arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Muhammad Aliman

28 papers · 2019–2026

2019: 22020: 62021: 72022: 12023: 62024: 12025: 42026: 1
2019peak 7 in 20212026

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 28 RSS

E-module in Blended Learning: Its Impact on Students’ Disaster Preparedness and Innovation in Developing Learning Media

Sumarmi Sumarmi, Syamsul Bachri, Listyo Yudha Irawan +1 more

Education · International Journal of Instruction · · cited 77× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

E-module was used as a guide to activities in the blended learning process. The purpose of this study was (1) to find out the implementation of learning using emodules with blended learning, (2) to determine the effect of using e-module with blended learning on student disaster preparedness, (3) to determine the effect of using e-module with blended learning on student innovation in designing learning media. The research method was quasi-experiment using pretest-posttest with nonequivalent control group design and independent sample t-test as data analysis. The research subject was the third-year students from geography department of 2017. The measurement of disaster preparedness and innovation in designing learning media used essay and assessment rubric. The results showed that there was an influence and compatibility of e-modules with blended learning on student disaster preparedness…

COMMUNITY BASED TOURISM (CBT) TO ESTABLISH BLUE ECONOMY AND IMPROVE PUBLIC WELFARE FOR FISHING TOURISM DEVELOPMENT IN KLATAK BEACH, TULUNGAGUNG, INDONESIA

Sumarmi Sumarmi, Elya Kurniawati, Muhammad Aliman

Sociology and Political Science · GeoJournal of Tourism and Geosites · · cited 47× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Klatak Beach has long been known by Tulungagung community, but it became famous after the construction of the southern crossing lane (Jalan Lintas Selatan). There were not many visitors who come there either. Currently, Klatak Beach was developed as a tourism area. This research aimed to find out: the potential of Klatak Beach, Tulungagung Regency in the development of fishing tourism, the community empowerment in lobster fishing tourism, and the strategy for developing lobster fishing tourism in Klatak Beach to create Blue Economy. This research used descriptive methods with quantitative and qualitative analysis techniques. The data used in this study are primary and secondary data, such as focus group discussions (FGD) with related parties. Secondary data were collected from government agencies, institutions, and the community. Data collection on this research was the primary data…

The effect of digital eco-learning in student worksheet flipbook to environmental project literacy and pedagogic competency

Sumarmi Sumarmi, Muhammad Aliman, Tuti Mutia

Education · Journal of Technology and Science Education · · cited 45× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The study aimed to determine 1) the effect of digital eco learning in student worksheet flipbooks on environmental literacy projects, and 2) the effect of digital eco learning in student worksheet flipbooks on student ecological competence. The research is a quasi-experimental study using a Pretest-Posttest Non-equivalent Control Group. The research subjects were students in the Environmental Geography course semester 6 of 2020, divided into the experimental and control groups. The research was conducted at the Geography Education study program, Social Science Faculty, State University of Malang, Indonesia. Data were analyzed using the independent sample t-test in SPSS version 23 for windows. The results found: 1) there is a significant effect of digital eco learning with student worksheet flipbook on environmental project literacy competence, and 2) there is a significant effect of…

The Effect of Experiential Learning Models on High School Students Learning Scores and Disaster Countermeasures Education Abilities

Sumarmi Sumarmi, Syamsul Bachri, Listyo Yudha Irawan +3 more

Education · Journal for the Education of Gifted Young Scientists · · cited 41× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Learning experiences are useful in increasing the learning scores. The purpose of this study was to: (1) Determine the effect of problem-based learning on learning outcomes; (2) Determine the effect of problem-based learning on disaster education abilities; (3) Know the effect of experiential learning on learning outcomes; and (4) Know the effect of experiential learning learning on disaster education abilities. This study used an experimental design with a pretest-posttest control group design. Data collection used observation sheets, questionnaires as an instrument of the implementation of learning models and education education, and tests that were used to know the learning scores. The results obtained was tested by ANOVA using SPSS for windows version 21. The results showed: There is a significant influence of problem-based learning models on learning scores; There is a significant…

Investigation of Early Marriage: A Phenomenology Study in the Society of Bawean Island, Indonesia

Singgih Susilo, Novia Fitri Istiawati, Muhammad Aliman +1 more

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Population and Social Studies · · cited 33× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The research aimed to interpret the perceptions of early marriage, the union of two people in which one or both are under 18 years of age, through a phenomenological approach. The analysis was performed using observation techniques along with participation in in-depth interviews supported with an inductive approach of documentation analysis. The results showed that the society in Bawean Island, Indonesia, perceived the need for early marriage of 15-16 years old girls as matchmaking, avoidance of the social sanction of fornication and out-of-wedlock pregnancy, and as an economical solution for parents to shift responsibility. The results further showed that matchmaking and the avoidance of fornication are significant motivators for early marriage. Also, it was found that early marriages caused adverse effects on the wife, husband, and children. The effects are related to cases of…

Problem-Based Service Learning’s Effect on Environmental Concern and Ability to Write Scientific Papers

Sumarmi Sumarmi, Syamsul i Bachr, Arif Baidowi +2 more

Education · International Journal of Instruction · · cited 29× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This study aimed to: (1) determine the effect of the problem-based service learning model based on the local wisdom of gugur gunung on the environmental concern of the students in Public Senior High School 1 Campurdarat. (2) Determine the effect of problem based service learning models on the ability to write scientific papers at Public Senior High School I Campurdarat. (3) Knowing the students' impressions of the implementation of the problem based service learning model based on the local wisdom of gugur gunung in Lake Buret, Tulungagung. The method used in this study was quasi experiment. The research design used was the post-test control group design with 2 groups: a) experimental group, which is students from class XI science 1 and b) control group, which is students from class XI science 3 of Public Senior High School I Campurdarat, Tulungagung Regency, Indonesia. Data was…

Students’ critical thinking skills based on gender and knowledge group

Silvia Marni, Muhammad Aliman, Suyono Suyono +2 more

Education · Journal of Turkish Science Education · · cited 28× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The study aimed to measure the validity of critical thinking instruments and determined the differences in critical thinking skills in terms of gender and knowledge group. The study was used survey method. Critical thinking instruments were developed based on the Facoine (2015)’s indicators of critical thinking. Data were obtained from 285 respondents (N = 285) of first-year students who took Indonesian language courses. Respondents consisted of 78 male and 207 female students. The 25 questions in critical thinking instruments were claimed valid and homogeneous with r count of 0.266. Data were analyzed using nonparametric statistics of Mann-Withney test in SPSS version 21 application for Windows. There was no significant difference in students' critical thinking skills in gender differences and knowledge groups. Result of the study showed that 22 sub-indicators of students’ critical…

THE EFFECT OF EARTHCOMM LEARNING MODEL AND SPATIAL THINKING ABILITY ON GEOGRAPHY LEARNING OUTCOMES

Muhammad Aliman, Budijanto Budijanto, Sumarmi Sumarmi +3 more

Geography, Planning and Development · Journal of Baltic Science Education · · cited 26× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Geography learning is meaningless if it is not followed by the development of students' spatial thinking ability. Research aimed to 1) determine the effect of earthcomm learning and conventional learning on geography learning outcomes, 2) find out the effect of spatial thinking ability on geography learning outcomes, 3) find out the interaction between the application of earthcomm learning and spatial thinking ability on geography learning outcomes. Research used a quasi-experimental non-equivalent control group design. The research sample was taken from three high schools in Malang City, Indonesia. Geography learning outcomes data were obtained from paper-based test and spatial thinking ability data obtained from spatial thinking test instruments. Data were analyzed using Two Way ANOVA test using SPSS devices. The results of the research, 1) there is an effect of the application of…

Problem-based learning using e-module: Does it effect on student’s high order thinking and learning interest in studying geography?

Bayu Wijayanto, Sumarmi Sumarmi, Dwiyono Hari Utomo +2 more

Education · Journal of Technology and Science Education · · cited 24× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

High Order Thinking Skills (HOTS) are abilities that students in the 21st century must acquire. Problem-based learning is one of the learning models to improve high order thinking skills. E-module is an innovative teaching tools used in geography education. Geography is the main focus of education in the 21st century, especially related to environmental issues. This study aimed to determine the effect of PBL with e-module based on HOTS to student’s learning interest in studying geography. The research population consisted of second-year students (grade 11) of social class in SMAN 2 Semarang (Public Senior High School). This research used a factorial experimental design. The data was collected using a test measuring HOTS and a questionnaire measuring enthusiasm for learning geography. The data were analysed using statistics, including the normality test, the homogeneity test, and…

PARTICIPATION OF GREEN ENVIRONMENTAL GROUP AND ULUR-ULUR LOCAL WISDOM ON BURET LAKE ECOTOURISM MANAGEMENT IN KARST AREA OF TULUNGAGUNG, INDONESIA

Elya Kurniawati, Sumarmi Sumarmi, Muhammad Aliman

Sociology and Political Science · GeoJournal of Tourism and Geosites · · cited 24× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Management of karst areas as attractive tourist spots is indeed very promising. Community participation is needed in managing tourist attractions. This research aims to determine: (1) The condition of Buret Lake tourism in the Tulungagung karst area (2) The participation of Green Environmental Group in the management of Buret Lake tourism (3) The existence of Ulur-ulur local wisdom supports the development of Buret Lake tourism. The approach used in this research was qualitative. Data collection was carried out by using observation, in-depth interviews, and documentation studies. The results showed that Buret Lake tourism is a very beautiful and unique karst area whose water source is able to irrigate the residents' fields in 4 villages continuously. The participation of the Green Environmental Group is very instrumental in managing tourist attractions and preserving the Buret Lake. The…

Project-Based Research Learning (PBRL) Integrated With E-Learning in Projects Completion

Sumarmi Sumarmi, Syamsul Bachri, Listyo Yudha Irawan +2 more

Education · International Journal of Emerging Technologies in Learning (iJET) · · cited 21× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Project-Based Research Learning (PBRL) is one of the learn-ing models that stimulate students to be active and innovative in developing products. The purposes of this study were to determine 1) the influence of the PBRL integrated with e-learning on students' spatial thinking ability, 2) the influence of the PBRL integrated with e-learning on the students' ability to make disaster management projects, and 3) the influence of the PBRL in-tegrated with e-learning on learning outcomes. The data analysis was used independent samples t-test from six essay questions and grading rubrics measurement. The results showed 1) a significant influence of the PBRL in-tegrated with e-learning on students spatial thinking ability, 2) an influence of the PBRL integrated with e-learning on the students' ability to make dis-aster management projects, and 3) a significant influence of the PBRL inte-grated…

Development of E-Learning, Mobile Apps, Character Building, and Outdoor Study (EMCO Learning Model) to Improve Geography Outcomes in the 21st Century

Hendri Prastiyono, Sugeng Utaya, Sumarmi Sumarmi +3 more

Education · International Journal of Interactive Mobile Technologies (iJIM) · · cited 17× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This development study aims to 1) create a learning model that fuses e-learning, a mobile app, character building, and outdoor study and 2) determine the effectiveness of the EMCO learning model on student learning outcomes. This study uses a research and development design with the model of Dick and Carey. A product feasibility test is performed by the learning, media, and materials expert validators, and the product’s effectiveness is tested by students. The data analysis includes descriptive statistics to determine the product feasibility and an independent sample t-test to determine the effectiveness of the learning model. The results of the expert validation show that the EMCO model is in the very good category and does not need revision. The EMCO model has a learning syntax with four phases: LKPD (student worksheet), assessment instrument, learning media, and teaching materials.…

THE EFFECT OF ECOTOURISM DEVELOPMENT ON MARINE CONSERVATION AREA IN WEST SUMATERA, INDONESIA

Universitas Andalas, Departement of Anthropology, Padang, Indonesia, Lucky Zamzami, Muhammad Aliman +3 more

Sociology and Political Science · GeoJournal of Tourism and Geosites · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Ecotourism is critical in conservation areas for the development of mutual relationships between the community, government and tourist in the marine conservation area. However, the community must be key stakeholders in maximizing benefits to local communities and obtaining environmental support to effectively manage conservation areas. This study aimed 1) to determine the socio-economic impact on fishermen community for the marine resource conservation, b) to investigate the socio-economic impact on the community's understanding and respect to support conservation. This research was conducted in the Ampiang Parak and Maligi villages. The research used a structured questionnaire and qualitative method using observation and interview to evaluate the fishermen community involvement in ecotourism management. The research discussed and explained the source, income, and employment allocation…

Ecotourism Development Strategies of Pulau Merah Beach, Banyuwangi, Indonesia

Sumarmi Sumarmi, Syamsul Bachri, Listyo Yudha Irawan +2 more

Sociology and Political Science · IOP Conference Series Earth and Environmental Science · · cited 11× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The study aimed to explain the development of ecotourism management strategies in Pulau Merah beach, Banyuwangi regency, Indonesia. Various aspects need to be considered by local government to increase tourism visit by monitoring 1) the increasing number of visitors, 2) estimated days of stay, and 3) cultural involvement as a tourist attraction. As natural tourist destination, Pulau Merah beach also are able to support the environment. It needed to be considered by the tour manager, so that ecotourism strategy needs to be applied. The research was used descriptive method with qualitative and quantitative techniques. The data used primary data through in-depth interview and secondary data through literature, documentation, and publication of tourism management. Process Hierarchy Analysis (AHP) was used to measure the implementation of ecotourism strategy in Pulau Merah beach.…

Development of E-Module Based on Geospatial Technology to Improve TPACK Competencies of Geography Pre-Service Teacher: A Needs Analysis Review

Bayu Wijayanto, Sumarmi Sumarmi, Dwiyono Hari Utomo +2 more

Education · TEM Journal · · cited 7× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

21st-century education affected pre-service teachers to have TPACK competencies. One way to support pre-service teacher to have TPACK competencies is through teaching materials. The development of e-modules, particularly those of geospatial technology, was prompted by the poor quality of the instructional materials utilized in geography classes. Therefore, a need analysis is required before designing and developing the e-modules. This research evaluated a need analysis based on the PRISMA 2020 guidelines. This research aimed to explain the need analysis related to: 1) curriculum documents, 2) the lecturing process, 3) the availability of laboratories, and 4) the student's need for e-module based on geomorphology course. The data was collected from 186 university students who were preparing as pre-service geography teachers. The results indicated that pre-service geography teachers…

Development of Mobile Learning App Based on Islamic and Science Integration to Improve Student Learning Outcomes

Saiful Amin, Sumarmi Sumarmi, Ramadhani Lausi Mkumbachi +2 more

Education · JURNAL IQRA · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The integration of Islamic and science in Mobile Learning App (MLA) is an innovative and flexible digital learning media to help students learn during pandemic. This study aimed 1) to develop of MLA integrated with Islamic and science, 2) to determine the effect of MLA integrated with Islamic and science on students learning outcomes. This study used the Gall, Gall, & Borg Research and Development (R&D) model. The product fitness has been tested by the expert validators in learning media, materials, linguistics, and integration of Islamic and science, and the product effectiveness has been tested on students. The result showed that: 1) the integration of Islamic and science in MLA was fit to be used in learning with effective category and 2) the integration of Islamic and science in MLA was effective to improve student's learning outcomes in hydrosphere topic. Suggestions for…

Student Retention in Distance Learning During the Covid-19 Crisis in Indonesia: Are We Disappointing Them?

Nevy Farista Aristin, Agus Purnomo, Joko Sayono +1 more

Education · Education Quarterly Reviews · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper aims to describe survey data on student retention in the distance learning in the form of learning comfort levels during the Covid-19 pandemic. The technique used to collect data is a survey at several universities in Indonesia on the subject of students and lecturers during the even semester of 2020. The results of the cross-section survey during distance learning show that the average level of comfort is low because one of them is in the reinforcement aspect. Tabulation analysis shows that lack of preparation results in learning to focus more on delivering teaching materials and too little to motivate them to learn. The perception of most of the community towards the meaning of distance learning makes learning reinforcement low for students. The impact is that learning only turns into e-teaching through the digital space. As an alternative to equal access to higher…

The Pedagogical and Professional Abilities of Pre-Service Teachers through a Project-Based Research Learning Model

Sumarmi Sumarmi, Alfyananda Kurnia Putra, Adellia Wardatus Sholeha +4 more

Education · AL-ISHLAH Jurnal Pendidikan · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Kurikulum Merdeka (Independent Curriculum) policy allows pre-service teachers to engage in two-semester internships, offering extended practical experience in schools. This study aimed to analyze the pedagogical and professional abilities of pre-service teachers in the digital era following the implementation of the Project-Based Research Learning model within the Teaching Assistance program. A mixed-methods approach was employed, combining quantitative and qualitative data. Research instruments included open-ended questionnaires and in-depth interviews. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistical techniques and thematic qualitative analysis. Findings revealed that pre-service teachers demonstrated strong pedagogical and professional competencies in the digital teaching environment after applying the Project-Based Research Learning model. Most participants favored group…

EMPOWERING OF COASTAL COMMUNITY ECOTOURISM: THE ROLE OF CULTURAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP AMONG FISHERMEN IN WEST SUMATRA, INDONESIA

Lucky Zamzami, Mira Hasti Hasmira, Junardi HARAHAP +1 more

Sociology and Political Science · GeoJournal of Tourism and Geosites · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Entrepreneurship development in the fisheries sector is important in poverty alleviation efforts. Although fishermen play a role as producers of fishery products, entrepreneurship in this field is increasingly recognized as positively contributing to reducing poverty. In addition, the integration of fishermen into the community and the local economy is increasingly seen as a significant factor in the success of entrepreneurship. This study examines the application and potential of cultural entrepreneurship in fishing communities, aiming to evaluate its effectiveness in addressing social-economic challenges and improving community welfare through the utilization of local knowledge and traditional skills. The research employed a qualitative approach, conducting interview studies, focus group discussion, and limited observation to assess the impact of cultural entrepreneurship practices…

Implementasi Model Project Based Learning Menggunakan Mind Map terhadap Keterampilan 4C Geografi Siswa Kelas X Fase E SMAN 15 Padang

Yola Nuraini Amri, Syafri Anwar, Muhammad Aliman

Education · MASALIQ · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Geography, as a discipline that studies the interaction between humans and the environment, as well as physical phenomena on Earth, plays an important role in developing 4C skills (Communication, Collaboration, Critical Thinking, and Creativity). However, many students still face challenges in applying 4C skills in geography learning. These challenges include a lack of student participation, as seen from their minimal involvement in class discussions, which hinders the development of communication and collaboration skills. This issue is often caused by low self-confidence or insufficient understanding of the material. Additionally, students frequently struggle with critical thinking, particularly in identifying and analyzing complex geographical problems. The method used in this research is descriptive qualitative, with the subjects selected using purposive sampling, resulting in a…

Efektivitas Augmented Reality Geography Games (ARGG) dalam Meningkatkan Kemampuan Berpikir Spasial pada Siswa Sekolah Menengah Atas

Muhammad Ansarullah S. Tabbu, Muhammad Aliman, A. Mannan +1 more

Applied Mathematics · LaGeografia · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Developing the necessary spatial thinking skills for students at the secondary school level remains a challenge. Augmented Reality Geography Games (ARGG) media technology is expected to be an engaging learning method for students, allowing them to interact directly with geographic concepts and gain a deeper understanding of location and space. The study aims to examine the effectiveness of using Augmented Reality Geography Games in improving students' spatial thinking skills. The research design used is a quasi-experimental design. The subjects in this study were students of SMA Negeri 13 Gowa class XI IPS. Data collection was done by using spatial thinking ability tests before and after intervention. The data collected were analyzed through the n-gain test and using statistical methods, namely the independent samples t-test. The results showed that the experimental group using…

Pemanfaatan Media Sosial dalam Ekowisata Air Terjun di Sumatera Barat (Sebuah Tinjauan Teoritis)

Muhammad Aliman

Sociology and Political Science · Jurnal Spasial · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

West Sumatra is a province that is around active volcanoes and has high rainfall. This condition forms a waterfall of 29 points or even more. In today's modern era, the functions and roles of social media such as Facebook, Line, Whatsapp, Twitter, and others are very important in providing information about unexplored waterfall ecotourism destinations. This article aims to describe the utilization of social media in disseminating waterfall attractions in West Sumatra. Writing is done based on observations and literature review from various secondary sources. The results of the analysis found several obstacles from the location of ecotourism waterfalls, among others, the absence of supporting tourist attractions, locations that are still difficult to follow, the management is still simple by the surrounding community and lack of security and comfort when tourists visit. This is a…

Kajian Teoritik Struktural Fungsional: Perspektif Ilmu Pengetahuan Sosial Terhadap Anak Jalanan di Kota Padang

Rahmi Juwita, Muhammad Aliman

Education · EDUSOS Jurnal Edukasi dan Ilmu Sosial · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Tujuan penelitian ini untuk mendeskripsikan permasalahan anak jalanan dilihat dari perspektif stuktural fungsional Hebert Spencer serta dikaji dari bidang Ilmu Pengetahuan Sosial, diantaranya: Sejarah, Ekonomi, Geografi, Sosiologi dan antropologi. Pendekatan kualitatif digunakan untuk mengumpulkan data dengan metode observasi lapangan dan kajian pustaka (sumber primer dan sekunder). Teknik analisis data menggunakan reduksi data, penyajian data dan penarikan kesimpulan. Hasil penelitian ini yaitu: (1) perspektif struktural fungsional Hebert Spencer mengkaji anak jalanan sebagai bagian dari masyarakat yang menggangu sub sistem. (2) Fenomena anak jalanan dalam studi IPS berhubungan dengan konsep: Sejarah (waktu), Ekonomi (Modal dan eksploitasi), Geografi (Wilayah, perkotaan, Urbanisasi, dan Fertilitas), Sosiologi (Lembaga keluarga, Sosialisasi kontrol sosial, dan Penyimpangan), dan…

The Revitalization of Rimbo Larangan for the Minangkabau Tribe: an Innovation to Enhance Environmental Awareness among High School Students

Muhammad Aliman, Sumarmi Sumarmi, Ravinesh Rohit Prasad +3 more

Cultural Studies · Journal of Innovation in Educational and Cultural Research · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Minangkabau community of West Sumatra is familiar for its local wisdom called rimbo larangan, particularly on a concept dealing with environmental conservation. Excessive forest exploitation made the local wisdom of rimbo larangan needs to be revitalized by the community. The research aimed to determine 1) the local wisdom of the Minangkabau community in managing rimbo larangan and 2) the implementation of local wisdom rimbo larangan in geography learning. The research was conducted in the rimbo larangan in Nagari Alam Pauh Duo, South Solok Regency, and Koto Malintang Nagari, Agam Regency, West Sumatra Province. The research design was a qualitative descriptive, and data was collected through interview, observation, documentation dan literature review. The research results illustrated that rimbo larangan is in good condition though some differences in the management. The revitalization…

Utilizing A Virtual Laboratory based on Mobile Learning: Implementation for Social Science Education Students in Indonesia to Improve Learning Outcomes

Abdul Bashith, Saiful Amin, Muhammad Aliman +3 more

Information Systems · Educational Process International Journal · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Background/purpose. Empirical data consistently demonstrate that social sciences education suffers from suboptimal learning outcomes, primarily due to overcrowded curricula and students' struggle to connect abstract theoretical concepts with real-world applications. Therefore, learning that implements technology to assist students in comprehending complex material is required so that they remain focused and understand it more easily. This study aims to evaluate the impact of utilizing a virtual laboratory based on mobile learning on the learning outcomes of students majoring in social sciences education. Furthermore, this study investigated student feedback about the utilization of this virtual laboratory based on mobile learning. Materials/methods. This quasi-experimental study utilized a non-equivalent control group design with a pre-test and post-test. The participants in this study…