arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations

The Soldiers' Tale: Bearing Witness to Modern War (review)

K. J. Phillips

· Biography

See on the map

Abstract

92 Biography 21.1 (Winter 1998) look to the role of sentiment in what seem to have been the most important crises of Jefferson's life—above all, the death of his wife, but also the earlier death of his sister Jane, and perhaps even the conclusion of his crush on Maria Cosway, as evidenced in the famous Head and Heart letter. If "The Life and Morals of Jesus" was the ultimate expression of Jefferson's religious sensibility, its roots run deeper than arid discussions about the quaUties of a rational deity, and his estimation of Jesus as a moral teacher says a great deal about how he might have understood his own religious biography. Indeed, what distinguished Jefferson most from Priestley's deism was his extended preoccupation with Jesus as an authoritative human figure of justice and compassion. We know that figure reflects somehow Jefferson's religious opinions, but Jefferson's Jesus has yet to be read as a mirror of Jefferson's soul. But this is perhaps tantamount to asking for a different kind of book than the author chose to write, and on his own terms Gaustad has written an exceUent account of Jefferson's public opinions about religion and his initiatives to protect its free expression. Frank Shuffelton Samuel Hynes, The Soldiers' Tale: Bearing Witness to Modern War. New York: Allen Lane-Penguin, 1997. 318 pp. $24.95, ISBN 0670 -86585-0. Samuel Hynes thoughtfully and provocatively analyzes memoirs by mostly British and American soldiers of World War I, World War II, and the Vietnam War. Although he does point out differences in style— WW II veterans adopt a more cynical, detached tone from the time they're shipped out, Vietnam vets use dirtier language—he is reaUy fashioning a consistent genre, a single "tale." Soldiers throughout the century, Hynes maintains, approach horrors with dispassionate, clinical realism; rarely mention the causes for which they are supposedly fighting; and often remember their war years as the best time of their Uves. At first incredible, this last claim for the personal rewards of war, which Hynes locates in comradeship and especiaUy the excitement of danger, becomes in the end his most valuable contribution. Unfortunately, he seems to be using this evidence of the pleasures of mUitary service to fend off antiwar sentiments, as if to say, "We boys are having a good time, so leave us alone!" Yet pacifists might also do well to face up to the positive enticements of war, as they search for causes and possible alternatives to the vast carnage of this century. Hynes writes in a gripping and lucid style. He prides himself on the objectivity of his vision, that of a Dante guiding us through heU, although he has, to my mind, a few blind spots. When he corrects the Reviews 93 view that aU WW I veterans became disillusioned, by pointing to more cheerful records, he annoyingly labels the despair a "myth," instead of calling both the sour and the nostalgic voices partial truths (101). He disapproves of the use of WW I as a "cautionary" tale, because its horrors were only "intermittent" (55). Hynes's airy word "myth" simUarly dismisses the version of the Vietnam War as a "horror story" (200). He advises us not to epitomize that war in the famous photo of a naked "little girl" running from what is "apparently" her napalmed vUlage (200). (Is it significant that he doesn't say "napalmed girl"?) And he offensively judges the behavior of Japanese suicide fighters in WW II "so aUen as not to be human" (163), yet he treats earlier European dreams of "death or glory, or both" much more indulgently—futile, maybe, but thoroughly human (47). Hynes dramatically shows that while British aristocrats at the outset of WW I were still expecting battle to resemble "field sports," technology, randomness, and anonymity made it much more difficult to glorify and aestheticize war (33). Twentieth-century war narratives instead "subvert the expectations of romance," defined as a world where individual actions and decisions cou

More like this