RUNNING HEAD: Interpreting unfamiliar graphs INTERPRETING UNFAMILIAR GRAPHS: A GENERATIVE, ACTIVITY THEORETIC MODEL°

Abstract

Interpreting unfamiliar graphs 2 INTERPRETING UNFAMILIAR GRAPHS: A GENERATIVE, ACTIVITY THEORETIC MODEL ABSTRACT: Research on graphing presents its results as if knowing and understanding was something stored in peoples ’ minds independent of the situation that they find themselves in. Thus, there are no models that situate interview responses to graphing tasks. How, then, we question, are the interview texts produced? How do respondents begin and end utterances? and What is the relation between words and gestures used as part of the communication? In this study, a dialectical model is presented that accounts for the situated nature of unfamiliar graph interpretation at three levels— collectively motivated activity, goal-directed actions, and unmediated operations. The tensions or contradictions inherent in these dialectical units at each level are understood to be the forces that drive situated graph interpretations. Informed by cultural-historical activity theory, graph interpretation sessions with scientists are used in this article as exemplary data.