Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science
Competent Workplace Mathematics: How Signs Become Transparent
See on the mapAbstract
Abstract: Many scientists, asked to interpret unfamiliar graphs that have nev-ertheless been culled from introductory undergraduate courses in their own field, experience problems and cannot give the standard answer accepted in the field. At the same time, these same scientists turn out to be highly competent when it comes to graphs from their immediate domain of research. In fact, sci-entists no longer separate talk about the graph and talk about the object that is represented. In this research, which is based on ethnographic studies among scientists and technicians, I show how interpretation initially requires tool me-diation. When scientists have become familiar with phenomenon, data collec-tion, and resulting graphs, they interpret the latter correctly without requiring prior transformation. As a result of scientists ’ embodied laboratory work, talk about graph and talk about the object are often indistinguishable. The process of developing competency in graph use is equivalent to that of a tool that be-comes transparent to the consciousness of its user; I describe this process in terms of activity theory as a transition from tool-mediated action to operation. In everyday cognition, no distinction is made between signs and referents (Hei-degger, 1977). When we come to a red light, we stop rather than going through a sequence that involves interpreting the light, thinking “I have to stop, ” and then