Education · National Centre for Vocational Education Research · · cited 44× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·
This project set out to explore how the changing environment is impacting on practitioners’ work and the implications these changes have for the quality of VET provision and the role of the new VET professionals. Three main research approaches were employed—a literature review, ten focus group discussions in five states in both capital cities and regional areas, and individual interviews.
Human Factors and Ergonomics · Journal of Vocational Education and Training · · cited 35× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Abstract This article reports an exploration of the experiences and perceptions of apprentices, workplace host employers and off-the-job teachers engaged in an apprenticeship programme regarding the nature and contributions of on and off-the-job environments to apprentices’ learning. An interpretive (expressive) approach was taken, using individual interviews and focus groups. Learning on-the-job was perceived to be more real life and focused on the ‘how’. Learning off-the-job was less pressured, broader in scope, more theoretical and concerned with ‘why’. The findings indicate that these two environments make valuable, but different contributions to apprentices’ learning and supports the need for both.
Education · Human Resource Development Quarterly · · cited 34× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Informal workplace trainers help employees learn what they need to know and do in order to get their job done. Little is known about the actions of informal workplace trainers, who may be colleagues or supervisors. This study provides an empirical basis for actions undertaken by informal workplace trainers. A total of 350 Australian enterprises were interviewed by telephone. Actions of informal workplace trainers were measured using a list of thirty-two statements based on prior qualitative research. Three factors were found to describe core role dimensions: support, structure, and performance. Also, three types of informal workplace trainer appeared: some had a passive indifferent role conception, a considerable number had a restricted role conception, and many had a broad, active role conception. Relationships of role dimensions and role conceptions with organizational context…
Early career teachers are increasingly required to be ‘classroom ready’ upon graduation and to demonstrate capabilities that match their more experienced colleagues. They are also joining a profession that is characterised by increased scrutiny and accountability driven by standards that seek to identify the hallmarks of good teaching. This agenda, constructed around a discourse of ‘quality’, has created dilemmas for early career teachers. However, little is known about how early career teachers navigate these pressures as they begin their careers. This article reports on a study that sought high-achieving graduate teachers’ perceptions of teacher quality and how they assessed their own practices within a ‘quality’ framework. The study found that high-achieving early career teachers wrestle with their perceptions of what a ‘good’ teacher might be and do, and how this contrasts with…
Human Factors and Ergonomics · Education + Training · · cited 28× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Purpose Proposes to provide a description of the factors that underlie retention and to develop a model of the process of retention. Design/methodology/approach A qualitative study was conducted in a selected number of occupational areas. Interviews were conducted with apprentices and trainees employed under a contract of training; apprentices/trainees who had recently completed their contract of training; employers/workplace supervisors and teachers/trainers. Findings Provides information about a range of factors and how they combined to shape the process of retention. Recognises that some of the identified factors are more amenable to interventions to enhance retention than others. Research limitations/implications The study did not attempt to cover all occupations in which apprentices are employed, or to provide any ranking of importance of factors in relation to the retention…
This study by Roger Harris, Michele Simons, Carmel McCarthy examines the nature of the training activity of private registered training organisations (RTOs) offered to Australian students in 2003, based on data from a national sample of 330 RTOs. The study also provides estimates of the private sector's overall contribution to the total vocational education and training (VET) effort in Australia for that year. Private providers are diverse and cover a wide variety of types. Generally they are small organisations offering a wide range of programs; both accredited and non-accredited. While there are some issues relating to data quality, it is clear they make a substantial contribution to the overall Australian VET effort. It is estimated that, in 2003, private RTOs had about 2.2 million students, which compares with 1.7 million students in the publicly funded sector in that year. However…
Human Factors and Ergonomics · Journal of Workplace Learning · · cited 23× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Purpose This paper aims to analyse, through the lens of learning network theory, ways in which external VET practitioners work within private enterprises to promote learning within these organizations. Design/methodology/approach The paper is based on analyses of six case studies in two Australian States, each comprising a vocational education institute and an enterprise. In total, 34 interviews were held with four groups of participant – TAFE managers and practitioners, enterprise personnel and worker‐learners – from different industries. Findings The paper finds that the overlaying of an external learning system on existing learning systems brings inevitable tensions that need to be carefully managed. VET practitioners working in industry operate in two worlds with very different cultures. They need to learn how to work within different power structures, how to build around existing…
Increasingly, vocational education and training practitioners work with industry and within private enterprises in arrangements that provide training for workers. Drawing on interviews with TAFE practitioners and managers, enterprise managers and on-the-job learners, Roger Harris, Michele Simons and Julian Moore highlight the expanding roles of TAFE practitioners in these training arrangements. They find that in private enterprises TAFE practitioners introduce new elements to learning, provide support to managers and workers, build links between the organisation and TAFE and raise training standards. They also foster a learning culture, support individual workers, and act as a model of lifelong learning. The impact of TAFE practitioners' work is also analysed from the perspective of the enterprises, and findings indicate that it is valued by industry counterparts. However, the success…
Education · Journal of Workplace Learning · · cited 21× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
In the 1990s, one of Australia's police services moved from a centralised, academy‐based system of training towards a more integrated model of professional development. As a consequence, probationary constables spent reduced time in the police academy (6 months) before moving into the workplace for 18 months of work‐based learning. This paper explores how those changes affected the ways in which probationary constables are viewed and accepted into the workforce. A useful model for this exploration is that of legitimate peripheral participation, as advocated by Lave and Wenger in 1991. Although Lave and Wenger acknowledge that peripherality, rather than being a negative term, allows for an understanding of inclusion into a community of practice, there is still a long journey to be travelled before full acceptance is accorded to the newcomer. By exploring the “voices” of the probationers…
Education · International Journal of Training Research · · cited 16× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Much of the literature on Vocational Education and Training (VET) professional development for teachers and trainers in Australia has been descriptive, outlining the development, construction and outcomes of a range of initiatives or analysing the nature and extend of initial and ongoing professional development for teacher sand trainers. There has been little critical analysis of curricula which led to the attainment what has been the most common Australian initial VET teacher/trainer qualification – the Certificate IV in Assessment and Workplace Training, either in terms of the intended or enacted curricula as it was delivered in many hundreds of locations across Australia. This paper addresses this gap. It presents the outcomes of research that examined ways in which learners and processes of learning were constructed, understood and embedded in the delivery of the Certificate IV in…
This study explored retention in apprenticeships and traineeships and factors that influence this process. The study is based on interviews with over 400 apprentices and trainees as well as with teachers, trainers and workplace supervisors. Identifies a range of personal, industry, labour market, workplace and training factors that contribute to the likelihood of an apprentice or trainee completing their training. It concludes with the view that retention is the collective responsibility of all parties involved - the individual, the employer and the provider of training
Human Factors and Ergonomics · International Journal of Training Research · · cited 12× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Debate about the benefits and problems with competency-based training (CBT) has not paid sufficient attention to the fact that the model satisfies a unique, contemporary demand for cross-occupational curriculum. The adoption of CBT in the UK and Australia, along with at least some of its problems, can be understood in terms of this demand. We argue that a key problem with CBT is that as a cross-occupational curriculum model it impacts too strongly on the way particular occupations are known and represented. Following this line of argument, we propose that more effective models will be those that are ‘epistemically neutral’ and thus responsive to the inherent knowledge and practice structures of occupations. We explore the ‘threshold concepts’ approach as an alternative that can claim to be sensitive to occupational structures. We indicate ways it contrasts with CBT but also note some…
This study evaluates a selection of career development services available for young people. It examines the characteristics of the services provided, with a focus on career decision-making and the provision of information about vocational education and training (VET) options. The education providers and young people surveyed were generally satisfied with the services provided. However, it was agreed that information about VET options could be improved. A better understanding of the ways in which young people seek help will enhance accessibility to services.
The views and opinions expressed in this document are those of the author/project team and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Australian Government, state and territory governments or NCVER Any interpretation of data is the responsibility of the author/project team
Training packages are a key reform of the vocational education and training (VET) system. In this report Michele Simons, Dave Meyers, Roger Harris and Kaaren Blom describe how the implementation of training packages has led to new, flexible approaches to training and assessment at six case study sites. It also shows this implementation has affected the role of registered training organisations, industry bodies, and enterprises. While most of these changes were positive, the case studies also revealed challenges experienced when these new approaches were implemented.
Education · Research in Post-Compulsory Education · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Ongoing reform in vocational education and training (VET) has placed significant pressure on leaders in private training organisations in terms of striking an ‘appropriate’ balance between educational and business imperatives. This paper draws on data from 34 interviews with leaders from 16 private registered training organisations in Australia to investigate how educational leadership is understood and enacted in their work. The study found that these leaders were able to articulate clearly the tensions between managing business imperatives and assuring quality educational outcomes. Further, they were conscious of the ways in which their leadership extended beyond their organisations into external environments in order to further educational as well as business goals. The findings suggest that, contrary to the popular notion of seeing educational and business leadership as competing…
Education · Higher Education Skills and Work-based Learning · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Purpose – As neoliberal reforms take hold in the vocational education and training (VET) sector in Australia, there is renewed interest in the quality of teaching practice. However, despite the value of practitioner inquiry to the quality of teaching in schools, scholarly practice in higher education, and established links between the quality of teaching and outcomes for learners and between practice-based inquiry and pedagogic innovation in VET, the practices has received little attention. The purpose of this paper is to explore the value of a college-wide culture of scholarly activity to learners, enterprises, VET institutions, educators and the national productivity agenda. Design/methodology/approach – Drawing on the education literature, empirical examples of scholarly activity drawn from the authors’ experiences of working with VET practitioners, this paper asks what constitutes…
This study aimed to examine the learning preferences of a group of New Apprentices (both apprentices and trainees) and the training preferences of their workplace trainers, and to explore the ways in which trainers take all these preferences into account when supporting learning in the workplace. Data on personality type and preferred and perceived learning/training environments were gathered from New Apprentices and trainers. Interviews were held with 36 New Apprentices and 30 trainers drawn from three industry areas (community services, manufacturing and retail) in South Australia, New South Wales and the Australian Capital Territory. This study is intended to be exploratory in nature. It takes as its starting point the assumption that, just as particular instructional preferences can be identified for more formalised learning environments (for example, classrooms), so might training…
Education · Journal of Education Policy · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
Internationally, education systems face significant challenges in ensuring adequate teacher supply, and thus early career teacher retention is critical. Effective induction, as a component of an overall retention strategy, is vital for early career teachers transitioning into the profession. In this critical policy study, we examined the emergence of the policy problem of the induction of precariously employed early career teachers. We examined two key Australian induction policies and their related contexts to determine how precarious early career teachers are positioned and how this positioning has changed over time, to expose the underlying power dynamics. This study used a ‘public issues’ and ‘private troubles’ lens to explore how the private troubles that these teachers face stem from larger social issues. The findings suggest that the evolution of induction policies from 2016 to…
This paper traces a history of training reforms in the Australian vocational education and training (VET) sector, identifying the key drivers for change and the manner in which successive waves of change have re-oriented the goals for the reform process. The authors critique the concepts of change underpinning these reforms and discuss the implications of this analysis for shaping VET teachers’ responses to change.
As the 'new economy' has taken hold, teachers within TAFE institutions have faced considerable challenges implementing training reforms which seek to transform educational practices in ways that are consistent with local, state and national goals for vocational education and training (VET). In many respects, TAFE and its teaching staff has been positioned as 'the problem' which training reforms were intended to 'solve' and implementation processes have spent a lot of time diagnosing problems with the TAFE system and little time seeking to understand what it means for TAFE systems to 'change' in response to the new training reforms. As such, little attention has been paid to the importance of developing an understanding of the nature of the educational change that teachers were being asked to implement, the process of change and what is required of teachers working in TAFE settings to…
Education · International Journal of Training and Development · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
The differences between on‐ and off‐job learning environments continue to be the subject of much debate, and the notion of complementarity between them is a perennial issue for most forms of training and development. This paper grapples with this issue in relation to apprentices in the building industry in Australia. It analyses the different perceptions of complementarity held by apprentices, host employers and college teachers. It strives to understand the diverse meanings of complementarity within the context of communities of practice in which apprentices acquire not only vocational knowledge and skills, but also a sense of identity through internalising sometimes complementary but often contradictory messages from their different learning environments. Their development towards the status of ‘competent tradespersons’ heavily depends on their individual abilities to integrate and…
Education · Australian Vocational Education and Training Research Association Conference · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·
One of the by-products of the growing level of activity in vocational education and training research has been the increasing demand on workplaces to act as sites for inquiry. In these instances, a common question that researchers need to confront from potential respondents is 'What's in it for me and my organisation?' The challenge for researchers is to employ data collection tools that will both assist the process of the data collection and offer the opportunity for benefits to respondents. This paper examines the methodology of using reflective journals as a data collection tool that facilitates the achievement of these twin goals. The rationale for the use of the journals, along with some of the practicalities in managing the data collection process, will be examined. Using a recent study analysing work-based learning as a case study, data evaluating the use of journals and their…
This preliminary review of literature on VET staff development underpins a national project exploring links between employment modes and staff development. Three key themes are distilled: changing VET context, increasing non-standard employment and shifting models of staff development. The paper then explores issues arising from each of these themes.
Education · Australian Journal on Ageing · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·
The role of the rural care worker is being affected by a number of significant social changes. This paper focuses on the competencies required by these workers and the most appropriate way of providing training in these changing times. A competency profile was developed and verified with 80 rural and 58 city care workers in South Australia, and a training needs analysis was completed with the rural care workers. The results of this research indicate that a number of care workers do not have formal training in aged care. Further, while most workers have experienced difficulties in gaining access to training, they firmly believe that on‐going development is important for them in their role as carers. The study also identified a number of areas where training was considered to be a priority and obtained opinions from care workers on the best ways to provide this training. A number of…