arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Sociology and Political Science

Pregnant Woman and Unborn Child: Legal Adversaries?

See on the map

Abstract

Maternal prenatal negligence cases are... plagued by moral complexity. The imposition of a duty of care upon pregnant women will interfere with their bodily integrity, privacy and autonomy rights in a way that it would not interfere with other persons who are not pregnant.1 In July 2002, a woman who was pregnant and HIV positive refused to undergo treatment that would have had the effect of reducing the risk of transmitting the virus to her unborn child. The President of the High Court, Finnegan J., advised her that if she refused to give birth in hospital he would have to make “much more serious orders affecting her bodily integrity.”2 What could such orders possibly be—forced confinement, 24-hour supervision, or the forced administration of medication? Since further details were not forthcoming we can only speculate. At issue here is the balancing of the rights of a woman and her unborn child in situations where what is medically required for the good of one may not necessarily be for the good, medical or otherwise, of the other. While possible legal conflicts of interest between pregnant women and their unborn children may be relatively new to Ireland— to the best of my knowledge this is the only Irish case of its kind—this issue has arisen in other jurisdictions. It is therefore worthwhile to see how these conflicts have been dealt with elsewhere as a clue to how they might be treated here. In this paper, I shall look at the way such problems have been dealt with in English law and in some of the states of the U.S.A. I shall suggest that, from the slender indications we have had, it seems more likely that the Irish courts will deal with such matters more as the Americans have done rather than as our English neighbours have done.

More like this