arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Ryan Beaton

6 papers · 2014–2025

2014: 12015: 02016: 02017: 02018: 12019: 12020: 02021: 12022: 02023: 12024: 02025: 1
2014peak 1 in 20142025

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–6 of 6 RSS

De facto and de jure Crown Sovereignty: Reconciliation and Legitimation at the Supreme Court of Canada Ryan

Ryan Beaton

Law · Constitutional Forum / Forum constitutionnel · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper offers a short story of Crown sovereignty at the Supreme Court Canada in order to shed light on questions the Court has raised about the legitimacy of Crown sovereignty over territory claimed by First Nations. In skeletal form, the story is simple. The Crown — first Imperial British and later Canadian federal and provincial — asserted sovereignty over what is now Canadian territory, and Canadian courts (and the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council) accepted those assertions without question. Yet the Supreme Court of Canada has lately qualified Crown sovereignty in striking ways, perhaps most notably in speaking of “de facto Crown sovereignty” in reasons released in 2004.

De facto and de jure Crown Sovereignty: Reconciliation and Legitimation at the Supreme Court of Canada

Ryan Beaton

Law · Constitutional Forum / Forum constitutionnel · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper offers a short story of Crown sovereignty at the Supreme Court Canada in order to shed light on questions the Court has raised about the legitimacy of Crown sovereignty over territory claimed by First Nations. In skeletal form, the story is simple. The Crown — first Imperial British and later Canadian federal and provincial — asserted sovereignty over what is now Canadian territory, and Canadian courts (and the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council) accepted those assertions without question. Yet the Supreme Court of Canada has lately qualified Crown sovereignty in striking ways, perhaps most notably in speaking of “de facto Crown sovereignty” in reasons released in 2004.The purpose behind this qualification, in line with the Court’s Aboriginal rights and title cases since Calder v British Columbia (Attorney General), seems to be to encourage the Crown to negotiate modern…

17 Articles 27 and 46(2): UNDRIP Signposts Pointing beyond the Justifiable-infringement Morass of Section 35

Ryan Beaton

Law · McGill-Queen's University Press eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper considers articles 27 and 46(2) of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), in the context of Canadian government promises implement UNDRIP domestically. In particular, I note that article 46(2) echoes much of the language of section 1 of Canada's Charter of Rights and Freedoms, a proportionality clause that has been incorporated (by analogy) as a limit on the constitutional protection of Aboriginal and Treaty rights in Canada. Article 46(2) might be used support arguments that the existing Canadian case law on Aboriginal and Treaty rights is already (largely) consistent with UNDRIP. I argue in this paper that such arguments flounder particularly on the procedural requirements of UNDRIP, notably those contained in article 27, which requires states establish, in conjunction with Indigenous peoples, procedures to recognize and adjudicate the…

Implementing UNDRIP Article 27 in Canada: assessing the role and promise of joint indigenous-crown adjudication

Rebeca Macias Gimenez, Ryan Beaton

Political Science and International Relations · Canadian Foreign Policy Journal · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Crown’s duty to consult Indigenous peoples on potential adverse impacts on Aboriginal Rights and Title has become a cornerstone of Canadian Aboriginal law over the past 20 years. However, critical gaps remain in available legal protections. For instance, while administrative decisions, such as permitting for natural resource extraction, are subject to the duty to consult, they cannot be challenged for potentially infringing rights until the alleged infringements have occurred and affected Indigenous groups can marshal the resources necessary to bring their claims to court. This vulnerability has hindered the potential for section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982, to recognize and uphold Indigenous laws and jurisdiction. We argue that good-faith implementation of UNDRIP Article 27 – calling for the establishment of joint Indigenous-Crown processes for adjudicating issues relating to…

Frontmatter

Robert Hamilton, John Borrows, Brent Mainprize +6 more

Health · University of Toronto Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Indigenous peoples in Canada are striving for greater economic prosperity and political self-determination. Investigating specific legal, economic, and political practices, and including research from interviews with Indigenous political and business leaders, this collection seeks to provide insights grounded in lived experience. Covering such critical topics as economic justice and self-determination, and the barriers faced in pursuing each, Wise Practices sets out to understand the issues not in terms of sweeping empirical findings but through particular experiences of individuals and communities. The choice to focus on specific practices of law and governance is a conscious rejection of idealized theorizing about law and governance and represents an important step beyond the existing scholarship.

Aboriginal Title in Recent Supreme Court of Canada Jurisprudence: What Remains of Radical Crown Title?

Ryan Beaton

Sociology and Political Science · Revue nationale de droit constitutionnel · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Three elements in the Supreme Court of Canada's current doctrine of Aboriginal title raise the question whether there is any meaningful content left to the notion of underlying, or radical, Crown title. The first element is the sui generis legal foundation of Aboriginal title in the Aboriginal use and occupation of land prior to the Crown's assertion of sovereignty. The second is the constitutional protection of Aboriginal title, including the potential requirement of full Aboriginal consent to certain Crown proposals. The final element is the Court's stated focus on reconciliation as the overarching goal of modern Aboriginal law, and on negotiation as the preferred means of achieving it. I argue that the first two elements have already in principle largely whittled down the doctrinal content of radical Crown title, while in practice its continued recognition creates the kind of…