arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Rainer Forst

45 papers · 2001–2026

2001: 32002: 02003: 02004: 02005: 12006: 02007: 22008: 02009: 02010: 02011: 22012: 22013: 32014: 32015: 22016: 22017: 22018: 42019: 12020: 82021: 12022: 12023: 32024: 12025: 32026: 1
2001peak 8 in 20202026

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 45 RSS

Power and reason, justice and domination: a conversation

Amy Allen, Rainer Forst, Mark Haugaard

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Political Power · · cited 267× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Through an email conversation between Allen, Forst and Haugaard, this article explores the relationship between the dyads power and reason, justice and domination. In much of the literature reason is considered either a mode of emancipation from power (Lukes) or, conversely, a subtle ruse of domination (Foucault). Here it is argued that reasoning is intrinsic to political power, with both the potential for power as justice (Arendt), and for power as domination (Foucault and Lukes). With power and reason as normatively neutral, with both/either normatively desirable and undesirable potentials, this raises the fundamental question of how to distinguish between justice and domination. These issues are explored, taking account of processes of subject formation and systems of thought.

The Justification of Basic Rights

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · Netherlands Journal of Legal Philosophy · · cited 231× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Justification of Basic Rights: A Discourse-Theoretical Approach In this paper, I suggest a discourse theory of basic legal rights that is superior to rival approaches, such as a will-based or an interest-based theory of rights. Basic rights are reciprocally and generally justifiable and binding claims on others (agents or institutions) that they should do (or refrain from doing) certain things determined by the content of these rights. We call these rights basic because they define the status of persons as full members of a normative order in such a way that they provide protection from severe forms of legal, political and social domination. The very ground of these rights is the status of persons as free and equal normative authorities within the order they are subject to. In other words, these rights are grounded in a fundamental moral right to justification.

Towards a Critical Theory of Transnational Justice

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · Metaphilosophy · · cited 220× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper argues for a conception of transnational justice that provides an alternative to globalist and statist views. In light of an analysis of the transnational context of justice, a critical theory is suggested that addresses the multiple relations of injustice and domination to be found in this context. Based on a universal, individual right to reciprocal and general justification, this theory argues for justifiable social and political relations both within and between states. In both of these contexts, it distinguishes between minimal and maximal justice and stresses the interdependence of domestic and transnational justice. On both levels, minimal justice calls for a discursive structure of justification, whereas maximal justice implies a fully justified basic social structure.

The Rule of Reasons. Three Models of Deliberative Democracy

Rainer Forst

Sociology and Political Science · Ratio Juris · · cited 133× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this paper, the author contrasts three models of deliberative democracy: a liberal one, a communitarian one, and an alternative to both. Rather than understanding deliberative democracy as the rule of principles of justice or of communal values, the third model conceives of it as the “rule of reasons.” On the basis of a discussion of seven components of an “ethos of democracy” (the cognitive capacities of citizens, political virtues, the cultural, institutional and material conditions of democracy, political legitimacy, and the “ground” of democracy), the third view, which is based on a theory of moral and political justification, emerges as superior.

Noumenal Power

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Political Philosophy · · cited 128× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

I N political or social philosophy, we speak about power all the time.Yet the meaning of this important concept is rarely made explicit, especially in the context of normative discussions. 1But as with many other concepts, once one considers it more closely, fundamental questions arise, such as whether a power relation is necessarily a relation of subordination and domination, a view that makes it difficult to identify legitimate forms of the exercise of power.To contribute to conceptual as well as normative clarification, in what follows I suggest a novel way to conceive of power.I argue that we only understand what power is and how it is exercised once we understand its essentially noumenal nature.On that basis, I defend a normatively neutral notion of power that enables us to distinguish more particular forms of power, such as rule, coercion, or domination.The analysis aims to…

A Kantian Republican Conception of Justice as Nondomination

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · Edinburgh University Press eBooks · · cited 76× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter explores the relationship between republican democracy and justice by comparing Philip Pettit's notion of neo-republicanism with that of Immanuel Kant. It begins by describing a republican, political conception of justice as nondomination and explaining why the discourse of republicanism and that of theories of justice often remain at odds with one another. It then considers the basis of a republican conception of justice as nondomination and locates it within the principle of justification, along with Pettit's idea of autonomy and respect. It also examines the notions of ‘arbitrariness’ and ‘domination’ as well as Pettit's ‘negative republicanism’ and its emphasis on legally and politically secure freedom of choice. The chapter argues that a Kantian interpretation of modern republicanism is more convincing than Pettit's ‘negative republicanism’.

Tolerance as a Virtue of Justice

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · Philosophical Explorations · · cited 57× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article argues that the civic virtue of tolerance has to be understood as a virtue of justice. Based on an analysis of the concept of toleration and its paradoxes, it shows that toleration is a 'normatively dependent concept' that needs to take recourse to a conception of justice in order to solve these paradoxes. At the center of this conception of justice lies a principle of reciprocal and general justification with the help of which a distinction between moral norms and ethical values is possible. While the former are strictly binding and define the realm of the tolerable, the latter are subject to reasonable disagreement that calls for toleration. Essentially, the virtue of tolerance is the capacity and willingness to accept the principle and criteria of justification of generally binding norms in an ethically pluralist society.This virtue is analyzed with respect to…

Noumenal power revisited: reply to critics

Rainer Forst

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Political Power · · cited 47× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this reply to critiques by Albena Azmanova, Pablo Gilabert, Mark Haugaard, Clarissa Rile Hayward, Matthias Kettner, Steven Lukes, and Simon Susen, Rainer Forst explains and expands upon his theory of ‘noumenal power.’ In particular, he stresses the non-normative character of the approach and clarifies how the account of the exercise of power as working through ‘giving’ reasons also includes non-reflexive and non-transparent forms of producing reasons in others. This has implications for aspects of power that relate to the unconscious, the body and for understanding ideological as well as structural power.

The ground of critique

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · Philosophy & Social Criticism · · cited 47× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In the practice of social criticism, the concept of human dignity has played and still plays an important role. In philosophical debates, however, we find widely divergent accounts of that concept, ranging from views based on a conception of human needs to religious approaches trying to explain the ‘inviolability’ of the person. The view presented here reconstructs the basic claim of human dignity historically and normatively as resting on the moral status of the person as a reason-giving, reason-demanding and reason-deserving being. The person as holding a basic moral right to justification is the true ground for the claim of having one’s dignity respected: as someone who must not be subjected to norms, rules, or institutions which cannot be properly justified to that person in appropriate practices of justification. To possess human dignity means being an equal member in the realm of…

First Things First

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · European Journal of Political Theory · · cited 45× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article analyses the debate between Nancy Fraser and Axel Honneth in a dialectical fashion. Their controversy about how to construct a critical theory of justice is not just one about the proper balance between `redistribution' and `recognition', it also involves basic questions of social ontology. Differing both from Fraser's `twodimensional' view of `participatory parity' and from Honneth's `monistic' theory of recognition, the article argues for a third view of `justificatory monism and diagnosticevaluative pluralism', also called the `first-things-first' approach. According to it, theories of recognition provide an essential sensorium for analyses of social suffering and of injustice, while with respect to the justification of justice claims, a discursive conception of justification is required. This, however, does not imply a purely `formal' account of justice; rather, it…

Political Liberty: Integrating Five Conceptions of Autonomy

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 45× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

1. Although "liberty" today is generally recognized as a fundamental criterion for the legitimacy of a society's basic institutional structure, disputes over its content continue unabated. Within the history of political philosophy as well as in contemporary debates, a wide variety of theories provide competing accounts, ranging from republicanism to Marxism, from libertarianism to various forms of liberalism ("perfectionist" or "political"). In the following, I want to suggest that the best way out of these controversies can be found in an intersubjectivist concept of political liberty comprised of an adequate integration of five different conceptions of individual autonomy.

“Reasonable” versus “True,” or the Morality of Worldviews

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 35× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

John Rawls claims that his idea of “justice as fairness” is a “freestanding” conception: it is supposed to “move entirely within the domain of the political” and “leave philosophy as it is.” The goal and feasibility of this strategy of avoidance depend on how we understand the term “political.” Rawls uses it in the fi rst place to specify the object domain of a political theory that deals with the institutional frame and basic structure of a (modern) society. The conventional element in the choice of basic concepts is never beyond controversy; but once a theory demonstrates its utility such discussions lose their point. However, a second and less trivial use of the term-“political” in contrast with “metaphysical”—leads to controversies that cannot be so easily resolved.1

“To Tolerate Means to Insult”: Toleration, Recognition, and Emancipation

Rainer Forst

Education · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 35× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In contemporary political discourse, the concept of toleration plays an important role, ranging from questions of the toleration of cultural and religious minorities within states to the alleged global "clash of civilisations." But while for some, toleration appears to be the magic word invoking a peaceful and cooperative way of living together in mutual recognition and political equality, for others it is a word signifying power, domination, and exclusion. And this ambivalence about the concept of toleration is not a recent phenomenon, for if we go back to the classic discussions of toleration in the Age of Enlightenment, the latter critique is what Goethe meant when he said: "Tolerance should be a temporary attitude only: it must lead to recognition. To tolerate means to insult." And the former praise of toleration is expressed by Voltaire, who spoke of toleration as l'apanage de…

Transnational Justice and Democracy: Overcoming Three Dogmas of Political Theory

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · Palgrave Macmillan US eBooks · · cited 34× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The title of my contribution seems to signal a tension, indeed virtually a contradiction, in a number of respects. Democracy is generally understood as a form of a political organization and government in which, through general and public participatory procedures, a sufficiently legitimate political will is formed that acquires the force of law. Justice, by contrast, appears (at least in the eyes of many theorists of democracy) to be a value external to this context that is understood not so much as connected with procedures of "input" or "throughput" legitimation but instead as a concept oriented to "outputs" or outcomes. At times, justice is even understood—alluding to Plato—as an otherworldly idea, which, when transported into the "cave" of everyday life, only causes trouble and ends up as an undemocratic elite project.1 In methodological terms, too, this difference is sometimes…

Toleration, justice and reason

Rainer Forst

Education · Manchester University Press eBooks · · cited 33× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In contemporary debates about the idea and the problems of a multicultural society the concept of toleration plays a major but by no means clear and uncontested role. This chapter distinguishes between a general concept and various more specific conceptions of toleration. It shows that the concept of toleration is marked by two paradoxes. The first paradox consists in the problem of how it can be morally right to tolerate what is morally wrong. The second paradox says that toleration, as soon as its limits are defined by a certain content, becomes intolerant toward those 'outside'. The chapter argues that that toleration is a virtue of justice and a demand of reason. It outlines four paradigmatic conceptions of toleration such as permission conception, co-existence conception, respect conception and esteem conception.

The Constitution of Justification

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 25× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter presents Rainer Forst’s responses to the authors of the preceding chapters. According to Forst, the topics that need to be addressed cover a very wide terrain, ranging from foundational questions about moral universality and the reflexivity of practical reason to questions of legal, political, and social justice, critical theory, the value of democracy, the justificatory practice of judicial review or the European polity. He attempts to address them from within the theory of justification that he has been developing over the years since writing his first book, Contexts of Justice (published in German in 1994). In order to do justice to the individual authors, Forst’s responses follow the order of the contributions, and are divided broadly into replies to the chapters that directly address his work and comments on the chapters that develop an argument in dialogue…

Political Liberalism: A Kantian View

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · Ethics · · cited 13× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article suggests a Kantian reading of Rawls’s Political Liberalism. As much as Rawls distanced himself from a presentation of his theory in terms of a comprehensive Kantian moral doctrine, we ought to read it as a noncomprehensive Kantian moral-political theory. According to the latter approach, the liberal conception of justice is compatible with a plurality of comprehensive doctrines as long as they share the independently defined and grounded essentials of that conception of justice—that is, as long as they are “reasonable,” to use the term that does most of the Kantian work.

A Critical Theory of Human Rights—Some Groundwork

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · Columbia University Press eBooks · · cited 12× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Human rights are a complex phenomenon, comprising an array of different aspects: moral, legal, political, and social. A philosophical account of human rights must integrate each of these aspects in the right way. In this chapter, Forst sketches a critical theory of human rights as an alternative to mainstream accounts. His own account begins from the oft- neglected social aspect—the perspective of participants in social struggles against exploitation and oppression—and seeks to reconstruct the basic emancipatory claim of human rights. Human rights, Forst argues, have a common ground in one basic moral right, the right to justification, and their legal and political function is to make this right socially effective.

The rule of unreason: Analyzing (anti‐)democratic regression

Rainer Forst

Sociology and Political Science · Constellations · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In contemporary debates about the crisis of democracy, it is often said that we are living in a time of an anti-democratic regression, and insofar as it is a phenomenon that develops within democratic systems, this is also called “democratic regression,” as Armin Schäfer and Michael Zürn (2021) do.1 I think this addresses a crucial dimension of the critical analysis of our present, but I also see the need for further conceptual reflection and clarification. For “regression” is a complex concept with many connotations, and its usage must be considered carefully, in particular because it is important to avoid several fallacies in the discussion about it, of which I discuss three—that of the status quo ante fixation (Section 2), that of the reduction of the concept of democracy (Section 3), and that of the misclassification of critiques of democracy (Section 4). These considerations lead…

Transnational Justice and Democracy

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · Palgrave Macmillan eBooks · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The title I have chosen seems to signal a tension, even a contradiction, in a number of respects. Democracy appears to be a form of political organisation and government in which, through general and public participatory procedures, a sufficiently legitimate political will is formed which acquires the force of law. Justice, by contrast, appears to be a value external to this context which is not so much linked to procedures of “input” or “throughput” legitimation but is understood instead as an output- or outcome-oriented concept. At times, justice is even understood as an otherworldly idea which, when transported into the Platonic cave, merely causes trouble and ends up as an undemocratic elite project. In methodological terms, too, this difference is sometimes signalled in terms of a contrast between a form of “worldly” political thought and “abstract” and otherworldly philosophical…

Debating the dimensions: Amy Allen, Rainer Forst and Isaac Ariail Reed in dialogue-review of<i>The Four Dimensions of Power</i>by Mark Haugaard

Amy Allen, Rainer Forst, Mark Haugaard +1 more

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Political Power · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this article Amy Allen, Rainer Forst and Isaac Reed debate the four dimensions of power, as framed by Mark Haugaard, in The Four Dimensions of Power, and Haugaard responds. This discussion involves the following: the relationship between agency and authority; ideology and acquiescence; power-over, power-to and power-with; structural constraint; bias and exclusion; the distinction between deep and shallow conflicts; the concept of reification; foundational Truth claims and modest truths; how social ontology or being-in-the-world relates to power; a pragmatist account of democracy as nonzero-sum power and its normative grounds; and a discussion of the relative value of theories.

The rational critique of social unreason. On critical theory in the Frankfurt tradition

Rainer Forst

Sociology and Political Science · Constellations · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

By “critical theory” in a general sense, we mean a unity of philosophical reflection and social scientific analysis informed by an interest in emancipation; all critical theories methodologically and normatively aim at uncovering forms of social domination and inquire into the possibilities of overcoming them. Critical theory in the tradition of what has been called the “Frankfurt School,” however, means something more specific: It develops a historically situated and normatively reflexive, systematic rational critique of existing forms of social unreason that are ideologically presented as forms of (individual and social) rationality — “the unreason of the dominant reason” (Adorno, 2005/1962, p. 151). It explains why that is the case (that is, it unveils the rationale for such unreason) and it also conceives of a (more) rational form of a social and political order.1 Specifically, it…

A critical theory of politics

Rainer Forst

Political Science and International Relations · Philosophy & Social Criticism · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this article, I address the various objections raised by Simone Chambers, Stephen White and Lea Ypi concerning my version of a critical theory of politics. I explain the basic assumptions that inform my account of a critique of relations of justification, its particular method and aims.

Justice and Democracy in Transnational Contexts: A Critical Realistic View

Rainer Forst, Ciaran Cronin

Political Science and International Relations · Social research · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Whereas in the area of international relations classical realism has come under attack, in political philosophy various versions of realism have recently been developed. Yet all of these approaches overlook either the reality of social conflicts or the emancipatory function of normative notions such as human rights or the meaning of political autonomy. A realistic and critical theory of transnational justice needs to begin with an analysis of the relations of rule and/or domination, whether within, between, or beyond states. And because reflexive justice requires structures of justification whereby those subject to rule or domination can become the normative authorities co-determining them, a complex account of transnational justice and democracy results. ”

Two stories about toleration

Rainer Forst

Education · Cambridge University Press eBooks · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In current social conflicts in European societies such as the ones concerning the crucifix in classrooms or the foulard or the burka worn in public, toleration is a concept claimed by all involved. The paper uncovers the historical and conceptual reasons for such ambivalence about the notion of toleration. It starts from a conceptual analysis and then reconstructs two stories about toleration which lead to two different conceptions of it – the hierarchical permission conception and the democratic respect conception. The paper applies these to current conflicts and argues for an understanding of toleration based on a certain form of mutual respect despite deep ethical disagreement.