arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Merijn Chamon

44 papers · 2011–2026

2011: 12012: 02013: 22014: 32015: 52016: 62017: 22018: 22019: 22020: 42021: 22022: 82023: 12024: 12025: 12026: 3
2011peak 8 in 20222026

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 44 RSS

EU agencies between <i>Meroni</i> and <i>Romano</i> or the devil and the deep blue sea

Merijn Chamon

Political Science and International Relations · Common Market Law Review · · cited 75× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

A contentious issue regarding the institutional phenomenon of agencification of the Union administration is the question whether and to which extent executive powers may be conferred on EU agencies. This question has arisen because the Treaties neither foresee nor exclude the possibility for the Union legislature to establish other bodies through secondary law. So far this question has also remained unresolved because the Court of Justice has not yet ruled on this specific issue. In the case law of the Court there are however rulings to be found, notably the Meroni and Romano cases, in which the conferral of powers on bodies more or less similar to EU agencies was reviewed. Unsurprisingly these rulings, and especially the Meroni ruling, have therefore attracted the attention of legal scholars in their attempts to frame the process of agencification in the EU. Although the Meroni ruling…

The non-emergency economic policy competence in Article 122(1) TFEU

Merijn Chamon

Law · Common Market Law Review · · cited 19× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The Next Generation EU (NGEU) programme has sparked a major constitutional debate in EU law, with assessments ranging from approving NGEU as creative legal engineering to repudiating it as breaching EU primary law.A third approach aims to transcend the first two by qualifying NGEU as a “constitutional moment” for the EU. What most of these assessments nonetheless have in common is that they – implicitly or explicitly – qualify Article 122(1)TFEU as an emergency legal basis. This contribution challenges the idea that Article 122(1) TFEU exclusively contains an emergency legal basis and provides a textual, systemic, historic and teleological reading of that legal basis in support. While reading Article 122(1)TFEU as such would both do away with most of the constitutional objections against NGEU and allow the EU to develop its own dedicated economic policy, complementing its coordination…

Provisional Application of Treaties: The EU’s Contribution to the Development of International Law

Merijn Chamon

Political Science and International Relations · European Journal of International Law · · cited 18× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Provisional application has become a quasi-automatic corollary to the signature of mixed bilateral European Union (EU) agreements. Resort to provisional application is thereby informed by a rationale hitherto unknown in international law: it allows federal polities where the federal level does not have exclusive treaty making powers to develop an effective external action that is not hindered by that polity’s complex internal division of competences. This article argues that the EU has also developed a rather consistent practice in relation to provisional application. The EU thereby distinguishes between its treaty partners whereby some of them simply agree that the EU unilaterally determines the scope of provisional application. Because of the reference to the EU’s internal division of competence, the internal law of the parties, something that is typically not relevant under…

Upholding the 'Community method': limits to the commission's power to withdraw legislative proposals-council v commission (C-409/13)

Merijn Chamon

Political Science and International Relations · Ghent University Academic Bibliography (Ghent University) · · cited 15× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

While all institutions traditionally agreed that the Commission can withdraw its legislative proposals for “administrative” reasons (e.g. in the case of an outdated proposal), the Commission’s competence to withdraw a proposal for political reasons was never generally accepted. The present case was the first in which this controversy was put to the Court. Because the Parliament and Council had (informally) clinched a deal in a way that, according to the Commission, undermined the purpose of the original proposal, the Commission withdrew the proposal, preventing the legislator from formally adopting the act. The Court was faced with two competing views on the role of the Commission in the legislative process and chose the golden mean, upholding the “Community method”: the Commission may withdraw its proposal if the legislator intends to alter its essential elements in such a way that the…

The Temporal Paradox of Regions in the <scp>EU</scp> Seeking Independence: Contraction and Fragmentation versus Widening and Deepening?

Merijn Chamon, Guillaume Van der Loo

Political Science and International Relations · European Law Journal · · cited 13× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This article investigates the possibility of regional entities within EU M ember S tates to become EU M ember S tates in their own right following their secession from their mother state. International law does not automatically allow such regions to remain EU M ember S tates since it refers this issue back to the constituent instruments of international organisations and a reading of both the EU T reaties and the ECJ 's jurisprudence seems to preclude such a ‘continued membership’. The article then further explores the legal issues which could arise during the accession process of the newly independent state. After suggesting solutions to bridge the gap between its secession and its own EU membership, it is argued that the key challenge for such a region would be to ensure a smooth transition, without the loss of prerogatives under EU law, from being an EU region to an EU M…

Institutional balance and Community method in the implementation of EU legislation following the Lisbon Treaty

Merijn Chamon

Political Science and International Relations · Common Market Law Review · · cited 12× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

On paper, the Lisbon Treaty radically changed the way in which EU law is implemented by defining a new institutional balance in Articles 290 and 291 TFEU, bringing decision-making in this area more in line with the traditional Community method. However, the real reform brought by the Lisbon Treaty depends on how the political institutions and the Courts interpret and apply the new Treaty rules. An analysis of seven years of post-Lisbon institutional practice and case law shows that in reality the institutions have largely undone Lisbon’s reform, meaning that the post-Lisbon institutional balance in this area largely resembles the pre-Lisbon one and that decision-making in this area fails to align with the Community method ideal type.

The legal framework for delegated and implementing powers ten years after the entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty

Merijn Chamon

Law · ERA Forum · · cited 9× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This Article gives an overview of the legal framework governing the exercise of the delegated and implementing powers foreseen in Articles 290 and 291 TFEU in light of the most recent jurisprudence of the EU Courts in this field. It clarifies what essential elements are under Article 290 TFEU, how the Courts test this requirement and how it relates to the requirement under Article 290 TFEU that a delegation must also be specific. The article subsequently discusses and compares the control regimes in place under Articles 290 and 291 TFEU, noting that in post-Lisbon institutional practice they have evolved towards each other. Linked to this is the question how delegated and implementing powers differ. In light of the Court’s jurisprudence the article concludes that it is up to the legislature to make this distinction and that the legislature can also create executive powers…

The dividing line between delegated and implementing acts, part two: The Court of Justice settles the issue in <i>Commission</i> v. <i>Parliament and Council (Visa reciprocity)</i>

Merijn Chamon

Political Science and International Relations · Common Market Law Review · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

View The dividing line between delegated and implementing acts, part two: The Court of Justice settles the issue in <i>Commission</i> v. <i>Parliament and Council (Visa reciprocity)</i> by Merijn Chamon - Common Market Law Review

EU Risk Regulators and EU Procedural Law

Merijn Chamon

Political Science and International Relations · European Journal of Risk Regulation · · cited 6× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Before the Treaty of Lisbon, EU agencies were unknown in the EU's primary law defined procedural law. Today, following (i) the Treaty's entry into force, (ii) the Common Approach on Decentralised Agencies and (iii) the European Court of Justice's ruling in Short–selling it is interesting to take a look at the peculiar position of EU agencies under the EU's primary and secondary law defined procedural law.

<i>FBF</i>: On the Justiciability of Soft Law and Broadening the Discretion of EU Agencies

Merijn Chamon, Nathan de Arriba-Sellier

Political Science and International Relations · European Constitutional Law Review · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Before FBF was decided by the Court of Justice, it was described as a golden opportunity to transform a 'wind of change' into a 'perfect storm'. In this metaphor, the wind represented different national legal systems becoming increasingly receptive to the judicial review of soft law, while the perfect storm would be the Court of Justice revisiting its own restrictive approach towards the justiciability of soft law.

The dividing line between delegated and implementing acts, part two: The Court of Justice settles the issue in Commission v. Parliament and Council (Visa reciprocity)

Merijn Chamon

Political Science and International Relations · Ghent University Academic Bibliography (Ghent University) · · cited 3× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

The present case is one of the many inter-institutional conflicts which recently came before the Court of Justice, dealing with controversies resulting from the Lisbon Treaty. That Treaty introduced the terms “delegated act” and “implementing act”, two non-legislative acts, in Articles 290 and 291 TFEU without making a clear distinction between them. It was therefore only a matter of time before the Court would be called upon to draw the dividing line. Biocides provided the first occasion to do so, but that opportunity was not fully seized by the Court. In Visa reciprocity however, the second case on the demarcation line between delegated and implementing acts, the Court seems to have settled the issue.

The Institutional Balance, an Ill-Fated Principle of EU Law?

Merijn Chamon

Political Science and International Relations · European Public Law · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The institutional balance is a concept often used in EU legal doctrine as well as being regularly invoked by parties before the Court. In theory, it is a genuine self-standing principle of EU law as recognized by the Court of Justice, in practice however it is simply used as an easy shorthand for the (Treaty-defined) rules governing the relations between the institutions. An analysis of the Court's jurisprudence indeed shows that despite having qualified the institutional balance as a legal principle, the Court is unreceptive towards arguments based thereupon. In combination with recent developments, inter alia related to the political responses to the euro crisis, flouting the EU's institutional balance, it may be questioned whether the institutional balance really is an actionable principle of EU law. The Court should clarify the situation by actually enforcing the institutional…

Why Banning Russian Tourists from Schengen Might not Be Unlawful

Merijn Chamon

Political Science and International Relations · DOAJ (DOAJ: Directory of Open Access Journals) · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Recently, politicians in different EU countries have suggested barring Russian tourists from visiting the EU. Such a ban would be in retaliation for the war waged by Russia against Ukraine. From a legal perspective, these suggestions raise the interesting question whether such a blanket ban would be lawful. From a legal perspective, the question is precisely whether there is a possibility to amend the existing acquis, in order to ban Russians from obtaining short term visas for the purpose of visiting Europe as tourists. It seems hardly tenable to argue that the EU (secondary) legislature is somehow bound by the ratio legis of the current Schengen visa system.

Between Added Value and Untapped Potential: The Boards of Appeal in the Field of EU Financial Regulation

Merijn Chamon, Diane Fromage

Political Science and International Relations · HAL (Le Centre pour la Communication Scientifique Directe) · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter examines the nature of the Boards of Appeal (BoAs) of EU financial agencies and the type of review they offer. It describes the different operation of the Joint Board of Appeal (JBoA) of the European Supervisory Authorities (ESA) and of the Appeal Panel (AP) of the Single Resolution Board (SRB).. The chapter analyses their decisions, which are binding and which follow appeal procedures that need to be exhausted before a procedure may be started before the EU Courts. It provides a comparative analysis of the JBoA and the AP, and assesses their suitability in providing effective and swift remedy to individuals.

Introduction

Merijn Chamon, Annalisa Volpato, Mariolina Eliantonio

Political Science and International Relations · Research Publications (Maastricht University) · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter provides the introduction to the edited volume by spotlighting the Boards of Appeal (BoAs) in the context of the rise of agencies in the EU administration. It sets out how BoAs are internal review bodies of EU agencies that allow a certain level of administrative protection which needs to be exhausted before private parties can seize the EU Courts but which, in principle, also allows a more in-depth review of agency decisions compared to the review offered by the courts. Sketching this context, the chapter identifies the overarching research question of the edited volume as how the Boards of Appeal should be conceptualized and assessed both as a mechanism of legal protection and as to the degree to which they deliver on their theoretic potential of more intense scrutiny. The introduction thereby also clarifies the approach adopted in the edited volume, the first…

Provisional Application’s Novel Rationale: Facilitating Mixity in the EU’s Treaty Practice

Merijn Chamon

Political Science and International Relations · T.M.C. Asser Press eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter argues that the EU has created a new use for the mechanism of provisional application of treaties foreseen in Article 25 VCLT. Differently from established rationales for relying on provisional application, the EU as a federal polity uses it to allow effective external action of the federal level without pushing out the Member States from the international plane (as would be the case in a typical federal polity). In EU terms, the PIL mechanism of provisional application facilitates the internal EU decision for mixed agreements. While useful and rather elegant, reliance on this mechanism also raises a host of further legal questions, both under PIL and EU law. The present chapter focuses on the latter and looks into how the Council of the EU defines the scope of provisional application; how these decisions should in theory be informative of the delimitation of competences…

Beyond delegated and implementing acts: where do EU agencies fit in the Articles 290 and 291 TFEU scheme?

Merijn Chamon

Law · Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In its post-Lisbon jurisprudence the CJEU has clarified how the new Treaty framework for comitology, i.e. Articles 290 and 291 TFEU, should be interpreted and applied by the political institutions. One of the questions under the new framework was the extent to which the EU legislature can confer executive powers on EU agencies even though this possibility is not foreseen in the Treaties. In the Short-selling case, the CJEU sanctioned this possibility without, however, integrating the conferral or delegation to agencies in the framework established by the Treaties. The chapter argues that this remains necessary in order to properly safeguard the Commission’s prerogatives under Articles 290 and 291 TFEU. The chapter identifies the building blocks that may constitute a third demarcation line that distinguishes Commission implementing acts from agency implementing acts. Finally, recent…

Limits to delegation under Article 290 TFEU

Merijn Chamon

Political Science and International Relations · Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

As noted by Z. Xhaferri in an earlier volume of the Journal, the Treaty of Lisbon, pursuant to Articles 290 and 291 Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU), created a new legal regime governing the ‘delegation’ of rule-making powers to the European Commission that left many questions unanswered. Despite the adoption of the Comitology regulation (pursuant to Article 291(3) TFEU) and an inter-institutional agreement on delegated acts (as such not required under Article 290 TFEU), the EU institutions did not fully manage to find a modus vivendi to put the new legal regime into practice. As a result, the Court of Justice was called upon in a number of cases to settle the contested questions.

In Search of an Agency Model

Merijn Chamon

Law · Oxford University Press eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This chapter looks into the EU agencies’ establishing acts. Although there is no framework for EU agencies and although they have been established in an ad hoc manner, the agencies’ statutes show significant similarities. This raises the question of whether an EU agency model may be identified, which is answered in the negative as it is found that the EU institutions have so far been engaged in a learning exercise, resulting in increasingly detailed and fine-tuned establishing acts. The Common Approach on Decentralised Agencies of 2012 is also assessed in this regard, with the finding that it is merely a half-hearted codification of existing practice. The often implicit assumption on the usefulness of a template for EU agencies is made explicit by linking this issue to the more fundamental problem of the EU’s legitimacy. In this regard the democratic deficit thesis is rejected…

The European Union railway agency under the fourth railway package: a political and legal perspective

Merijn Chamon

Law · Ghent University Academic Bibliography (Ghent University) · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Under the fourth railway package, the ERA would become a genuine decision-making agency. The new role for the ERA, as envisaged by the Commission, wlll be placed in the broader context of the agencification of the EU administration. From a political perspective, the fourth railway package will be seized to look at the different interests at stake when an EU agency is strengthened (or established). Further, the revision is one of the first opportunities for the institutions to apply the Common Approach on Decentralised Agencies and as a result, it should prove to be an interesting test case. From a legal perspective there is the question what the limits under the Treaties are to agencification and whether the proposed new powers for the ERA respect these limits.

The Establishment of AMLA in Light of the Common Approach on EU Decentralised Agencies

Merijn Chamon

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract The establishment of the Anti-Money Laundering Authority (AMLA) raises several issues of particular relevance in light of the Common Approach on EU Decentralised Agencies. This inter-institutional agreement, adopted in 2012, was intended to rationalize the process of EU agencification. However, it was already partially outdated when adopted, and since 2012, institutional practice has further evolved, making the Common Approach even more obsolete. This chapter examines the selection of the AMLA seat, AMLA’s political accountability, and the administrative review mechanism foreseen in the AMLA Regulation, assessing these features of AMLA in light of the relevant provisions of the Common Approach. The chapter identifies where the institutions’ approach to establishing AMLA departs from the Common Approach and argues that the Common Approach should be updated in light of…

A silent revolution: EU agencies’ right to intervene in direct actions

Merijn Chamon

Political Science and International Relations · Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter shows how a recent development in the decisions on requests for leave to intervene in annulment proceedings before the General Court and the Court of Justice of the EU has resulted in a de facto amendment of Article 40 of the Statute of the Court of Justice of the EU. Whereas, on paper, the latter juxtaposes the privileged interveners (EU institutions and Member States) with all other types of parties, in a series of orders a semi-privileged group of interveners consisting of the EU bodies, offices and agencies of the Union has effectively been created. While this group has to show a direct and existing interest in the result of the case in order to intervene, that requirement is applied to them in a malleable way, in light of the particular situation of those bodies, offices and agencies in that they are public law bodies that do no act pursuant to private interests.

Empowering the Green Deal: significant delegation and constitutional limits in CBAM and CRMA

Merijn Chamon, Thomas Verellen

Law · Edward Elgar Publishing eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The European Union's Green Deal extends its influence beyond environmental policy, introducing instruments like the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) and the Critical Raw Materials Act (CRMA) to link market access and internal market measures to environmental performance. This chapter examines the delegation of powers within these instruments, focusing on the constitutional framework and its alignment with the EU's green transition goals. By analyzing the delegation choices in CBAM and CRMA, the chapter assesses whether these choices comply with the EU's constitutional framework and contribute to the Green Deal's objectives. The analysis reveals that while the constitutional framework is flexible and fit for purpose, political negotiations often shape delegation choices more than legal constraints. The chapter concludes that the success of CBAM and CRMA in achieving their goals…

Suspension of EU Association Agreements Does Not Require Unanimity

Merijn Chamon

Political Science and International Relations · VUBIR (Vrije Universiteit Brussel) · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In its meeting on 15 July 2025, the Council of the EU failed to adopt concrete measures vis-à-vis Israel, limiting itself to an “exchange of views on an inventory of possible follow-up measures”. This hesitant approach stands in contrast to clear indications that Israel is in breach of its human rights obligations under Article 2 of the EU-Israel Association Agreement (AA), and to the EU’s own obligation to work towards consolidating human rights and the principles of public international law pursuant to Article 21 TEU. While a suspension of the entire AA was never really foreseeable, an important question relates to the voting threshold within the Council that would apply to such a decision relating to the AA.

Switzerland’s Structural Participation in EU Agencies

Merijn Chamon

Political Science and International Relations · VUBIR (Vrije Universiteit Brussel) · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

While many EU decentralised agencies are in principle open to third country participation, it remains exceptional that third countries structurally participate in these EU bodies. The exceptions here, first, are the States parties to the European Economic Area (EEA) Agreement but, second, also Switzerland. Switzerland structurally participates in five EU agencies and, just like is the case for the EEA States, this participation goes as far as having a limited voting-right in some of these bodies. The legal setup through which Switzerland participates in EU agencies is more cumbersome than the mechanism through which the EEA EFTA States’ participation in EU agencies is enabled. This chapter maps in which EU agencies Switzerland participates and analyses how this is realised from a legal perspective. It also looks closer into the arrangements concluded between the EU and Switzerland on…