Author

William Labov

62 papers · 1968–2024

1968peak 12 in 20062024

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 62 RSS

The Social Stratification of English in New York City.

Harry J. Crockett, William Labov

Linguistics and Language · American Sociological Review · October 1968 · cited 3,098× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Part I. Problems and Methods of Analysis: 1. The study of language in its social context 2. First approach to the structure of New York City English 3. The social stratification of English in New York City department stores 4. The isolation of contextual style 5. The linguistic interview 6. The survey of the lower east side Part II. Social Differentiation: 7. Class differentiation of the variables 8. Further analysis of the variables 9. Distribution of the variables in apparent time 10. Other linguistic variables Part III. Social Evaluation: 11. Subjective evaluation of the variables 12. Self-evaluation and linguistic security 13. General attitudes towards the speech of New York City Part IV. Synthesis: 14. The structure of the New York City vowel system.

The intersection of sex and social class in the course of linguistic change

William Labov

Linguistics and Language · Language Variation and Change · July 1990 · cited 1,450× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

ABSTRACT Two general principles of sexual differentiation emerge from previous sociolinguistic studies: that men use a higher frequency of nonstandard forms than women in stable situations, and that women are generally the innovators in linguistic change. It is not clear whether these two tendencies can be unified, or how differences between the sexes can account for the observed patterns of linguistic change. The extensive interaction between sex and other social factors raises the issue as to whether the curvilinear social class pattern associated with linguistic change is the product of a rejection of female-dominated changes by lower-class males. Multivariate analysis of data from the Philadelphia Project on Linguistic Change and Variation indicates that sexual differentiation is independent of social class at the beginning of a change, but that interaction develops gradually as…

Transmission and diffusion

William Labov

Linguistics and Language · Language · June 2007 · cited 854× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The transmission of linguistic change within a speech community is characterized by incrementation within a faithfully reproduced pattern characteristic of the family tree model, while diffusion across communities shows weakening of the original pattern and a loss of structural features. It is proposed that this is the result of the difference between the learning abilities of children and adults. Evidence is drawn from two studies of geographic diffusion, (i) Structural constraints are lost in the diffusion of the New York City pattern of tensing short- a to four other communities: northern New Jersey, Albany, Cincinnati, and New Orleans, (ii) The spread of the Northern Cities Shift from Chicago to St. Louis is found to represent the borrowing of individual sound changes, rather than the diffusion of the structural pattern as a whole.

The Study Of Language In Its Social Context

William Labov

Linguistics and Language · 31 Dec 1971 · cited 704× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The work which is reported in this study is an investigation of language within the social context of the community in which it is spoken. It is a study of a linguistic structure which is unusually complex, but no more so than the social structure of the city in which it functions.Within the linguistic structure, change has occurred on a large scale, and at a rapid pace which is even more characteristic of the changing structure of the city itself. Variability is an integral part of the linguistic system, and no less a part of the behavior of the city. To assess the relative complexity of the linguistic problem presented by New York City, it may be useful to compare this investigation to an earlier study of a sound change in progress that I carried out on the island of Martha's Vineyard (Labov 1963). This earlier work traced the distribution of a particular sound feature as it varied…

Objectivity and commitment in linguistic science: The case of the Black English trial in Ann Arbor

William Labov

Linguistics and Language · Language in Society · August 1982 · cited 501× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

ABSTRACT Though many linguists have shown a strong concern for social issues, there is an apparent contradiction between the principles of objectivity needed for scientific work and commitment to social action. The Black English trial in Ann Arbor showed one way in which this contradiction could be resolved. The first decade of research on Black English was marked by violent differences between creolists and dialectologists on the structure and origin of the dialect. The possibility of a joint point of view first appeared in the general reaction of linguists against the view that blacks were linguistically and genetically inferior. The entrance of black linguists into the field was a critical factor in the further development of the creole hypothesis and the recognition of the distinctive features of the tense and aspect system. At the trial, linguists were able to present effective…

The child as linguistic historian

William Labov

Linguistics and Language · Language Variation and Change · March 1989 · cited 485× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

ABSTRACT Though the diachronic dimension of linguistic variation is often identified with linguistic change, many stable linguistic variables with no synchronic motivation show historical continuity with little change over long periods of time. Children acquire at an early age historically transmitted constraints on variables that appear to have no communicative significance, such as the grammatical conditioning of ( ing ) in English. Studies of ( td ) and ( ing ) in King of Prussia families show that children have matched their parents' patterns of variation by age 7, before many categorical phonological and grammatical rules are established. Some dialect-specific and socially marked constraints are acquired before constraints with general articulatory motivation. Constraints on ( td ) appear in the speech of a 4-year-old, but there is no evidence in the productions of a 2-year-old…

Negative attraction and negative concord in English grammar

William Labov

Linguistics and Language · Language · December 1972 · cited 316× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The attraction of the negative to subject any is an invariant rule for all dialects of English, and appears to respond to the distributive and hypothetical features of this indeterminate. Negative concord, on the other hand, is a variable rule which distributes the negative rightward in response to affective factors. It is progressively extended from one dialect to another in an implicational series which initiates negation in new positions as the rule approaches obligatory status in the original environments.

One Hundred Years of Sound Change in Philadelphia: Linear Incrementation, Reversal, and Reanalysis

William Labov, Ingrid Rosenfelder, Josef Fruehwald

Linguistics and Language · Language · March 2013 · cited 284× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The study of sound change in progress in Philadelphia has been facilitated by the application of forced alignment and automatic vowel measurement to a large corpus of neighborhood studies, including 379 speakers with dates of birth from 1888 to 1991. Two of the sound changes active in the 1970s show a linear pattern of incrementation in succeeding decades. The fronting of back upgliding vowels/aw/and/ow/shows a reversal in the direction of change, beginning with those born after 1940. The study also finds a general withdrawal from two salient features of local phonology, tense/æh/and/oh/, led by those with higher education. Younger speakers with higher education have also reorganized the traditional Philadelphia tense/lax split of short-a to form a nasal system with tensing before all and only nasal consonants. The development of the Philadelphia vowel system can be understood in the…

On the uses of variable rules

David Sankoff, William Labov

Linguistics and Language · Language in Society · August 1979 · cited 279× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The introduction of variable rules ten years ago has provoked a variety of critical reactions; among these Kay & McDaniel's (1979) review appears as a clear and penetrating study of many issues neglected or unresolved in earlier discussions. It is refreshing to observe an approach to the problems of variation and sociolinguistics relatively free from the ideological constraints that other critiques have inherited from formal linguistics (e.g. Bickerton 1971, 1973; Gazdar 1976). They bring to the discussion of variable rules a clarity gained by several years' reflection on the early statistical approaches, together with a certain distance from current sociolinguistic methodological developments and problems. At the same time, there are some attendant disadvantages of such a distance; these appear in their treatment of the work that preceded probabilistic models, in their lack of…

Near-mergers and the suspension of phonemic contrast

William Labov, Mark Karen, Corey Miller

Linguistics and Language · Language Variation and Change · March 1991 · cited 218× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

ABSTRACT In 1972, Labov, Yaeger, and Steiner reported a series of “near-mergers” that have since proved to be difficult to assimilate to the standard conception of the phoneme and that challenged our current understanding of how language production is related to perception and learning (Labov, Yaeger, & Steiner, 1972). In these situations, speakers consistently reported that two classes of sounds were “the same,” yet consistently differentiated them in production. Labov (1975a) suggested that this phenomenon was the explanation for two “falsely reported mergers” in the history of English, where word classes were said to have merged and afterward separated. It appears that sound change may bring two phonemes into such close approximation that semantic contrast between them is suspended for native speakers of the dialect, without necessarily leading to merger. This article reports on…

Properties of the sociolinguistic monitor<sup>1</sup>

William Labov, Sharon Ash, Maya Ravindranath +3 more

Linguistics and Language · Journal of Sociolinguistics · September 2011 · cited 184× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper investigates the perceptual aspect of quantitative sociolinguistic variation in order to derive properties of a sociolinguistic monitor integrated into linguistic processing in real time. A series of experiments measured listeners’ sensitivity to frequencies in the form of variable percentages of the non‐standard apical form of the variable (ING). Subjects heard ten trial readings of broadcast news from the same speaker, and rated them on a seven‐point Likert scale of professional suitability. Responses conformed closely to a logarithmic function in which the effect of each deviation from the norm was proportional to the percent increase in deviations. The logarithmic pattern of responses was replicated in group and individual experiments in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and in group experiments in Columbia, South Carolina and Durham, New Hampshire. South Carolina subjects were…

Are Black and White Vernaculars Diverging? Papers from the NWAVE XIV Panel Discussion

Ralph W. Fasold, William Labov, Fay Boyd Vaughn-Cooke +4 more

Linguistics and Language · American Speech · 1987 · cited 174× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Ralph W. Fasold, William Labov, Fay Boyd Vaughn-Cooke, Guy Bailey, Walt Wolfram, Arthur K. Spears, John Rickford, Are Black and White Vernaculars Diverging? Papers from the NWAVE XIV Panel Discussion, American Speech, Vol. 62, No. 1 (Spring, 1987), pp. 3-80

Learning to talk Philadelphian: Acquisition of short <i>a</i> by preschool children

Julie Roberts, William Labov

Linguistics and Language · Language Variation and Change · March 1995 · cited 159× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

ABSTRACT Recent work in the acquisition of variation has shown that children begin to learn patterns of stable variation at a very early age. In fact, it appears that they acquire variable rules at about the same time as they are acquiring related categorical rules. Little is known, however, about the transmission from generation to generation of features undergoing sound change in progress. Therefore, this study examines the acquisition of the Philadelphia short a pattern by 18 3- and 4-year-old children. Even though this pattern of the raising and tensing of short a is a complex one, the children had, for the most part, acquired it. In almost all cases, the children matched the short a distribution both of their parents and a group of adult Philadelphians who were interviewed in the mid 1970s and described in Labov (1989b). These results indicate that even the youngest members of the…

Phonetics, phonology and social meaning

Penelope Eckert, William Labov

Linguistics and Language · Journal of Sociolinguistics · 17 Aug 2017 · cited 149× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Linguistic variation has consistently been found to have social meaning in its association with the status and stance of speakers in the context of interaction. This indexical function of variation can contribute to the advancement of ongoing linguistic change. Style shifting in individual sociolinguistic interviews is an indirect indication of social meaning, but the clearest demonstrations are found in studies of speakers in a range of social contexts. We explore and clarify the nature of social meaning in variation, and its relation to linguistic change. Phonological variables are most readily adapted to convey social meaning by their frequency, flexibility and freedom from referential functions. After providing several kinds of evidence of social meaning in phonological variation, we argue that meaning accrues specifically to concrete sounds – to phonetic elements – and not to the…

The Regularity of Regular Sound Change

William Labov

Linguistics and Language · Language · March 2020 · cited 148× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The regularity of sound change as set out by the scholars of the late nineteenth century is a fundamental principle of historical linguistics. The principle as recognized by the Neogrammarian linguists states that once a sound change has begun, it affects every word in the vocabulary that contains the sound in question. The principle has been disputed by many linguists and especially dialectologists, who argue that ‘every word has its own history’. This article demonstrates how the Neogrammarian principle operates in one prototypical change in progress, the raising of the mid front long vowel /ey/ before a consonant in Philadelphia English. Mixed-level regression analysis shows consistent phonetic constraints across the nineteenth century, with no effect of word frequency. The regularity of sound change is reflected in the common pattern of behavior of the most frequent words, those of…

The linguistic consequences of being a lame

William Labov

Linguistics and Language · Language in Society · April 1973 · cited 146× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

ABSTRACT The most uniform and characteristic variety of Black English is the grammar used by members of the vernacular culture in pre-adolescent and adolescent years: the ‘Black English Vernacular’. Less regular varieties which show the influence of other dialects, are used by isolated individuals within the community (‘lames’) who are less familiar with vernacular norms. Rules that are categorical for the vernacular are often variable for lames. Within the vernacular peer groups, core members show the most regular or frequent use of characteristic rules such as the deletion of is . Since most linguists grow up relatively isolated individuals within their own communities, it is important that they become aware of the linguistic consequences of being lame, and apply this knowledge in their methodology. Who's the lame who says he knows the game And where did he learn to play? – The Fall

The anatomy of style-shifting

William Labov

Linguistics and Language · Cambridge University Press eBooks · 3 Jan 2002 · cited 135× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The development of sociolinguistic methodology has witnessed a continual tension between two approaches to contextual style: style-shifting as a naturalistic, ethnographic phenomenon, and style-shifting as a controlled device for measuring the dynamics of sociolinguistic variation. In many ways, the naturalistic approach is the most immediately appealing and satisfying. We would like to know as much as possible about the ways that speakers shift forms and frequencies in the course of every-day life. Styleshifting seems to be one of the keys to what we now see as the central problem of the theory of language change: the transmission problem. In the course of linguistic change, children learn to speak differently from their parents, and in the same direction that their parents learned to talk differently from their own parents. To trace this post-vernacular reorganization, we will need to…

The Social Stratification of (r) in New York City Department Stores

William Labov

Linguistics and Language · 1997 · cited 126× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Anyone who begins to study language in its social context immediately encounters the classic methodological problem: the means used to gather the data interfere with the data to be gathered. The primary means of obtaining a large body of reliable data on the speech of one person is the individual tape-recorded interview. Interview speech is formal speech — not by any absolute measure, but by comparison with the vernacular of everyday life. On the whole, the interview is public speech — monitored and controlled in response to the presence of an outside observer. But even within that definition, the investigator may wonder if the responses in a tape-recorded interview are not a special product of the interaction between the interviewer and the subject. One way of controlling for this is to study the subject in his own natural social context — interacting with his family or peer group…

Rules for Ritual Insults

William Labov

Sociology and Political Science · 1997 · cited 124× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A great variety of terms describe this activity:1 the dozens, sounding and signifying are three of the most common. The activity itself is remarkably similar throughout the various black communities, both in the form and content of the insults themselves and in the rules of verbal interaction which operate. In this section we will refer to the institution by the most common term in Harlem — sounding.

Competing systems in Philadelphia phonology

William Labov, Sabriya Fisher, Duna Gylfadottír +2 more

Linguistics and Language · Language Variation and Change · October 2016 · cited 87× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This is a study of the competition of linguistic systems within the speech community, tracing the opposition of distinct phonological configurations. Among younger Philadelphians oriented to higher education, the traditional short-a system is giving way to the nasal system, in which all prenasal vowels are tense. We present evidence that this shift occurs systematically in both the lax and tense allophones. The degree of conformity to each system is measured for 106 subjects by the Pillai statistic; community-wide patterns are revealed by regression modeling and bimodality diagrams. Adherence to the traditional system is greatest for White speakers who graduated from Catholic high schools, while the nasal system is strongest for graduates from elite schools with special admission requirements. African American students show no orientation to the traditional system, but parallel…

Listeners' sensitivity to the frequency of sociolinguistic variables

William Labov, Sharon Ash, Maciej Baranowski +3 more

Linguistics and Language · Research Explorer (The University of Manchester) · 2006 · cited 52× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Introduction Over the past 40 years, studies of linguistic variation have produced a great deal of data on the regular social and stylistic stratification of sociolinguistic variables. Finegrained differences have been observed and replicated in the production of stable sociolinguistic variables like (ING), (DH), or Spanish (S), with significant differences between four or five social levels and four or five stylistic levels (Labov 1966, Trudgill 1974, Cedergren 1973, Weinberg 1974). Figure 1 is a typical product of such studies: the graphic representation of a cross-tabulation of the social and stylistic stratification of (ING) in NYC. The vertical axis is the frequency of the non-standard apical variant in the

11. On the Use of the Present to Explain the Past

William Labov

Linguistics and Language · 2013 · cited 51× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter shows long-standing problems of historical linguistics, which can be resolved by using general principles drawn from phonetic and sociolinguistic research. It draws upon sociolinguistic studies of present-day speech communities to show how such a merger could have been reported in the first place, and why there is so much disagreement about it. It also draw upon spectographic analyses of sound change in progress to show how the ea class could be re-separated from one class and joined to another. The chapter presents fresh data on a second well-known and parallel case: the reported merger and later re-separation of line and loin. It focuses on the fundamental weakness of the minimal pair test and the inadequacy of uncontrolled intuitions and self-report as a basis for describing phonological systems; and the strength of a technique which uses the speech of everyday life as…

What is to be learned

William Labov

Artificial Intelligence · Review of Cognitive Linguistics · 7 Dec 2012 · cited 43× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper is an effort to define the target of the language learner: asking, what are the data that the child pays attention to in the process of becoming a native speaker? In so doing, we will necessarily be engaged in the more general effort to define language itself. The general argument to be advanced here is that the human language learning capacity is outward bound , that is, aimed at the acquisition of the general pattern used in the speech community. The end result is a high degree of uniformity in both the categorical and variable aspects of language production, where individual variation is reduced below the level of linguistic significance.

UNENDANGERED DIALECT, ENDANGERED PEOPLE: THE CASE OF AFRICAN AMERICAN VERNACULAR ENGLISH

William Labov

Linguistics and Language · Transforming Anthropology · 22 Mar 2010 · cited 43× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

African American Vernacular English (AAVE) is not an endangered language variety; on the contrary, it is continuing to develop, as all languages, and to diverge from other varieties. The primary correlates of such divergence are residential segregation and poverty, which are part of a developing transgenerational cycle that includes also crime, shorter life spans, and low educational achievement. The most immediate challenge is creating more effective educational programs on a larger scale. In confronting residential segregation, we must be aware that its reduction will lead to greater contact between speakers of AAVE and speakers of other dialects. Recent research implies that, if residential integration increases significantly, AAVE as a whole may be in danger of losing its distinctiveness as a linguistic resource. While many of us would regret a decrease in the eloquent syntactic and…

Co-existent systems in African-American vernacular English

William Labov

Linguistics and Language · 23 Sep 2021 · cited 42× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Bailey's approach to African-American vernacular English (AAVE) is exemplified in her first paper on the topic, “A new perspective in Negro English dialectology”. Her insights into the nature of the dialect were motivated in part by her reaction against the dialectological view of AAVE as a collection of mistakes or deviations from Standard English. Though Bailey did not study every-day speech in Jamaican Creole English or AAVE, she was well aware of variation that did not fit within the rules of her grammar. The resolution into separate dialects is in fact the limiting case of the general solution to the problem of variation. The analytical task is to discover what this surface variation reflects in the organization of the grammar: mere phonetic variability, variation in a more abstract phonological rule, the variable insertion of a morpheme, the alternation of allomorphs, variation in…