arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Rupert Cross

16 papers · 1964–1992

1964: 21965: 11966: 11967: 01968: 01969: 01970: 01971: 01972: 01973: 01974: 11975: 01976: 01977: 01978: 01979: 11980: 01981: 01982: 01983: 01984: 01985: 01986: 01987: 01988: 01989: 01990: 01991: 91992: 1
1964peak 9 in 19911992

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–16 of 16 RSS

Precedent in English Law

Rupert Cross, J. W. HARRIS

Law · Columbia Law Review · · cited 80× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The English doctrine of precedent ratio decidendi and obiter dictum stare decisis exceptions to stare decisis precedent as a source of law precedent and judicial reasoning precedent and legal theory the future.

Precedent as a Source of Law

Rupert Cross, John William Harris

Law · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract We have now completed the account of the operation of the rules of precedent summarized on p. 6. These rules generate what may not ineptly be described as ‘jurisprudential’ problems of their own. Are they rules of law? Can the rules of precedent be based on precedent? Why does the idea of the prospective overruling of a judicial decision tend to be anathema to an English lawyer when retrospective legislation is equally abhorrent to him? Brief discussions of these questions will be found in Chapters VII and VIII. This chapter and Chapter VI are primarily concerned with problems posed by case-law generally. They would arise even if the English rules of precedent were very different from what they are. They stem from the older and more important rule that judges must have regard to case-law. In what sense is a judicial decision, i.e. a precedent, a source of law? Do decided cases…

An Attempt to Update the Law of Evidence

Rupert Cross

Law · Israel Law Review · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

When Dean Feller did me the honour of inviting me to give the Lionel Cohen lecture for 1973 one of the subjects I submitted, and the one accepted by him, was “Reforming the Law of Evidence—The English Experience”. For me those were the halcyon days before the publication of the 11th Report of the Criminal Law Revision Committee; the law of evidence in civil cases had been modernised by the Civil Evidence Acts of 1968 and 1972, and I pictured the draft Criminal Evidence Bill annexed to the 11th Report going merrily through Parliament, if not without some protest and amendment, at least with celerity and the certitude of becoming law. Alas, this was not to be. To describe the reception of the Report as “unenthusiastic” would be the understatement of the century; but, although I must confess to considerable pessimism concerning the questions when and to what extent the draft Bill will…

The English Doctrine of Precedent

Rupert Cross, John William Harris

Law · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract It is a basic principle of the administration of justice that like cases should be decided alike. This is enough to account for the fact that, in almost every jurisdiction, a judge tends to decide a case in the same way as that in which a similar case has been decided by another judge. The strength of this tendency varies greatly. It may be little more than an inclination to do as others have done before, or it may be the outcome of a positive obligation to follow a previous decision in the absence of justification for departing from it. Judicial precedent has some persuasive effect almost everywhere because stare decisis (keep to what has been decided previously) is a maxim of practically universal application. The peculiar feature of the English doctrine of precedent is its strongly coercive nature. English judges are sometimes obliged to follow a previous case although they…

Exceptions to Stare Decisis

Rupert Cross, John William Harris

Law · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract One of the defects of the preliminary statement of the English rules of precedent in Chapter I is that, the House of Lords apart, it does not refer to the existence of important exceptions to the rule of stare decisis. The purpose of the present chapter is to analyse those exceptions. They have varied from period to period for stare decisis has been the general rule in England for a considerable time. It will be convenient to begin by saying something of Sir William Holdsworth’s views on this subject before discussing the notion of overruling a case which is essential to a proper understanding of the rest of the chapter. Holdsworth’s general thesis was that the English doctrine of precedent hits the golden mean between too much flexibility and too much rigidity; for it gives to the legal system the rigidity which it must have if it is to possess a definite body of principles…

Ratio Decidendi and Obiter Dictum

Rupert Cross, John William Harris

Law · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract According to the preliminary statement of the English rules of precedent contained in the last chapter, every court is bound to follow any case decided by a court above it in the hierarchy, and appellate courts (other than the House of Lords) are bound by their previous decisions. This statement is too concise because it does not indicate that the only part of a previous case which is binding is the ratio decidendi (reason for deciding). The principal object of the present chapter is to consider what is meant by the ratio decidendi of a case when the phrase is used by judges and other lawyers and by what methods it may be determined. This will show what is entailed by ‘following’ or ‘applying’ a case and by being ‘bound; by a previous decision, although these matters are not discussed until the beginning of the next chapter. The ratio decidendi is best approached by a…

Stare Decisis

Rupert Cross, John William Harris

Law · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract According to the preliminary statement of the English doctrine of precedent in Chapter I, a court is bound to follow any case decided by a court above it, and appellate courts (other than the House of Lords) are bound by their previous decisions. What is meant by saying that a court is ‘bound to follow a case’ or ‘bound by a decision’? In this context, according to orthodox theory, ‘case’ and ‘decision’ mean ratio decidendi. In other contexts they may respectively mean a particular piece of litigation, and the judgment or order of court by which that litigation is determined. ‘Judgment’ is also a word of many meanings. It may signify a court order as when we say that A got judgment for £100, it may signify everything said by a judge with regard to the grounds for making an order (the entirety of his opinion including statements of fact and obiter dicta), or it may be used…

The Future

Rupert Cross, John William Harris

Law · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Precedent rules are based on the practice of the judges. The basic rules set out on page 6 seem firmly established. In particular, the rule that intermediate appellate courts are generally bound by their own decisions has not been questioned since the decision of the House of Lords in Davis v. Johnson. Nevertheless, the view has been expressed in the Privy Council that opinions of the supreme tribunal on such a question cannot constitute the ratio decidendi of any case and are not therefore strictly binding. One cannot rule out the possibility that, at some future date, a full court of the Court of Appeal will decide to abrogate or modify the rule in Young v. Bristol Aeroplane Co. Ltd. What the reaction of the House of Lords would be to such a move, and what the final upshot, must remain matters of mere conjecture. All one can say is that most commentators believe that such a…

Introduction

Rupert Cross, John William Harris

Law · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract PRECEDENT is usually discussed in books on jurisprudence. Jurisprudence may be roughly described as the study of a lawyer’s fundamental assumptions. Bentham spoke of it as ‘the art of being methodically ignorant of what everybody knows’. If for ‘every-body’ we substitute ‘every lawyer’, we arrive at the conception of jurisprudence to which the following pages seek to give effect. Every lawyer, whether he is a practitioner or a legal writer, usually takes for granted the meaning of such statements as ‘that is a rule of law’, ‘this was the ratio decidendi of the case’, ‘the decision is binding on the Court of Appeal, but not on the House of Lords’, and ‘X has a legal right to be paid £100 by Y’. One of the purposes of jurisprudence is to elucidate these statements. It is not, or at least need not be, the only purpose of jurisprudence. A consideration of the ethical or social…

Precedent and Judicial Reasoning

Rupert Cross, John William Harris

Law · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter begins with a consideration of the extent to which judicial reasoning about law may be properly described as either ‘deductive’ or ‘inductive’. The question is probably less significant than the frequency with which it is raised suggests, but the discussion makes it possible to bring into relief certain features of English case-law which have a bearing on the application of precedent. The rest of the chapter is primarily concerned with reasoning by analogy. A few remarks were made on this topic in Chapter I, and it is now proposed to consider this feature of the English doctrine of precedent in greater detail. The subject is an important one because it is principally by means of such reasoning that the judges have developed a coherent body of law. Having ascertained the ratio decidendi of a previous case, and having, where necessary, interpreted that case in the…

Precedent and Legal Theory

Rupert Cross, John William Harris

Law · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The English doctrine of precedent raises problems in relation to any proposed definition of law. For the purposes of the present discussion, these problems can, in the main, be reduced to two questions; (i) Does the proposed definition include the rationes decidendi of cases as well as the contents of legislation? (ii) Does the proposed definition include the rules which confer authority on the ratio decidendi of a case, i.e. the rules by virtue of which a particular ratio has the force of law? If the answer to the first question is in the negative, the definition must be rejected in so far as it purports to be applicable to the English legal system. No lawyer would hesitate to say that the rule in Rylands v. Fletcher is just as much a rule of English law as the statutory requirement that a will must be signed by two witnesses. It is perhaps more doubtful whether the proposed…

The First Two Vinerian Professors: Blackstone and Chambers

Rupert Cross

Political Science and International Relations · William and Mary law review · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This is the second in a series of four articles commemorating the bicentennial of American legal education, dating from the establishment of the first chair of law and police, occupied by George Wythe, at the College of William and Mary on December 4, 1779. The colonial antecedents to the College's formal relation to professional legal education may be traced to the career of Sir John Randolph, a student at William and Mary, 1705-1713, who then prepared for the bar at Gray's Inn, London (1715-1717). Randolph's two sons, Peyton ("The Patriot") and John ("The Tory") followed his example, first at the College of William and Mary and subsequently at the Middle Temple. His grandson, Edmund, after study at the College on the eve of the Revolution, read for the bar under his father and uncle. The Randolphs and their cousins, Thomas Jefferson and John Marshall, were prototypes of various…

The General Part of the Criminal Law of Norway. By Johannes Andenaes, trans. Thomas P. Ogle. [South Hackensack, N.J.: Fred B. Rothman & Co.; London: Sweet & Maxwell Ltd.1965. xxiii and 346 pp. £4 4s. $13.50.]

Rupert Cross

Political Science and International Relations · International and Comparative Law Quarterly · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The General Part of the Criminal Law of Norway. By Johannes Andenaes, trans. Thomas P. Ogle. [South Hackensack, N.J.: Fred B. Rothman & Co.; London: Sweet & Maxwell Ltd.1965. xxiii and 346 pp. £4 4s. $13.50.] - Volume 15 Issue 2-3

Statutes: Criminal Evidence Act, 1965

Rupert Cross

Law · Modern Law Review · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

THE threatened statutory reversal of the Burmuh Oil case ' and Rookes v. Barnard 2 gave rise to much wailing and gnashing of teeth; nothing of the sort is likely to follow upon the reversal by the Criminal Evidence Act, 1965, of Myers v. Director o/ Public Prosecutions.''I n that case the House of Lords held that the reception of manufacturers' records compiled on information supplied by workmen as evidence of the numbers on cylinder blocks put into cars infringed the rule against hearsay, and the majority of the House held that the records were not admissible by way of exception to the hearsay rule.I n words substantially borrowed from the Evidence Act, 1938, which only applies to civil proceedings, section 1 (1) of the new Act provides that " In any criminal proceedings where direct oral evidence of a fact would be admissible, any statement contained in a document and tending to…

Russell on Crime. Twelfth edition. By J. W. C. Turner, <scp>m.c., ll.d.</scp> [London: Stevens &amp; Sons, Ltd.1964. Two volumes. (1) clvii, 810 and (index) 62 pp.; (2) xiv, 813–1583 and (index) 62 pp. £14 14s. net.]

Rupert Cross

Law · The Cambridge Law Journal · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Russell on Crime. Twelfth edition. By J. W. C. Turner, m.c., ll.d. [London: Stevens &amp; Sons, Ltd.1964. Two volumes. (1) clvii, 810 and (index) 62 pp.; (2) xiv, 813–1583 and (index) 62 pp. £14 14s. net.] - Volume 22 Issue 2

The Law of Evidence in South Africa. By A.P. O'Dowd. [Cape Town, Wynberg, Johannesburg: Juta and Co. Ltd.; Distributed in the United Kingdom by Sweet &amp; Maxwell. 1968. xxx and 195 pp. 4.4s.]

Rupert Cross

Law · International and Comparative Law Quarterly · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Law of Evidence in South Africa. By A.P. O'Dowd. [Cape Town, Wynberg, Johannesburg: Juta and Co. Ltd.; Distributed in the United Kingdom by Sweet &amp; Maxwell. 1968. xxx and 195 pp. 4.4s.] - Volume 13 Issue 4