether the measures taken do, in fact, satisfy the requirements of the decision. This, in turn, relies upon states engaging in good faith, victims having a voice, and civil society organizations seizing the opportunity to influence the follow-up process. Using empirical data from interviews in selected states in the African, Inter-American and European regions, and within regional and United Nations bodies, this article argues that in no human rights ‘system’ are all these expectations met, in part because follow-up work is inadequately resourced. It argues that…

Poverty, inequality and human rights: do human rights make a difference?

Alice Donald, Elizabeth Mottershaw

Sociology and Political Science · Middlesex University Research Repository (Middlesex University Of London) · · cited 19× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

How other countries have used human rights to tackle poverty and how this could be applied in the UK.
\nPeople working to tackle poverty in the UK are increasingly interested in using human rights in their work. This study looks at how this has been done in other countries, its impact on affected communities, debate, policy and government programmes, and its relevance for the UK.
\nThe report covers:
\nhow human rights have been used to understand poverty;
\nhow communities experiencing poverty use human rights to act against injustice, build alliances between disparate groups, and articulate their conditions and claims;
\nthe tools that communities and their allies use to hold the state accountable for its human rights obligations;
\nhow human rights have been implemented in practice in anti-poverty work by governments and other organisations; and
\nlessons…

Principled Resistance to ECtHR Judgments – A New Paradigm?, edited by Marten Breuer

Alice Donald

Political Science and International Relations · The European Convention on Human Rights Law Review · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

I first encountered the notion of ‘principled’ objection by states to implement-ing judgments of the European Court of Human Rights in 2014, when ‘principled non-compliance’ was identified by the Norwegian scholar, Andreas Føllesdal, as the ‘ultimate correction device’ should Strasbourg judges ‘make mistakes’ in their dynamic interpretation of the European Convention on Human Rights. Føllesdal distinguished such ‘civil disobedience’, which would be resolved through judicial dialogue, from bad faith non-compliance. [...]

The Dynamics of Domestic Human Rights Implementation: Lessons from Qualitative Research in Europe

Alice Donald, Anne-Katrin Speck

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Human Rights Practice · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract It is widely acknowledged that the implementation of international human rights judgments is conditioned by domestic factors; yet the means by which judgments exert—or fail to exert—influence on domestic actors and processes is less well understood. This article presents qualitative research undertaken in three European states between 2016 and 2018 to trace the path between selected judgments involving structural or systemic violations and subsequent action by both state and non-state actors. The rich account of the implementation process thereby constructed reveals, in some cases, a direct—and even immediate—causal path between a decision and actions leading to compliance and, in others, a more indirect or uncertain relationship. The article reveals the dynamic and iterative nature of the implementation process, which may at times stall and at other times accelerate and which…

Religion or belief, equality and human rights in England and Wales

Alice Donald

Law · Middlesex University Research Repository (Middlesex University Of London) · · cited 10× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This report examines the law in relation to equality, human 
\nrights and religion or belief and how it is understood and applied in the workplace and in public services. Through interviews with religion or belief groups and other stakeholders, the research shows that the law is contested. Tensions exist between some 'religious' and 'secular' perspectives and between the religion and sexual orientation equality strands. Nevertheless, there is some consensus, for example concerning the need both to avoid unnecessary litigation and to develop principles to avoid disputes. Ground rules to ensure more temperate public debate are also required.

The right to freedom of religion or belief and its intersection with other rights

Alice Donald, Erica Howard

Political Science and International Relations · Middlesex University Research Repository (Middlesex University Of London) · · cited 8× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This paper was commissioned by ILGA-Europe, to examine how the right to freedom of religion or belief intersects with other human rights, including the rights to freedom of expression, freedom of assembly, and to be protected from discrimination and hate speech. The paper examines in particular the tension between religious freedom and the rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex (LGBTI) people, which is a matter of controversy in both legal and political discourse in Europe and elsewhere. In particular, some Christian organisations and commentators have portrayed anti-discrimination law as conflicting directly with the right to freedom of religion or belief. Such arguments are increasingly couched in terms of the asserted ‘right’ of religious individuals conscientiously to opt out of providing goods or services to same-sex couples or to express views that might be…

Evaluating the Impact of Human Rights Litigation on Policy and Practice: A Case Study of the UK

Alice Donald, Elizabeth Mottershaw

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Human Rights Practice · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article examines the methodological challenges in evaluating whether, and how, human rights litigation has an impact in the world outside the courtroom. Drawing on research carried out for the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) in Britain on the impact of selected human rights legal cases on the delivery of public services, it argues that assessing impact requires us to cast the net wide. Impact may be evident in legal judgments and the generalizable principles they enshrine. Impact may be seen in resulting changes to public policy and its implementation - including the process by which decisions are made. It may also be evident in outcomes in the form of both empirical social realities and the experience of people delivering and using the services that are implicated in the judgment. The article further argues that understanding the mechanisms by which legal judgments are…

Human Rights: The Essential Frame of Reference in the Global Response to COVID-19

Alice Donald, Philip Leach

Sociology and Political Science · intR2Dok (Staatsbibliothek zu Berlin) · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

It is mistaken to conceive of COVID-19 principally as a threat whose eradication necessarily requires rights to be sacrificed. Rather, human rights standards and principles offer a means of transparently balancing competing interests and priorities in the cauldron of COVID-19 decision-making – and rights-respecting measures which secure public confidence are likely to be more effective and sustainable over time than arbitrary or repressive ones.

Human Rights – the Essential Frame of Reference in Response to the COVID-19 Pandemic

Alice Donald, Philip Leach

Sociology and Political Science · Middlesex University Research Repository (Middlesex University Of London) · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The COVID-19 pandemic underscored the indivisibility and interdependence of human rights, as states’ pre-existing failure to realise economic and social rights, especially the right to health, exacerbated the spread of the virus, in turn creating the conditions for authoritarian power grabs and severe incursions into rights of all kinds. This chapter argues that it is mistaken to conceive of COVID-19 – or future pandemics – principally as a threat whose eradication requires rights to be sacrificed. Nor do human rights hinder decisive action to contain disease. Rather, human rights standards and principles offer a means of transparently balancing competing priorities in the cauldron of decision-making during a health emergency. The chapter synthesises trends in states’ human rights performance during the pandemic and explains the wide-ranging nature of their obligations. It explores…

Lessons for a ‘Post-Pandemic' Future

Joelle Grogan, Alice Donald

Information Systems · Middlesex University Research Repository (Middlesex University Of London) · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter synthesises findings from the analysis of law – and the application of law – during the COVID-19 pandemic in a range of national contexts, and draws lessons to strengthen preparedness for future emergencies. It ventures that states on the spectrum from democracy to autocracy exhibited a wide variety of approaches that defy easy categorisation and challenge pre-existing assumptions about state responses during emergency. Democracies and autocracies proved equally, and unpredictably, vulnerable to the pandemic in terms of both public health outcomes, and the ‘health’ of their institutions and their capacity to adapt and effectively respond to pandemic conditions. The chapter ventures that good governance and public trust have proved inseparable during the COVID-19 pandemic and must be the focus for investment and development. The chapter makes recommendations in respect of…

Advancing Debate about Religion or Belief, Equality and Human Rights: Grounds for Optimism?

Alice Donald

Law · Oxford Journal of Law and Religion · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Legal judgments concerning equality or human rights and religion or belief have frequently provoked controversy in Britain. This article examines why this has occurred. It does not attempt a detailed analysis of the case law; rather, it discusses how the law has been understood and invoked in public discourse. It argues that debate about religion or belief and its place in society has been unduly dominated by particular—and sometimes partial—understandings of legal judgments. It proposes that the most productive level of engagement for those who wish to advance debate, practice and understanding in relation to religion or belief is with ‘front line’ decision-makers, such as public servants and workplace managers. It ventures that in the long term an approach based on human rights principles is likely to be more satisfactory than one which is based principally on equality.

Identifying human rights stories: a scoping study

Alice Donald, Elizabeth Mottershaw

Sociology and Political Science · Middlesex University Research Repository (Middlesex University Of London) · · cited 2× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This report explores ways of generating stories that show how the Human Rights Act (HRA) 1998 affects the lives of people in the UK. Human rights ‘stories’ are instances in which arguments based on human rights law, whether alone or alongside other arguments, achieve beneficial outcomes for individuals or groups, whether procedural or substantive, by means of: litigation; decisions taken by public authorities; or public advocacy, lobbying and campaigning. The premise of the report is that the HRA is often misrepresented as benefiting litigious individuals at the expense of the public interest. Consequently, there is a need to bring more systematically into the public domain human rights stories that concern everyday scenarios affecting many people, and that reflect the impact of human rights standards and principles both inside and outside the courts. The report is based on documentary…

Developing a Bill of Rights for the UK

Alice Donald

Political Science and International Relations · Middlesex University Research Repository (Middlesex University Of London) · · cited 2× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This research identifies and explores best practice processes for developing a new Bill of Rights for the UK. Drawing on interviews with 43 key individuals and other secondary evidence, it analyses the position of the main UK parties and the legal, constitutional and political implications of devolution; assesses the processes pursued to create Bills of Rights in Canada, New Zealand, South Africa, Australia and Northern Ireland; identifies key principles that should underpin the development of a Bill of Rights, and 
\noutlines policy implications in relation to any future process.

Time for the Gloves to Come Off?: The Response by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe to Rule of Law Backsliding

Alice Donald, Anne-Katrin Speck

Political Science and International Relations · The European Convention on Human Rights Law Review · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe has limited tools to respond to rule of law backsliding by member states. Sanctions have never been used for this purpose, and the Assembly’s monitoring procedure—the most significant tool of scrutiny—presents a mixed picture. This article focuses on four states exhibiting severe rule of law backsliding: Hungary, which has evaded the procedure; Poland, which was placed under monitoring in 2020; Turkey, which in 2017 became the first state to have monitoring reopened; and Azerbaijan, which has been under monitoring since 2001. Through a first-ever analysis of debates, voting patterns, and tactics used in the Assembly, the article elucidates how proponents and opponents of monitoring have framed their arguments in the battleground of ideas about democracy and the rule of law in Europe. It concludes that the Assembly should…

National parliaments as guarantors of human rights in Europe: handbook for parliamentarians

Alice Donald, Anne-Katrin Speck

Political Science and International Relations · Middlesex University Research Repository (Middlesex University Of London) · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This handbook for parliamentarians from all over Europe, which was published by the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE), sets out ways and means to protect and implement human rights, within a democracy underpinned by the rule of law.

A Bill of Rights for the United Kingdom? Lessons from Overseas

Alice Donald

Political Science and International Relations · British Academy eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The right to participate in choosing or changing a constitution is becoming established in law and theory. The means of realising that right in the formation of Bills of Rights, and the consequences for democratic legitimacy, are matters of debate and experimentation. This chapter explores the processes used to develop Bills of Rights (or proposed Bills) in the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand, and analyses key aspects of the design of those processes. It examines the context for creating a new UK Bill of Rights, including the work of the Commission on a Bill of Rights established in 2011. It reflects on the challenges facing the Commission in the light of experience overseas. It concludes that, on present evidence, the Commission is highly unlikely to achieve an outcome which might enjoy democratic legitimacy, in the sense of having been subject to inclusive and…

A Badge of Dishonour

Alice Donald

Political Science and International Relations · Open MIND · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Calls for the UK to leave the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) have become commonplace in British political debate. Reform UK has announced withdrawal as its day one priority, the centre-right Conservative party could be on the brink of adopting exit from the ECHR as a flagship policy, and even some Labour MPs are thinking the unthinkable.

Legislating fiction

Alice Donald, Joelle Grogan

Sociology and Political Science · DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Members of Parliament in the UK will on 16 and 17 January 2024 debate the Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Bill, which ‘gives effect to the judgement of Parliament that the Republic of Rwanda is a safe country’ for asylum-seekers. The Supreme Court unanimously ruled in November 2023 that Rwanda was manifestly not safe as asylum seekers sent to the country would face a real risk of ill-treatment due to insufficient guarantees against refoulement. The Bill thus aims to use law to determine a factual situation for as long as the law is in force. This blog discusses the risks inherent in creating such a ‘legal fiction’ and how the Bill could be revised to mitigate this risk, before assessing the chances of it becoming law in the currently turbulent political context.

Defeat in the Supreme Court

Alice Donald, Joelle Grogan

Political Science and International Relations · DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

On 15 November 2023, the UK Supreme Court (UKSC) unanimously declared the government’s policy of removing some asylum seekers to Rwanda to process their claims unlawful. Like the Court of Appeal, it found substantial grounds for believing that asylum seekers would face a real risk of ill-treatment because of insufficient guarantees against refoulement. This post explores the origin and significance of the UKSC judgment and the legal and policy implications of the UK government’s immediate response to it.

The UK vs the European Court of Human Rights- On a Politically Engineered Collision Course?

Alice Donald, Philip Leach

Information Systems · DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In recent months, the UK government has tabled two Bills before Parliament which would have the consequence – and almost certainly have the intention – of setting the UK on a collision course with the Council of Europe, and especially the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). Both the Bill of Rights Bill and the Illegal Migration Bill, introduced on 22 June 2022 and 7 March 2023 respectively, contain provisions that openly flout the UK’s obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). This post details how the Bills serve to undermine the UK’s obligations under the ECHR and explains their significance within the larger debate surrounding the UK’s possible withdrawal from the Convention. It places this debate in the context of the rarely-convened Council of Europe summit of heads of state and government in Reykjavik in May 2023, whose ambitious agenda is…

Compliance in the UK in the age of subsidiarity

Alice Donald

Political Science and International Relations · Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter focuses on the United Kingdom's relationship with the European Convention on Human Rights system and its compliance with judgments of the European Court of Human Rights. It discusses the paradox presented by, on the one hand, the intense controversy that often surrounds human rights in the UK and, on the other hand, its relatively strong record of implementing judgments of the Court, which is due to the robust institutional arrangements that exist to ensure compliance with supranational human rights rulings at the level of the executive, Parliament and the judiciary. The chapter illustrates the political nature of the implementation process by means of two cases (on prisoner voting and on the retention of biometric data) that provoked contrasting responses from the UK authorities. The chapter situates this discussion of the UK's record in the context of the 'age of…

Engaging with Europe after Brexit: time to reset the UK’s relationship with the Council of Europe

Alice Donald, Philip Leach

Political Science and International Relations · Middlesex University Research Repository (Middlesex University Of London) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

The article analyses the UK’s relationship with the Council of Europe. Traditionally, a strong supporter of the Strasbourg mechanisms, relations in recent years have been decidedly rocky. Nevertheless, the article argues that in the post-Brexit era, the time is ripe for the UK to reset its relationship with the Council of Europe and reclaim the moral and political leadership that it once showed.

Wholehearted? Half-hearted? The response from the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe to recent developments in Turkey

Alice Donald, Anne-Katrin Speck

Political Science and International Relations · Ghent University Academic Bibliography (Ghent University) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe has limited tools of sanction and scrutiny at its disposal to respond to serious transgressions of member states. Since the failed coup attempt in Turkey and the government’s subsequent crackdown, sanctions have barely been discussed, let alone used, in the Assembly. However, the monitoring procedure, the most significant tool of scrutiny, has been reopened in respect of Turkey—a step without precedent in the 70 years of the Assembly’s existence. Drawing on documentary sources and interviews, this paper analyses the three key debates about Turkey in the Assembly since the failed coup d’état. The paper documents how Turkey has disputed any criticism of its actions and pushed back against all exceptional treatment as punitive and damaging to long-standing relations. It finds that political support for the Erdoğan regime has been unstable…

Time for Strasbourg to Open its Doors to Turkey’s Purged Public Servants

Alice Donald

Political Science and International Relations · DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A report by the Turkey Human Rights Litigation Support Project (TLSP) provides fresh evidence that the Commission formed in 2017 to examine the mass dismissals of public servants and liquidation of media outlets and other organisations functions arbitrarily and without transparency. Together with concerns about judicial review by administrative courts and the Constitutional Court, the report casts serious doubt on whether victims of abuses committed under emergency laws have access to an effective domestic remedy – a finding with implications for the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) as it considers the long queue of Turkish applications before it.