arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Samantha Besson

58 papers · 1999–2026

1999: 12000: 02001: 02002: 02003: 12004: 22005: 02006: 12007: 02008: 22009: 52010: 02011: 22012: 52013: 12014: 02015: 22016: 32017: 42018: 32019: 32020: 32021: 52022: 22023: 52024: 32025: 12026: 4
1999peak 5 in 20092026

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 58 RSS

The Extraterritoriality of the European Convention on Human Rights: Why Human Rights Depend on Jurisdiction and What Jurisdiction Amounts to

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · Leiden Journal of International Law · · cited 148× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The extraterritoriality or extraterritorial application of international and European human rights treaties refers to the recognition by those treaties' states parties of the international and European human rights of individuals or groups of individuals situated outside their territory and, in a second stage, to the identification of their corresponding duties to those individuals. Examples of extraterritoriality abound in international human rights practice, and in particular in the European Court of Human Rights’ case law. Except for vague and often misleading gestures to the universality of human rights, which allegedly requires their extraterritorial application, however, many of the normative considerations underlying the extraterritorial applicability of human rights have not been broached in the human rights law literature. Nor, conversely, have human rights theorists…

Subsidiarity in International Human Rights Law—What is Subsidiary about Human Rights?

Samantha Besson

Sociology and Political Science · The American Journal of Jurisprudence · · cited 104× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Subsidiarity is <it>en vogue</it> in international human rights law. From a largely implicit and mainly jurisprudential principle used in discrete guises by international human rights courts, it has become increasingly present in human rights reasoning and is about to become entrenched in the text of international human rights treaties. Past the usual truisms about States having the primary responsibility to secure human rights and international human rights institutions having only a supervisory function, however, the notion, role and justification of subsidiarity in international human rights law remain very difficult to capture. Broadly speaking, scholarly strategies have divided into two groups. Most authors focus on one aspect of subsidiarity (usually the margin of appreciation of domestic authorities), while fewer look for the broader underpinning principle. The former…

Legitimate actors of international law-making: towards a theory of international democratic representation

Samantha Besson, José Luis Martí

Political Science and International Relations · Jurisprudence · · cited 88× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article addresses the identity of the legitimate actors of international law-making from the perspective of democratic theory. It argues that both states or state-based international organisations, and civil society actors should be considered complementary legitimate actors of international law-making. Unlike previous accounts, our proposed model of representation, the Multiple Representation Model, is based on an expanded, democratic understanding of the principle of state participation: it is specifically designed to palliate the democratic deficits of more common versions of the Principle of State Consent. Second, it endorses a qualified version of the Principle of Civil Society Participation, one that is much more restrictive and more critical of the democratic defects of civil society actors than most of its current supporters. Finally, it reveals how the democratic strengths…

State Consent and Disagreement in International Law-Making.<i>Dissolving the Paradox</i>

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · Leiden Journal of International Law · · cited 73× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article starts with a paradox: international law-making is ridden with reasonable disagreement and yet no state can be bound by international law without its consent and hence without agreement. Breaking away from the pragmatic resignation that prevails among international law scholars on this question, the article proposes an interpretation of the role of state consent that both fits and justifies its central role in the practice of international law-making and, hopefully, strengthens the latter's legitimacy in the future. Its proposed justification actually lies in the circumstances of reasonable disagreement among democratic states and this proposal dissolves the paradox. The article argues that, in international law as it is the case domestically, consent is neither a criterion of validity of law nor a ground for its legitimate authority. It also dispels two myths…

Human rights and democracy in a global context: decoupling and recoupling

Samantha Besson

Sociology and Political Science · Ethics & Global Politics · · cited 66× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Human rights and democracy have been regarded as a mutually reinforcing couple by many political theorists to date. The internationalisation of human rights post-1945 is often said to have severed those links, however. Accounting for the legitimacy of international human rights requires exploring how human rights and democracy, once they have been decoupled or disconnected, can be recoupled or reunited across governance levels (vertically) and maybe even at the same governance level (horizontally) albeit beyond the state. The article does so in three steps. The first prong of the argument is dedicated to presenting the moral-political nature of human rights and their relationship to political equality and, hence, their inherent legal nature from a democratic theory perspective. The second section of the article then draws some implications for the domestic or international levels of…

Human Rights and Constitutional Law

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 58× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract International human rights law and constitutional rights law have distinct albeit complementary functions. This chapter attempts to clarify those respective and complementary functions of international and domestic human rights to shed light on key issues in human rights theory, such as the nature of human rights (moral and/or legal) and the legitimacy of human rights law (domestic and/or international). The complementarity in function of the two human rights regimes reflects what is referred to as the ‘mutual legitimation’ of international and domestic human rights, and their corresponding ‘mutual positivization’ or mutual legal validation. Following a discussion of the underlying understanding of human rights, and in particular of their legal nature and relationship to moral rights, the chapter examines the constitutional dimension of human rights in three constellations…

European Legal Pluralism after <i>Kadi</i>

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · European Constitutional Law Review · · cited 46× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Relationships between international, EU, domestic law – Different legal orders – Different jurisdictions – Validity, rank, effects of international law in EU legal order – Kadi – Court of First Instance in Kadi – Advocate-General in Kadi – European Court of Justice in Kadi – Pluralism concept of AG Maduro – European legal pluralism reconsidered

The European Union and Human Rights: Towards A Post-National Human Rights Institution?

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · Human Rights Law Review · · cited 46× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

There is growing evidence that the European Union (EU) is becoming more involved in human rights protection and has the capacity to turn into an unprecedented post-national human rights protection institution. Based on that evidence, this article suggests different arguments in favour of a further development in this direction. These arguments stem not only from a general global justice approach to post-national institutions’ responsibilities, but also from the concept of human rights itself and the specific needs of human rights protection at the post-national level. The EU's institutional framework presents advantages that fit the general criteria of institutional design in the human rights context. Of course, many doubts and critiques may be raised against an entity which started primarily as a functional and economic institution, and important reforms, some of which are ventured in…

THE BEARERS OF HUMAN RIGHTS’ DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES FOR HUMAN RIGHTS: A QUIET (R)EVOLUTION?

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · Social Philosophy and Policy · · cited 41× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract: Recent years have seen an increase of interest on the part of human rights theorists in the “supply-side” of human rights, i.e., in the duties or obligations correlative to human rights. Nevertheless, faced with the practically urgent and seemingly simple question of who owes the duties related to international human rights, few human rights theorists provide an elaborate answer. While some make a point of fitting the human rights practice and hence regard states as the sole human rights duty-bearers merely by referring to that practice, others criticize the “state-centric” approach to human rights duty-bearers and expand the scope of the latter to include any international institution beyond the state and even private actors. Curiously, however, even those more expansive accounts of human rights duty-bearers are usually very evasive about why it should be so and especially…

Gender Discrimination under EU and ECHR Law: Never Shall the Twain Meet?

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · Human Rights Law Review · · cited 40× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Gender discrimination is addressed differently under Article 14 ECHR and EU primary and secondary legal provisions. This is no wonder, since the role and scope of non-discrimination law in both legal orders are not the same, and since the scope of jurisdiction of the European Court of Human Rights and the European Court of Justice applying those provisions differ drastically as well. While this observation is not new, the potential discrepancy between the two non-discrimination regimes and the two Court's case law constitutes an increasing concern for national authorities and individuals in the 27 European Union (EU) Member States. As a result, gender discrimination is one of the many facets of the current human rights competition raging between the two European organisations, but also of the recent judicial attempts at minimising potential conflicts through mutual borrowings. The…

Is the Ideal of a Deliberative Democracy Coherent?

Jose Luis Marti, Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 36× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In what follows, I would like to contribute to a defense of deliberative democracy by giving an afrmative answer to the question in the title. The goal is admittedly humble. For the coherence of an ideal says nothing about its desirability, feasibility or overall appropriateness.1 And, indeed, I will not address these further issues here. But, though humble, the goal of assessing the coherence of an ideal seems to take precedence over any of the other issues. For addressing such issues with regard to an incoherent ideal would be pretty pointless. Of course, all of this assumes that the coherence of the ideal is not self-evident. It is not hard to show why this is so. According to the ideal of a deliberative democracy, political decisions should be made on the basis of a process of public deliberation among citizens. Thus, political decision-making procedures should be both democratic…

International courts and the jurisprudence of statehood

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · Transnational Legal Theory · · cited 27× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

International courts (ICs) have not only been specifying States’ duties, but have also contributed to the definition of States themselves. The article focuses on the case-law of three ICs: the International Court of Justice qua generalist international law court, and its making of the ‘internationalised State’; the European Court of Human Rights qua regional human rights court, and its moulding of the ‘democratic State’; and the Court of Justice of the European Union qua court of a regional economic organisation, and its making of the ‘managerial State’. The first part assesses the role of ICs in the development of the international law of statehood. The second part identifies the making of the State in the three ICs’ case-law and compares the ways in which statehood is actually performed through international jurisprudence. A third part presents three critiques of the contemporary…

The Truth about Legal Pluralism - Nico Krisch. Beyond Constitutionalism, The Pluralist Structure of Postnational Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010), 330 p., ISBN 9780199228317

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · European Constitutional Law Review · · cited 27× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Truth about Legal Pluralism - Nico Krisch. Beyond Constitutionalism, The Pluralist Structure of Postnational Law (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010), 330 p., ISBN 9780199228317 - Volume 8 Issue 2

Law Beyond the State: A Reply to Liam Murphy

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · European Journal of International Law · · cited 23× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Voluntarism about the very sources of international law is incoherent, but there is a better way to interpret this view. The sources of international law being what they are, legal obligations are never imposed on states without their consent. ... The claim ... is false (though perhaps it

From European Integration to European Integrity: Should European Law Speak with Just One Voice?

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · European Law Journal · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract: This article examines whether and how the moral principle of legal coherence or integrity, which has recently been developed further as a response to disagreement in the national legal context, applies to European law. According to the European integrity principle, all national and European authorities should make sure their decisions cohere with the past decisions of other European and national authorities that create and implement the law of a complex but single European legal order. Only by doing so, it is argued, can the European political and legal community gain true authority and legitimacy in the eyes of the European citizens to whom all these decisions apply. Although European integrity is primarily a product of European integration, it has gradually become one of the requirements of further integration. The article suggests that the principle of European integrity…

The Reception Process in Ireland and the United Kingdom

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · HAL (Le Centre pour la Communication Scientifique Directe) · · cited 13× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter examines the reception of the ECHR in the UK and Ireland both before and after incorporation. Both countries incorporated the ECHR using roughly the same model. One might have assumed that the mode of incorporation into a dualist legal order would largely determine outcomes. In Ireland and the UK, however, the impact of acts of incorporation was heavily mediated by pre-existing constitutional structure and practice.

<i>Ubi Ius, Ibi Civitas</i>: A Republican Account of the International Community

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 10× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The notion of international community is en vogue and pervades international law. Curiously, there are no shared understandings, however, among international lawyers about what this community is or should be. Without a clear conception of the nature, boundaries, and constituency of the community or communities concerned by international law-making and of the ways to link their interests and decisions back to national political communities, efforts made to institutionalize global democracy, or at least to develop mechanisms of international accountability are seriously hindered.Based on republican premises, this chapter argues that the international community should be conceived as a community of both States and individuals and constructed as multilevel, multilateral, and pluralistic. It refines the controversial criterion of inclusion in the international political community…

Evolutions in Non-Discrimination Law within the ECHR and the ESC Systems: &lt;I&gt;It Takes Two to Tango in the Council of Europe&lt;/I&gt;

Samantha Besson

Law · The American Journal of Comparative Law · · cited 8× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Recent years have seen important developments in the antidiscrimination case law of the European Court of Human Rights and the European Committee on Social Rights. While the latter has always been a privileged European forum for discrimination monitoring and, when applicable, for discrimination-based collective complaints (with a third of its decisions to date raising discrimination issues), the former has also developed an interesting albeit more marginal antidiscrimination case law and has issued a series of crucial decisions in the last five years or so. The purpose of this Article is to assess and compare the take of the two leading human rights bodies of the Council of Europe and their complementary and mutually reinforcing approaches, by situating them within the broader context of substantive changes in antidiscrimination law in the European Union. The two European institutions'…

Human rights as transnational constitutional law

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Human rights are often taken to epitomize the existence of global constitutional law or, at least, of global constitutionalism. Since 1945, human rights have been protected through both domestic (constitutional) human rights law and international (universal and/or regional) human rights law, and monitored and interpreted by their corresponding domestic and international human rights institutions. This has led to well-known and extensive discussions about the dual constitutionalization of human rights and/or about the duality of constitutional law itself. This chapter takes the debate one step further and complements these dual approaches to human rights law with a more integrated conception or, in short, with a truly transnational one. Starting from what it describes as the transnational practice of human rights law and developing the best interpretation thereof, the chapter discusses…

Comparative Law and Human Rights

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · HAL (Le Centre pour la Communication Scientifique Directe) · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter discusses the boundaries, the authority, and the methods of comparative human rights law (CHRL). It first explains what comparing human rights means and how it developed historically, along with some distinctions between subfields of CHRL, before considering the transnational consensus method, how it works, and how it relates to some of the general methods of comparative law. It goes on to examine the authority of and the justifications for the authority of CHRL, the democratic objection to the legitimacy of CHRL, and selected issues in CHRL. In particular, it analyzes three potential solutions to the problem of securing the universal scope of CHRL: the turn to quantitative methods in CHRL, the development of (trans-)regional human rights comparison, and generalizing CHRL to all universal human rights treaty bodies. In conclusion, the chapter argues that, unlike other areas…

Cities as democratic representatives in international law-making

Samantha Besson, José Luis Martí

Political Science and International Relations · Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Cities increasingly contribute to international law-making. There are several reasons why this should be considered a positive development. First, states are unable to take sufficient action to address many pressing global challenges and are not representing all their citizens effectively in international law-making. Second, cities are particularly well suited to address those challenges – due to, for example, their proximity to their citizens or their ability to coordinate transnational action – and are especially able to act as legitimate representatives of their citizens in international law-making. In this chapter, we argue for the normative view that cities should be regarded as democratic representatives in international law-making, operating within a larger system of multiple (public and private) representation. Cities may not claim to exert exclusive international democratic…

Law and Republicanism: Mapping the Issues

Samantha Besson, José Luis Martí

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This introductory chapter discusses some of the fundamental theoretical principles underlying republicanism in general, and legal republicanism in particular. The goal is to set a research agenda for the years to come through a survey of the main issues raised by legal republicanism. The chapter identifies central issues that constitute the focal point of most disagreements internal to the republican tradition.

Sources of International Human Rights Law

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter discusses the sources of international human rights law (IHRL) in the light of general international law scholarship. It addresses the question of the autonomy of IHRL as a self-contained regime of international law and, accordingly, that of the ‘generality’ of general international law in respect of sources. It argues that there are at least three features of IHRL that account for their specificities in terms of sources and are reflected thereby. These are: their dual moral and legal nature as rights, and the corresponding objectivity that characterize some of their sources; their dual domestic and international legality as legal rights, and the corresponding transnationality of some of their sources; and their universality as moral and legal rights, and the corresponding generality of some of their sources. Finally, the chapter tackles the distinctiveness of the…

Moral Philosophy and International Law

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter offers a critical discussion of the origins, aims, and main contributions of moral philosophies of international law. Then, in moving beyond mere exposition, the chapter turns to a meta-theoretical discussion of international law, and in particular to how international legal theory should best be conceived and conducted. The chapter argues for the development of normative legal philosophies of international law that take the normativity of law and hence its legality more seriously than international legal theorists have so far, but also than moral philosophers of international law have themselves, thus breaking away from the sterile oppositions between ‘realist’ and so-called ‘moralist’ approaches to international law.

Four Arguments Against Compromising Justice Internally

Samantha Besson

Political Science and International Relations · Oxford Journal of Legal Studies · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

AbstractThis article examines whether legal compromise on matters of justice amounts to a desirable response to the problem raised by reasonable pluralism in politics. Attitudes toward compromise are ambiguous: it is generally seen as much as a valuable technique for settling conflicts by mutual accommodation as a prejudicial concession of one's integrity. The article aims to resolve this paradox by distinguishing cases where compromises of principle cannot be tolerated from those in which they can be. By developing Ronald Dworkin's distinction between internal and external compromises, the article shows that an internal compromise, that combines different conceptions of the same principle or of incommensurable and non-distinct principles, constitutes at the most a second-best alternative. Such a compromise fails to capture the core of our sense of law's intelligibility, justice…