arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Peter Fitzpatrick

48 papers · 1984–2021

1984: 21985: 11986: 01987: 11988: 01989: 11990: 01991: 01992: 11993: 01994: 21995: 11996: 11997: 01998: 21999: 12000: 22001: 52002: 12003: 12004: 32005: 22006: 32007: 02008: 02009: 32010: 22011: 02012: 12013: 32014: 32015: 12016: 02017: 12018: 02019: 12020: 22021: 1
1984peak 5 in 20012021

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 48 RSS

Racism and the Innocence of Law

Peter Fitzpatrick

Law · Journal of Law and Society · · cited 60× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In liberal views of the world, law is manifestly incompatible with racism. Where racist practice infects law that can only be something aberrant and remediable. Exploring the British situation as a case, I will argue that on the contrary racism is compatible with and even integral to law. I try to show that the very foundational principles of law as liberal legality import racism into law, those principles of equality and universality which stand in their terms opposed to racism. The aim is not to dismiss law, nor to expose liberal legality as a sham. But nor is it to retrieve law and add to the list of obviously desirable variants on how to combat racism through law, such as recent left strategies.2 The point is, rather, to make such acts, gestures, discourses which ... had seemed to go without saying become problematic, difficult, dangerous.3 A note on the term racism: I will use it…

Law and Societies

Peter Fitzpatrick

Law · Osgoode Hall law journal · · cited 57× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Professor Fitzpatrick offers an examination of bourgeois legality as the concrete embodiment of modern law. Citing examples from the prison system and the workplace, he finds that modern law exists in certain relations of opposition and support with other social forms. From these relations, certain modes of convergence and separation between law and other social forms are identified and explored. To test the utility of this analysis, Fitzpatrick provides an extended application to traditional scholarship about the nature of law and its relation to society. The central focus in this enquiry is the idea of integral plurality as a vehicle by which the abstracted, unitary and universalistic pretensions of the modern legal system may be exposed. This article is available in Osgoode Hall Law Journal: http://digitalcommons.osgoode.yorku.ca/ohlj/vol22/iss1/5

Traditionalism and Traditional Law

Peter Fitzpatrick

Demography · Journal of African Law · · cited 45× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

John Berger tells the story of the peasant Lucie Cabrol in terms of her “three lives” because she lived and lived on in three different ways. Readers of the story in Lucie Cabrol's village say she now has four lives. The fourth is in her story. My theme to-day is that representations of knowledge give a life to that knowledge. This life shapes the object of the knowledge. That may appear an intensely academic concern and it is. But I will show that it is, in the same moment, an indispensible practical and political concern. I start in good company with that body of revisionist scholarship which shows that traditional law or customary law was a creation of the colonial period. For an initial instance, I will depart once only in this lecture from Africa for Oceania. I use this instance because it is compact, irresistible and needs to be better known to legal science. In colonial Fiji…

‘Gods would be needed…’: American Empire and the Rule of (International) Law

Peter Fitzpatrick

Political Science and International Relations · Leiden Journal of International Law · · cited 26× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In the perennial debate over whether the dependence of international law on power is complete or whether international law maintains some independence for itself, the latter position is increasingly and at best marginal. Here that direction of the debate is reversed. The very dependence of international law on power is integral to a relation of mutual dependence between them. It is in this relation that power constituently depends on an international law which, in its turn, contains a primal efficacy. That efficacy is illustrated in its countering the claims of American empire.

Being Social in Socio-Legal Studies

Peter Fitzpatrick

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Law and Society · · cited 18× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Although this may be an intensely secular occasion, I will begin with a seasonal text for Advent from the Gospel according to Luke. In chapter one, there is the rhapsodic prophecy of Zacharias on the birth of his son John the Baptist where, in a verse of piercing and now melancholy beauty, verse 78, he attributes all that the Baptist will achieve to 'the tender mercy of our God; whereby the dayspring on high hath visited us'. It is the absence of such a visitation, the absence of transcendent origin, in the world of socio-legal studies that I want to talk about. To be more precise, the uncertainty of identity in socio-legal studies is it social, or is it legal, or some mixture of these? has not been relieved by the constant search for some resolving presence, for something that will enable us to say at last what it is. In my argument, the quest for identity is impelled, not by the…

‘The damned word’: Culture and Its (In)compatibility with Law

Peter Fitzpatrick

Law · Law Culture and the Humanities · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The compatibility and incompatibility between law and culture are identified through an analysis of relation. By way of exploring the elusiveness of conceptions of culture and of law, a commonality relating them is arrived at, one that indicates not only what they constituently share but also what distinguishes them from each other. So far an abstract abstract. The abstractness of the comment itself is relieved by references to a case study and by resorting to etymologies.

Is Humanity Enough? The Secular Theology of Human Rights

Peter Fitzpatrick

Sociology and Political Science · OAR@UM (University of Malta) · · cited 12× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

© Peter Fitzpatrick. All rights reserved. This paper may be freely circulated in electronic or hard copy provided it is not modified in any way, the rights of the author not infringed, and the paper is not quoted or cited without express permission of the author. The editors cannot guarantee a stable URL for any paper posted here, nor will they be responsible for notifying others if the URL is changed or the paper is taken off the site. Electronic copies of this paper may not be posted on any other website without express permission of the author.

Juris-fiction:Literature and the Law of the Law

Peter Fitzpatrick

Sociology and Political Science · BIROn (Birkbeck, University of London) · · cited 11× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

An Ordinary Evening in New Haven" Lauding editors on these occasions is rightly suspect, but here it is simply unavoidable.Gary Boire's pathbreaking, of course, conspectus and analysis of colonial law and postcolonial literature provides not only a point of departure for my paper but also its generative orientation -a continuing on the path broken.Briefly, for now, Boire draws on representations of law in postcolonial literatures to reveal a disruptive ambivalence in colonial law.Bluntly, for now, I will try to show how that ambivalence also constitutes law, and not just colonial law, and try to show how this constitution of law can be derived from a quality of literature, and not just postcolonial literatures.All of which will not involve minimizing or marginalizing the postcolonial in its relation to law or to literature.On the contrary, the postcolonial will provide the focal opening…

"What Are the Gods to Us Now?": Secular Theology and the Modernity of Law

Peter Fitzpatrick

Sociology and Political Science · Theoretical Inquiries in Law · · cited 10× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Integrating responses of Nietzsche to the death of God with classic instances of modernist political theory, a constituent parallel is drawn between monotheistic religion and modern law — a parallel in that each matches the other, but a parallel also in that neither ever meets the other. This relation yet differentiation reveals an ontologically challenging modern law that conforms to, yet completely counters, its positivist and instrumental subordinations in modernity.

The Revolutionary Past: Decolonizing Law and Human Rights

Peter Fitzpatrick

Sociology and Political Science · BIROn (Birkbeck, University of London) · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Combining a radical revision of the historical formation of occidental law with perspectives derived from decolonial thought, this paper advances a deconstruction of occidental law. That deconstruction is then brought to bear on human rights. Although occidental law and human rights are shown in this way to be imperial in orientation, that same deconstruction reveals resistant elements in law and in human rights. These are elements which the decolonial can draw on in its commitment to intercultural transformation.Key words: human rights, post-colonialism, decolonization.

Necessary fictions: Indigenous claims and the humanity of rights

Peter Fitzpatrick

Anthropology · Journal of Postcolonial Writing · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Indigenous right insistently challenges the surpassing arrogations of sovereign right. In so doing, it affirms dimensions of being‐together denied or stunted in sovereign modes of political formation. This force of Indigenous right is amplified here through legal and literary instantiations. These, in turn, uncover the continuously created and fictional quality of rights, revealing them to be necessary fictions.

Enduring Freedom

Peter Fitzpatrick

Sociology and Political Science · Theory & Event · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Enduring Freedom Peter Fitzpatrick (bio) The lie of the ideal has hitherto been the curse on reality.... — Nietzsche, Ecce Homo, Foreward, para. 2 (his emphasis). The seemingly progressive point was already banal but of late it is being made with renewed intensity. It is to the effect that hostility to the United States would diminish or cease if only there were an export of that country’s virtuous attributes, pre-eminently freedom and democracy, rather than their being checked through military and other oppressions. The more solipsistic, and it would seem more common, view would have it that the extraversions of the United States are in any case always in the cause of the good. The near-corollary is that “anti-Americanism” can be countered by promoting a more adequate picture of the United States and its deeds.[1] That such hostility may amount to more than this is for George W. Bush…

Still Not Being Modern: Law and the Insistence of Myth

Peter Fitzpatrick

Law · Australian Feminist Law Journal · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Nietzsche's supremely sane, if overworked, madman provides the mythic orientation for this article. It is 'we' who have killed God, he reveals, and as a result we are left 'straying as through an infinite nothing', and left having to invent new 'sacred games'. These, however, are a diversity and diversity does not, and cannot, take the place of the transcendent and all-encompassing singularity that was the occidental deity. With the supposedly secular Occident unable to embed its all-surpassing coherence in a positive transcendence, resort is had to a negative universal reference unfolded by way of a myth of origin. That myth configures a cohering identity of an occidental modernity formed as the antithesis yet comprehension of designated 'others'. The article then turns to what this myth imports for our understanding of 'modern' law, matching such law to the generative dimensions of…

Ultimate Legality: Reading the Community of Law

Peter Fitzpatrick, Tara Mulqueen, Abdul Paliwala +1 more

Law · Journal of Law and Society · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article is a contribution to the occasional series dealing with a major book that has influenced the author. Previous contributors include Stewart Macaulay, John Griffith, William Twining, Carol Harlow, Geoffrey Bindman, Harry Arthurs, André‐Jean Arnaud, Alan Hunt, Michael Adler, Lawrence O. Gostin, John P. Heinz, Roger Brownsword, Roger Cotterrell, Nicola Lacey, Carol J. Greenhouse, and David Garland. An initial twist: several acute observers would consider the way I read to be the most influential effect of reading on me – a way of reading that extends beyond the specificity of the text yet, in so doing, connects integrally with it. Salvation of specificity is at hand, however. That way of reading is intimately reflective of Derridean deconstruction and a hugely influential reading becomes his ‘Force of Law’. A problem ensues. Other influential reading came before my…

Latin roots: the force of international law as event

Peter Fitzpatrick

Political Science and International Relations · BIROn (Birkbeck, University of London) · · cited 6× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Book synopsis:
\nEvents: The Force of International Law presents an analysis of international law, centred upon those historical and recent events in which international law has exerted, or acquired, its force. From Spanish colonization and the Peace of Westphalia, through the release of Nelson Mandela and the Rwandan genocide, and to recent international trade negotiations and the 'torture memos', each chapter in this book focuses on a specific international legal event. Short and accessible to the non-specialist reader, these chapters consider what forces are put into play when international law is invoked, as it is so frequently today, by lawyers, laypeople, or leaders. At the same time, they also reflect on what is entailed in naming these ‘events’ of international law and how international law grapples with their disruptive potential. Engaging economic, military, cultural…

Crime as Resistance: The Colonial Situation

Peter Fitzpatrick

Sociology and Political Science · The Howard Journal of Criminal Justice · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract: Criminal law in the colonial situation subordinates resistance in a double marginalisation. With one, resistance is rendered as peripheral to and as comprehensively dominated by that which is resisted. With the other, that which is resisted — colonial domination — is constituted as transient and exceptional, yet also as necessary for the inevitable march of progress. Resistance to it thus becomes multiply futile. Making these marginalised positions the focus of enquiry reveals the basic and enduring significance of crime as resistance to colonial rule. Such a reversal of perspective not only questions the exceptional nature of colonialism but also reveals colonial dimensions of ‘crime’ in the West.

Foucault’s other law

Peter Fitzpatrick

Sociology and Political Science · BIROn (Birkbeck, University of London) · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Book synopsis: Re-reading Foucault: On Law, Power and Rights is the first collection in English fully to address the relevance of Michel Foucault’s thought for law. Foucault is the best known and most cited of the late twentieth-century’s ‘theory’ academics. His work continues to animate a range of different critical work across intellectual disciplines in the arts, humanities and social sciences. There has, however, been relatively little examination of the legal implications and applications of Foucault’s work. This book fills that gap, providing an in-depth analysis of Foucault’s thought as it pertains to a range of different legal themes, such as: the opposition between ‘law’ and ‘the juridical’; the problem of moral and legal judgment; the historical basis of rights; and the political dimensions (and limitations) of contemporary human rights discourse. Including contributions from…

'The new constitutionalism' : the global, the postcolonial and the constitution of nations

Peter Fitzpatrick

Law · Law Democracy & Development · · cited 5× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Warily, but I hope not too wearily, I want to return to some old ground in constitutional law and question certain distinctions which go to constitute it. These are distinctions between the international and the national, public law and private law (a distinction which seems to retain a stronghold on the ordering of legal knowledge in South Africa), the distinction between written and unwritten constitutions, and the whole divide between what typically goes in a constitution and what typically does not. My purpose in departing from such distinctions is not simply to better order or disorder our legal knowledge but, rather, to show how these distinctions increasingly obstruct an adequate perception and an adequate response to that which goes to the making, to the constituting of constitutions, and thence to the terms of our being together, This is a growing inadequacy which is not only…

Access as justice

Peter Fitzpatrick

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 5× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

With the considerable help of Derrida, aptly aided by Mandela, this paper advances an idea of justice as integral to law. Thence, by way of an homology with such justice, access also is shown to be integral to law. What impels the overall argument is the primacy accorded to law in the constitution of the social bond.

Asian Stereotypes in Recent Australian Plays

Peter Fitzpatrick

Sociology and Political Science · Australian Literary Studies · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Discusses the treatment of Asian themes and the influence of Asian theatrical models in the work of Alex Buzo, John Romeril, Louis Nowra, Tony Strachan, and the New Zealander Vincent O'Sullivan, with particular emphasis on the representation of stereotypes and attempts to engage with Australian interpersonal and institutional racism.

Taking place: Westphalia and the poetics of law

Peter Fitzpatrick

Law · London Review of International Law · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The poem has to keep its possibility. It cannot be rendered into an insistent meaning. Yet the poem is also a ‘way of happening’, a way of bringing possibility into happening. And Cixous would find an intimate tie linking poetry and the happening of history, an ever-generative history, and would find this at its ‘most compelling’ in ‘the texts of some Russian women poets’. So, a belated epigraph from Tsvetayeva: "What shall I do … " "with all this immensity" "in a measured world?" What follows is an awed companion-piece to Yoriko Otomo’s ‘Her proper name: a revisionist account of international law’. It is entirely amenable yet a matter of affinities rather than explicit interpretation. These affinities will be evoked by way of a shared terminology: time, feminine, law, myth, sovereign, Westphalia. Quotations in italics will be from the poem.

Legal Theology: Law, Modernity and the Sacred

Peter Fitzpatrick

Sociology and Political Science · BIROn (Birkbeck, University of London) · · cited 4× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

This article argues that there is both sameness and difference as between the secular and the religious, and that law, modern law, is constituently enmeshed within this sameness and difference. That combination of sameness and difference, along with the integral part of law, is traced in a cumulation of three historicities, the first being the creation of the world's imperium, of the modern world-system, in the sixteenth century. Then, with the second historicity we have the time of revolutions, seen here as almost revolutions, of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. And finally, with the third historicity we have the time of high modernism and the death of God in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Each of these three phases is captured, as it were, in the work of a corresponding thinker who is taken to be a telling instance: Vitoria, Hobbes, Nietzsche. All of that is then…

“Always More To Do”: Capital Punishment And The (De)Composition Of Law

Peter Fitzpatrick

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract To begin, or even to attempt a beginning, is already to deny the reign of finality. It may be as well to summon such reassurance at a time when progressive, rational utilitarian arguments for punishing and not punishing are very much at bay and retribution seems so conclusively resurgent. That outcome is perhaps nowhere so marked as in the revival of capital punishment in the United States. Not only has the rise of capital punishment put paid to evolutionary optimism about the meliorative history of punishment-an optimism that was hardly dented by those revisionist histories most conspicuously associated with Foucault-but it has also contributed to a sense of the futility of committed intellectual work on capital punishment, to a certain terminal perplexity. Hugo Bedau no less, while “still nursing the unconquerable hope,” pessimistically concluded a recent survey of capital…

A Primary Study on Long Term Care in China: Perceptions of the Elderly

Fang Qiu, Scott Stegall, Deborah Gritzmacher +2 more

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Management Policy and Practice · · cited 3× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

China has undergone dramatic changes in both economic and social situations for the past three decades. Faced with the challenges of an aging population, internal migration of labor, and rapid urbanization, China’s current tradition of providing care for the elderly is no longer viable. A preliminary survey was conducted to collect data from Nanchang City in the Jiangxi Province of China to explore ideas of current and future generations concerned with Long Term Care facilities. This pilot study analyzes the preferences and perceptions of the elderly.

‘Enacted in the destiny of sedentary peoples’: racism, discovery and the grounds of law

Peter Fitzpatrick

Geography, Planning and Development · BIROn (Birkbeck, University of London) · · cited 3× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Whilst the racial, and racist, basis of the doctrine of discovery is a modern innovation, the doctrine owes much to its pre-modern forms and ethos. The finding and settlement of putatively unknown lands has long been attended with mythic and religious justification and with rituals of appropriation all of which strikingly resemble modern practice. Similarity in this case, however, serves to dramatize difference. What marks modern discovery of the occidental variety is the displacement of the mythic and religious by a combination of racism and legalism. The story of that displacement is told here along with an analysis of the poverty, not to say vacuity, of the doctrine of discovery as a justification for imperial appropriation. Since the story is told in broadly historical terms, its conception of the modern relies on the temporal ‘depth’ which historians usually attribute to this term…