arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Jan Halberda

12 papers · 2011–2025

2011: 22012: 02013: 02014: 22015: 12016: 12017: 02018: 02019: 02020: 12021: 02022: 12023: 12024: 12025: 2
2011peak 2 in 20112025

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–12 of 12 RSS

The principle of good faith and fair dealing in English contract law

Jan Halberda

Law · Pravovedenie · · cited 10× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Given that continental civil law scholarship applies the concept of good faith in either a subjective (honesty in fact) or objective sense (good faith and fair dealing), the present article focuses on the latter one. The traditional view in England and Wales discards the recognition of a general principle of good faith and fair dealing in English law. English courts have adopted a piecemeal solutions approach (as shown by the judicial decisions issued in Interfoto Picture Library (1987) and Walford v. Miles (1992)). Meanwhile, the principle in question, along with the concept of the freedom of contract, is one of the most important principles of the continental civil law tradition (cf. art. 1104 of the French Civil Code, § 157, § 242 of the German Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, art. 2 (1) of the Swiss Zivilgesetzbuch, art. 6:2 Burgerlijk Wetboek, art. 5 of the Polish Civil Code, art. 2 (1)…

Winds of Change in Common Law Jurisdictions

Jan Halberda

Political Science and International Relations · Homo Politicus (Academy of Humanities and Economics in Lodz) · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter finds the emergence of the concept of good faith and fair dealing (good faith in an objective sense) in English contract law as a consequence of a dialogue that has been conducted by courts of leading common law jurisdictions over the past several decades. While the prevailing view denies recognition of the general principle of good faith in the law of England and Wales, recent cases acknowledge, in certain circumstances, the possibility of implying it between parties to a contract. This change of heart is plausibly enhanced by a comparative analysis of authorities that originate in such Commonwealth countries as Australia and Canada. The courts in these jurisdictions, in turn, carefully examine those American (United States’) sources, wherein the duty of good faith in the performance of contracts was overtly recognized much earlier.

Argumentacja historyczno-prawna w orzecznictwie Izby Lordów przełomu XX i XXI wieku na przykładzie nawiązań do sprawy Moses v. MacFerlan z 1760 roku

Jan Halberda

Law · Krakowskie Studia z Historii Państwa i Prawa · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Arguments of a Legal Historical Nature as Found in Judicial Decisions Taken by the House of Lords at the Turn of the 21st Century and Illustrated by References to the Case Moses v. MacFerlan 1760 Through an analysis of cases of unjust enrichment (law of restitution), and investigation of the lines along which the judges invoked the landmark case of Moses v. MacFerlan (1760), the author of the paper discusses the role played by legal history in disputes carried on in the House of Lords. After elaborating the details of the aforementioned case (2), he presents the doctrine of implied contract that prevailed in the 19th century (3), and discusses the opinions of the Lords articulated at the turn of the twenty-first century on the occasion of their discussing the meaning of the principle of unjust enrichment (4a). Likewise he discusses the introduction into English law of the change of…

Mistake of law and mistake of fact in English law of restitution

Jan Halberda

Law · Tijdschrift voor Rechtsgeschiedenis / Revue d Histoire du Droit / The Legal History Review · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The paper discusses the history of the English law doctrine according to which the mistake of law ( error iuris ) is a bar for restitution. The author seeks to analyze the premises of mistake that led to recovery of the payment. Since the adjudication of the leading case Bilbie v . Lumley (1802) it was settled by the courts that he who had paid while operating under mistake of fact could demand restitution. On the other hand the one who acted under mistake of law could not. Over the last two centuries, until the ground-breaking decision in Kleinwort Benson Ltd v . Lincoln City Council (1999), the distinction into mistake of law and mistake of fact was very important in cases of undue payment. The author ventures whether there are any foundations for the promotion of the thesis that the aforementioned distinction might be an example of the reception of continental doctrines by the…

Equity and Equality in Richard Francis's Maxims of Equity1

Jan Halberda

Political Science and International Relations · Jagiellonian University Repository (Jagiellonian University) · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter presents various patterns of using the term “equity” in Richard Francis's book Maxims of Equity (London, 1727) and its affinity with both law and equality. This chapter refers to the Anglo-American legal tradition. It examines a work of legal literature published during the period when the understanding of the concept of equity was being transformed: the shift from case-to-case adjudication towards the establishment of equity law as a mature legal system based on the doctrine of precedent. The titular maxims of equity were, and are, the guiding principles of the legal order around which the interpretation of particular legal doctrines revolves. The chapter researches the links between concepts of equity, law, justice, and equality, focusing, in particular, on the maxim “Equality is equity.” It shows that the problem of equal treatment of similarly positioned parties was a…

Introduction. Kaleidoscope

Iwona Barwicka-Tylek, Jan Halberda, Maciej Mikuła

Political Science and International Relations · Homo Politicus (Academy of Humanities and Economics in Lodz) · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The present volume is the result of two international workshops organised in 2023 at the Faculty of Law and Administration of the Jagiellonian University in Kraków. These were the milestones of the project entitled “Hector: Heritage, Culture, Norms,” 1 which was funded by the Jagiellonian University in the framework of the Initiative of Excellence – Research University programme: “Research Platforms in the Heritage Priority Research Area (2nd edition)” (2022–2024). The sequel to this project is the research group “Hector. Heritage, Culture, Norms 2.0” (2024–2026) operating within the Critical Heritage Studies Hub, another part of the Initiative of Excellence – Research University programme. 2

The Spurious Precedent of High Trees (1947): Excessive Judicial Law-Making in English Law

Jan Halberda

Law · Forum Prawnicze · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The article, after presenting the underpinnings of the doctrine of precedent (section 1), and acknowledging the law-making role of courts in England and Wales (section 2), focuses on the High Trees case decided in 1947. Section 3 presents its facts, section 4 outlines the reasoning that led to the judgment, while section 5 discusses the outcome of this ruling, which invited recognition of the so-called High Trees principle, which is the doctrine of promissory estoppel. While this case is the starting point for cases of promissory estoppel in modern law, it is also an illustration of how excessive judicial law-making can go beyond reasonable limits.

Proprietary estoppel – koń trojański prawa spadkowego?

Jan Halberda

Law · Ksiegarnia Akademicka Publishing eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Proprietary Estoppel – A Trojan Horse in the Succession Law? In recent decades the doctrine of proprietary estoppel has been applied to avoid the formalism of the Wills Act 1837. That act sets out the requirements of formal validity of a will. The proprietary estoppel could be applied if a carer has spent a significant part of his or her life taking care for another in reliance of his promise to transfer all or part of the estate to her. Afterwards it frequently turned out that irrespective of the deceased’s promises and the carer’s detrimental reliance the estate passed to distant relatives due to non-compliance with the Wills Act 1837. In such cases the courts often intervened to give a helping hand to such carers thereby fulfilling the goal of equity – as in a case of Re Basham (1986). Over time, the doctrine of proprietary estoppel began to be abused. Today it is applied in cases of…

MECHANIZM PROCESOWY ‘WAIVER OF TORT’ W ŚWIETLE PRZEMIAN ANGIELSKIEGO ‘COMMON LAW’

Jan Halberda

Law · Zeszyty Prawnicze · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

THE DOCTRINE OF WAIVER OF TORT IN THE LIGHT OF ENGLISH COMMON LAW TRANSFORMATIONSummary The waiver of tort was a legal fiction that enabled a plaintiff to sue in quasi-contract in lieu of tort. This was a common law doctrine that resulted from the domination of procedural rules over substantive ones. Each of medieval writs initiated peculiar proceedings that had been drafted specially for separate causes of action. As this proceedings differentiated between themselves, plaintiffs attempted to use those writs that restricted the scope of applicable defenses. Hence one of the most popular actions was a quasi-contractual formula named “indebitatus assumpsit for money had and received”. As compared with the tort actions this formula enabled plaintiff to avoid consequences of “actio personalis moritur cum persona” rule and shortened periods of limitation. That is the reason why plaintiffs…

Angielska doktryna promissory estoppel a polska klauzula nadużycia prawa

Jan Halberda

Law · Krakowskie Studia z Historii Państwa i Prawa · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The English doctrine of promissory estoppel and the Polish clause of abuse of law The article discusses the problem of evolution and the premises used in applying the English concept known as promissory estoppel. The birth of this legal concept has been discussed on the example of the most important court cases, the so called leading cases, such as, among others, that of High Trees (1947) and Combe v. Combe (1951), in which it was lord Denning who adjudicated. In the article, the author also analyzes the general principles of invoking promissory estoppel. He indicates that in the course of a court trial it is necessary to prove the existence of a promise, on the basis of which the person who was promised something, while acting in accordance with the common sense, decided to withdraw and by undertaking certain definite steps ultimately suffered a loss, whereas withdrawal on the part of…

Niesłuszne zbogacenie w polskim kodeksie zobowiązań z 1933 r.

Jan Halberda

Law · Jagiellonian University Repository (Jagiellonian University) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This paper is concerned with the law of restitution that was in force in Poland during the inter-war period. After 1918 Poland was divided into five legal regions (section 1.1). The state authorities nominated the Committee of Drafters whose task was to unify the law (1.2). In respect of unjustified enrichment the drafters took into account contemporary laws – Code Napoléon, ABGB, BGB, Obligationenrecht (1.3). After more than one decade the code of obligations (1933) finally went into force in 1934. The code provided for the premises (2.1) and the object of the action founded on unjustified enrichment (2.2). The code lacked however the regulation that might answer the question on this remedy’s nature, namely whether it was a subsidiary or an independent one (2.3). While the drafters took into account Austrian, French, German and Swiss civil codes, it seems that the Polish unjustified…

Paralely mezi římským právem soukromým a anglickým common law (ilitigatio, obligatio)

Jan Halberda

Law · Jagiellonian University Repository (Jagiellonian University) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

The paper starts with the presentation of factors that propably stand behind the analogies between Roman Civil Law and English Common Law (1). These factors concern the framework of sources of law – the dominance of case-law, the dogma of unalterable good-old law (2). Then the text presents the phenomenon of domination of procedural rules over the substantive ones. Even English legal historians, although reluctant to concede that Romanisation also took place in Albion, admit that to a certain degree “their” original writs and forms of action in common law functioned similarly to the formulary system of Roman law (3). A number of parallels was detectable in the sphere of substantive law as well. There the paper focuses on the obligation law, especially the contract law (4) and restitution law (5). Due to the procedural reasons (“ubi remedium, ibi ius” - rule), the separate branches of…