arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

The Ideological Origins of American Federalism , by Alison L. LaCroix.

Bruce Miroff

· Publius The Journal of Federalism

See on the map

Abstract

Since the publication of Bernard Bailyn’s classic work, The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution, in 1967, numerous authors have used both his intellectual approach and the opening words of his title. Working in this vein, Alison LaCroix, a legal historian, attempts to do for American federalism what Bailyn famously accomplished for the American Revolution. In LaCroix’s view, the sources of the American “federal idea” (p. 6) have heretofore been overlooked. The prevailing scholarly consensus treats federalism as a “by-product” (p. 2) of debates at the Constitutional Convention in 1787, an unintended structure of governmental authority that had to be retrospectively turned into political theory in the pages of The Federalist and other works. LaCroix rejects the standard portrait of the Convention as the birthplace of federalism. She suggests that the Founders’ thinking on the possibilities of dividing authority was informed by intellectual developments in earlier years. The wellspring for the “federal idea,” she argues, was not the revolutionary period preceding the Constitutional Convention, but the decade-long debate of 1765–1775 between spokesmen for the British Empire and spokesmen for the American colonies.

More like this