arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Law

St George's Health Care NHS Trust vs SR v Collins and Others ex parte S

Kay Lalor, Andrés Pucheu, Annapurna Waughray

· Bloomsbury eBooks

See on the map

Abstract

NHS Trust v S, R v Collins and others ex parteS 1 reiterates general principles of patient autonomy and self-determination, it is of special significance for women because of its unequivocal affirmation that a competent pregnant woman can refuse medical treatment even if that refusal may result in harm to her or the foetus. 2 It also establishes that mental health legislation cannot be used to prevent a competent pregnant woman from exercising this right.In confirming that the right of an adult of sound mind to refuse any or all medical treatment 'reflects the autonomy of each individual and the right of self-determination', 3 the Court of Appeal held that while pregnancy increases the personal responsibilities of a woman it does not diminish her entitlement to decide whether or not to undergo medical treatmentan unborn child is not a separate person from its mother.Its need for medical assistance does not prevail over her rights. 4 St George's Health Care Trust v S, R v Collins and others ex parte S thus addresses three important issues: first, a pregnant woman's right to decline medical treatment even where this may harm her unborn child; second, that this right is not diminished because her decision to exercise it contravenes societal expectations of pregnant women or appears morally repugnant; and third, mental health legislation cannot be deployed to detain and treat an individual against her will merely because her thinking process is unusual or even bizarre, irrational, and contrary to the views of most people.In the case of a pregnant woman, the fact that her thinking may result in harm to her unborn baby does not mean that she must therefore be mentally disordered. ContextHistorically, women have existed in the domain of the 'private', especially in relation to pregnancy and motherhood.Often this meant that the voices and experiences of pregnant women were silenced or minimised.There is a long association of female reproduction with weakness or 'hysteria', which was said to show that women were unfit to participate in the 1 [1999] Fam 26. 2 Ibid, 43. 3 Ibid. 4Ibid, 50.

More like this