arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Law

Recognition of New Interests in the Law of Torts

E. F. Albertsworth

· California Law Review

See on the map

Abstract

Recognition of New Interests in the Law of TortsISTORICALLY, the process of giving recognition to the claims, wants, and demands of individuals as subjects of rights was first by writ or remedy, next by admitting certain rights, and lastly by recognizing certain interests.Under this method, if there was no appropriate remedy, there could be no legal right, however pressing the claim might be, morally, for recognition by the law.In such case, where the law itself did not grant relief, either self-help or the help of the gods provided practically the only method of redress.Only slowly, through extension of writs and remedies, and by the enforcement of duties, by the praetors in Roman Law and by the chancellors in English Equity, did first duties arise, and then legal rights, resulting consequently in independence of the methods of enforcement; yet considerable time elapsed before the final step was taken, namely, to recognize the interest, which existed apart from the law, and then to elevate this into a legal right, protected by the proper legal remedy.The stage of development from remedy to interest is clearly seen both in the Roman and in the common law.In the primitive law, when the state was weak, self-help or help of the gods, to secure protection of the interests of individuals, was largely relied upon.So in the Roman Law the creditor might bring.the debtor into court through force, by the legis actio per man=s injectionem; or he might himself seize the goods of the debtor who failed to pay his debt, by the legis actio per pignoris capionem. 1 Elaborate provisions, therefore, in both the Roman and the common law, grew up with respect to self-help, as recapture of chattels from a thief on fresh pursuit; re-entry on land of which one had been forcibly dispossessed; defense of one's person or nearest relatives; abatement of nuisance where there was no opportunity to apply I Sohm, Institutes of Roman Law, 3d ed., 229; Pound, Readings in Roman Law, 88."It is not at all certain that the legis actio per pignoris capionern is a vestige of self-help, although so given by some writers on Roman Law.Nevertheless, in view of the fact that the lex Julia de Vi forbade forcible enforcement of debts by the creditor, imposing severe penalties upon the creditor, it has been placed among the actions of self-help; but the action was from early times confined in narrow limits.See

More like this