arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

Attack by a Turkey: Learning to Write History from Bernard Bailyn

Robert J. Allison

· The New England Quarterly

See on the map

Abstract

IN the mid-1980s, Bernard Bailyn, having earlier redefined our understanding of the American Revolution's origins, turned his attention to the great debate of 1787–1788 on ratifying the Constitution. During a year as Pitt Professor of American History at Cambridge University (1986–1987), he wrote a preliminary version of his lecture “The Ideological Fulfillment of the American Revolution,” which he delivered at Oxford University in the Spring of 1987. He gave another version at the American Historical Association Annual Meeting in Washington that December.In 1987, the nation observed the Constitutional Convention's bicentennial. Chief Justice Warren Burger had retired from the Court to lead the commemorative efforts. For Bailyn, however, the important events were the public debates over ratification after the Convention finished its work, not the Convention itself. He was fond of James Madison's comment from 1796, that the Constitution was “nothing but a dead letter until life and validity were breathed into it by the voice of the people”: its meaning would not be found in the Convention at Philadelphia, but in the state conventions which ratified it. Bailyn used this quotation as his epigraph when he republished his own 1987 lecture on ratification in an essay concluding the twenty-fifth and fiftieth anniversary editions of Ideological Origins of the American Revolution.1Bailyn returned to Harvard in the fall of 1987, the same time I arrived as a graduate student. A used copy of the 1967 edition of The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution, which cost fifty cents at the Phoenix Public Library's book sale, had made me think seriously of studying history, rather than continuing on my career trajectory as a cook at the Phoenix Hilton. I came to Boston, finished college at the Harvard Extension School, and in the fall of 1987 enrolled in Bailyn's seminar. Others have written about Bailyn's teaching method and the seminar's format, which did not change from year to year, though the students did. Our cohort did not seem very exciting—there were a lot of awkward silences. Either we were too awed by Bailyn, or too impressed with ourselves, to move the conversation along. Early on he suggested paper topics. The one most intriguing to me was to look into the relationships among the Otis family of Barnstable—a remarkable group that included a diverse array of characters who wrote a lot. Their papers, he told us, were waiting to be mined at the Massachusetts Historical Society. When I went to talk to him about the topic, he was apologetic. One of the students, a visitor from England, had already chosen that one. Why didn't I pick something else?He had also mentioned the origins of the Second Amendment. I had done some research on the Constitution's ratification, thanks to a summer NEH fellowship which had allowed me to examine the role of slavery in the constitutional debates. I went to work on the topic, using the terrific volumes being produced by the State Historical Society of Wisconsin.2 Midway through the semester he began one seminar session sliding an index card across the table to the student on my right, “Here's an article that will be helpful!” Then to the student on my left, “I just found a document you should look at,” and she busily wrote down the citation. Then he gave me a blank look and asked, “What are you working on again?”A week or two later I went to our assigned meeting on the paper. After hearing about my pile of research, he asked, “Why are you writing this?” I sensed that the wrong answer would be, “Because the paper I wanted to write was taken, so you told me to do this one.” So, I said something else—not realizing that this question, “Why are you writing this?” as his “So what?” or “Who cares?” or “What's the news here?” was not about me, but about the topic. It was not the last time he would ask it. This has been a valuable lesson in teaching, as was his constant effort that semester to spark our lagg

More like this