arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Gender Studies

Gay Men and Feminist Women in the Fight for Equality: “What Did You Do During the Second Wave, Daddy?”

Evan Brody

· QED A Journal in GLBTQ Worldmaking

See on the map

Abstract

Over the past decade various events in the United States have provoked a renewed focus on social activism. Social movements related to racial justice, environmental activism, women's rights, affordable housing, LGBTQ+ rights, gun control, and labor rights, to name just a few, have dominated mainstream news reporting and social media postings. This attention has also engendered a conversation about coalition building and the ways in which groups can leverage their relative relation to power to not only help their own causes, but also to bring awareness and attention to other marginalized groups. These moments of activism are often assumed to be in conversation with one another, but in reality the connection between marginalized groups is not automatic, but purposively and intentionally cultivated through coalition building and dialogue. It is within this cultural context, and with this assumption in mind, that D. Travers Scott's Gay Men and Feminist Women in the Fight for Equality enters the conversation.Although not a historical project, the book is motivated by past anecdotal evidence about the connection between gay men and feminist women in the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries. Scott scrutinizes these assumed links throughout the manuscript and asks: “What have been the communications between, about, and among feminist women and gay men in their respective social movements” (127)? This question is explored through a variety of methods and texts, such as historiographic discourse, archival evidence, representations in film and scholarly texts, online communities, and the voices of the gay men and feminist women involved in struggles for equality. Although Scott acknowledges the strategic essentialism that accompanies organizing individuals within distinct and clear gender and/or sexual identities, his use of multiple theories and methods, both interpretive and empirical, represents a queer methodology, informed by the work of scholars such as Jack Halberstam, among others, which refuses dominant modes of producing and validating knowledge and recognizes that all subjects are constructed and potentially unstable.Scott connects Foucauldian ideas of power-knowledge and its discourses to Manuel Castell's work on networks to better understand how webs of overlapping communicative and power relations between feminist women and gay men are organized into both cooperative and competitive relations. It is interesting that he also uses Karan Barad's work on entanglement to push forward understandings of identity as fluid and changing. Scott interweaves these theories most robustly in the Introduction and penultimate chapter, though the residue and influence of each, especially as discrete concepts, is apparent throughout the book. The use of Barad's notion of entanglement, again aligned with the tenets of queer theory, allows Scott to acknowledge the ways in which subjectivities and subjects are not separate things, but rather entangled ongoing processes of becoming and re-becoming. He also recognizes the ways in which studying this dynamism forces researchers to make an “agential cut” that acknowledges the boundary making we take up to discuss, unpack, and compare identities. This focus comes up often throughout the book as Scott begins with seemingly fixed categories, feminist women/gay men, constructed as such to recognize the political necessity of doing so, while still acknowledging and centering the idea that these social categories are discursively constituted and highly contingent.In chapter 1 Scott focuses on what has been said historically, in books and magazines, about these two groups. His findings situate the competing and often contradictory public memories of these social movements, especially as they relate to social acceptance, civil rights, and media visibility, in order to illustrate how the discursive residue of the past, including its erasures of certain identities and its elevation of others, influ

More like this