arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Geoff Pearson

57 papers · 1999–2024

1999: 12000: 02001: 02002: 32003: 12004: 12005: 02006: 22007: 22008: 12009: 12010: 12011: 32012: 82013: 22014: 32015: 12016: 102017: 12018: 32019: 12020: 02021: 22022: 02023: 32024: 7
1999peak 10 in 20162024

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 57 RSS

'Keeping the Peace': Social Identity, Procedural Justice and the Policing of Football Crowds

Clifford Stott, James Hoggett, Geoff Pearson

Gender Studies · The British Journal of Criminology · · cited 131× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper explores the relevance of the Elaborated Social Identity Model of Crowd Behaviour and Procedural Justice Theory to an understanding of both the presence and absence of collective conflict during football (soccer) crowd events. It provides an analysis of data gathered during longitudinal ethnographic study of fans of Cardiff City Football Club-a group of supporters with a notorious history of involvement in 'hooliganism' within the English domestic Football Leagues. The analysis suggests that the perceived legitimacy among fans of the way they were policed affected the internal dynamics, patterns of collective action and overall levels of 'compliance' among the fan group. On this basis, we contend that these processes mediated both a long-term decline but also the sporadic reemergence of collective conflict during crowd events involving the fans. The paper concludes by…

A different kind of ethics

Jason Ferdinand, Geoff Pearson, Mike Rowe +1 more

Sociology and Political Science · Ethnography · · cited 88× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Drawing on four `tales from the field', provided one each by the authors, this article examines the ethical and moral dilemmas ethnographers can face during their research. In particular, we address two key questions. First, what does being ethical actually involve? Second, is there a moral duty owed by researchers and, if so, to whom is this duty owed? The article reviews current debates over ethics in ethnographic research, specifically the responsibilities of the researcher to his/her research subjects, before turning to the four `tales from the field'. These tales form the basis for a discussion of a researcher's ethical responsibilities when confronted with wrongdoing, in different forms, in the course of their fieldwork.

The researcher as hooligan: where ‘participant’ observation means breaking the law

Geoff Pearson

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Social Research Methodology · · cited 56× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article focuses on the problems faced by researchers carrying out participant observation in fields where the committal of criminal offences is the norm. Can participation in criminal activity by a researcher be justified on the grounds that it is necessary to prevent the distortion of the field? Alternatively, can the difficulties in gaining and maintaining access in such spheres excuse such conduct? The article considers the current guidance given to researchers in the social sciences and the peculiar pressures placed on them when carrying out fieldwork in ‘criminal’ areas. Examples from the author’s own experiences carrying out covert participant observation within crowds of ‘risk’ football supporters are used to illustrate that in such fields the committal of offences can be unavoidable and that further guidance – but not regulation – is required to protect academics carrying…

Football Banning Orders, Proportionality, and Public Order Policing

Clifford Stott, Geoff Pearson

Gender Studies · The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice · · cited 55× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract: This article provides a critical analysis of the UK legislation on football banning orders. The historical development of this legislation is outlined and concerns are raised about its impact upon civil liberties and human rights, particularly with respect to Section 14B of the Football (Disorder) Act 2000. The article then outlines a body of research on crowd psychology, public order policing and football ‘disorder’ that questions the determining role of the banning order in the reduction of English ‘hooliganism’ at international football tournaments. With regard to tests of proportionality the article concludes by raising important questions about the efficacy and justifiability of football banning orders as a long-term strategy for the management of football ‘hooliganism’.

Body-Worn Cameras and the Law of Unintended Consequences: Some Questions Arising from Emergent Practices

Mike Rowe, Geoff Pearson, Elizabeth Turner

Political Science and International Relations · Policing A Journal of Policy and Practice · · cited 44× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Research on body-worn cameras (BWC) has tended, through evaluations or randomized controlled trials, to look to demonstrate some assumed benefit or consequence of the use of BWC. This article is concerned with the ways in which police officers use and talk about BWC and draw on ethnographic research over the past 30 months in one force as it rolled out the use of cameras. BWC have become a useful tool in the array of those available to officers. At the same time, they come with some downsides. There are pressures to use the cameras in more and more encounters with the public and while their use may raise the standards of police–citizen interactions, there is also a concern that they constrain discretion. Beyond their immediate use, questions about their evidential value have also emerged. Finally, we begin to question the model of accountability cameras present to the public.

The hoolifan: Positive fan attitudes to football ‘hooliganism’

Joel Rookwood, Geoff Pearson

Gender Studies · International Review for the Sociology of Sport · · cited 43× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Popular accounts of ‘football hooliganism’ have identified the phenomenon as being harmful and damaging for both the sport of football and the interests of spectators who attend matches. As a result, it has been generally assumed that ‘non-hooligan’ supporters disapprove of their hooligan counterparts and their activities. However, this one-sided account does not recognize the views of a significant proportion of match-going fans who consistently express positive attitudes towards the ‘hooligans’ who follow their team. Based on a series of ethnographic studies of football fans from 1995 to 2010, this article casts light on the positive role that hooligans are perceived to perform by many fans who attend home and away matches with their club. The research demonstrated that hooligans were believed to play vital roles in distraction, protection and reputation for many non-hooligan fans and…

Public order and the rebalancing of football fans' rights: Legal problems with pre-emptive policing strategies and banning orders

Mark James, Geoff Pearson

Political Science and International Relations · Northumbria Research Link (Northumbria University) · · cited 36× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

The policing of football supporters in the UK is resource-intensive and expensive, with football crowds seen by many forces as inherently prone to misbehaviour, disorder and violence. As a result they are regularly subjected to high-profile, heavy-handed and intrusive policing strategies that are often designed with the imposition of a civil “banning order” on supposed “risk supporters” in mind. This article analyses underlying assumptions about the nature and risk of football crowds and, drawing comparisons with the ways in which political protests are policed and applying jurisprudence from a series of high-profile protest cases, questions the legality of dominant policing approaches to football crowds under both English public law principles and the European Convention on Human Rights. It concludes by proposing how strategies could be developed in a way that both protects the public…

Football Banning Orders: Analysing Their Use in Court

Mark James, Geoff Pearson

Political Science and International Relations · The Journal of Criminal Law · · cited 36× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In the months prior to the 2006 FIFA World Cup in Germany, the government funded a number of targeted policing operations aimed at securing Football Banning Orders against known or suspected football hooligans. This article is based on court observations and associated interviews carried out in early 2006 in and around Manchester. It evaluates the application process, the legal tests applied and the quality of the evidence relied on by courts when determining whether the imposition of a Football Banning Order is necessary to prevent future football-related disorder being committed by the respondent. In particular, the analysis focuses on whether the use of a civil procedure can continue to be justified in the light of the punitive length of and conditions attached to these Orders, whether the correct standard of proof is being applied by the court at all stages of the application and…

Policy, Practicalities, and PACE s. 24: The Subsuming of the Necessity Criteria in Arrest Decision Making by Frontline Police Officers

Geoff Pearson, Mike Rowe, L. J. Turner

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Law and Society · · cited 31× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

PACE, as amended by the Serious Organised Crime and Police Act 2005, establishes a complex framework of factors that police officers must consider during arrest decision making. Officers must possess a reason to arrest, it must be necessary to arrest for that reason, and they must give at least a ‘cursory consideration’ to alternatives. Based on a four‐year ethnographic study of frontline officers from two forces in Northern England, we argue that the 2005 reforms have not achieved their aims. The new regime tasks officers with undertaking a complex legal assessment prior to arrest, but officers are often confused about the necessity criteria which, moreover, is typically a minor consideration in contrast to demanding practical and policy pressures. This means that unlawful and non‐human‐rights‐compliant arrests continue to be regularly made and, equally significantly, many suspects are…

Enabling an Evidence-Based Approach to Policing Football in the UK

Clifford Stott, Geoff Pearson, Owen West

Political Science and International Relations · Policing A Journal of Policy and Practice · · cited 28× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Across the last 10 years, the policing of demonstrations in the UK has witnessed substantive change in terms of both statutory guidance and operational practices. With this study, we highlight how the policing of football crowds in the UK has, to date, yet to undergo similar change, despite being covered by the same statutory guidance. On the basis of largely qualitative data and analysis generated through a quasi-ethnographic approach, we explore the dynamics of police football crowd interactions. We identify how current approaches can fail to adequately understand the nature of risk and lead to a disproportionate deployment of resources both of which have the potential to increase rather than reduce the risk of disorder. We propose that forces develop and test innovative approaches to football policing that are engrained in existing public order guidance, but which move away…

Qualifying for Europe? The Legitimacy of Football Banning Orders ‘On Complaint’ under the Principle of Proportionality

Geoff Pearson

Sociology and Political Science · Entertainment and Sports Law Journal · · cited 24× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Football Banning Orders ‘on Complaint’ are now seen as an essential part of the fight against ‘hooliganism’ by English football supporters abroad. However, they have been criticised for infringing the fundamental rights of supporters who have not been convicted of any offence and as such they are only justifiable under EU law and the ECHR if they are proven to be a proportionate response to the problem. A fall in arrests at recent tournaments has led many to claim that ‘the end justifies the means’, a claim supported by the Court of Appeal’s decision in Gough. This article assesses whether Banning Orders on Complaint do indeed satisfy the principle of proportionality, questioning not only the decision in Gough but also the legitimacy and value of Banning Orders as a response to football crowd disorder more generally.

Sporting Justifications under <scp>EU</scp> Free Movement and Competition Law: The Case of the Football ‘Transfer System’

Geoff Pearson

Sociology and Political Science · European Law Journal · · cited 23× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Governing bodies have significant autonomy in the organisation of professional sport in the EU , a situation now supported by A rticle 165 TFEU. However the post‐ L isbon competence for sport does not grant any exemption for practices that infringe fundamental freedoms or competition law; such infringements can only be justified where they are a proportionate response to an inherent need in that sport. The football ‘transfer system’ has been the subject of a series of EU law challenges, but continues to place obstacles in the way of the free movement of players between M ember S tates and may restrict the ability of most clubs to compete for the elite players. C ourt of A rbitration for S port decisions in transfer dispute cases have entrenched this situation, and recent evidence casts doubt on both the ability of the authorities to justify the current system and the 2001…

Learning and practicing police craft

Mike Rowe, Elizabeth Turner, Geoff Pearson

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Organizational Ethnography · · cited 19× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Purpose The authors consider current policy debates in the UK about the professionalisation of the police to respond to changing patterns of crime and, specifically, the suggestion that officers be educated to degree level. Drawing on the ethnographic evidence, the purpose of this paper is to focus attention on how officers learn, and continue to develop the applied, that is the craft aspects of the work of uniformed constables. Design/methodology/approach The authors draw on a long-term ethnographic project observing officers during the course of their duties. The focus is on the use of discretion and of particular powers. But in the course of the research, the authors also observe the way officers behave and the way they talk about their job. Findings The authors suggest that, while there may be a role for degree qualifications, attention needs to be paid to the practices the authors…

Police Powers and Public Assemblies: Learning from the Clapham Common ‘Vigil’ during the Covid-19 Pandemic

Clifford Stott, Matthew Radburn, Geoff Pearson +3 more

Political Science and International Relations · Policing A Journal of Policy and Practice · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The policing of peaceful public assembly during the Covid-19 pandemic has been one of the most central challenges to police legitimacy. This is arguably because mass gatherings are assumed to carry a high risk of contagion yet, at the same time, peaceful public assembly is a protected human right. In this article, we explore this issue by using a case study to provide a detailed chronological interactional analysis of the policing operation surrounding a highly controversial public assembly that took place on Clapham Common in March 2021 in London, England. We explore the utility of a research and theory-based model for public order policing in pandemics as a framework for understanding the way the event evolved and identifying what lessons can be learnt for policing assemblies, both in future pandemics and more generally. We contend that ambiguity in the application of…

For business or pleasure? A discussion of the impact of European Union law on the economic and socio‐cultural aspects of football

Liz Crolley, Roger Levermore, Geoff Pearson

Sociology and Political Science · European Sport Management Quarterly · · cited 10× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Over the last century, football has evolved dramatically. The most significant feature of this has been the rapid commercialisation of the professional game, which has made many European clubs immensely successful in diversifying revenue streams as well as in playing terms. But for clubs in the European Union, this process has also brought new challenges. European Union law regulates economic activity between member states and as UEFA and its top clubs increase their economic powers, so the rules and regulations governing them fall within the remit of the European Commission and Court of Justice. As a result, practices such as pan‐European broadcasting and transfer of players must abide by the Treaty on the European Union. However, football also exists within a socio‐economic sphere, and this regulation is transforming football as a cultural entity; a sport that is recognised by the EU…

A cure worse than the disease? Reflections on<i>Gough and Smith v. chief constable of Derbyshire</i>

Geoff Pearson

Sociology and Political Science · Entertainment Law · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Gough and Smith had unsuccessfully appealed 1 against the imposition upon them of two-year football ‘banning orders’ under the Football Spectators Act 1989, s.14(a) as amended by the Football (Disorder) Act 2000. They both had one previous conviction for an offence of violence, unrelated to football, in 1998 and 1990 respectively. Each had been the subject of a ‘profile’ prepared by the police, which indicated that they had repeatedly been involved in, or had been near to, incidents of violence at or near football matches.

Getting Public Law Back into a Critical Condition: The Rule of Law as a Source for Immanent Critique

Geoff Pearson, Michael Salter

Law · Social & Legal Studies · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article explores a series of issues that arise in relation to the methodology of conducting a critique of legal ideologies. It addresses the attempt by the Sheffield School of public law to formulate and apply an 'immanent' model of critique that builds upon the position developed by the Frankfurt School of critical social theory. We address difficulties that arise with the Sheffield School's interpretation of this model of critique, not least the problems with its attempt to apply a clear-cut distinction between wholly internal, immanent and external modes of critique. Our overall aim is to formulate a more adequate model of ideology critique that is able to overcome the various difficulties we have discovered within the Sheffield School's model. We argue that this can be achieved without relapsing back into the no less serious contradictions which can arise with external modes of…

Legal Responses to Football ‘Hooliganism’ in Europe—Introduction

Peter T. M. Coenen, Geoff Pearson, Anastassia Tsoukala

Sociology and Political Science · ASSER international sports law series · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this introduction, the authors explain the subject and the motivations behind this collection. They explain the methodology used, the rationale for the jurisdictions chosen and the value of this contribution to the existing literature on the subject of football crowd regulation and management. They consider the transnational responses to football-related disorder: for example, the European Convention in Spectator Violence and Misbehaviour at Sports Events, and in Particular Football Matches 1985, and the relevant legislative instruments as well as the role of the European Union in the regulation of football-related disorder. The authors explain how the legal regulation of football-related disorder relates to civil rights/liberties and human rights law. Finally, the authors explain the difficulties attached to the use of the term ‘football hooliganism’.

Gone fishing: The operation of police vehicle stops in England and Wales

Geoff Pearson, Mike Rowe

Political Science and International Relations · Criminology & Criminal Justice · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article analyses the operation of police vehicle stop checks in England and Wales. In contrast to other common police powers, vehicle checks are remarkably under-regulated and have received little academic attention, but they are regularly used coercive powers supported by criminal sanction. Based upon a 6-year ethnographic study, including observations of 205 vehicle stops, this article sets out how stop checks are used as part of routine policing. We consider their effectiveness in reducing crime and assess their link to stop and search. Our data cast doubt on the effectiveness of self-generated vehicle stop checks for identifying crime and indicate that they may play a role in driving racial disproportionality in stop and search. We conclude that stop checks should be recorded by officers, which will improve the accountability of the power and could provide important data for…

A commentary on ‘&lt;i&gt;Little Hooliganz: The Inside Story of Glamorous Lads, Football Hooligans and Post-Subculturalism&lt;/i&gt;’ by Professor Steve Redhead

Dr Geoff Pearson

Gender Studies · Entertainment and Sports Law Journal · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Issue 8(2) of this Journal included the article, ‘Little Hooliganz: The Inside Story of Glamorous Lads, Football Hooligans and Post-Subculturalism’ by Prof Steve Redhead. The author is professor of Sport and Media Cultures at the Chelsea School, Brighton University, and has been carrying out research on football fan sub-cultures, including but not limited to the issue of ‘football hooliganism’, for over 20 years. He describes his work on hooliganism as part of the ‘cluster’ of postmodern sub-cultural theory, which has been under-represented since extensive academic study on the issue of football crowd disorder began in the late 1970s. Redhead considers that the phenomenon of contemporary football crowd disorder has been diminishing significantly since the early 1990s (1993: 2) and he shares the views held by academics such as Gary Armstrong and Richard Giulianotti that much of the…

Conclusions: Social Control at the Expense of Civil Liberties and Human Rights

Anastassia Tsoukala, Geoff Pearson, Peter T. M. Coenen

Sociology and Political Science · ASSER international sports law series · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Despite significant differences in both fan culture and the problems of violence and disorder in connection with football, there has been a convergence of legal and policing tools designed to manage football crowds across Europe. Set in a wider neoliberal political context, where there is an increasing emphasis on prevention and security at the expense of more traditional modes of criminal justice, the management of football crowds across Europe has seen the introduction and development of pre-emptive policing powers, administrative ‘control orders’, and the gathering and sharing of personal information on suspected ‘hooligans’. This increasing social control of football crowds has been at the expense of both traditional state civil liberties and also human rights under the ECHR. These security-centric approaches to football crowd management are disproportionate to their human rights…

Legal Responses to Football Crowd Disorder and Violence in England and Wales

Mark James, Geoff Pearson

Sociology and Political Science · ASSER international sports law series · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Legal responses to football crowd disorder in England and Wales are often seen as best-practice by authorities in other European states. This is because so-called ‘hooliganism’ was considered to be a serious problem in the UK in the 1970s and 1980s but following a series of legislative and police strategy changes, crowd disorder and violence in and around British stadia is now rare. However, while changes in policing strategy have been important in this development, we should not overestimate the impact of legislation and in particular football banning orders. Some laws have not been proven to be effective, some may be counterproductive, and other ‘non legal’ factors have played an important role in the reduction in violence and disorder. Furthermore, serious questions remain about the proportionality and legality of some policing and legislative measures when assessed against civil…

Ethical committee frameworks and processes used to evaluate humanities research require reform: Findings from a UK-wide network consultation

Jonathan Kasstan, Geoff Pearson

Sociology and Political Science · Accountability in Research · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

BACKGROUND: Qualitative Humanities research is perturbed by ethical review processes that routinely invoke epistemological assumptions skewed towards positivistic or deductive research, giving rise to several concerns, including increased risk aversion by University Research Ethics Committees (URECs) and the evaluation of qualitative research designs according to STEM standards. METHODS/MATERIALS: This paper presents findings from an AHRC-funded research network built to better understand how research ethics frameworks and processes might be reformed to more appropriately fit ethically challenging qualitative methodologies. RESULTS: There remains dissatisfaction with the current processes for awarding ethical approval and the subsequent management of ethical dimensions of projects. In spite of recent developments, UREC frameworks remain seriously flawed, with a wide divergence in the…

Experiences with Audio Feedback in a Veterinary Curriculum

Susan Rhind, Graham W. Pettigrew, Jo Spiller +1 more

Education · Journal of Veterinary Medical Education · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

On a national scale in the United Kingdom, student surveys have served to highlight areas within higher education that are not achieving high student satisfaction. Of particular concern to the veterinary and medical disciplines are the persistently poor levels of student satisfaction with academic feedback compared to students in other subjects. In this study we describe experiences with audio feedback trials in a veterinary curriculum. Students received audio feedback on either an in-course laboratory practical report or on an in-course multiple-choice test. Shortly after receiving their feedback, students were surveyed using an electronic questionnaire. In both courses, more students strongly agreed that audio feedback was helpful compared to either text-based (course A) or whole-class (course B) feedback. When asked to reflect on the helpfulness of various types of feedback they had…

The Legality and Effectiveness Of Using Football Banning Orders In The Fight Against Racism and Violence at Sports Events

Geoff Pearson, Mark James

Sociology and Political Science · ASSER international sports law series · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Social cues, such as eye gaze and pointing fingers, can increase the prioritisation of specific locations for cognitive processing.A previous study using a manual reaching task showed that, although both gaze and pointing cues altered target prioritisation (reaction times [RTs]), only pointing cues affected action execution (trajectory deviations).These differential effects of gaze and pointing cues on action execution could be because the gaze cue was conveyed through a disembodied head; hence, the model lacked the potential for a body part (i.e., hands) to interact with the target.In the present study, the image of a male gaze model, whose gaze direction coincided with two potential target locations, was centrally presented.The model either had his arms and hands extended underneath the potential target locations, indicating the potential to act on the targets (Experiment 1), or had…