Author

Timothy Callaghan

37 papers · 2011–2026

2011peak 6 in 20222026

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 37 RSS

Encouraging COVID-19 Vaccine Uptake through Effective Health Communication

Matt Motta, Steven Sylvester, Timothy Callaghan +1 more

Health · SocArXiv (OSF Preprints) · 8 Sep 2020 · cited 164× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Context: Overcoming the COVID-19 pandemic will require millions of Americans to vaccinate against the virus. Unfortunately, previous research suggests that many Americans plan to refuse a vaccine; thereby jeopardizing collective immunity. We investigate the effectiveness of three different health communication frames hypothesized to increase vaccine intention; emphasizing either (1) personal health risks, (2) economic costs, or (3) collective public health consequences of not vaccinating.Methods: In a large (N = 7,064) and demographically representative survey experiment, we randomly assigned respondents to read pro-vaccine communication materials featuring one of the frames listed above. We also randomly varied the message source (ordinary people vs. medical experts) and availability of information designed the “pre-bunk” concerns about expedited clinical trial safety.Findings: We find…

Why States Expand Medicaid: Party, Resources, and History

Lawrence R. Jacobs, Timothy Callaghan

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Health Politics Policy and Law · 21 Jun 2013 · cited 143× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

After the passage of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act in March 2010 and the affirmation of its constitutionality by the Supreme Court in 2012, key decisions about the implementation of health care reform are now in the hands of states. But our understanding of these decisions is hampered by simplistic sortings of state directions into two or three simple, rigid categories. This article takes a different approach--it tracks the variations in relative state progress in implementing Medicaid expansion across a continuum of activities and steps in the decision-making process. This new measure reveals wide variation not only among states that have adopted Medicaid expansion but also among those that have rejected it but have also made progress. We use this new measure to spotlight cross-pressured Republican states that have adopted Medicaid expansion or have prepared to move…

Identifying the prevalence, correlates, and policy consequences of anti-vaccine social identity

Matt Motta, Timothy Callaghan, Steven Sylvester +1 more

Health · Politics Groups and Identities · 30 May 2021 · cited 74× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Scholarly and journalistic profiles of anti-vaxxers – i.e., individuals who are active in efforts to oppose widespread vaccination – suggest that some Americans may identify with the “anti-vaccine” label in order to fulfill social goals (e.g., a sense of belonging in a broader community). This is potentially problematic, as anti-vaxx social identification (AVSID) could imply increased receptivity to vaccine misinformation, and resistance to evidence-based medicine. In a large and demographically representative survey (N = 1001), we propose a novel measure of AVSID, and take stock of its prevalence and correlates. We find that about 22% of Americans always (8%) or sometimes (14%) self-identify as “anti-vaxxers” (activists who support vaccine refusal), and that those who do tend to embrace the label as a form of social identity. We also find that people who score highly on our AVSID…

Correcting Misperceptions about the MMR Vaccine: Using Psychological Risk Factors to Inform Targeted Communication Strategies

Kristin Lunz Trujillo, Matt Motta, Timothy Callaghan +1 more

Sociology and Political Science · Political Research Quarterly · 23 Mar 2020 · cited 72× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Many Americans endorse misinformation about vaccine safety. This is problematic because those who do are more likely to resist evidence-based policies, such as mandatory vaccination for school attendance. Although many have attempted to correct misinformation about vaccines, few attempts have been successful. This study uses psychological correlates of vaccine misinformation acceptance to develop a novel misinformation correction strategy by tailoring provaccine messages to appeal to these psychological traits. For example, people with higher moral purity levels are more likely to view vaccines as contaminating the body, but messages highlighting disease via under-vaccination can use their higher moral purity to push them toward vaccine support. Using a large survey experiment ( N = 7,019) and a smaller replication experiment ( N = 825) of American adults, we demonstrate that…

Healthy People 2020: Rural Areas Lag In Achieving Targets For Major Causes Of Death

Sirin Yaemsiri, Johanna M. Alfier, Ernest Moy +6 more

Health · Health Affairs · December 2019 · cited 56× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

For the period 2007-17 rural death rates were higher than urban rates for the seven major causes of death analyzed, and disparities widened for five of the seven. In 2017 urban areas had met national targets for three of the seven causes, while rural areas had met none of the targets.

The pervasiveness and policy consequences of medical folk wisdom in the U.S.

Matt Motta, Timothy Callaghan

Sociology and Political Science · Scientific Reports · July 2020 · cited 54× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Medical folk wisdom (MFW) refers to widely held, but factually inaccurate, beliefs about disease, immunity, pregnancy, and other medically-relevant topics. Examples include the idea that fasting when feverish ("starving a fever") can increase the pace of recovery, or that showering after sex can prevent pregnancy. The pervasiveness of MFW, and whether or not it-like other forms of medically-relevant misinformation-shapes Americans' health behaviors and policy preferences is an important and under-studied question. We begin this research by proposing and validating a novel measure of MFW; including a short-form scale suitable for administration in public opinion surveys. We find that nearly all Americans-irrespective of socio-economic status, political orientation, and educational background-endorse at least some aspects of MFW. Concerningly, and consistent with the idea that folk wisdom…

Incentives for COVID-19 vaccination

Noel T. Brewer, Alison M. Buttenheim, Chelsea Clinton +9 more

Health · The Lancet Regional Health - Americas · 24 Feb 2022 · cited 43× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Author(s): Brewer, Noel T; Buttenheim, Alison M; Clinton, Chelsea V; Mello, Michelle M; Benjamin, Regina M; Callaghan, Timothy; Caplan, Arthur; Carpiano, Richard M; DiResta, Renee; Elharake, Jad A; Flowers, Lisa C; Galvani, Alison P; Hotez, Peter J; Lakshmanan, Rekha; Maldonado, Yvonne A; Omer, Saad B; Salmon, Daniel A; Schwartz, Jason L; Sharfstein, Joshua M; Opel, Douglas J

Looking for Answers: Identifying Search Behavior and Improving Knowledge-Based Data Quality in Online Surveys

Matt Motta, Timothy Callaghan, Brianna Smith

Sociology and Political Science · International Journal of Public Opinion Research · 7 Sep 2016 · cited 29× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Internet surveys are cost-effective and convenient, but give respondents the opportunity to search the Web for answers to factual questions. Surprisingly, few have investigated the quality of political knowledge data collected in crowd-sourced Internet samples. Using a novel technique to identify individual “cheaters” across six data sets—collected on Amazon’s Mechanical Turk (professionalized paid “workers”) and SurveyMonkey (less-professionalized unpaid “audiences”)—we find that cheating is pervasive. In addition to detecting “cheaters,” we also show that their political knowledge is significantly inflated compared with non-cheaters, posing problems for the accurate measurement of knowledge. Fortunately, we also demonstrate that question-wording alterations can significantly improve data quality and show that cheating is less-common on mobile survey-taking platforms (compared with…

“Gay” or “Homosexual”? The Implications of Social Category Labels for the Structure of Mass Attitudes

Brianna Smith, Zein Murib, Matt Motta +2 more

Sociology and Political Science · American Politics Research · 2 May 2017 · cited 28× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Multiple identity and identification terms are used in social science research on sexuality, including clinical terms such as “homosexual” and “heterosexual” and more colloquial terms such as “gay” and “straight.” In this article, we show that far from being synonyms, these terms have consequences for attitudes about gay and lesbian rights. We begin by providing a historical overview of the terms “homosexual” and “gay and lesbian,” showing the different connotations that social groups have come to associate with these terms. We then analyze a split-ballot experiment embedded in the 2012 American National Election Study (ANES) and show that group identity and authoritarianism shape attitudes toward “homosexual” rights differently than “gay and lesbian” rights.

Private Citizens as Policy Entrepreneurs: Evidence from Autism Mandates and Parental Political Mobilization

Timothy Callaghan, Steven Sylvester

Political Science and International Relations · Policy Studies Journal · 17 Jun 2019 · cited 27× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Growing bodies of research in the social sciences point to politicians, bureaucratic officials, interest groups, and other actors who serve as policy entrepreneurs. In this paper, we argue that private citizens can also serve a primary role as policy entrepreneurs. To analyze this phenomenon, we investigate the behavior of private citizens and their role in changing state policies surrounding insurance mandates for autism coverage. Using a thematic analysis of focus groups and interviews conducted with individuals active in the push for autism policy change, we demonstrate that private citizens meet all of the requirements identified for policy entrepreneurs in the existing literature. We then investigate when, why, and how these private citizens step forward into the policy process as entrepreneurs. We show that entrepreneurship occurs when private citizens have needed resources, a…

Process Learning and the Implementation of Medicaid Reform

Timothy Callaghan, Lawrence R. Jacobs

Political Science and International Relations · Publius The Journal of Federalism · 2014 · cited 20× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

As the implementation of health care reform proceeds in the face of ongoing political conflict, variations in state decisions are shaping important aspects of its pace and scope. This article investigates five potential explanations for state implementation of the Medicaid expansion—state party control, economic affluence, the trajectory of established policy, state administrative capacity, and the process of learning from intergovernmental bargaining. Our analysis of fifty states finds, not surprisingly, that party control of government influences state decisions. We also find, however, several additional and striking influences on states—namely, the trajectory of established policy for vulnerable populations and, of particular importance, state learning about the process of intergovernmental bargaining.

Return of the “Rightful Remedy”: Partisan Federalism, Resource Availability, and Nullification Legislation in the American States

Adam Olson, Timothy Callaghan, Andrew Karch

Law · Publius The Journal of Federalism · 13 Oct 2017 · cited 19× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The early twenty-first century has seen elevated tensions between the American states and their national government. The proliferation of state proposals to “nullify” national laws is one manifestation of this intergovernmental conflict. Nullification legislation has appeared in every state and addressed issues that span the ideological spectrum. This article builds an original dataset of over 1,500 nullification proposals that appeared in state legislatures from 2010 to 2016. It identifies three types of nullification-related legislation, including one that has not previously been recognized in the literature, and finds that very little current nullification-related activity consists of classical efforts to declare a national law null and void. It also assesses the factors associated with the introduction and enactment of nullification legislation. Its analysis reveals that, consistent…

Unearthing the Hidden Welfare State: Race, Political Attitudes, and Unforeseen Consequences

Timothy Callaghan, Adam Olson

Political Science and International Relations · The Journal of Race Ethnicity and Politics · 6 Feb 2017 · cited 18× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This paper incorporates the role of race into our understanding of the hidden welfare state by exploring the implications of racialization of hidden welfare state programs for mass attitudes. We explain how traditional welfare programs have been racialized historically and the implications of that racialization on attitudes towards welfare programs. We then discuss how the same fate could befall hidden programs for the poor if “unearthed” as hidden welfare state scholars have suggested. Finally, we carry out an experiment racializing a hidden welfare state program in the same way that traditional welfare state programs have been racialized historically. Our analysis finds that only when the hidden welfare state program is described using traditional racial stereotypes, support for the program drops significantly among racially resentful. Our findings suggest that the inclusion…

Past experiences with surprise medical bills drive issue knowledge, concern and attitudes toward federal policy intervention

Timothy Callaghan, Simon F. Haeder, Steven Sylvester

Political Science and International Relations · Health Economics Policy and Law · 21 Oct 2021 · cited 15× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Scholars and journalists have devoted considerable attention to understanding the circumstances in which Americans receive surprise medical bills. Previous research on this issue has focused on the scope of the problem, including the conditions that are most likely to lead to surprise bills. However, the existing literature has almost exclusively relied on claims data, limiting our understanding of consumer experiences and attitudes toward policy changes to address surprise billing. Using a survey administered to a nationally representative sample of 4998 Americans, we analyze consumer experiences with surprise billing, knowledge of the issue, how concerned Americans are about receiving surprise bills and how past experiences influence policy preferences toward federal action on surprise billing. Our analysis demonstrates that knowledge and concern about surprise billing are the highest…

The Minnesota Multi‐Investigator 2012 Presidential Election Panel Study

Philip G. Chen, Jacob Appleby, Eugene Borgida +9 more

Political Science and International Relations · Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy · 20 Jan 2014 · cited 13× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In an analysis of the 2012 presidential election, we sought to optimize two key desiderata in capturing campaign effects: establishing causality and measuring dynamic (i.e., intraindividual) change over time. We first report the results of three survey‐experiments embedded within a three‐wave survey panel design. Each experiment was focused on a substantive area of electoral concern. Our results suggest, among other findings, that retrospective evaluations exerted a stronger influence on vote choice in the referendum (vs. the choice) frame; that among White respondents, racial animosity strongly predicted economic evaluations for knowledgeable Republicans who were led to believe that positive economic developments were the result of actions taken by the Obama administration; and that information‐seeking bias is a contingent phenomenon, one depending jointly on the opportunity and…

Physician Trust in the News Media and Attitudes toward COVID-19

Kirby Goidel, Timothy Callaghan, David Washburn +4 more

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Health Politics Policy and Law · 23 Nov 2022 · cited 12× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

CONTEXT: Previous research has established the importance of primary care physicians in communicating public health directives. The implicit assumption is that, because of their expertise, doctors provide accurate and up-to-date information to their patients independent of partisan affiliation or media trust. METHODS: The authors conducted an online survey of 625 primary care physicians and used the results to test (1) whether physician trust in media outlets is consistent with their political partisanship, and (2) whether trust in media outlets influences (a) personal concern that someone in their family will get sick, (b) perceptions about the seriousness of the pandemic as portrayed in the media, and (c) trust in federal government agencies and scientists. FINDINGS: Physicians are better positioned to critically evaluate health-related news, but they are subject to the same biases…

Disparities in Prenatal Immunization Rates in Rural and Urban US Areas by Indicators of Access to Care

Ravneet Kaur, Timothy Callaghan, Annette K. Regan

Health · The Journal of Rural Health · 14 Feb 2022 · cited 10× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

PURPOSE: To evaluate disparities in urban-rural immunization rates among pregnant women by indicators of access to health care. METHODS: We analyzed Phase 8 (2016-2018) Pregnant Risk Assessment Monitoring System data for 82,603 respondents who recently gave birth to a live infant. Uptake of influenza (33 states) or Tdap (19 states) vaccines was compared for rural versus urban areas of participating states. We compared the prevalence of immunization for rural versus urban areas by indicators of health care access using average marginal predictive values from multivariable regression models. FINDINGS: Although nearly half (48.2%) of pregnant women in rural areas relied on Medicaid to fund prenatal care, rural-residing women were less likely to live in a state offering full coverage under Medicaid to pregnant women than urban-residing women (93.9% vs 98.0%, respectively). Among states with…

“The CDC Won't Let Me Be”: The Opinion Dynamics of Support for CDC Regulatory Authority

Matt Motta, Timothy Callaghan, Kristin Lunz Trujillo

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Health Politics Policy and Law · 7 Jul 2023 · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

CONTEXT: The CDC's ability to respond to communicable disease threats has recently met significant political and legal opposition. The authors unpack the influence of political ideology on support for CDC authority, and they experimentally assess whether highlighting ideology's role in responding to health threats might bolster CDC support. METHODS: The authors fielded a demographically representative online survey experiment to 5,483 US adults. They assessed the sociopolitical correlates of CDC attitudes via multivariate regression analyses limited to a study-wide treatment group. Additionally, they tested the effectiveness of their experimental treatments via multivariate models that interact indicators of stimulus exposure with political ideology. FINDINGS: Although most Americans support the CDC's role in responding to health crises, self-identified conservatives are significantly…

Is President Obama’s Race Chronically Accessible? Racial Priming in the 2012 Presidential Election

Matthew D. Luttig, Timothy Callaghan

Sociology and Political Science · Political Communication · 2 May 2016 · cited 8× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A vast literature indicates that racial animosity has a pervasive influence on the public’s evaluations of U.S. President Barack Obama. Can political communications enhance and/or defuse the link between White Americans’ racial attitudes and evaluations of Barack Obama? In this article, we report the results of an experiment conducted in the midst of the 2012 presidential campaign which examines the effect of political rhetoric on the extent to which evaluations of Barack Obama are racialized. Drawing from research on attitude strength and pretreatment effects in experimental studies, we argue that the use of racial appeals in the pretreatment environment and the strength of citizens’ preexisting attitudes toward the incumbent president may produce a downward bias in average estimates of racial priming effects toward President Obama. After accounting for individual differences in the…

Bill Content, Legislative Outcomes, and State-Level Resistance to National Policies

Timothy Callaghan, Andrew Karch

Political Science and International Relations · State Politics & Policy Quarterly · 30 Mar 2021 · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Recently, scholars of the lawmaking process have urged their colleagues to devote more attention to the potential impact of bill content on legislative outcomes. Heeding their call, this paper builds an original dataset of over 5,000 pieces of state-level legislation addressing issues that span the ideological spectrum. It compares proposals that challenge the authority of the national government in a specific domain to proposals that lack federalism-related implications and finds that the former, all else being equal, make less legislative progress toward enactment. In addition, it categorizes the measures that resist national laws based on the specific nature of the challenge they pose. Its analysis finds that measures that are inconsistent with existing national law but work within the law’s legal framework make more legislative progress than measures that seek to nullify…

Exploring the role of discretionary income as a social determinant of health

Sophia Anyatonwu, Timothy Callaghan

Health · Health Services Research · 29 Aug 2022 · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

OBJECTIVE: The object of this study is to explore the impact of discretionary income on the overall well-being of Americans. DATA SOURCE: The data source used for this study was 2017 Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System data comprising 12 states that used the Social Determinants of Health (SDOH) module. STUDY DESIGN: Multivariable logistic regression models were used to analyze the relationship between discretionary income and self-reported health status after adjusting for common SDOH measures, sociodemographic factors, chronic conditions, and perspectives and experiences of respondents regarding specific aspects of their health. Average marginal effects (AME) were reported. DATA COLLECTION/EXTRACTION METHODS: Not applicable. PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: At all income levels, those with discretionary income at the end of the month were 6-7 percentage points more likely to report better…

Modification and validation of a vaccine hesitancy scale for adolescent COVID-19 vaccination

Annette K. Regan, Marie-Claude Couture, Timothy Callaghan +3 more

Health · Vaccine · 10 Nov 2024 · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

BACKGROUND: Vaccine hesitancy is an urgent public health threat. While tools have been developed to monitor vaccine hesitancy among parents and the general adult population, no such tool exists for adolescents. METHODS: We modified an existing adult Vaccine Hesitancy Scale to create a teen COVID-19 Vaccine Hesitancy Scale (tVHS-COVID) for adolescents and their parents. To validate our scale, we conducted a nationally representative survey of 764 parent-teen dyads. We performed exploratory factor analysis (EFA) to determine the factor structure followed by confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) to test the factor structure validity using two random subsets. We evaluated internal consistency by Cronbach alpha values and construct validity by comparing tVHS-COVID scores to intention to receive future COVID-19 doses. RESULTS: EFA suggested a three-factor structure with 13-items. CFA indicated…

Dynamic Federalism and the Implementation of the Affordable Care Act

Timothy Callaghan, Lawrence R. Jacobs

Political Science and International Relations · 2013 · cited 2× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Political maneuvering over health care reform continues and will likely persist. The reality, however, is that health reform is now proceeding in Washington and in states across the country after the Supreme Court’s affirmation of the Affordable Care Act of 2010 (ACA) and President Barack Obama’s reelection. The pace and scope of health reform is, however, varying across states. This paper investigates four potential explanations for the variation in state decisions to implement the Medicaid expansion – state party control, economic affluence, the trajectory of established policy, and the process of learning about intergovernmental bargaining. Our analysis of 50 states finds that party control is a dominating influence on state decisions; but economic affluence and process learning impacted states with Democratic governors. The findings suggest that while party casts a long shadow over…

Public Risk Perceptions and Policy Attitudes Toward Highly Pathogenic Avian Influenza

Matt Motta, Kristin Lunz Trujillo, Dominik Stecuła +3 more

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Health Politics Policy and Law · 19 Nov 2025 · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

CONTEXT: Attention to the potential impact of highly pathogenic avian influenza (H5N1, or "bird flu") on human health increased following documentation of mammalian transmission in spring 2024 and the prevalence of H5N1 in the commercial dairy supply. The authors aim to quantify (a) the prevalence and (b) the sociopolitical correlates of public concern about H5N1 as well as support for policy action aimed at reducing its potential health risks. METHODS: In a nationally representative survey of N = 831 US adults, the authors asked respondents to answer questions about their levels of concern about H5N1 transmission, beliefs about the safety of consuming unpasteurized milk products, and support for policy interventions. RESULTS: Few Americans express high levels of concern about H5N1 health risks. People who express lower levels of concern about H5N1 and those who hold inaccurate or…

Examining COVID-19 Vaccine Hesitancy in Nairobi, Kenya, Using the Modified 5 Cs Model

Christine Crudo Blackburn, Leila Abdullahi, Timothy Callaghan +3 more

Health · Health Security · 3 Mar 2025 · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this study, we identify facilitators and barriers to COVID-19 vaccination in Nairobi, Kenya, using the modified 5 Cs model for vaccine hesitancy. We conducted 33 in-person interviews in Nairobi, Kenya. Participants were recruited using convenience sampling by a member of the research team who resides in Nairobi and speaks Swahili. Interviews were audio recorded and transcripts were analyzed using thematic analysis. The modified 5 Cs model for vaccine hesitancy was applied to create a codebook prior to analysis. Participants cited misinformation, lack of trust in the science behind the vaccine, and concerns about side effects as reasons for not receiving the COVID-19 vaccine. Facilitators for choosing to receive the vaccination included concerns about the severity of COVID-19, vaccination requirements for school and employment, and communication from the government. This study is the…