Prime Ministerialisation and Presidential Analogies: A Certain Difference in Interpretive Evolution
Keith Dowding's article (Dowding, 2013) offers a concerted counter argument to the various depictions of the British prime minister that are allegedly dependent upon an inappropriate usage of presidential categories of analysis and interpretation. In many respects, the piece is a tightly composed and carefully controlled exposition on the various objections to this particular type of analysis that depends upon the usage of comparative points of reference. The clarity and direction of the presented case along with the deployment of evidentiary trails in support of the adopted strategic objective has much to commend it. To that extent, and in the light of its own purposive properties, it ranks as a thoroughly consistent exercise of sustained argumentation. The essence of the piece is one of asserting a case of mistaken identity. Whether it is a matter of unconscious reflexive intuition…