arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Robin Cooke

49 papers · 1954–2013

1954: 11955: 01956: 01957: 01958: 01959: 01960: 01961: 11962: 01963: 01964: 01965: 01966: 01967: 01968: 01969: 01970: 01971: 01972: 01973: 01974: 01975: 11976: 01977: 01978: 11979: 11980: 01981: 01982: 01983: 11984: 01985: 01986: 21987: 21988: 21989: 31990: 01991: 11992: 21993: 41994: 21995: 31996: 41997: 31998: 41999: 22000: 12001: 12002: 02003: 22004: 12005: 12006: 12007: 02008: 02009: 12010: 02011: 02012: 02013: 1
1954peak 4 in 19932013

Papers

showing 1–25 of 49 RSS

The Law Lords: An Endangered Heritage

Robin Cooke

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 18× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This is a defence by Lord Cooke of the multiple roles of the House of Lords, which at the time functioned as the final court of appeal for the United Kingdom. This was a personal defence written in response to proposals at the time (subsequently adopted) for a Supreme Court of the United Kingdom. He begins by critiquing the doctrine of the separation of powers by reference to historical writings. He then outlines the particular functions of the Law Lords, before discussing the 1999 Royal Commission on the Reform of the House of Lords and its subsequent report, with particular emphasis on the submission of Lord Wilberforce. Lord Cooke then provides examples of non-judicial contributions by particular Lords of Appeal, before arguing that the status quo is consistent with art 6(1) of the European Convention on Human Rights. Lord Cooke concludes with a defence of the particular judicial…

The Road Ahead for the Common Law

Robin Cooke

Law · International and Comparative Law Quarterly · · cited 12× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In the 1996 Hamlyn Lectures, under the title Turning Points of the Common Law , I examined four great cases where the House of Lords set the law of England, and consequently the law of most of the English-speaking world, on a new course by reversing decisions of the courts below. They were Salomon v Salomon & Co Ltd 1 (insistence on separate identities of company and controlling shareholder); Woolmington v Director of Public Prosecutions 2 (discovery of a golden thread about onus of proof in English criminal law); Hedley Byrne & Co Ltd v Heller 3 (qualified acceptance of duty of care in tort to safeguard against economic damage); and Anisminic Ltd v Foreign Compensation Commission 4 (affirmation that material errors of law by administrative bodies are alwaysredressible by courts).

The Suggested Revolution Against the Crown

Robin Cooke

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 9× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In this article, Sir Robin examines the legal implications of a potential abolition of the monarchy in New Zealand. He begins by describing the legal history of New Zealand, as a member of the Commonwealth with the Queen as its head of state. Sir Robin then discusses what conditions might be required for the judiciary to uphold a New Zealand statute abolishing the monarchy. These conditions include evidence of significant public support for a republic as well as evidence of substantial Māori concurrence. He concludes that the legal and constitutional implications would be complex and that, beyond legal concerns, there would also be significant political and national issues at play.

The Place of Equity and Equitable Doctrines in the Contemporary Common Law World: A New Zealand Perspective

Robin Cooke

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 9× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In this paper on the topic of equity, Sir Robin Cooke begins by outlining various philosophies on equity and its relationship with common law before turning to consider equity as applied in the New Zealand Court of Appeal. Lord Cooke does this through a discussion of the following cases that had come before the Court while he was a member: Day v Mead [1987] 2 NZLR 443 (CA), Aquaculture Corp v New Zealand Green Mussel Co [1990] 3 NZLR 299 (CA), Gathergood v Blundell & Brown Ltd [1992] 3 NZLR 643 (CA), DFC New Zealand Ltd v Goddard [1992] 2 NZLR 445 (CA), Liggett v Kensington [1993] 1 NZLR 257 (CA) (Goldcorp), Mouat v Clark Boyce [1992] 2 NZLR 599 (CA), and Phillips v Phillips [1993] NZFLR 321 (CA). Lord Cooke notes that healthy cross-fertilisation between jurisdictions in relation to the development of equity has led to a “common movement” across the common law world “towards an equity…

An Impossible Distinction

Robin Cooke

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 8× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In this article Cooke J discusses the liability in negligence of builders, manufacturers, and local authorities for defective buildings. He argues that those who put members of the community into what are intended to be sound and durable structures (such as homes) intended for a succession of people should be expected to take reasonable care that these structures are fit for use. He considers, in particular, that a local authority’s duty of care stems from its control over the building inspection process, and therefore it should be required to take care not to cause or contribute to causing economic loss to homeowners. Cooke J discusses this duty of care in light of judicial developments in England and the United States of America. Abstract written by Elizabeth Chan

The Struggle for Simplicity in Administrative Law

Robin Cooke

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 8× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This is a revised version of a paper presented on 20 February 1986 by Sir Robin Cooke on administrative law. Sir Robin draws on more than 35 years of experience in the field to articulate what he considers to be a more “simple” approach to understanding administrative law. He begins with some warnings, cautioning counsel against the following: relying on extra-judicial comments by the judiciary (especially out of context), a dogmatic labelling of particular legal issues as being either “public” or “private”, and the use of obscure complications of principle. He then explains that the essential function of judicial review is to ensure that decision-makers act in accordance with the law, fairly and reasonably. Sir Robin then discusses each of these three heads, noting that they overlap. In doing so, he draws on cases, including Northumberland [1952] 1 KB 338, Associated Provincial Picture…

Empowerment and accountability: The quest for administrative justice

Robin Cooke

Sociology and Political Science · Commonwealth Law Bulletin · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This text is a revised and annotated version of a lecture delivered by Sir Robin Cooke at the Fifth Judicial Colloquium on the Domestic Application of International Human Rights Norms at Balliol College, Oxford on 22 September 1992. In this lecture, Sir Robin assesses the extent to which the three branches of government are empowered and accountable to each other. He argues that the legislature is empowered by and therefore accountable to the judiciary. He explains that the scope of executive accountability turns on the suitability of the subject-matter of the decision for judicial review. He then cautions that the judiciary should be independent of executive influence. Sir Robin concludes by expressing guarded support for the appointment of judges by an independent judicial appointments commission.

The New Zealand National Legal Identity

Robin Cooke

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 4× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In this article, Sir Robin Cooke advocates for the abolition of the right of appeal from the New Zealand Court of Appeal to the Privy Council in two parts. First, he describes New Zealand’s “distinct national legal identity” by discussing how New Zealand law has developed in a number of different fields, including criminal, family, property, contract, employment, torts, and administrative law. In the second part, he argues for abolition of the right of appeal to the Privy Council. Sir Robin outlines this argument by referring to his personal experience as a member of the Privy Council, historic examples of New Zealand appeals, and the development of a distinct New Zealand national legal identity. Abstract by Tim Cochrane.

The Role of Judges

Robin Cooke

Political Science and International Relations · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 3× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This is a paper originally presented by Lord Cooke at the Building the Constitution conference of the Institute of Policies Studies in Wellington on 7 and 8 April 2000. In it, Lord Cooke stresses four themes. First, that the New Zealand constitution is unique in its form and, although “no machinery for changing its machinery had been laid down”, courts may not recognise radical changes made without “overwhelming general and Maori support”. Secondly, entrenchment of human rights was necessary for human civilisation. Thirdly, appeals to the Privy Council should be abolished and, fourthly an acceptable replacement could be a “Supreme Court of New Zealand, consisting of a few permanent local judges, augmented by one or two overseas judges”, similar to the practice used by the House of Lords, Privy Council, Hong Kong Court of Final Appeal, and Supreme Court of Fiji.

The Myth of Sovereignty

Robin Cooke

Political Science and International Relations · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 2× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Sovereignty is often characterised by British constitutional orthodoxy as the attribute of an independent and supreme authority, usually located in Parliament by virtue of the supremacy of legislation. In this article, Lord Cooke dispels the myth that any single organ of government exercises sovereignty as a matter of constitutional law, and instead presents a vision of interaction and collaboration in the exercise of governmental power under modern Westminster constitutions.

The Crimes Bill 1989: A Judge's Response

Robin Cooke

Sociology and Political Science · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 2× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This is a lecture given by Sir Robin Cooke as part of a series at Victoria University of Wellington in June 1989 on the Crimes Bill that had recently been introduced into Parliament. Sir Robin takes a critical look at different aspects of the Bill and expresses significant reservations about the merits of some of the major features of the Bill in its (then) present form. In particular, he expressed three categories of concern. The first is about the “ambivalent” changes affecting murder, manslaughter, grave wounding and the open-ended insanity clause. The second is the omission of drugs-related crimes. Finally, Sir Robin notes that there is a need for further attention to be given to computer crimes. He views the (then) proposed overhaul of the Crimes Act 1961 as valuable but considers it is a project requiring further work.

Third Thoughts on Administrative Law

Robin Cooke

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 2× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This is a revised version of an address delivered by Sir Robin Cooke at an Auckland District Law Society seminar on 22 May 1979. It was his third Law Society address on the topic of general administrative law (the first and second reported at [1960] NZLJ 128 and [1975] NZLJ 529 respectively). Throughout the address, Sir Robin reflects on a speech given by Lord Diplock in 1974 (reported at [1974] CLJ 233). He begins by discussing recent leading cases from the United Kingdom. Sir Robin then turns to New Zealand. First, he discusses the “revolution” brought about in New Zealand as a result of the enactment of the Judicature Amendment Act 1977. He then considers some New Zealand judicial themes, commenting briefly on Fitzgerald v Muldoon [1976] 2 NZLR 615 (SC), as well as recent case law emphasising the importance that public decision-makers provide giving reasons for their decisions. He…

Remoteness of Damages and Judicial Discretion

Robin Cooke

Law · The Cambridge Law Journal · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The law about remoteness of damage in contract and tort is in a strangely unsettled state. Pursuing justice in individual cases, the courts have felt driven into vacillations on points of general principle which have not shown our system of case law at its best. Yet there is perhaps no field of common law in which there have been so many attempts by judges, and at a high level of authority, to formulate principles or rules in exact terms. A glance over ground mainly very familiar may not be wasted if it happens to contribute anything towards attaining a more stable perspective.

A Constitutional Retreat

Robin Cooke

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In this paper Lord Cooke considers R (on the application of Jackson) v Attorney General [2005] UKHL 56, [2006] 1 AC 262, which was a challenge to the validity of the Hunting Act 2004. He describes the central issue in Jackson as being “whether the power to legislate without the consent of the House of Lords, which power was conferred by the Parliament Act 1911, could be exercised, as it was in the 1949 Act, to shorten certain time stipulations contained in the 1911 Act itself”. Lord Cooke first outlines the key legislative provisions and then turns to the reasoning of the House of Lords. He focusses on three key points. He first critiques the House of Lords’ statutory interpretation of the key legislation section, section 2(1) (as outlined by Lord Rodger). He then assesses the “political fact” argument (as discussed by Lord Hope). Thirdly, Lord Cooke stresses that case authorities could…

The British Embracement of Human Rights

Robin Cooke

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This text is a revised version of a lecture delivered by Lord Cooke at a conference on incorporation of the European Convention on Human Rights held at the University of Edinburgh Law School on June 26, 1998. The author compares the Human Rights Act 1998 with the equivalent provisions of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 and draws a number of distinctions. He suggests that the interpretative obligation in section 3 is arguably more emphatic in its terms and may authorize courts to adopt a strained construction of legislation in order to achieve compatibility with Convention rights. This will involve something not far short of a “quantum leap” in the courts’ approach to statutory construction. The new declaration of incompatibility is identified as a significant advance on the New Zealand legislation, as is the inclusion of an express remedies clause. Lord Cooke suggests that by…

The Judge in an Evolving Society

Robin Cooke

Law · Victoria University of Wellington Law Review · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this address, given to Judges and Judicial Officers of the High Court of Hong Kong on 17 December 1997, Lord Cooke speaks of the development of a common law of the world with particular reference to the Basic Law of Hong Kong.

The Liberation of English Public Law

Robin Cooke

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In this lecture, the fourth of Lord Cooke's Hamlyn Lectures on “Turning Points in the Common Law”, Lord Cooke discusses the issue of when courts have jurisdiction to review decisions of tribunals or inferior courts, drawing on Anisminic Ltd v Foreign Compensation Commission [1969] 2 AC 147 (HL(E)). This lecture suggests four possible approaches the House of Lords could have taken in Anisminic. It also discusses Lord Diplock’s approach to this issue by comparing his judgment in the Court of Appeal in Anisminic with his subsequent judgment in the House of Lords in O’Reilly v Mackman [1983] 2 AC 237 (HL(E)). Lord Cooke notes that this latter judgment extended Anisminic by essentially abolishing the distinction between errors of law going to jurisdiction and errors of law within jurisdiction, with two exceptions. The lecture finally remarks on the “muddled” Australian approach, and links…

Master Goff's Common Law Through Commonwealth Eyes

Robin Cooke

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This paper is a tribute to Lord Goff, an English law lord. Lord Cooke assesses the development of the English common law from a Commonwealth lens. In particular, he discusses how in the second half of the 20th century, some courts in Commonwealth countries became bolder in diverging from principles established by the English common law. Lord Cooke then outlines how, in turn, the English courts became more willing to treat Commonwealth decisions as not so much “essays in the application of the principles of the common law of England” but as sources of comparative law. He concludes by noting that the fact that the “rest of the common law world” had grown up and “mainly [stood] on its own feet” did not at all diminish the international respect for English judges. Abstract by Elizabeth Chan.

Administrative Law: The Vanishing Sphinx

Robin Cooke

Sociology and Political Science · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In this article, Mr Cooke discusses administrative law as an evolving area of law. He begins by identifying key English, Australian, and New Zealand texts on administrative law. He then discusses two major decisions on substantive administrative law in the House of Lords, Animisnic Ltd v Foreign Compensation Commission [1969] 1 All ER 208 (HL) and Padfield v Minister of Agriculture [1968] 1 All ER 694 (HL), as well as discussing developments in procedural administrative law. Lastly, he outlines some institutional/statutory aspects of administrative law, including the possible extension of the Ombudsman’s functions, the establishment of the Administrative Division of the (then) Supreme Court, the enactment of the Judicature Amendment Act 1972, and the work of statutory tribunals. Abstract by Elizabeth Chan.

Administrative Law—Natural Justice—Right to a Hearing

Robin Cooke

Law · The Cambridge Law Journal · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this article, Robin Cooke discusses when the administrative law duty to provide a hearing to persons likely to be prejudicially affected arises. He discusses this duty, also known as the rule audi alteram partem, in light of R v Metropolitan Police Commissioner [1953] 1 WLR 1150 (QB). He compares the “form over substance” approach adopted by Lord Chief Justice Goddard with the approach of the New Zealand Court of Appeal in New Zealand Dairy Board v Okitu Dairy Co Ltd [1953] NZLR 366 (CA). After providing three caveats to his advice, Mr Cooke draws from these and other cases seven factors indicating that a right to a hearing should be implied. Abstract by Tim Cochrane.

Book Review: Waitangi and Indigenous Rights: Revolution, Law and Legitimation by FM Brookfield

Robin Cooke

Sociology and Political Science · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In this book review, Sir Robin gives glowing praise for Professor FM Brookfield’s book, Waitangi and Indigenous Rights: Revolution, Law and Legitimation as a major contribution to the legal literature concerning revolutions. Sir Robin concentrates on four points. First, he comments on Professor Brookfield’s broad definition of “revolution”, noting that most constitutions originate in revolutions which are legitimated in effectiveness over time. Secondly, he mentions the role of de facto courts in exercising supra-constitutional powers to accept a lawful constitution in revolutionary times. Thirdly, he discusses the application of Professor Brookfield’s explanation of “revolutions” to the New Zealand context. Finally, he explains Professor Brookfield’s own “revolution” to establish a Māori national representative body to consider proposed legislation affecting Māori rights.

The Road Ahead for the Common Law1

Robin Cooke

Political Science and International Relations · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter discusses the work of the English courts, identifying some current lines of development and some that can lie ahead. It looks at the influence of international law, the division of labor between the courts and the legislator, and the development of written law in the common law system.

The Basic Themes

Robin Cooke

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This short article is a revised version of comments given by Lord Cooke at the final session of the New Zealand Centre for Public Law’s First Annual Conference on the Primary Organs of Government, held at the Victoria University of Wellington Law School on 28 and 29 November 2003. In these comments, given as part of a panel discussion on Supreme Court reform and other topical issues, Lord Cooke returns to some themes of the first session, focussing on remarks given by Professor Mark Tushnet and Professor George Williams. In doing so, Lord Cooke comments on the controversial terms “sovereignty” and “judicial supremacy”, related remarks given by Professor Philip Joseph, and the possibility of collusion between branches of government as a result of s 3(2) of the Supreme Court Act 2003.

Final Appeal Courts: Some Comparisons

Robin Cooke

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In this article, Lord Cooke comments on final appellate courts, drawing on his observations serving as a judge on a number of final appellate courts, including the House of Lords, the Privy Council, the New Zealand Court of Appeal (as a de facto final appellate court), and other courts in the Pacific. He begins by outlining differences, including in the areas of court procedure, style of advocacy, and approaches to human rights in different final appellate courts. In particular, he discusses the work and judicial collegiality at the Supreme Court of the United States. He also comments on the increasing diversity of membership among the judges of the House of Lords, and discusses the continuing role of the Privy Council in a much diminished Commonwealth jurisdiction. In light of his judicial experiences, Lord Cooke concludes by offering ideas on how New Zealand’s judicial structure might…

Tribute to Dr James Williams

Robin Cooke

Law · Victoria University of Wellington Law Review · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A memorial service was held at Victoria University to honour the life and work of Dr JamesWilliams, former Professor of English and New Zealand Law, Principal and then first Vice-Chancellor of the Victoria University of Wellington, who died suddenly at his home in Sydney on Monday, 12 January 1976.Mr Justice Cooke spoke of Dr Williams and his contribution to the law.