arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Rustam Atadjanov

33 papers · 2016–2026

2016: 12017: 12018: 12019: 62020: 02021: 02022: 72023: 12024: 32025: 02026: 13
2016peak 13 in 20262026

Papers

showing 1–25 of 33 RSS

Human Rights as a Concept of Public Law: Challenges for Central Asian Higher Education Systems

Rustam Atadjanov

Law · SpringerBriefs in political science · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter first explains human rights as a concept of public law and briefly analyzes its legal nature. Second, the chapter outlines the particular challenges this concept presents for the Central Asian countries and their formal education sectors. Treating the concept as a predominantly legal phenomenon, it considers how human rights play into key ideas such as the Rechtsstaat and its crucial elements: rule of law and civil society. Further, it scrutinizes the role of human rights education (HRE) and knowledge dissemination in raising legal awareness and promoting legal culture among the population, a particularly relevant problem for the Central Asian countries. The chapter then proceeds to address issues of disseminating knowledge on human rights, primarily in the formal education sectors and hence public (but also private) higher education institutions that impart legal…

War Crimes Committed During the Armed Conflict in Ukraine: What Should the ICC Focus On?

Rustam Atadjanov

Political Science and International Relations · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Despite the claims that the ongoing armed conflict in Ukraine has become a “frozen zone”, the reality demonstrates such a characterization runs afoul of the facts: hostilities continue on, with the increasing number of cases of massive human rights violations following the use of force by the Russian Federation in Crimea and its participation in the conflict in Eastern Ukraine. According to multiple reports, those violations in many cases amount to war crimes. It is thus necessary to ensure a proper compliance with legal rules applicable in the course of armed conflict, i.e., rules of international humanitarian law. Making sure the perpetrators of such crimes are brought under proper responsibility in accordance with relevant international criminal law standards is of equal importance. The matter of analysing and properly qualifying the human rights violations as crimes under the…

Domestic Implementation of Crimes against Humanity in Central Asia

Rustam Atadjanov

Sociology and Political Science · Asian Journal of Comparative Law · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A bstract Crimes against humanity constitute mass crimes against civilian populations and represent the so-called ‘core crimes’ of international criminal law. Central Asian states have so far abstained from incorporating the corpus delicti of crimes against humanity in their criminal legislation. After a short overview of the current status of crimes against humanity under international law, this article analyses the domestic legislation of five Central Asian countries: Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan. It looks at current Criminal Codes to suggest how those could be strengthened by the inclusion of properly formulated crimes against humanity dispositions, taking into account the peculiarities of these national legal systems. The article also offers a brief review of possible factors which might have precluded the states in question from proper…

Holding the Aggressor Accountable

Rustam Atadjanov

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Peacekeeping · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The issue of the necessity to bring those responsible for the commission of crimes under international law during the ongoing international armed conflict in Ukraine, i.e., the aggressive war of the Russian Federation against sovereign Ukraine, does not raise any principal questions or doubts on the side of the international community. It is the matter of an appropriate forum, or fora to do so that needs to be properly addressed. This piece looks at possible judicial venues for holding the main ringleader of the aggressive war, namely, the President of the Russian Federation, and his closest high-ranking officials personally accountable for core crimes as a matter of individual criminal responsibility. Prospects for three judicial mechanisms, either already existing or potential, are reviewed and brief reflections are offered as to the realistic scenarios for each of those…

Individual Criminal Responsibility of the Russian State Representatives for Their War Crimes and Crimes against Humanity in Ukraine

Rustam Atadjanov

Political Science and International Relations · Право України · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The military invasion of Ukraine by the Russian Federation since February 2022 has led to widespread international condemnation and close scrutiny.Among the various key aspects of this phase of the conflict, one of the most pressing legal issues is the commission of war crimes and crimes against humanity.These acts represent not only egregious violations of international law but also pose significant threats to peace, security, and the sovereignty of Ukraine, a recognized subject of international law.The need to address and delineate the legal responsibility of those guilty of committing these violations is both urgent and critical.This scholarly article aims to analyze the individual criminal responsibility of Russian state representatives for their involvement in war crimes and crimes against humanity in Ukraine.By looking at specific cases and the framework of international criminal…

Humanity

Rustam Atadjanov

Political Science and International Relations · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The discussion of values protected by international law will not diminish in significance. Those are quite diverse and heterogeneous as is the extent to which they have been established or clarified in law. If some of them have already been legally well defined, this is not so for others. The concept of humanity belongs to such yet undefined concepts. While it is hard to imagine a more compelling and global idea for appeal in the modern public discourse worldwide than the idea of humanity it is also difficult to find a more ambiguous category. No explicit definition of ʻhumanityʼ currently exists in international legal documents or in relevant case-law. The chapter argues that without understanding this basic underlying value many important questions will continue arising on the precise nature of key relevant legal categories in different branches of international law. It then offers…

Norman Geras,<i>Crimes Against Humanity: Birth of a Concept</i>

Rustam Atadjanov

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Criminal Justice · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

There is abundant legal literature on crimes against humanity. The historical development, practical application, material and mental elements as well as the scope and role in international criminal law and international law, pertinent jurisdiction and many other aspects of crimes against humanity have been the subject of both general and detailed analysis. Such aspects are often hotly debated. Some scholars have argued that it does not serve a purpose to ask philosophical questions about what constitutes humanity, its nature or why there should be crimes against humanity. According to this view, the focus of the discussion should be on the need to have the norm as well as its scope, content, enforcement, sanctions, remedies and prevention. 1 There is a valid point in the second part of this reasoning. However, it is difficult to agree with the first part. Analysing the nature, raison…

Interpretation of Law

Rustam Atadjanov

Law · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter explores the concept, methods, and types of legal interpretation, emphasizing its central role in the implementation and correct application of legal norms. Interpretation is defined as the process of clarifying and explaining the true meaning of legal rules in specific contexts, bridging the gap between abstract legal texts and concrete social realities. The chapter outlines the structure of interpretation through its object (normative text), method (legal-logical analysis), and subject (actual meaning), and explains how these interact to derive regulatory significance. It presents key interpretive methods such as grammatical, logical, systematic, historical-political, teleological, special-legal, and functional, each contributing uniquely to uncovering legislative intent. Types of interpretation are classified as official (normative and case-specific) and unofficial…

Society as a Legal Phenomenon

Rustam Atadjanov

Political Science and International Relations · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter explores the concept of society as a foundational legal phenomenon, emphasizing its central role in shaping, reflecting, and being shaped by legal norms. It begins by differentiating various definitions of society and argues for a legal interpretation that sees society as the structured and normative interaction of individuals and groups. This chapter asserts that understanding society from a legal standpoint is essential for comprehending how law emerges from, and functions within, social realities. It examines the distinction between society and civil society, critiques the overemphasis on the state in legal thinking, and promotes a society-centered approach aligned with integrative legal theory. The chapter also delves into the complex web of social norms—legal, moral, religious, customary, and explains how they regulate behavior. Legal norms are presented as the most…

Lawful Behavior and Legal Responsibility

Rustam Atadjanov

Political Science and International Relations · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter explores the dual concepts of lawful behavior and legal responsibility as central elements in the regulation of social relations. It begins by defining lawful behavior as conduct aligned with legal norms and examines its types such as marginal, conformist, habitual, and socially active, based on motivation and internalization of legal values. The chapter stresses the role of legal culture and conscious engagement in fostering stable, socially beneficial conduct. The second part analyzes unlawful behavior (offenses), outlining its legal characteristics and structural elements: subject, subjective side (guilt), object, and objective side (harm and causality). It categorizes offenses into criminal, administrative, civil, disciplinary, procedural, and international violations. The final section presents legal responsibility as the coercive response to offenses, detailing its…

Power and State

Rustam Atadjanov

Sociology and Political Science · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter examines the nature, structure, and functions of power and the state through a legal lens, situating them within the broader framework of societal organization and legal theory. The chapter opens by exploring various types of power in society—political, economic, religious, charismatic, legal, and introduces distinctions such as legal versus legitimate power and formal versus shadow power. It then turns to the state as the central wielder of public power, defining its unique features including sovereignty, universality, legislative monopoly, and its public and institutional character. The state is analyzed as both a political and legal organization, with emphasis on its role in upholding the rule of law, advancing public welfare, and mediating collective interests. The chapter provides a detailed overview of historical and contemporary theories of state formation, including…

Major Contemporary Legal Systems

Rustam Atadjanov

Law · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter presents a comparative overview of the world’s major legal systems, classifying them into distinct legal families based on their historical roots, core principles, and structural features. It begins by distinguishing between national legal systems and broader legal traditions, introducing six primary families: Romano-Germanic (continental), Anglo-American (common law), socialist, Islamic, Hindu, and African customary law. The chapter analyzes the Romano-Germanic system as codified and norm-based, rooted in abstract legislation and hierarchical legal codes. In contrast, common law relies on judicial precedent and the doctrine of stare decisis to ensure consistency and adaptability through case law. The socialist legal system, influenced by Marxist-Leninist ideology, prioritizes public ownership, centralized planning, and state interests over individual rights. Islamic law…

Conclusion

Rustam Atadjanov

Law · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter summarizes the core arguments and overarching vision of the textbook, emphasizing the need for a reimagined legal theory in post-Soviet states—one that views law not merely as a tool of state power but as a societal institution grounded in values, justice, and pluralism. It revisits each chapter’s contribution to this framework, from the theoretical foundations to the practical mechanisms of legal interpretation, behavior, and responsibility. The chapter reinforces the central thesis: that legal reform in the region requires both a critical break from statist-positivist legacies and a forward-looking embrace of legal culture, civil society, and rule-of-law principles. The author calls on academics, educators, and legal practitioners to engage with these ideas, not as final answers but as starting points for further dialogue and transformation. The book closes with the hope…

The Notion of Law

Rustam Atadjanov

Law · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter addresses one of the most foundational and contested questions in legal theory: what is law? The chapter surveys the major approaches to understanding and defining law (normativist, naturalist, and sociological) highlighting their respective strengths and limitations. It argues that each perspective captures essential but partial truths, and makes the case for an integrative or synthetic approach as the most comprehensive and context-sensitive understanding. Law, in this view, is a system of normative standards rooted in justice and equality, protected by society, and designed to regulate the interactions of free wills in a pluralistic environment. The chapter explores the core characteristics of law: normativity, generality, systematicity, binding nature, and the balance between stability and dynamism. It presents law as a distinctive social regulator, contrasting it with…

Rechtsstaat (State of Law) and Civil Society

Rustam Atadjanov

Law · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter provides a comprehensive examination of the concept of the Rechtsstaat, or State of Law, tracing its historical roots, theoretical evolution, core principles, and practical relevance especially in post-Soviet contexts. The chapter begins with a detailed historical account, highlighting the contributions of thinkers from Solon and Aristotle to Locke, Kant, Montesquieu, and beyond, who shaped the idea of law-bound statehood, grounded in justice, individual rights, and the limitation of power. It distinguishes Rechtsstaat from mere legalism, emphasizing that legality alone is not sufficient: laws must be just, fair, and serve human dignity. The chapter then presents key elements that define a Rechtsstaat: rule of law, supremacy of human rights and freedoms, mutual responsibility between state and citizen, separation of powers, high legal culture, and the essential role of…

The Principles and Functions of Law

Rustam Atadjanov

Law · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter explores the foundational principles and core functions of law, explaining how they shape the nature, structure, and purpose of legal systems. It begins by defining principles of law as overarching ideas that guide the formation, interpretation, and application of legal norms, emphasizing their role in ensuring freedom, justice, and order in society. General principles such as social freedom, justice, democracy, humanism, equality, legality, and responsibility, are presented as universal standards embedded in both national and international law. The chapter also introduces cross-branch (interdisciplinary) and branch-specific principles, illustrating how legal coherence is maintained across diverse areas like criminal, civil, and procedural law. A key discussion focuses on the controversial yet increasingly accepted role of legal principles as sources of law, especially in…

Sources of Law

Rustam Atadjanov

Law · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter provides a comprehensive examination of the diverse sources from which law derives its authority, structure, and guiding principles, especially within the complex legal cultures of post-Soviet states. It begins with a broad, pluralistic definition of “source of law” that includes not only formal state-issued instruments but also societal customs, judicial precedents, scholarly doctrine, and general moral principles. The chapter explores how legal custom, emerging from longstanding social practices, becomes a binding legal norm once recognized by the state. Judicial precedent is addressed as a means of ensuring consistency and adaptability, particularly in common law systems, with an emphasis on how precedent could be cautiously integrated into civil law traditions. Juridical doctrine is presented as an influential interpretive tool, often bridging the gap between codified…

The Subject of the Common Theory of Law

Rustam Atadjanov

Law · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter defines the core subject and methodology of the Common Theory of Law, positioning it as both a legal and social science that investigates the universal patterns, origins, and evolution of legal phenomena. It explains the discipline’s role in identifying the systemic nature of law within society, distinct from narrower sectoral legal sciences. The chapter outlines its essential functions—cognitive, heuristic, and prognostic—and details the methodological principles that guide its research, including historicism, objectivity, concreteness, and pluralism. Logical tools such as induction, deduction, synthesis, and hypothesis formulation are highlighted as mechanisms for scientific inquiry and theory building. Furthermore, the chapter explores the Common Theory’s integrative function within the legal sciences, providing the conceptual foundation for both theoretical-historical…

The Main Theories of the Origin and Nature of Law

Rustam Atadjanov

Law · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter offers a comprehensive and structured overview of the key theories explaining the origin and nature of law, tracing their development from mythological and religious conceptions to modern libertarian legal thought. Beginning with ancient beliefs in divine or supernatural sources of law, the chapter explores how early civilizations justified authority and legal norms through the will of gods. It then moves to patriarchal and paternalistic conceptions, examining how historical legal systems reinforced gender hierarchies and limited personal autonomy under the guise of care and protection. The organic theory likens society and the state to living organisms, with legal institutions functioning like interdependent organs. Classical natural law and social contract theories are discussed as foundational rationalist frameworks, highlighting law’s moral underpinnings and its…

A Critical Reflection on Positivist Approaches Toward International Law in Central Asia

Rustam Atadjanov

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter critically examines the influence of positivist approaches on the development and application of international law within Central Asian contexts, encompassing Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan. Through a meticulous review of existing legal frameworks, including constitutions and laws concerning international treaties, this essay aims to uncover the significant trends shaping the region’s legal landscape. It will delve into the evolution of these laws to uncover local decision-makers’ attitudes toward international law and its domestic enforcement. By exploring the prevailing perceptions of law both at the state and societal levels, the chapter seeks to illuminate how these attitudes have shaped the understanding and reception of international legal principles, norms, and key concepts such as rule of law and human rights in Central…

The Genocide Case against Israel: from the Victim’s Side to the Defendant’s Bench?

Rustam Atadjanov

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of International Peacekeeping · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article presents a scholarly analysis of the United Nations International Court of Justice’s ( icj ) preliminary rulings issued in January, March, and May 2024 regarding South Africa’s genocide case against Israel, initiated in December 2023. The study critically examines these initial rulings, identifying the compelling arguments presented by the Court and comparing it to some other recent cases such as Nicaragua v. Germany . Employing a legal analytical methodology, the piece argues for the significant judicial implications of the icj ’s preliminary findings and offers a tentative forecast for the expected main judgment. It further delves into the proper qualification of the crime of genocide as well as its characterization as a human rights law violation, providing the author’s perspective on the seriousness of the genocide allegations from both sides involved in this…

Implementation of International Human Rights Law during Situations of Violence: The Central Asian Experience

Rustam Atadjanov

Political Science and International Relations · Baltic Yearbook of International Law Online · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The Central Asian region is periodically prone to turbulent and destabilizing events. Many human rights challenges arise, with multiple violations and restrictions of individual human rights and freedoms (e.g., civil and political rights) taking place, during, but also as a short-term and long-term result of these tumultuous events. Existing (or non-existent) legal frameworks have played an instrumental part in this status quo . It is important to scrutinize the abovementioned challenges and factors, and propose potentially workable solutions to address the problems in this area. With the use of legal analytical, historical and comparative methods, this paper reviews and systematizes some major situations involving violence which have taken place on the territory of five Central Asian States, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan, since they gained…

Olivier Beauvallet (ed.), Dictionnaire encyclopédique de la justice pénale internationale (Berger-Levrault, 2017), 1052 pp.

Rustam Atadjanov

Political Science and International Relations · Central Asian yearbook of international law and international relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Olivier Beauvallet (ed.), Dictionnaire encyclopédique de la justice pénale internationale (Berger-Levrault, 2017), 1052 pp. A good encyclopedic dictionary aims at offering a complete description of the topic, with a choice of entries arranged alphabetically and selected to convey a range of knowledge. The “Dictionnaire encyclopédique” under this review deals with international criminal justice and lays out fundamental elements of the modern system of international criminal justice as well as the underlying theory and present practice. The review explains the coverage, purposes, language aspects, and substantive elements of the entries in the dictionary citing several selected examples out of those entries. It also points out some of the missing elements in the dictionary’s content which, if included, could have only benefited the already very well written and edited volume. The main…

The Concept of Humanity in International Criminal Law

Rustam Atadjanov

Political Science and International Relations · Central Asian yearbook of international law and international relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Concept of Humanity in International Criminal Law It is difficult to find a more ambiguous and multifaceted category than the concept of humanity. This is all the more striking considering its widespread appearance and countless invocations in legal, political, ethical, social and cultural spheres, expressly or otherwise. Among the words several different connotations are mankind, humaneness, human dignity and human nature. But there is no explicit or accepted definition of the term “humanity” in international legal documents or in relevant case law. Often used in the legal literature, first of all with reference to the famous Martens’ Clause, the concept of “humanity” does not yet have a comprehensive formulation in international criminal law or in other relevant branches of law, for that matter. To tackle the issue, the present article argues that in order to properly assess the…

Crimes Against Humanity

Rustam Atadjanov

Political Science and International Relations · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Crimes against humanity represent one of the so-called “core crimes” or crimes under international law. They constitute mass crimes against a civilian population and may be the most commonly known among the different of types international crimes used for labeling mass atrocities almost every time when there is news that such have occurred. The phenomenon of crimes against humanity continues to sparkle lots of debates both scholarly and practical. The modern definition of crimes against humanity is firmly established in the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court. Despite this, many important doctrinal and normative issues (e.g., protective scope, contextual element, policy requirement and civilian population) are actively debated in scholarship and practice. This chapter discusses the key contextual elements of crimes against humanity, as well as the individual criminal acts…