arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Merris Amos

15 papers · 2001–2024

2001: 12002: 02003: 02004: 02005: 02006: 02007: 02008: 02009: 12010: 02011: 02012: 52013: 32014: 02015: 12016: 12017: 12018: 02019: 02020: 02021: 02022: 02023: 12024: 1
2001peak 5 in 20122024

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–15 of 15 RSS

The Value of the European Court of Human Rights to the United Kingdom

Merris Amos

Law · European Journal of International Law · · cited 27× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

National debates concerning the appropriate role of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) in the United Kingdom (UK) recently intensified with the suggestion by the government that the UK might leave the European Convention on Human Rights system. It has been argued that a British Bill of Rights, to replace the current system of national human rights protection provided by the Human Rights Act 1998, would provide better protection than the ECtHR, making its role in the national system redundant. Claiming that the ECtHR is legitimate and has an impact that is usually illustrated by the transformative power of judgments more than 10 years’ old, have not provided a convincing answer to this claim. In this article, rather than legitimacy or impact, the value of the ECtHR to the objective of protecting human rights through law is assessed. Three different levels of value are identified…

THE DIALOGUE BETWEEN UNITED KINGDOM COURTS AND THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS

Merris Amos

Political Science and International Relations · International and Comparative Law Quarterly · · cited 19× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract In this article the scope for dialogue between UK courts and the European Court of Human Rights is considered in theory and in practice. Having demonstrated that meaningful dialogue does take place in certain circumstances, the author considers the impact of dialogue and questions whether or not there can be any further expansion in dialogue whilst avoiding negative outcomes such as confusion over the creation of human rights norms and a loss in legitimacy for national courts adjudicating upon human rights issues.

Problems with the Human Rights Act 1998 and How to Remedy Them: Is a Bill of Rights the Answer?

Merris Amos

Law · Modern Law Review · · cited 13× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Recently there has been much discussion of the prospect of replacing, or supplementing, the Human Rights Act 1998 (HRA) with a British bill of rights. The Government, opposition Conservative Party and others have published detailed plans and research reports. Whilst there has been some limited examination of the alleged failures of the HRA in providing effective legal protection for human rights, the debate has not been accompanied by a thorough examination of these types of problems with the HRA, free from political criticisms. Drawing on research concerning aspects of the HRA carried out over the past ten years, it is possible to identify concrete problems which have prevented the HRA from meeting the objectives originally set for it. But given the limitations of the present debate, future plans do not adequately address many of these problems making it uncertain how effective any new…

Transplanting Human Rights Norms: The Case of the United Kingdom's Human Rights Act

Merris Amos

Law · Human Rights Quarterly · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In this article, the United Kingdom's Human Rights Act is considered as a legal transplant of the European Convention on Human Rights to the domestic system. Existing literature concerning legal transplants is applied to determine whether the problems experienced by the HRA are partly due to its status as a transplant. It is concluded that whilst the Act has not been a failure, the literature can explain some of the issues that have arisen. In particular, the UK experience demonstrates that for longevity and legitimacy, building a national human rights instrument requires more than a simple transplant from the international legal system to the national.

The Second Division in Human Rights Adjudication: Social Rights Claims under the Human Rights Act 1998

Merris Amos

Sociology and Political Science · Human Rights Law Review · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

© The Author 2015. The Human Rights Act 1998 (UK) primarily protects civil and political rights although in recent years a number of claims have also been brought concerning the protection of social rights. Claimants have used Articles 8 and 14 of the European Convention on Human Rights to argue that the withdrawal, or non-provision, of a particular state benefit is incompatible with their Convention rights. By comparison to the adjudication in other types of HRA claim, courts have usually treated these claims less favourably. There is a reluctance to extend the HRA to this type of claim; relevant judgments of the European Court of Human Rights have not been followed; and the standard of review applied to justifications for interference is usually the reasonableness, rather than the proportionality standard. Explanations for the difference are considered and it is concluded that there…

Extending the liability of the state in damages

Merris Amos

Sociology and Political Science · Legal Studies · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

It is still the case in English law that invalid administrative action alone gives rise to no claim for damages. Individuals suffering loss as a result of invalid administrative action may remain uncompensated unless they have a private law remedy against the public body such as a claim in tort or contract. Notwithstanding this prohibition, the passage of the Human Rights Act 1998 and developments in Community damages law have greatly increased the liability of public bodies in damages. However, the extension of liability in these areas raises questions as to whether it is satisfactory or even possible for the prohibition on damages for invalid administrative action to be maintained given the anomalies that have and will be created. Statutory reform, drawing on Community law, the Human Rights Act and jurisprudence of the European Court of Human Rights, may go some way towards resolving…

Reality Amidst Rhetoric: Implementation of ECtHR Judgments in the UK

Merris Amos

Political Science and International Relations · The European Convention on Human Rights Law Review · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article concerns the implementation of judgments of the European Court of Human Rights in the United Kingdom. The rhetoric of politicians who object to the Court and raise problems with the implementation of its judgments is contrasted with the reality of implementation. It is shown that the UK is a good international citizen which takes its obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights seriously. Problems with implementation, such as those raised by the prisoner voting judgment, Hirst (No 2), are useful tools for politicians seeking to provoke anti-European sentiment. However, with this judgment now implemented, this strategy is no longer as successful as it once was.

DEMOCRATIC STATE, AUTOCRATIC METHOD: THE REFORM OF HUMAN RIGHTS LAW IN THE UNITED KINGDOM

Merris Amos

Political Science and International Relations · International and Comparative Law Quarterly · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract On 22 June 2022 the Bill of Rights Bill to replace the Human Rights Act 1998 was introduced to the United Kingdom (UK) Parliament. Just over a year later, it was withdrawn. This was not a minor update, as claimed by the Conservative government, but a wholesale revision of a fundamental feature of UK constitutional arrangements. Given that the UK has no codified constitution, it is not out of the ordinary for constitutional change to proceed via ordinary Act of Parliament. But what was unusual was the informal methods used by the government in its attempt to push through its bill of rights. Searching for a word or phrase to capture what happened over this time in the UK is difficult, not only because of the absence of a conventional method for constitutional change. Most scholarship focuses on formal rather than informal processes for amendment. The purpose of this article is…

The impact of human rights law on measures of mass surveillance in the United Kingdom

Merris Amos

Political Science and International Relations · Queen Mary Research Online (Queen Mary University of London) · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Comparative. Constitutionalism. The decade after 11 September 2001 saw the enactment of counter-terrorism laws around the world. These laws challenged assumptions about public institutions, human rights and constitutional law.

From Monologue to Dialogue

Merris Amos

Political Science and International Relations · British Academy eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In recent years, there has been considerable discussion of the dialogue which takes place between UK courts, adjudicating in claims brought under the Human Rights Act 1998, and the European Court of Human Rights. This chapter examines the characteristics of this relationship and, utilising case law examples, considers the question of whether the metaphor of dialogue is entirely accurate. Also considered are the outcomes, both actual and potential, from a dialogue between national courts and a supranational court. It is clear that dialogue can have an impact on the creation of human rights norms, judicial power, and the legitimacy of human rights law. The UK example is employed to illustrate these outcomes in practice, and also to highlight the potential pitfalls of extensive dialogue with a supranational court.

What Has Human Rights Law Done for the Media?

Merris Amos

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

When the Human Rights Act (HRA) came into force on 2 October 2000, there was cause for the media to celebrate. Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), which protects the right to freedom of expression, had at last been given legal effect in United Kingdom. Ten years later media is concerned at the restriction imposed upon them by Article 8 of ECHR, the right to respect for private life. This chapter considers the framework of domestic human rights law which now supports, as well as interferes with, media activities. It then considers the advantages and disadvantages of human rights law for the media, in particular the right to freedom of expression. The chapter discusses the media's perceptions of the HRA and the right to freedom of expression, and offers conclusion concerning possible future directions for the law of human rights as it relates to the media.…

Introduction: Freedom of Expression and the Media

Merris Amos, Jackie Harrison, Lorna Woods

Law · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This book is concerned with these issues as they affect the contemporary media, the practice of journalism and why imposed constraints and the extent of the freedoms attached to freedom of expression are managed, and why they may or may not be ultimately regarded as legitimate or not legitimate. Most of the chapters in this book assume a UK regulatory framework; which, influenced by the EU requirements, imposes a diffferentiated burden on the broadcast media by comparison with the press and, to some degree, content on the Internet. The appropriate regulatory burden for each type of medium has been the subject of as much debate as freedom of expression itself. While much of the discussion in the media focusses on the threats posed by other individuals seeking to exercise their rights - to reputation or to privacy - freedom of expression may also be balanced against other interests.…

Proposals for the Reform of Sections 3 and 4 of the Human Rights Act 1998

Merris Amos

Political Science and International Relations · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

In recent times sections 3 and 4 of the Human Rights Act 1998, which allow UK courts to provide remedies where an Act of Parliament is incompatible with Convention rights, have been subject to criticism by government ministers and others. In this paper these criticisms are evaluated and it is also asked whether or not an alternative system of protection is really possible whilst the UK remains a Contracting State to the European Convention on Human Rights.

Standing to Seek a Remedy for a Violation of Human Rights Law – A New Model for a New Bill of Rights?

Merris Amos

Law · SSRN Electronic Journal · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

The Commission on a Bill of Rights is currently considering the creation of a UK Bill of Rights which builds on obligations under the European Convention on Human Rights. A key aspect of the effectiveness of any future bill of rights is who will have standing - the ability to bring legal proceedings for a violation of human rights law. In the Human Rights Act 1998, a narrow victim test was adopted and interest groups have not been able to bring test cases in relation to perceived violations of human rights law where victims have not been forthcoming. In this paper it is argued that where human rights are at stake, a broad test of standing should be adopted and the actio popularis, or action of the people in the public interest, should be entirely possible.

Conclusion: Utilising a Human Rights Framework

Merris Amos, Jackie Harrison, Lorna Woods

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This book has considered a variety of issues concerning media practice, media regulation and freedom of expression from different perspectives, and from this four sub-themes emerge. First, the question of whether or not the media should be regulated at all. Second if we are to accept some regulation of the media, the problems inherent in determining where to draw the line. Third, the difficulties involved in regulating a new and changing media. And finally, a discussion of how it is possible to ensure that all voices, who would like to be heard, are being heard. This chapter will conclude with a discussion of how the right to freedom of expression, and other important human rights, apply to all of these themes and rather than inhibiting media freedom, can help achieve goals which might otherwise be difficult to realise. Keywords:freedom of expression; human rights; media; media freedom…