Social Sciences · Political Science and International Relations
Thomas Jefferson: A Biography of Spirit and Flesh by Thomas S. Kidd (review)
See on the mapAbstract
Reviewed by: Thomas Jefferson: A Biography of Spirit and Flesh by Thomas S. Kidd Daniel McDonough (bio) Thomas Jefferson: A Biography of Spirit and Flesh. By Thomas S. Kidd. (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2022. Pp. 310. $30.00 cloth; $23.00 paper) There is much more of spirit than of flesh in this stimulating biography of Thomas Jefferson from the prolific pen of Thomas S. Kidd, a leading scholar of early America and author of several important works in the field, including studies of general religious history, the Great Awakening, and biographies of George Whitefield, Patrick Henry, and Benjamin Franklin. Kidd now accepts the challenge posed by the most elusive of founders, Thomas Jefferson. Noting the difficulty of his task, Kidd begins with "This is a biography of a brilliant but troubled person" (p. 1). The thousands of extant Jefferson writings have only intensified the problem of the historian: temperamentally averse to conflict and aware from early manhood that he was writing for the historical record, Jefferson's letters were not always reflective of his true feelings. Kidd patiently and judiciously works through the sometimes conflicting statements in search of the real Jefferson. While no one will ever present the definitive Jefferson, Kidd paints a thoughtful and human portrait that captures the essence of the man. While some favor a more topical approach, Kidd presents Jefferson's life in the traditional chronological format, which works well here, placing Jefferson's choices in clearer context and providing better understanding of the development of his thought. The greatest strength and most significant contribution of this work, as might be expected from this author, lies in its portrayal of Jefferson's religious and spiritual development. Kidd insists that Jefferson has been often misunderstood as a devoted Deist and child of the French Enlightenment. While crediting Jefferson's unconventional religious views and [End Page 63] general dedication to Enlightenment principles, Kidd notes that Jefferson never described himself as a Deist. Indeed, when he used the term, it was always in reference to others and never to himself. Rather, Kidd points to the impression that the orthodox Anglicanism that was rampant in the Virginia of Jefferson's youth had upon him. Jefferson was, and remained to the end of his life, a student of the Bible who often laced his writings with passages from both the Old and New Testaments. In assessing Jefferson's spirituality, Kidd asserts that "the most decisive season of Thomas Jefferson's life" came in the months surrounding the Louisiana Purchase (p. 166). Sparked by his relationships with Benjamin Rush and Joseph Priestley (who died in early 1804) and, perhaps, the death of his younger daughter Maria (called Polly, who died in April 1804), Jefferson sought to systematize his views. The resulting "Syllabus of an Extract of the Merits of the Doctrines of Jesus, Compared with Those of Others" has been lost, but most likely served as the basis for his later "The Life and Morals of Jesus of Nazareth." Among the general excellence of these discussions, one issue deserves more consideration: Kidd does make reference to Jefferson's anticlericalism, but this is a point that merits greater development, as Jefferson's deep anti-clericalism was often mistaken for irreligion. A second major strength is Kidd's focus on race. While calling out the hypocrisy of the conflict between Jefferson's stated principles and his lifetime as an enslaver, Kidd sees the chasm as being narrower than generally accepted, though mostly because he believes that Jefferson's progressivism on the race question has been exaggerated. Jefferson sincerely disliked slavery and considered the issue the most vexing facing the young nation, but he never considered, as stated clearly in Notes on Virginia, Blacks in any way equal to whites. This applied, too, to Phillis Wheatley and Benjamin Banneker, both of whom Jefferson den