Ethics in Ecumenical Dialogues: A Survey and Analysis
Two perceptions dominate discussions of the topic of this essay. (1) On the one hand, it is widely said that the need for an discussion of and ethical questions is ever more important, both because of the need for the church to give a common moral witness and because of the appearance of new, potentially church-dividing or communion-hindering ethical disputes between and within the churches. (2) On the other hand, laments are common that dialogues, mired down in arguments over classical dogmatic differences, have generally failed to take up ethical matters. (3) The first perception is all too accurate. The churches certainly do need to give a common moral witness. The 2008 American presidential election demonstrated the divisive potential of differences between churches over ethics. Many of us, myself included, have been pulled into difficult conversations about the continuing unity or…