Public service responsiveness to users’ demands and needs: theory, practice and primary healthcare in England
Rod Sheaff, Susan Pickard, Keri E. Iyall Smith
Analyses and policy statements about publicly funded services frequently distinguish ‘demands’ from ‘needs’. The distinction has been challenged, calling into question the coherence of formulating welfare policy and evaluating public services in terms of needs. This paper explicates the conceptual distinction between demands and needs in terms of derived demand and information asymmetry. ‘Needs’ can be defined as ‘rational demands’, where ‘rational’ means ‘consistent and evidence–based’, and ‘demands’ as ‘desires’ rather than ‘effective (i.e. economic) demand’. On that basis, practical demand management in needs–based public services would require: 1. Knowledge of users’ demands for services; 2. Content analyses of users’ demands to identify any misinformed demands; 3. Conversion of any misinformed demands into evidence–based specifications of needs; 4. Formulating coherent…