arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Tim Rood

41 papers · 1998–2025

1998: 111999: 12000: 02001: 02002: 02003: 02004: 02005: 02006: 22007: 02008: 02009: 12010: 12011: 02012: 22013: 12014: 02015: 32016: 22017: 02018: 32019: 42020: 32021: 02022: 32023: 02024: 22025: 2
1998peak 11 in 19982025

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 41 RSS

Herodotus and foreign lands

Tim Rood

Anthropology · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 91× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In the preface to his Histories, Herodotus promises to describe the great and wonderful deeds and monuments displayed both by Greeks and by non- Greeks as well as to explain why they fought against each other. He proceeds at once to what he claims is a Persian account of the origin of their disputes. The account attributed to the Persians turns out to be a sort of mythographic pastiche describing how enmity arose first when a Greek woman, Io, was seized by Phoenicians, and then from the seizure of three other women (Europa, Medea, and Helen). This Persian account of the origin of hostilities between Greeks and barbarians includes, among other notable features, the first ethnographic observation in Herodotus' Histories (1.4.4):

Xenophon's parasangs

Tim Rood

Anthropology · The Journal of Hellenic Studies · · cited 43× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This paper analyses one aspect of Xenophon's representation of space, focusing on the famous stages-and-parasangs formula employed by Xenophon in the Anabasis . It starts by discussing the meaning of his terms, and then explores patterns of repetition and variation in his account of the march, split into three sections (the marches upcountry, to the sea and along the coast). Rather than explaining Xenophon's usage in terms of sources, it suggests that variations in the marching formula elaborate the successive stages of the Greeks' encounter with the spaces of the Achaemenid Empire.

Redeeming Xenophon: historiographical reception and the transhistorical

Tim Rood

Anthropology · Classical Receptions Journal · · cited 32× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The aim of this article is to explore some of the ramifications of Charles Martindale’s work for the study of the reception of classical historiography and to highlight some of the particular challenges facing researchers in this branch of reception studies. Historiography is a relatively undeveloped field within the area of classical reception studies, though there are signs that this is starting to change (notably through the large AHRC-funded project on the reception of Thucydides run by Neville Morley at Bristol University2).There is, however, a strong tradition of research on the influence of ancient historians on the modern conception and writing of history, associated above all with the work of Arnoldo Momigliano and more recently with that of Antony Grafton.3 The particular influence of reception studies themselves may be seen in the indirect light shed on the reception of…

A Delightful Retreat: Xenophon and the Picturesque

Tim Rood

Anthropology · · cited 32× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter explores a number of portrayals of Xenophon living an idyllic life in picturesque Scillus. It begins by exploring through the lens of the eighteenth-century vogue for the picturesque the underpinnings of Mitford's fascination with Xenophon's Scillus and the ideological complications that this fascination introduced into his work. The discussion of Mitford?s picture of Xenophon?s estate is enriched by comparison with the accounts of a number of early nineteenth-century travellers who (unlike Mitford) had ventured close to Scillus itself and who left equally striking recreations. By analysing this sample of responses to Scillus, the author hopes to shed light on the ideological implications of the image of Xenophon as English gentleman. One question this chapter raises is whether studying the reception of Xenophon's Scillus adds anything to our understanding of Xenophon…

Introduction

Mathura Umachandran, Tim Rood

Anthropology · Classical Receptions Journal · · cited 30× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This special issue brings together six of the papers delivered at a conference Anachronism and Antiquity: Configuring Temporalities in Ancient Literature and Scholarship held at Florida State University in March 2018 in connection with the Leverhulme-funded project Anachronism and Antiquity based at the Faculty of Classics, University of Oxford (October 2016–September 2019).1 The goal of the Anachronism and Antiquity project was to undertake a systematic study of the concept of anachronism in Greco-Roman antiquity and of the role played by the idea of anachronism in the formation of the concept of antiquity itself. Topics that fall within its scope include: the post-classical origins of the term ‘anachronism’ and its application in modern scholarship in Classics and the philosophy of history; the presence of anachronism in a variety of classical texts, including drama, historiography…

Self-Characterization and Political Thought in Xenophon’s Anabasis

Tim Rood

Anthropology · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 28× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter analyses Xenophon’s self-portrayal in Anabasis, particularly in the scene after the arrest of the generals where Xenophon rises to prominence in his own account and in the retreat to the sea. It reads Xenophon’s account of the recreation of a sense of community in the Greek army from its position of aporia at the start of Book 3 against sophistic accounts of human development. At the military level, the Greek army is shown gradually learning from experience and from physical necessities. This gradual process at a military level contrasts with the charismatic leadership of Xenophon. The chapter suggests that Xenophon’s rhetoric in his three speeches at the start of Book 3 mirrors Greek political thought about the construction of political communities while characterizing Xenophon himself as an adroit political agent.

Objectivity and Authority: Thucydides’ Historical Method

Tim Rood

Anthropology · · cited 20× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A vivid vignette in Thucydides' narrative of fourth year of Peloponnesian War describes how Spartans get news to besieged city of Mytilene. Thucydides traces detail of Salaithos' journey to Mytilene. He perhaps even arouses some admiration for cunning of this Spartan, who manages to slip into a besieged city through enemy lines. Thucydides' regular allusions to himself as writer are most obvious way in which he breaks stream of factual narrative. The formulation the war of Peloponnesians and Athenians itself reflects Thucydides' attempt to build up an image of himself as an impartial narrator. His neutral formulation mirrors, perhaps, Herodotus' claim at start of his work: to preserve for posterity great and wonderful deeds, some performed by Greeks, some by barbarians. Keywords: Athenians; Mytilene; Peloponnesian war; Thucydides

From Ethnography to History

Tim Rood

Anthropology · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 13× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The aim of this chapter is to analyse the role played by ethnography in perceptions of the opposition between Herodotus and Thucydides and of the development of Greek historiography. From a vast range of possible evidence, I have selected a number of writers, some influential in their own right, some simply representative of their age. I will focus in turn on the place of ethnography in narratives of the development of historiography, in views of Herodotus’s own work and in comparisons between Herodotus and Thucydides. This reception history will show how views of the ancient development of the genre of historiography were influenced by new conceptions of history in the modern world, in particular by the new forms of historicism that develop over the course of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Besides its inherent intellectual interest, the story unfolded here is important for…

3 Polybius, Thucydides, and the First Punic War

Tim Rood

Anthropology · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter argues that Polybius engaged with Thucydides in a far more extensive and suggestive way than has been appreciated. It focuses on a particularly rich set of correspondences between two sections of Polybius (his account of the First Punic War and his analysis of the Roman constitution) and two sections of Thucydides (his analysis of the causes of the Peloponnesian War and his account of Athens' doomed invasion of Sicily). It also argues that Polybius picks up Thucydides' broader depiction (in both speech and narrative) of the Athenian and Spartan characters. By exploring these various intertexts, the chapter offers a new way of understanding Polybius' portrayal of Roman expansionism. It suggests that the links discussed are not mere literary ornaments but part of a deeper historiographical patterning of great expeditions which encourages readers to reflect on…

Thucydides and his Predecessors

Tim Rood

Anthropology · Histos · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Thucydides' response to his literary predecessors has been explored with some frequency in recent years.Several articles have appeared even since Simon Hornblower recently wrote that 'two areas needing more work are Thucydides' detailed intertextual relation to Homer and to Herodotus'. In these discussions, Thucydides tends to be seen as inheriting a wide range of specific narrative techniques from Homer, and as alluding to particular passages in epic through the use of epic terms and through the broader structuring of his story.It has also been stressed that Thucydides' relationship with Homer should be studied in the light of the pervasive Homeric charge found in the work of Herodotus, the greatest historian before Thucydides.Nor is Thucydides' debt to Herodotus merely a matter of his taking over Herodotus' Homeric features: it is seen, for instance, in his modelling of his Sicilian…

Mythical and Historical Time in Herodotus

Tim Rood

Anthropology · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

‘At the very beginning of non-contemporary history there was myth.’1 Thus wrote John Marincola, in a much-cited section of Authority and Tradition in Ancient Historiography devoted to history and myth or, more precisely, the ways in which historians established authority by their exclusion, and occasional inclusion, of myth. One of the attractions of Marincola’s discussion is that he stresses not just the reaction against the ‘mythical’ that was one of the hallmarks of the historiographic tradition at least from Thucydides onwards, but also the continuing importance of myth for writers such as Diodorus Siculus and Dionysius of Halicarnassus. ‘The charms of myth, like those of the Sirens’, he concludes, ‘were simply too great to resist.’2

Xenophon de Halbattiker?

Luuk Huitink, Tim Rood

Anthropology · Lampas · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Summary This article analyses Xenophon’s lexical choices in Anabasis . It examines ancient and modern critical approaches to his language: Xenophon has often been criticized for lapses from ‘pure’ Attic, but this notion of a ‘pure’ Attic should be regarded as a conservative response to the increasing variety of spoken Attic in the fourth century BC. Xenophon’s lexical choices reflect the influence both of this ‘Great Attic’ (which developed into koine Greek) and of the non-parochial historiographical tradition inaugurated by Thucydides.

Mapping Spatial and Temporal Distance in Herodotus and Thucydides

Tim Rood

Anthropology · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter explores the intersection of space and time in both Greek and modern writers. The first section analyses the idea of parallels between the way of life found in distant areas and in the distant past. The second section discusses how Thucydides explicitly elaborates in his Archaeology a theory of human development according to which practices that were once common to all peoples now survive in certain parts of the Greek world as well as among non-Greeks, and how he sees the Peloponnesian War as marking the breakdown of the spatial and temporal divisions set up in the Archaeology. The final section shows how many aspects of this sort of (explicit and implicit) spatial-temporal patterning can be found in Herodotus’ work. It suggests some reasons why (unlike Thucydides) Herodotus does not unite these aspects in a concentrated vision of spatio-temporal developments.

Nikias and Athens

Tim Rood

Anthropology · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Our great historian—after devoting two immortal books to this expedition—after setting forth emphatically both the glory of its dawn and the wretchedness of its close, with a dramatic genius parallel to the Oedipus Tyrannus of Sophokles—when he comes to recount the melancholy end of the two commanders, has no words to spare for Demosthenes (far the abler of the two, who perished by no fault of his own), but reserves his flowers to strew on the grave of Nikias, the author of the whole calamity.

E. H. Carr and Alfred Zimmern: utopia, reality, and the twenty years’ crisis

Tim Rood

Sociology and Political Science · International Theory · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article offers a new approach to the opposition of utopianism and realism in interwar International Relations. It first analyses how E. H. Carr drew on Karl Mannheim to develop that opposition in his 1939 classic, The Twenty Years’ Crisis , and how Alfred Zimmern, one of Carr’s predecessors in the Woodrow Wilson Chair in International Politics at Aberystwyth, responded to Carr and his Mannheimian model in a review in the Spectator as well as in private correspondence with Norman Angell and others. It then offers a close reading of Carr’s allusions to Zimmern in his discussions of power, morality, and international law, and of the passages from Zimmern’s works that Carr was quoting. Analysis of how Carr and Zimmern read each other’s works and of some of Zimmern’s other writings suggests that they were closer in thought than Carr was willing to allow and that it was Carr’s…

Alfred Zimmern’s Early Political Thought II: Liberalism, Burke and <i>The Greek Commonwealth</i>

Tim Rood

Political Science and International Relations · History of Political Thought · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This is the second of two articles analysing the intellectual formation of Alfred Zimmern, a leading figure in the study of International Relations in the first half of the twentieth century. Drawing on many archival sources, it argues against claims in recent scholarship that Zimmern should be classified as a Burkean liberal. It first outlines Zimmern’s frequent advocacy of Socialism and state intervention, and then examines the politics of Zimmern’s famous monograph The Greek Commonwealth (1911), suggesting that the influence of Aristotle and Anthropology, and not just Burke, can be seen in his portrayal of the power of tradition in early Greece, and that this traditionalism is presented as preparing for the revolutionary freedom claimed for the classical polis.

Zimmern, Athens, and the British Empire: Ancient and Modern Imperialism in <i>The Greek Commonwealth</i>

Tim Rood

Sociology and Political Science · Modern Intellectual History · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article offers a reading of the intersections of ancient and modern imperialism in Alfred Zimmern's 1911 monograph The Greek Commonwealth: Politics and Economics in Fifth-Century Athens . The first section looks at Zimmern's use of ancient and modern comparisons and shows that, far from modernizing the ancient Greeks, as scholars have argued, he in fact insistently drew attention to the differences between the ancient and modern worlds. The second section examines the complexities of Zimmern's narrative of the Athenian empire, in particular the tension between politics and economics intimated by the book's subtitle and foregrounded by its structure. The article as a whole sets Zimmern's account in the context of Edwardian reflections on ancient and modern imperialism and shows, with the help of his own reflections, that his use of historical parallels was designed to encourage…

From <i>The Greek Commonwealth</i> to <i>The Commonwealth of Nations</i> : Zimmern, Curtis, and a Tale of Two Titles

Tim Rood

Political Science and International Relations · Global Intellectual History · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article analyses the development of the notion of ‘commonwealth’ within the Round Table group in relation to two books: Alfred Zimmern’s The Greek Commonwealth (1911) and Lionel Curtis’ The Commonwealth of Nations (1916). Modern historians of International Relations have argued that the title of Zimmern’s book alluded to conceptions of the British empire as a ‘commonwealth’. Drawing on previously unused archival sources and on detailed study of the different editions of The Greek Commonwealth, this article shows that Zimmern’s title did not refer to any form of political organization larger than the city-state and that IR historians have wrongly read into Zimmern’s book both the idea of commonwealth and the reading of the Athenian empire developed by Lionel Curtis. The article explores Curtis’ development of the concept of commonwealth and its reception by Zimmern and other members…

Cato the Elder, Livy, and Xenophon’s Anabasis

Tim Rood

Anthropology · Mnemosyne · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article argues firstly that Cato the Elder’s account of a daring plan involving the tribune Caedicius in the First Punic War is modelled on a scene in Xenophon’s Anabasis . It then argues that Livy’s account of a heroic escape in the First Samnite War orchestrated by P. Decius Mus is modelled not just on the First Punic War episode described by Cato, as scholars have suggested, but on the same passage of Xenophon; it also proposes that Livy’s use of Xenophon may be mediated through Cato. The article then sets out other evidence for the use of Xenophon in Roman historiography and explores the implications of the proposed intertextuality for Roman self-positioning and for ideas of leadership and military hierarchy. The article as a whole suggests that the influence of Xenophon on Latin historiography is greater than has often been conceived.

Introduction

K. Scarlett Kingsley, Giustina Monti, Tim Rood

Anthropology · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The ancient historian’s privileged discursive position within the text depends upon the creation of a circuit of consent with the audience, one that establishes the narrator’s power and authority in detailing the unfolding of past events, their causes, and the agents animating them. The contract between the narrator and audience is brought about by the careful curation of the historian’s agency in and out of the process of textual production. In antiquity, the stakes for this curation were even higher than in modernity because of the widespread association of literary production with individual character. The struggle for authority was uniquely pressing for Greek and Roman historians, as their texts could not call upon the inspiration of the Muse as the poets could. As a result, the self-positioning of the historian was highly self-aware and charged with meaning, constructed in relation…

The Authoritative Historian: Tradition and Innovation in Ancient Historiography

K. Scarlett Kingsley (17249278), Giustina Monti (17163715), Tim Rood (17249281)

Sociology and Political Science · Figshare · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

&lt;p&gt;In this volume an international group of scholars revisits the themes of John Marincola's ground-breaking Authority and Tradition in Ancient Historiography. The nineteen chapters offer a series of case studies that explore how ancient historians' approaches to their projects were informed both by the pull of tradition and by the ambition to innovate. The key themes explored are the relation of historiography to myth and poetry; the narrative authority exemplified by Herodotus, the 'father' of history; the use of 'fictional' literary devices in historiography; narratorial self-presentation; and self-conscious attempts to shape the historiographical tradition in new and bold ways. The volume as a whole presents a holistic vision of the development of Greco-Roman historiography and the historian's dynamic position within this practice.- Provides extremely broad coverage across…

Reading Thucydides in the Early Twentieth Century (on B. Earley, The Thucydidean Turn: (Re)Interpreting Thucydides’ Political Thought Before, During and After the Great War)

Tim Rood

Anthropology · Histos · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

he Thucydidean Turn starts with the Thucydides trap-Graham Allison's recent attempt to conceptualise the relations between China and the US through Thucydides' analysis of how the fear engendered in Sparta by Athenian growth 'made war inevitable'.Earley (henceforth E.) then turns back from the 'trap'-which he claims has 'given greater public prominence to Thucydides than the Greek historian has ever enjoyed in the past' ()-to analyse an earlier period of scholarly interest in Thucydides.In the rest of the book, he explores readings of Thucydides' political thought in Great Britain in the first half of the twentieth century-Britain being, he suggests, the country where the influence exerted by contemporary events (the Boer War, the First World War) on Thucydidean scholarship was greatest.E.'s overarching argument is that these readings form a neglected background to the disciplinary…

Vasileios Liotsakis, Redeeming Thucydides’ Book VIII. Narrative Artistry in the Account of the Ionian War, Berlin – Boston (De Gruyter) 2017 (Trends in Classics Supplementary Volume 48), X, 201 S., ISBN 978-3-11-053207-4 (geb.), € 109,95

Tim Rood

Anthropology · Klio · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Article Vasileios Liotsakis, Redeeming Thucydides’ Book VIII. Narrative Artistry in the Account of the Ionian War, Berlin – Boston (De Gruyter) 2017 (Trends in Classics Supplementary Volume 48), X, 201 S., ISBN 978-3-11-053207-4 (geb.), € 109,95 was published on November 1, 2019 in the journal Klio (volume 101, issue 2).

Bibliography

Luuk Huitink, Tim Rood

Anthropology · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This is the first comprehensive commentary on a section of Xenophon's Anabasis in English for almost a century. It provides up-to-date guidance on literary, historical and cultural aspects of the Anabasis and will help undergraduate students to read Greek better. It also incorporates recent advances in Xenophontic scholarship and Greek linguistics, showcasing in particular Xenophon's linguistic innovations and varied style. Advanced students and professional scholars will also profit from the sustained attention which this commentary devotes to Xenophon's varied narrative strategies and to the reception of episodes from Anabasis III in antiquity. The introduction and commentary show that Xenophon is just as important (if not more so) to the development of Greek historiography, and of Greek prose in general, as Herodotus and Thucydides.

Introduction

Luuk Huitink, Tim Rood

Anthropology · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This is the first comprehensive commentary on a section of Xenophon's Anabasis in English for almost a century. It provides up-to-date guidance on literary, historical and cultural aspects of the Anabasis and will help undergraduate students to read Greek better. It also incorporates recent advances in Xenophontic scholarship and Greek linguistics, showcasing in particular Xenophon's linguistic innovations and varied style. Advanced students and professional scholars will also profit from the sustained attention which this commentary devotes to Xenophon's varied narrative strategies and to the reception of episodes from Anabasis III in antiquity. The introduction and commentary show that Xenophon is just as important (if not more so) to the development of Greek historiography, and of Greek prose in general, as Herodotus and Thucydides.