arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Simon Lester

34 papers · 1999–2026

1999: 12000: 12001: 02002: 02003: 02004: 02005: 12006: 12007: 32008: 22009: 22010: 12011: 22012: 12013: 12014: 22015: 22016: 22017: 12018: 22019: 32020: 22021: 12022: 02023: 22024: 02025: 02026: 1
1999peak 3 in 20072026

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 34 RSS

WTO Dispute Settlement 1995–2016—A Statistical Analysis

K. Leitner, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 31× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Since 2002, we have presented in this journal a statistical analysis of World Trade Organization (WTO) dispute settlement (DS). This year, we continue that analysis by adding data for 2016. The statistical analysis below focuses on several different aspects of the DS system. First, we will examine the ‘complaints’. Specifically, we will look at: ... ... Finally, we include data on the country of origin of WTO panelists. Generally, a ‘complaint’ arises under WTO DS when one Member1 requests consultation with another Member pursuant to the DSU. For each ‘complaint’, the WTO Secretariat assigns an individual DS number. As of 1 January 2017, there have been 5182 WTO complaints filed under the DSU. Over the past 22 years, the number of complaints filed each year is as follows:

The Rise of Populist Nationalism and the Renegotiation of NAFTA

Simon Lester, Inu Manak

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 30× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Countries that have traditionally led the way in promoting economic globalization and its institutions have seen a recent surge of populism and nationalism, calling into question the liberal international economic order. The rhetoric of these critics is often vague, however, and it is unclear what a populist or nationalist approach to international economic policy would look like. The North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) renegotiation initiated by the Trump administration could give us the first clues. Will their proposals destroy the trading system as we know it, or merely tweak it? This article examines these issues by discussing the concepts of nationalism and sovereignty, and then viewing the Trump administration’s specific NAFTA proposals through those lenses.

The Rule of Precedent and the Role of the Appellate Body

James Bacchus, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of World Trade · · cited 23× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The crisis over appointments to the WTO's Appellate Body has been one of the most challenging conflicts the GATT/WTO system has ever seen, threatening to destroy a core institution of the world trading system. The Appellate Body has played a valuable role in dispute settlement, by providing a coherent set of jurisprudence to guide WTO Members as to the meaning of WTO law. The Appellate Body does not create formal "precedent," but nevertheless its reasoning in past cases serves informally to create expectations as to the meaning of the WTO agreements. The United States has objected to the Appellate Body's treatment of past rulings, arguing that the Appellate Body has elevated these rulings to "binding precedent." However, a careful reading of the language used by the Appellate Body to describe its views indicates that the Appellate Body has not done so. The U.S. objections are one part…

WTO Dispute Settlement 1995–2015—A Statistical Analysis

K. Leitner, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 21× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Since 2002, we have presented in this Journal a statistical analysis of World Trade Organization (WTO) dispute settlement. This year, we continue that analysis by adding data for 2015. The statistical analysis below focuses on several different aspects of the dispute settlement system. First, we will examine the ‘complaints’. Specifically, we will look at: Next, we will examine the ‘decisions’ that have been made pursuant to the Dispute Settlement Understanding (DSU), that is, the panel and Appellate Body reports and the arbitration awards and decisions. In particular, we will look at the following: We will then consider separately the issue of complaints and decisions relating to ‘compliance’ under the special provisions of DSU Article 21.5. Finally, we include data on the country of origin of WTO panellists. Generally, a ‘complaint’ arises under WTO dispute settlement when one Member…

A Proposal for a Committee on National Security at the WTO

Simon Lester, Inu Manak

Political Science and International Relations · eYLS (Yale Law School) · · cited 19× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

World Trade Organization (WTO) committees meet regularly to monitor and oversee the implementation of the WTO agreements. It rarely makes the news, but this work is nonetheless an important supportive function of the organization. The committees cover a wide range of topics, and some have been added from time to time. In this Article, we propose a Committee on National Security to address the growing challenge to the trade regime presented by national security measures. WTO litigation has a limited ability to handle these sensitive issues, and there would be great value in a committee designated to provide oversight of these measures. This would include the following components: a forum for regular discussion and coordination of approaches on trade-related aspects of national security matters; a monitoring mechanism to increase transparency on the use and application of national…

Original Meanings and the Film Dispute: The Drafting History, Textual Evolution, and Application of the Non-Violation Nullification or Impairment Remedy

Simon Lester, James P. Durling

Political Science and International Relations · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 17× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This Article has two broad objectives. First, we explore in detail the historical and textual origins of the NVNI remedy. Given the potential implications of legal interpretations made by the Film panel, we have explored the origins of the NVNI remedy as deeply as the historical record permits. Second, we use this history to assess whether the Film panel properly respected the text and original intent of the NVNI provision.

Access to Trade Justice: Fixing NAFTA's Flawed State-to-State Dispute Settlement Process

Simon Lester, Inu Manak, Andrej Arpas

Political Science and International Relations · World Trade Review · · cited 15× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Without a properly functioning dispute process, the obligations in a trade agreement may not be worth much. As part of the NAFTA renegotiation, the NAFTA parties should try to fix certain flaws in the NAFTA Chapter 20 dispute settlement process that emerged a few years after NAFTA came into force. Chapter 20 was used regularly in its early years, but usage dropped considerably after panel selection was blocked in a case involving US restrictions on Mexican sugar. In this paper, we examine recent innovations on panel selection in the TPP, CETA, and JEEPA dispute provisions, and draw from those to develop principles that can guide revisions to the NAFTA Chapter 20 panel selection process.

WTO Dispute Settlement from 1995 to 2005 – A Statistical Analysis

K. Leitner, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 11× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In each of the last several years, we have presented in this journal a statistical analysis of World Trade Organization (WTO) dispute settlement. This year, we continue that analysis by adding data for 2005. The statistical analysis below focuses on several different aspects of the dispute settlement system. First, we will examine the ‘complaints’. Specifically, we will look at the following: Next, we will examine the ‘decisions’ that have been made pursuant to the Dispute Settlement Understanding (DSU), that is, the panel and Appellate Body reports and the arbitration awards and decisions. In particular, we will look at the following: Finally, we will consider separately the issue of complaints and decisions relating to ‘compliance’ under the special provisions of DSU Article 21.5. Generally, a ‘complaint’ arises under WTO dispute settlement when one Member1 requests consultations with…

The problem of subsidies as a means of protectionism: Lessons from the WTO EC - 'Aircraft case'

Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Melbourne journal of international law · · cited 10× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In this article, I examine the problem of subsidies in international trade. In this regard, I consider that a possible purpose of international regulation of subsidies is to fight protectionist subsidies, as opposed to subsidies used for other goals. With this purpose in mind, I then consider whether the Agreement on Subsidies and Countervailing Measures ('SCM Agreement') can be said to reflect this purpose. I also discuss whether the interpretations of the SCM Agreement in the EC - Aircraft dispute provide any insights on this issue. The dispute involved alleged subsidies to the aircraft maker Airbus by the European Union and certain member state governments, and has been one of the highest profile and most commercially significant disputes in the history of the WTO. The issues in the case were extensively argued by two of the leading WTO members, and thus its findings on these issues…

WTO Dispute Settlement 1995-2012--A Statistical Analysis

K. Leitner, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In each of the past few years, we have presented in this journal a statistical analysis of World Trade Organization (WTO) dispute settlement. This year, we continue that analysis by adding data for 2012. The statistical analysis below focuses on several different aspects of the dispute settlement system. First, we will examine the ‘complaints’. Specifically, we will look at: Next, we will examine the ‘decisions’ that have been made pursuant to the Dispute Settlement Understanding (DSU), that is, the panel and Appellate Body reports and the arbitration awards and decisions. In particular, we will look at the following: We will then consider separately the issue of complaints and decisions relating to ‘compliance’ under the special provisions of DSU Article 21.5. Finally, we include data on the country of origin of WTO panelists. Generally, a ‘complaint’ arises under WTO dispute…

WTO Dispute Settlement 1995–2004: A Statistical Analysis

K. Leitner, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

1The authors are the co-founders of WorldTradeLaw.net LLC. They can be reached via e-mail at [email protected] or through the ‘Contact Us’ page on the http://www.worldtradelaw.net web site. The statistics presented in this article are taken from the Dispute Settlement Commentary service offered on the http://www.worldtradelaw.net web site.

Trump's First Trade Deal: The Slightly Revised Korea-U.S. Free Trade Agreement

Simon Lester, Inu Manak, Kyounghwa Kim

Political Science and International Relations · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 8× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

While the renegotiation of the North American Free Trade Agreement has received far more attention, a lesser-known U.S. trade deal has also been reworked. In April of 2017, President Trump proclaimed his displeasure with the Korea-U.S. Free Trade Agreement (commonly referred to as “KORUS”), stating, “It was a Hillary Clinton disaster, a deal that should’ve never been made.” Trump said he had told the South Koreans, “We’ll either terminate or negotiate. We may terminate.” This set the wheels in motion for a relatively low-profile trade renegotiation that became Trump’s first trade deal. The renegotiation of KORUS provides a useful example of Trump’s trade dealmaking in practice. As we will show below, the renegotiation made only minor changes to the agreement and could be taken to mean that the reality of Trump’s trade policy may not always match the rhetoric. However, the…

WTO Dispute Settlement 1995-2007 - A Statistical Analysis

K. Leitner, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 8× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In each of the last several years, we have presented in this journal a statistical analysis of WTO dispute settlement. This year, we continue that analysis by adding data for 2007. The statistical analysis below focuses on several different aspects of the dispute settlement system. First, we will examine the ‘complaints’. Specifically, we will look at: Next, we will examine the ‘decisions’ that have been made pursuant to the DSU, that is, the panel and Appellate Body reports and the arbitration awards and decisions. In particular, we will look at the following: We will then consider separately the issue of complaints and decisions relating to ‘compliance’ under the special provisions of DSU Article 21.5. Finally, instead of commenting on the data as we have in past years, this year we have added additional data on the country of origin of WTO panelists. Generally, a ‘complaint’ arises…

Domestic Tobacco Regulation and International Law: The Interaction of Trade Agreements and the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control

Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of World Trade · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

For the most part, conflict between domestic tobacco regulation/international tobacco control instruments and international trade obligations is more imaginary than real. In practice, domestic regulation can be carried out consistently with trade obligations. Nevertheless, there is at least a small chance of actual conflict between international tobacco rules and trade obligations. Where such conflict arises, this paper argues that proper treaty interpretation requires that trade obligations, as the 'harder' version of law, would take precedence over conflicting tobacco rules. For public health advocates who have concerns about this, the solution is not to exclude tobacco from trade agreements, but to refine existing trade obligations.

WTO Dispute Settlement 1995-2013--A Statistical Analysis

K. Leitner, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Since 2002, we have presented in this journal a statistical analysis of World Trade Organization (WTO) dispute settlement. This year, we continue that analysis by adding data for 2013. The statistical analysis below focuses on several different aspects of the dispute settlement system. First, we will examine the ‘complaints’. Specifically, we will look at the following: Next, we will examine the ‘decisions’ that have been made pursuant to the Dispute Settlement Understanding (DSU), that is, the panel and Appellate Body reports and the arbitration awards and decisions. In particular, we will look at the following: We will then consider separately the issue of complaints and decisions relating to ‘compliance’ under the special provisions of DSU Article 21.5. Finally, we include data on the country of origin of WTO panelists. Generally, a ‘complaint’ arises under WTO dispute settlement…

WTO Dispute Settlement 1995-2011--A Statistical Analysis

K. Leitner, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In each of the past few years, we have presented in this journal a statistical analysis of World Trade Organization (WTO) dispute settlement (DS). This year, we continue that analysis by adding data for 2011. The statistical analysis below focuses on several different aspects of the DS system. First, we will examine the ‘complaints’. Specifically, we will look at: Next, we will examine the ‘decisions’ that have been made pursuant to the Dispute Settlement Understanding (DSU), that is, the panel and Appellate Body reports and the arbitration awards and decisions. In particular, we will look at the following: We will then consider separately the issue of complaints and decisions relating to ‘compliance’ under the special provisions of DSU Article 21.5. Finally, we include data on the country of origin of WTO panelists. Generally, a ‘complaint’ arises under WTO DS when one Member1 requests…

WTO Dispute Settlement 1995-2010--A Statistical Analysis

K. Leitner, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In each of the last few years, we have presented in this Journal a statistical analysis of World Trade Organization (WTO) dispute settlement (DS). This year, we continue that analysis by adding data for 2010. The statistical analysis below focuses on several different aspects of the dispute settlement system. First, we will examine the ‘complaints’. Specifically, we will look at: Next, we will examine the ‘decisions’ that have been made pursuant to the Dispute Settlement Understanding (DSU), that is, the panel and Appellate Body reports and the arbitration awards and decisions. In particular, we will look at the following: We will then consider separately the issue of complaints and decisions relating to ‘compliance’ under the special provisions of DSU Article 21.5. Finally, we include data on the country of origin of WTO panelists. Generally, a ‘complaint’ arises under WTO DS when one…

WTO Dispute Settlement 1995-2009 -- A Statistical Analysis

K. Leitner, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In each of the last few years, we have presented in this journal a statistical analysis of World Trade Organization (WTO) dispute settlement. This year, we continue that analysis by adding data for 2009. The statistical analysis below focuses on several different aspects of the dispute settlement system. First, we will examine the ‘complaints’. Specifically, we will look at: Next, we will examine the ‘decisions’ that have been made pursuant to the Dispute Settlement Understanding (DSU), that is, the panel and Appellate Body reports and the arbitration awards and decisions. In particular, we will look at the following: We will then consider separately the issue of complaints and decisions relating to ‘compliance’ under the special provisions of DSU Article 21(5). Finally, we include data on the country of origin of WTO panelists. We conclude this year's piece with a section on the rise…

WTO Dispute Settlement 1995-2008--A Statistical Analysis

K. Leitner, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In each of the last few years, we have presented in this journal a statistical analysis of WTO dispute settlement. This year, we continue that analysis by adding data for 2008. The statistical analysis below focuses on several different aspects of the dispute settlement system. First, we will examine the ‘complaints’. Specifically, we will look at: Next, we will examine the ‘decisions’ that have been made pursuant to the Understanding on Rules and Procedures Governing the Settlement of Disputes (DSU), that is, the panel and Appellate Body reports and the arbitration awards and decisions. In particular, we will look at the following: We will then consider separately the issue of complaints and decisions relating to ‘compliance’ under the special provisions of DSU Article 21.5. Finally, we include data on the country of origin of WTO panelists, as well as new data on the gender of…

WTO Dispute Settlement 1995-2006--A Statistical Analysis

K. Leitner, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In each of the last several years, we have presented in this journal a statistical analysis of WTO dispute settlement. This year, we continue that analysis by adding data for 2006. The statistical analysis below focuses on several different aspects of the dispute settlement system. First, we will examine the ‘complaints’. Specifically, we will look at: Next, we will examine the ‘decisions’ that have been made pursuant to the DSU, that is, the panel and Appellate Body reports and the arbitration awards and decisions. In particular, we will look at the following: Finally, we will consider separately the issue of complaints and decisions relating to ‘compliance’ under the special provisions of DSU Article 21.5. Generally, a ‘complaint’ arises under WTO dispute settlement when one Member1 requests consultations with another Member pursuant to the DSU. For each ‘complaint’, the WTO…

WTO Dispute Settlement 1995-2014--A Statistical Analysis

K. Leitner, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Since 2002, we have presented in this journal a statistical analysis of World Trade Organization (WTO) dispute settlement. This year, we continue that analysis by adding data for 2014. The statistical analysis below focuses on several different aspects of the dispute settlement system. First, we will examine the ‘complaints’. Specifically, we will look at: Next, we will examine the ‘decisions’ that have been made pursuant to the Dispute Settlement Understanding (DSU), that is, the panel and Appellate Body reports and the arbitration awards and decisions. In particular, we will look at the following: We will then consider separately the issue of complaints and decisions relating to ‘compliance’ under the special provisions of DSU Article 21.5. Finally, we include data on the country of origin of WTO panelists. Generally, a ‘complaint’ arises under WTO dispute settlement when one Member1…

Dispute settlement

Victoria Donaldson, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

As international trade disputes have shifted over the years from diplomatic exercises to more legalistic contests, the dispute settlement procedures set out in trade agreements have taken on a more important role. The dispute provisions of the GATT 1947 were a mere two paragraphs. Over the years, these provisions were supplemented with additional rules, eventually developing into the detailed procedures of the WTO's Dispute Settlement Understanding. And in the 350-plus WTO disputes that have been brought since the WTO's inception, these rules have been elaborated by panels and the Appellate Body. The result is that today the WTO's dispute procedures are well-developed, widely studied, and generally considered reliable and credible by governments and other actors.

Digital Trade Agreements and Domestic Policy

Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 3× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

National debates over policies that affect the flow of digital information are heating up as censorship, surveillance, control over personal data, and requirements to store data locally have emerged as contentious political issues. In the coming years, governments will need to carefully craft policies that preserve the free flow of information and avoid data nationalism. But these policies are not just domestic in nature. The regulations that emerge will have an international dimension due to their impact on companies and individuals in other countries. In an ideal word, domestic regulation would not lead to trade conflict, but in reality it often does. To address the conflicts that might arise from regulatory effects abroad, there have been efforts at the bilateral, regional, and multilateral level to develop international rules on digital governance. The scope of digital trade…

The GATT Origins of TBT Agreement Articles 2.1 and 2.2

Simon Lester, W. Stemberg

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Economic Law · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

After a long period with limited examination in WTO case law, this past year saw three important cases explore the boundaries of TBT Agreements Articles 2.1 and 2.2. In U.S. – Clove Cigarettes, U.S. – Tuna II, and U.S. – COOL, WTO panels and the Appellate Body established important new jurisprudence on both of these provisions. While these cases are likely to be the primary basis for future application of these provisions, there may also be important guidance to be drawn from the past. These provisions have their origins in the Tokyo Round GATT Standards Code negotiations and some earlier GATT discussions just before that Round. These early talks about possible multilateral obligations on standards provide useful insights on the thinking of governments, and inform the current legal obligations in this area. In this article, we review the GATT negotiations related to substantive…

European Communities —Measures Affecting the Approval and Marketing of Biotech Products. WT/DS291/R, WT/DS292/R, & WT/DS293/R

Daniel Bodansky, Simon Lester

Political Science and International Relations · American Journal of International Law · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

European Communities—Measures Affecting the Approval and Marketing of Biotech Products. WT/DS291/R, WT/DS292/R, & WT/DS293/R. At < http://www.wto.org/english/tratop_e/dispu_e/dispu_status_e.htm >. World Trade Organization Panel, September 29, 2006 (adopted November 21, 2006). In what was by far the longest panel report in the World Trade Organization’s history, a WTO panel ruled last September that various parts of the European Communities’ regulatory regime for the approval and marketing of “biotech products” (that is, products that contain, or are made from or with, genetically modified organisms (GMOs)) violated the Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures (SPS Agreement). The panel report was not appealed and was adopted by the WTO Dispute Settlement Body on November 21, 2006. In recent years, a heated international debate has developed regarding…