arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Adam Perry

46 papers · 2007–2026

2007: 12008: 02009: 12010: 02011: 12012: 32013: 12014: 32015: 02016: 12017: 32018: 32019: 32020: 22021: 12022: 12023: 62024: 02025: 102026: 6
2007peak 10 in 20252026

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 26–46 of 46 RSS

Democratic Conventions

Adam Perry

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Section I sets out the basis of the author’s taxonomy of constitutional conventions. The taxonomy classifies conventions as either justified or unjustified. Within the category of justified conventions, a distinction is drawn between conventions that promote democracy and conventions that promote good government. Section II explains that democratic conventions all shift power in one way or another. The rest of Chapter 3 presents the various democratic conventions, including conventions that shift power to democratic bodies (section III), to more representative democratic bodies (section IV), and to the people (section V). Section VI discusses putative conventions that restrain government activity, including during and after an election period.

Identification, Declaration, and Codification

Adam Perry

Law · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter is about the identification of conventions. Courts have tended to identify conventions using a test proposed by Jennings. That test produces false positives, however. Section II sets out a better test, based on the definition from Chapter 2. Section III then considers the case for codifying conventions. The benefits of codification are likely to be modest. The risks, meanwhile, are significant. Section IV discusses whether judges should declare conventions. It is argued that, if referred a question about conventions, the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council should answer that question, depending on the nature of the question.

The Case for Conventions

Adam Perry

Law · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter is about whether it is better to regulate important matters using conventions or non-customary rules like statutes. Section II clarifies the question. Section III explains that the emergence and change of conventions is decentralized and case-based. These features give conventions important advantages over other types of rules (section IV). Compared with non-customary rules, conventions are stable and flexible. They avoid concentrations of power. Conventions also help constitutional actors to acquire, aggregate, and assess information. Section V situates the case for conventions within a broader conservative tradition. Section VI concludes by addressing several worries about conventions, namely that they are slow to arise, unsystematic, and undemocratic.

Bad Conventions

Adam Perry

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Chapters 3 and 4 discussed conventions that are justified. This chapter is about conventions that are unjustified. Three sets of conventions are singled out for criticism. The first are the conventions that give members of the royal family the right to block legislation that affects them specially (section II). The second set gives the monarch influence over ministers (section III). Finally, and perhaps more controversially, section IV argues against the convention that prevents the House of Lords from rejecting delegated legislation. Section V concludes with some suggestions about why bad conventions arise and persist, including the failure to appreciate their lack of justification.

Definition

Adam Perry

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Chapter 2 is about the definition of a constitutional convention. Section II sets out the criteria for a good definition. Later sections propose a definition that meets those criteria. Section III argues that conventions are norms, specifically rules (section IV). They arise from patterns of actions and attitudes rather than being laid down or enacted. That makes conventions a type of customary rule (section V). In addition to being customary rules, conventions are important (section VI) and political (section VII). Section VIII draws the discussion together, states the author’s preferred definition precisely, and explains why some superficially similar norms are not conventions. The rest of the chapter discusses existing definitions, including those from John Stuart Mill, Edward Freeman, AV Dicey, and Ivor Jennings (section IX).

Conventions and Laws

Adam Perry

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter is mainly about whether conventions are laws. The question is difficult because while all laws are relevant in determining people’s legal rights and duties, some rules that are not laws are also legally relevant. Somehow, we need to distinguish rules that are laws from rules that are merely legally relevant. Section II reviews and rejects all the existing tests. Then, drawing on a suggestion by Geoffrey Marshall, it distinguishes between direct and indirect legal relevance. Laws are, roughly, those rules that are of direct legal relevance. Other rules are of at most indirect legal relevance. As merely indirectly relevant rules, conventions are not laws. The practical importance of this distinction is explained. Section III explores the relationship between conventions and equity. Section IV explains how conventions could crystallize into laws, and argue that…

R (Evans) v Attorney General [2015] UKSC 21

Adam Perry

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter reviews and critiques the case of Evans v Attorney General [2015] UKSC 21. It provides an excellent opportunity to see how diverse constitutional topics, such as parliamentary sovereignty, the rule of law, the separation of powers, the monarchy, and constitutional conventions interact. It also provides a chance to reflect on the importance and strength of the principle of legality.

<i>WEDNESBURY</i> UNREASONABLENESS

Adam Perry

Law · The Cambridge Law Journal · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Administrative decisions are unlawful if they are unreasonable, in the sense that Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd. v Wednesbury Corporation made famous. What is Wednesbury unreasonableness, precisely? Courts have not clearly said, and existing academic answers are flawed. Here I propose a new answer. My claim, roughly, is that a Wednesbury unreasonable decision is one that a court is entitled, given the evidence before it, to conclude was wrong, given the evidence before the authority when it made the decision. In a slogan: Wednesbury unreasonableness is demonstrable wrongness.

Consistency in Administrative Law

Adam Perry

Law · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter argues that English law should require administrative officials to treat like cases alike. The exception is if an official is more likely to decide a case correctly than the official who decided a previous and like case. The burden should be on the claimant to prove that his or her case was treated differently than a previous and like case. The burden should be on the official to show that he or she falls within the scope of the exception. Although these claims are relatively modest, they are practically important. In particular, they suggest that many cases in English administrative law should have been decided differently.

Plainly Wrong

Adam Perry

Law · Modern Law Review · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

English law and wider common law jurisprudence have endorsed the condition that an appellate court should reject a trial judge's finding of fact which it believes is ‘plainly wrong’. Courts have not explained what makes a finding plainly wrong, however. Scholars have largely ignored the issue. This article draws on recent work in epistemology to provide a new analysis of the plainly wrong standard. Rationally, a court should not believe both (1) that a judge is a better fact finder and (2) that the judge was wrong to find some fact. If it does believe both, it should abandon the belief it is less confident of. So, a court should reject a judge's finding if it is more confident that it is wrong than that the judge is a better fact finder. This analysis has implications for review of administrative fact finding and for judicial deference generally.

Pardons

Adam Perry

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Pardon powers are ubiquitous but difficult to justify. A pardon power is, roughly, a power that is (a) possessed by a non-judicial official, (b) used to cancel legal liability to a criminal sanction in a particular case without thereby altering the law, and (c) unconstrained by law. This chapter provides a novel defence of pardon powers. It argues that pardon powers are an appropriate vehicle for selective deviation. Selective deviation calls for a power that can be used to set aside the code without changing it. It calls for a power that can be used inconsistently. Moreover, it calls for a power that is not in the hands of a body institutionally disposed towards consistency in decision-making, such as the judiciary. This defence overcomes various objections to pardon powers, such as the objection from the separation of powers and the objection from the rule of law.

Strained Interpretations

Adam Perry

Law · Oxford Journal of Legal Studies · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Judges often give statutes strained interpretations. What makes an interpretation strained? What, if anything, justifies a strained interpretation? Is there always a point past which an interpretation would be too strained, or are there some interpretations which judges are entitled to adopt, whatever a statute says? I claim to answer all of these questions. Using the formula about conditional probability known as Bayes’ theorem, I offer a precise definition of a strained interpretation, and identify two reasons for strained interpretations. I claim that the case for strained interpretations is often stronger than is realised, and illustrate that claim with a novel defence of the House of Lords’ decision in Anisminic Ltd v Foreign Compensation Commission. Finally, I suggest that even if a legislature is sovereign, there may be meanings which a legislature is unable to enact into law.…

Standing and civic virtue

Farrah Ahmed, Adam Perry

Law · Oxford University Research Archive (ORA) (University of Oxford) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Analyses the concept of public interest standing in judicial review cases. Lists the criteria that have been used by the courts to assess an applicant's public interest standing, and suggests why these claimant-based factors are controversial. Proposes a rationale for the factors that is based on the notion of civic virtue. Discusses ways in which the law of public interest standing could be improved.

Abstract: The State of Plastic Surgery Education Outside of the Operating Room

Mark Fisher, Stephen Lu, Adam D. Perry +3 more

Gender Studies · Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery Global Open · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

INTRODUCTION: Plastic surgery education consists of technical skills, surgical decision-making, and the knowledge necessary to provide safe patient care. Competency in these modalities is ensured by requiring case minimums, and oral and written examinations. However, there is a paucity of information detailing the various teaching modalities residency programs utilize outside of the operating room (OR). METHODS: A 16-question survey was sent to all integrated and independent program directors. Information regarding non-surgical resident education was collected and analyzed. RESULTS: There were 43- responses (45%). Most programs had 6–10 faculty (43%), and a majority (85%) required faculty to participate in resident education outside of the OR. Residents most commonly had 3–4 hours (43%) of protected educational time 1 day per week (53%). Non-surgical education consisted of weekly…

Advances in High-Resolution Spectroscopic Measurements of Molecular Ions in the Mid-Infrared

Adam J. Perry

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Infrared spectra of molecules typically probe transitions between rotation-vibration en-ergy levels. Such transitions provide valuable information to theorists who try to map out the potential energy landscape of molecules and produce models and methods to predict the spectra of other molecules. Predictions of molecular vibrational spectra are becoming more

Constitutional Conventions and the <scp>P</scp>rince of <scp>W</scp>ales

Adam Perry

Sociology and Political Science · Modern Law Review · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The U pper T ribunal (Administrative Appeals Chamber) held in Evans v Information Commissioner that certain correspondence between P rince C harles and government officials must be disclosed under freedom of information legislation. Much of the judgment was devoted to a discussion of the constitutional conventions applicable to P rince C harles, and the case provides a useful example of how conventions and laws can interact. In this note, I argue that the U pper T ribunal misunderstood how conventions are distinguished from one another, and misapplied the test for the identification of conventions.

Exploring the critical moments when the Baptist denomination divided: Does revisiting these moments give hope to reconciliation between the ‘Union’ and ‘Convention’?

Luvuyo Ntombana, Adam Perry

Law · HTS Teologiese Studies / Theological Studies · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article evaluated interpretations between members of the Baptist Union of South Africa (BUSA) and the Baptist Convention of South Africa (BCSA), revisiting a particular moment, the merger talks of 1980s, at the time when the Baptist Church further entrenched these divisions. The Baptist Church has a crippling historical relationship to the present, particularly as members of the faith interpret their sides of the story as being the ‘right’ ones. This article grew out of the ethnographic work undertaken by the primary author, Luvuyo Ntombana (2007), and his involvement with the Baptist Church. It is felt that in order to create a sacred Church, congregations ought to move away from arguing about past events toward a more positive rethinking of what lessons can be learned from the past. Therefore, this article argued that by revisiting critical moments for the Church, such as the…

Acceptance and Social Rules

Adam Perry

Political Science and International Relations · Cadmus - EUI Research Repository (European University Institute) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

One of HLA Hart’s main contributions to jurisprudence is his theory of social rules. Hart claimed that a social rule has an external, behavioural aspect, and an internal, attitudinal aspect. However, Hart’s description of the internal aspect of social rules left much to be desired. Drawing on recent work in the philosophy of action, I argue that the internal aspect of social rules is best thought of as the widespread ‘acceptance’ that an action should be performed. The technical notion of acceptance I rely on is related to Hart’s own understanding of acceptance, but the two differ in several important respects.

Unlucky Section 13: Sexual Activity Between Children and the Sexual Offences Act 2003

Adam Perry

Sociology and Political Science · King s Law Journal · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The purpose of section 13 of the Sexual Offences Act 2003 is to protect children from sexual exploitation by other children. To achieve that end, the section prohibits almost all sexual activity between children, and so prohibits mostly innocent, ordinary activity. The government in 2003 trusted that prosecutors would exercise their discretion to trim section 13’s overreach. However, prosecutorial discretion carries its own high costs: it deters conduct beyond section 13’s intended scope, and it undermines the rule of law. Moreover, there was a better alternative, open to the government at the time. Prohibiting only sexual activity between dissimilar aged children would have largely achieved section 13’s purpose without the same need for prosecutorial discretion.

Which Cases are "Such Cases": Interpreting and Applying Section 12 of the Clayton Act

Adam B. Perry

Political Science and International Relations · Fordham law review · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This Note examines an issue currently dividing the nation's circuit courts of appeal. The issue presented is how courts should interpret and apply Section 12 of the Clayton Act, the long-arm and venue statute for private antitrust actions brought against corporate defendants. Section 12's poor construction has resulted in courts applying section 12 differently to similar sets of facts. This Note thoroughly discusses section 12 as it relates to antitrust law generally and the procedural elements of bringing a private antitrust action in federal court, examines the existing section 12 case law that illustrates the conflict and the arguments on both sides, and proposes a hybrid solution that best satisfies Congress's intent.