Author

Nigel Edley

11 papers · 1996–2024

1996peak 2 in 19992024

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–11 of 11 RSS

Negotiating Hegemonic Masculinity: Imaginary Positions and Psycho-Discursive Practices

Margaret Wetherell, Nigel Edley

Gender Studies · Feminism & Psychology · August 1999 · cited 1,002× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this article we provide a critical analysis of the concept of hegemonic masculinity. We argue that although this concept embodies important theoretical insights, it is insufficiently developed as it stands to enable us to understand how men position themselves as gendered beings. In particular it offers a vague and imprecise account of the social psychological reproduction of male identities. We outline an alternative critical discursive psychology of masculinity. Drawing on data from interviews with a sample of men from a range of ages and from diverse occupational backgrounds, we delineate three distinctive, yet related, procedures or psycho-discursive practices, through which men construct themselves as masculine. The political implications of these discursive practices, as well as the broader implications of treating the psychological process of identification as a form of…

Jockeying for Position: The Construction of Masculine Identities

Nigel Edley, Margaret Wetherell

Gender Studies · Discourse & Society · April 1997 · cited 441× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this paper we examine the construction of masculine identities within a real-life social situation. Using data from an extensive series of interviews with small groups of sixth-form (17-18-year-old) students attending a UK-based, single-sex independent school, the analysis looks at the action orientation of different constructions of identity. More specifically, it focuses upon how the identity talk of one particular group of students were oriented towards managing their subordinate status within the school. In a number of instances the identity of the `new man' was adopted as a strategy of resistance. However, it was found that the more common strategy involved buying back into values embodied within a more traditional definition of masculinity.

Jekyll and Hyde: Men's Constructions of Feminism and Feminists

Nigel Edley, Margaret Wetherell

Gender Studies · Feminism & Psychology · November 2001 · cited 191× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Research and commentary on men's responses to feminism have demonstrated the range of ways in which men have mobilized both for and against feminist principles. This article argues that further analyses of men's responses require a sophisticated theory of discourse acknowledging the fragmented and contradictory nature of representation. A corpus of men's talk on feminism and feminists was studied to identify the pervasive patterns in men's accounting and regularities in rhetorical organization. Material from two samples of men was included: a sample of white, middle-class 17-18-year-old school students and a sample of 60 interviews with a more diverse sample of older men aged 20 to 64. Two interpretative repertoires of feminism and feminists were identified. These set up a `Jekyll and Hyde' binary and positioned feminism along with feminists very differently as reasonable versus extreme…

Imagined futures: Young men's talk about fatherhood and domestic life

Nigel Edley, Margaret Wetherell

Gender Studies · British Journal of Social Psychology · June 1999 · cited 179× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

As part of an extensive series of interviews about men and masculinity, small groups of 17 to 18-year-old male students were invited to look forward to their future romantic and domestic lives. Their responses were analysed using the approach and methods of discourse analysis in order to examine both the interpretative resources used within their accounts and to look at how the young men attempted to manage the 'ideological dilemma' (Billig, Condor, Edwards, Gane, Middleton & Radley, 1988) that was framed by these cultural themes. The analysis describes three such strategies while paying particular attention to the 'action orientation' (Heritage, 1984) of these constructions. Finally, the paper moves on to discuss, albeit briefly, the broader implications of this research.

Unravelling Social Constructionism

Nigel Edley

Sociology and Political Science · Theory & Psychology · June 2001 · cited 153× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Social constructionist research is an area of rapidly expanding influence that has brought together theorists from a range of different disciplines. At the same time, however, it has fuelled the development of a new set of divisions. There would appear to be an increasing uneasiness about the implications of a thoroughgoing constructionism, with some regarding it as both theoretically parasitic and politically paralysing. In this paper I review these debates and clarify some of the issues involved. My main argument is that social constructionism is not best understood as a unitary paradigm and that one very important difference is between what Edwards (1997) calls its ontological and epistemic forms. I argue that an appreciation of this distinction not only exhausts many of the disputes that currently divide the constructionist community, but also takes away from the apparent radicalism…

A discursive psychological framework for analyzing men and masculinities.

Margaret Wetherell, Nigel Edley

Gender Studies · Psychology of Men & Masculinity · 21 Jul 2014 · cited 101× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper aims to describe and promote a Discursive Psychological approach to studying men and masculinity. It begins by showcasing some of our own research in this area, before moving on to compare and contrast the central tenets of this approach with those underpinning one of the mainstays of North American scholarship on men and masculinity: the Gender Role Strain Paradigm. We argue that, despite significant points of overlap, Discursive Psychology differs from the Gender Role Strain Paradigm in several key respects; including its treatment of variability, its theory of ideology and its model of the social actor. We claim that, in line with the precepts of Discursive Psychology, gender researchers need to pay closer attention to the nuances of men’s talk and to see masculinities as practical accomplishments, rather than the (inevitable) playing‐out of particular role prescriptions.

Gender practices: Steps in the analysis of men and masculinities

Margaret Wetherell, Nigel Edley

Gender Studies · Nottingham Trent University's Institutional Repository (Nottingham Trent Repository) · 1998 · cited 70× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In this chapter we want to focus on men and forms of masculinity. Our aim is to explore some of the approaches and concepts which we think should form the basis for an adequate <i>feminist social psychology</i> of masculine identities. We will argue that such a social psychology can draw from recent developments in poststructuralist theory (broadly defined) but must also take as its topic the everyday practical activities of men, and thus must find ways of productively researching masculinities <i>in situ</i>, in context.

Masculinity, power and identity

Nigel Edley, Margaret Wetherell

Gender Studies · Nottingham Trent University's Institutional Repository (Nottingham Trent Repository) · March 1996 · cited 69× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

About the book:\nMasculinity is gaining increasing popular and academic interest. At one level, football hooligans, absent fathers, 'Essex man' and 'new men' are regular media presences. At the same time, masculinity is the subject of increasingly sophisicated theoretical discussion, and there are a wide range of accounts of what masculinity means.\n\nUnderstanding Masculinities is the first introductory text to examine the range of different theoretical and methodological approaches to the understanding of masculinity. It brings together overviews of the key theoretical debates with new empirical material, focusing on different social and cultural arenas, and the wide range of masculinities which exist. It discusses education, unemployment, sport, sexuality, HIV, and black masculinities. Understanding Masculinities critically explores the gendered and sexual dynamics of…

Critical Perspectives on Using Interviews and Focus Groups

Nigel Edley, E. Litosseliti

Education · City Research Online (City University London) · 20 Sep 2018 · cited 6× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In this chapter we look at the use of both interviews and focus groups within social science and linguistics research.Working on the basis that they are closely related methods, we begin by examining the arguments, put forward by a number of critical commentators, that they are fundamentally flawed in offering up artificial or contaminated data.In line with those criticisms, we agree that there are some serious problems involved where they are deployed and understoodin traditional terms -as means of mining particular 'nuggets of truth'.Rather, following a more constructionist stance, we recommend that interviews and focus groups are treated as collaborative or interactional events in which the interviewer or moderator plays an important, participative role.So conceived, we argue that there is still a legitimate case for employing either of these research methodsand we end by providing a…

Positioning and Masculinity

Nigel Edley

Gender Studies · 5 Jun 2024 · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter offers a critical review of how Positioning Theory—and, in particular, the concept of subject positions—has been employed within the field of men and masculinities research. Drawing upon a wide range of published work (much of it coming from the leading international masculinity journals) the review covers three main areas of interest: i) research focusing on the intersections between masculinity and sexuality, class, ethnicity, and age; ii) attempts to understand how positioning serves to constitute or shape men’s subjective experiences; and iii) the ongoing debates about hegemonic masculinity and the status and significance of so-called hybrid masculinities. Throughout, an emphasis is placed on understanding masculinities as discourse practice.

Irony and Origami

Nigel Edley

Sociology and Political Science · 23 Sep 2016 · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Unfolding Social Constructionism is a book that stands as a testimony to the growing influence of social constructionism right across the social sciences. Gone are the days when it was just a voice from the margins—now it is a force to be reckoned with. Here Hibberd locks horns with social construc-tionism’s most pivotal character: Kenneth Gergen. In a careful review of his work, she dissects the key components of constructionism’s meta-theory, and she also considers (and dismisses) some of the more common lines of cri-tique. Yet for all her sophistication, Hibberd misses (or refuses?) something very simple—that her own critique is a view from somewhere. She simply asserts realist epistemology as the truth, without for one moment seeing the irony of this assertion (from a social constructionist perspective, that is). I put her straight....