Citizenship, the demands of justice, and the moral relevance of political borders
Jules L. Coleman, Sarah Harding
By what standards ought the immigration policies of nations be assessed? Answering this question requires that we draw several preliminary distinctions. In the first place, immigration is a form of access to political borders. Access, in turn, can take many forms, from travel to temporary residence, to permanent residence, and, ultimately, to citizenship. Let us refer to these as various forms of status. Different countries provide different bundles of resources to individuals depending on their status. Thus we can distinguish between status, the conditions for obtaining that status, and the bundles of resources that status entitles one to. In the first part of this essay, we explore the various forms of access to political borders individuals can obtain, the conditions that must be satisfied in order to obtain them, and the bundles of resources the status makes available. Our empirical…