arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Matthew Radburn

18 papers · 2016–2026

2016: 22017: 02018: 12019: 02020: 32021: 72022: 22023: 22024: 02025: 02026: 1
2016peak 7 in 20212026

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–18 of 18 RSS

When is policing fair? Groups, identity and judgements of the procedural justice of coercive crowd policing

Matthew Radburn, Clifford Stott, Ben Bradford +1 more

Political Science and International Relations · Policing & Society · · cited 90× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Procedural justice theory (PJT) is now a widely utilised theoretical perspective in policing research that acknowledges the centrality of police ‘fairness’. Despite its widespread acceptance this paper asserts that there are conceptual limitations that emerge when applying the theory to the policing of crowd events. This paper contends that this problem with PJT is a result of specific assumptions that are highlighted by two studies using a novel experimental approach. Study 1 systematically manipulated the social categories used to describe crowd participants subjected to police coercion. The experiment demonstrates how these social categories dramatically affected participants’ perceptions of the same police action and that it was participants’ relational identification with the police, rather than a superordinate category, that mediated the association between judgements of…

The social psychological processes of ‘procedural justice’: Concepts, critiques and opportunities

Matthew Radburn, Clifford Stott

Political Science and International Relations · Criminology & Criminal Justice · · cited 71× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Contemporary research on policing and procedural justice theory (PJT) emphasizes large-scale survey data to link a series of interlocking concepts, namely perceptions of procedural fairness, police legitimacy and normative compliance. In this article we contend that as such, contemporary research is in danger of conveying a misreading of PJT by portraying a reified social world divorced from the social psychological dynamics of encounters between the police and policed. In this article we set out a rationale for addressing this potential misreading and explore how and why PJT researchers would benefit both theoretically and methodologically through drawing upon advances in theoretical accounts of social identity, developed most notably in attempts to understand crowd action. Specifically, we advance an articulation of a ‘process-based’ model of PJT’s underlying social and subjective…

Policing the COVID-19 pandemic: police officer well-being and commitment to democratic modes of policing

Arabella Kyprianides, Ben Bradford, Marcus Beale +3 more

Political Science and International Relations · Policing & Society · · cited 70× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Police organisations have a wealth of experience in responding to emergencies, but COVID-19 is unprecedented in terms of the speed, scale and complexity of developing doctrine and its implementation by officers. The crisis also threw into sharp relief the fact that police policy and, crucially, practice are always implemented within wider social, political and economic contexts. Using online survey data collected from 325 police officers based at forces operating across different UK contexts (cities, conurbations, towns and rural areas), we seek to understand officer experiences and perceptions of policing COVID-19. In particular, we examine whether (internally) organisational climate and (externally) the UK government’s response to COVID-19 were important to (a) officers’ support for police use of force at times of emergency, (b) officer’s support for procedurally just policing at…

Patterns of ‘Disorder’ During the 2019 Protests in Hong Kong: Policing, Social Identity, Intergroup Dynamics, and Radicalization

Clifford Stott, Lawrence Ka-Ki Ho, Matthew Radburn +3 more

Sociology and Political Science · Policing A Journal of Policy and Practice · · cited 59× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Across the latter half of 2019, Hong Kong became the focus of world attention as it was rocked by a wave of increasingly violent confrontations between police and protesters. Both inside and outside the Territory, several powerful political actors have argued that the paramilitary-style police interventions used to manage the protests were necessary because the disorder was being fermented by agitators. In contrast, this article explores the utility of the Elaborated Social Identity Model of crowd behaviour to help explore and explain some of the social psychological dynamics through which the 2019 protests became ‘radicalised’. The article explores three key phases of their evolution to draw out the patterns of collective action and variations in policing approaches. We show that early demonstrations were focused predominantly on preventing the implementation of controversial…

Policing football ‘risk’? A participant action research case study of a liaison-based approach to ‘public order’

Clifford Stott, Owen West, Matthew Radburn

Political Science and International Relations · Policing & Society · · cited 59× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper reports upon the first formal academic analysis of the deployment of a dialogue based and explicitly non-coercive ‘Police Liaison Team’ (PLT) within the public order policing operation surrounding a football fixture. The study uses an approach based upon Participant Action Research to first generate changes to operational practices and then to analyse the consequences of these changes upon the dynamics of the event and of the public order policing operation itself. Data is drawn from multiple sources including direct observation and post event focus groups. It is argued that the PLT played an important role in terms of enhancing police capacity for dialogue and communication with ‘risk’ fans, adding depth and quality to risk assessment as well as assisting in the avoidance of ‘disorder’ and police coercion. Problems were identified in terms of strategy, inappropriate…

Identity, legitimacy and cooperation with police: Comparing general-population and street-population samples from London.

Arabella Kyprianides, Ben Bradford, Jonathan Jackson +3 more

Political Science and International Relations · Psychology Public Policy and Law · · cited 41× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Social identity is a core aspect of procedural justice theory, which predicts that fair treatment at the hands of power holders such as police expresses, communicates, and generates feelings of inclusion, status, and belonging within salient social categories. In turn, a sense of shared group membership with power holders, with police officers as powerful symbolic representatives of “law-abiding society,” engenders trust, legitimacy, and cooperation. Yet, this aspect of the theory is rarely explicitly considered in empirical research. Moreover, the theory rests on the underexamined assumption that the police represent one fixed and stable superordinate group, including the often-marginalized people with whom they interact, and that it is only superordinate identification that is important to legitimacy and cooperation. In this article, we present results from two U.K.-based studies that…

A social identity perspective on interoperability in the emergency services: Emergency responders' experiences of multiagency working during the COVID‐19 response in the UK

Louise Davidson, Holly Carter, Richard Amlôt +4 more

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management · · cited 19× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Recent research has shown that multiagency emergency response is beset by a range of challenges, calling for a greater understanding of the way in which these teams work together to improve future multiagency working. Social psychological research shows that a shared identity within a group can improve the way in which that group works together and can facilitate effective outcomes. In the present study, 52 semistructured interviews were conducted with 17 strategic and/or tactical responders during the COVID-19 pandemic to understand the possible role of shared identity in the multiagency response to COVID-19 and whether this was linked to factors that facilitated or challenged interoperability. Findings show evidence of a shared identity at a horizontal intergroup level among responders locally. However, there was limited evidence for a shared identity at the vertical intergroup level…

How do police officers talk about their encounters with ‘the public’? Group interaction, procedural justice and officer constructions of policing identities

Matthew Radburn, Leanne Savigar-Shaw, Clifford Stott +2 more

Political Science and International Relations · Criminology & Criminal Justice · · cited 19× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Despite widespread empirical support for Procedural Justice Theory, understanding the role of police psychology in shaping encounters with ‘citizens’ is relatively opaque. This article seeks to address this gap in the literature by exploring how officers talk about themselves and their colleagues and deploy social categories to understand their interactions with ‘the public’. The qualitative thematic analysis draws upon 22 semi-structured interviews conducted with officers in various roles and teams within a large metropolitan police force in England. Our thematic analysis demonstrates the centrality of procedural fairness in officers’ talk (in terms of internal relations with colleagues and external relations with ‘the public’). Interviewees described complex internalised theories of social relations, differentially positioning themselves in relation to other colleagues and multiple…

Police Powers and Public Assemblies: Learning from the Clapham Common ‘Vigil’ during the Covid-19 Pandemic

Clifford Stott, Matthew Radburn, Geoff Pearson +3 more

Political Science and International Relations · Policing A Journal of Policy and Practice · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The policing of peaceful public assembly during the Covid-19 pandemic has been one of the most central challenges to police legitimacy. This is arguably because mass gatherings are assumed to carry a high risk of contagion yet, at the same time, peaceful public assembly is a protected human right. In this article, we explore this issue by using a case study to provide a detailed chronological interactional analysis of the policing operation surrounding a highly controversial public assembly that took place on Clapham Common in March 2021 in London, England. We explore the utility of a research and theory-based model for public order policing in pandemics as a framework for understanding the way the event evolved and identifying what lessons can be learnt for policing assemblies, both in future pandemics and more generally. We contend that ambiguity in the application of…

Procedural justice as a reward to the compliant: an ethnography of police–citizen interaction in police custody

Leanne Savigar-Shaw, Matthew Radburn, Clifford Stott +2 more

Political Science and International Relations · Policing & Society · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper contributes to the literature on Procedural Justice Theory (PJT) by exploring its capacity to explain the dynamic interactions between police and citizens within the context of police detention. Analysis is based on observation and interviews in police custody suites (i.e. locations where arrested citizens are formally processed and held) within one of the larger metropolitan police forces in the UK. The qualitative thematic analysis highlights how, in order to adequately understand police–detainee interactions, it is critical that PJT properly recognises (a) the importance of context for framing ‘procedurally fair’ encounters, (b) the central role and consequences of categorisation, and (c) the role of power in shaping police–citizen encounters. The paper concludes by exploring the implications of this research for assumptions regarding the causal ordering often assumed in…

Group processes and interoperability: A longitudinal case study analysis of the UK’s civil contingency response to Covid-19

Matthew Radburn, Clifford Stott, Bethan Morgan +3 more

Sociology and Political Science · Keele Research Repository (Keele University) · · cited 13× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Our case study explored a Local Resilience Forum’s (LRF) civil contingency response to COVID-19 in the UK. We undertook 19 semi-structured ethnographic longitudinal interviews, between 25th March 2020 and 17th February 2021, with a Director of a Civil Contingencies Unit and a Chief Fire Officer who both played key roles within their LRF. Within these interviews, we focused on their strategic level decision-making and how their relationship with national government impacted on local processes and outcomes. Using a form of grounded theory, our data describes the chronological evolution of an increasingly effective localised approach toward outbreak control and a growing resilience in dealing with concurrent emergency incidents. However, we also highlight how national government organisations imposed central control on aspects of the response in ways that undermined or misaligned with…

Spontaneous public response to a marauding knife attack on the London underground: Sociality, coordination and a repertoire of actions evidenced by <scp>CCTV</scp> footage

Terry Au‐Yeung, Richard Philpot, Clifford Stott +2 more

Sociology and Political Science · British Journal of Social Psychology · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Across a range of recent terrorist attacks in the United Kingdom, the question of how crowds behave in confined public space is an important concern. Classical theoretical assumptions are that human behaviour in such contexts is relatively uniform, self-interested and pathological. We contest these assumptions by reporting on a study of public response to a marauding knife attack that occurred on London's underground rail network in 2015. The analysis draws primarily upon footage from 27 CCTV cameras positioned across the station footprint supplemented by social media, news footage, radio logs and incident reports. Using an innovative methodology, we topographically and chronologically mapped behaviours during the incident. The analysis demonstrates that while rapid egressions occurred as the threat escalated, at every phase of the incident members of the public intervened spontaneously…

Police discretion and the role of the ‘spotter’ within football crowd policing: risk assessment, engagement, legitimacy and de-escalation

Mike Hope, Matthew Radburn, Clifford Stott

Political Science and International Relations · Policing & Society · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Discretion is a key feature of policing, yet its surrounding research has historically been heavily reliant upon exploring interpersonal or dyadic encounters between individual officers and members of the public. More recently, studies have explored how discretionary decisions by police officers impact upon and interact with group-level and organisational processes but few studies have explored the relevance of discretion to debates in the literature on public order policing. Correspondingly, there is to date only a limited body of research exploring the nature and dynamics of dialogue-based football-related public order policing. This study addresses these combined gaps by drawing upon data from interviews with specialist football officers, referred to as ‘spotters’ or Dedicated Football Officers, from five English police forces. Our analysis critiques the idea that these specialist…

Emergency responders’ experiences of multi-agency working during the COVID-19 response in the UK: Social identity as part of the problem and part of the solution

Louise Davidson, Holly Carter, Richard Amlôt +4 more

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Recent research has shown that multi-agency emergency response is beset by a range of problems, calling for a greater understanding of the way in which these teams work together to improve future multi-agency working. Social psychological research shows that a shared identity within a group can improve the way in which that group works together and can facilitate effective outcomes. Thus, seventeen semi-structured interviews were conducted with strategic and tactical responders during the COVID-19 pandemic to explore whether there was any evidence that a shared identity was part of the solution to challenges faced, and if so, how and when shared identity arose. Findings suggest that two forms of group relations were particularly relevant: horizontal intergroup relations – the relationships among responders at the local level; and vertical intergroup relations – the relationship between…

On the identity dynamics of police legitimacy and public cooperation among a general population and a London street population

Arabella Kyprianides, Ben Bradford, Jonathan Jackson +3 more

Political Science and International Relations · PsyArXiv (OSF Preprints) · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Social identity is a core aspect of procedural justice theory, which predicts that fair treatment at the hands of power holders such as police expresses, communicates and generates feelings of inclusion, status and belonging within salient social categories. In turn, a sense of shared group membership with power-holders, with police officers as powerful symbolic representatives of “law-abiding society”, engenders trust, legitimacy and cooperation. Yet, this aspect of the theory is rarely explicitly considered in empirical research. Moreover, the theory rests on the under-examined assumption that the police represent one fixed and stable superordinate group, including the often marginalised people with whom they interact, and that it is only superordinate identification that is important to legitimacy and cooperation. In this paper we present results from two UK-based studies that…

A social identity perspective on interoperability in the emergency services: Emergency responders’ experiences of multi-agency working during the COVID-19 response in the UK

Louise Davidson, Holly Carter, Richard Amlôt +4 more

Sociology and Political Science · Figshare · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Recent research has shown that multi-agency emergency response is beset by a range of problems, calling for a greater understanding of the way in which these teams work together to improve future multi-agency working. Social psychological research shows that a shared identity within a group can improve the way in which that group works together and can facilitate effective outcomes. In the present study, 52 semi-structured interviews were conducted with 17 strategic and tactical responders during the COVID-19 pandemic to understand the possible role of shared identity in the multi-agency response to COVID-19. Findings suggest that two forms of group relations were particularly relevant: horizontal intergroup relations – the relationships among responders at the local level; and vertical intergroup relations – the relationship between responders at the local level and national level.…

Policing in the COVID19 space: Authority, legitimacy and adaption in a time of ambiguity

Arabella Kyprianides, Leanne Savigar-Shaw, Marcus Beale +3 more

Political Science and International Relations · Staffordshire Online Repository (Staffordshire University) · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

UK police forces have a wealth of experience in responding to emergencies but COVID-19 is unprecedented in terms of the speed, scale and complexity of developing doctrine and its implementation by officers across the UK. However, in meeting this adversity lies unparallel opportunity for important learning and knowledge development. Drawing on interviews with senior and operational police officers, this article outlines our research on how the fast-changing legislative and guidance frameworks imposed on policing during the COVID-19 crisis have created immense leadership and operational challenges. Yet, narratives around both ‘self-legitimacy’ and ‘bounded authority’ exemplify the limits of police authority in a rapidly evolving policing context.

Exploring the dynamics of identity, procedural justice and police legitimacy in the context of anti-war demonstrations in the UK

Angus Chan, Ben Bradford, Clifford Stott +1 more

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Police Science & Management · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This study explores the role of social identity and group-level processes in shaping public perceptions of police legitimacy and procedural justice during anti-war demonstrations in the United Kingdom. Building on procedural justice theory and extending the findings of Radburn and colleagues, we conducted two studies to examine how social context and identification with protestors influenced evaluations of protest policing. Study 1 investigates the impact of prior attitudes towards the Israel–Palestine conflict on perceptions of procedural fairness, identification with police and legitimacy. Results show that participants who viewed a video of the policing of protests over the war in Gaza who identified with pro-Palestine protestors viewed the police as less procedurally fair and legitimate than with neutral or pro-Israel attitudes. These findings affirm the importance of social…