Social Sciences · Communication
Review of “Are We the 99%? The Occupy Movement, Feminism, and Intersectionality”
See on the mapAbstract
When social movements attempt to speak for wide swaths of the population, they have faced criticism for their exclusion of many groups. In particular, many critiqued the 1970s feminist movement for ignoring the experiences and needs of non-white women as well as LGBTQ people, and activists inside this movement formed separate organizations, subgroups, and coalitions to better address their needs (Ferree and Hess 2002; Mann and Huffman 2005; Roth 2017; Schneider and Pham 2017). Similar to how the feminist movement, among others, marginalized some groups and then became segmented, Are We the 99%? demonstrates how the Occupy Movement disregarded various identities and issues of its constituencies to its own detriment. Hurwitz documents the Occupy Movement through an ethnographic examination of the largest centers of its activism on both the East and West Coasts of the United States. In addition to her 2012 participant observation, Hurwitz interviewed 73 movement participants in-depth. Although her data collection began after the largest movement events in fall of 2011 and involved limited hours in the field, she appears to have overcome this not only through her interviews, but also through a digital ethnography of the movement that was both televised and well covered on social media and in movement documents. Rather than examine the movement as a whole, Hurwitz focused her analysis on the experiences of women and queer activists in order to correct the male-dominated media record.