arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Matteo Turri

30 papers · 2008–2025

2008: 12009: 12010: 02011: 02012: 12013: 02014: 22015: 02016: 112017: 12018: 12019: 42020: 22021: 02022: 22023: 12024: 02025: 3
2008peak 11 in 20162025

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–25 of 30 RSS

The determinants of university strategic positioning: a reappraisal of the organisation

Tatiana Fumasoli, Giovanni Barbato, Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · Higher Education · · cited 101× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This paper makes a contribution to the debate on university organisational actorhood by theorising the determinants of institutional strategic positioning. It argues that besides environmental forces and managerial rationality, the organisational dimension needs to be accounted for. Addressing the mixed empirical evidence in the relevant literature, we conceptualise the organisational dimension as a meso-level intervening variable mediating both external influences (outside-inside) and organisational action (inside-outside). We operationalise the organisational dimension along three components: organisational structure, identity and centrality, which are further elaborated in sub-components and indicators. A set of hypotheses to be tested in empirical research is provided. The paper offers new perspectives on the dynamics of change in higher education and on strategic agency of…

New Public Management Reforms in the Italian Universities: Managerial Tools, Accountability Mechanisms or Simply Compliance?

Martina Dal Molin, Matteo Turri, Tommaso Agasisti

Political Science and International Relations · International Journal of Public Administration · · cited 47× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Since 2009, a cross-sectorial reform based on the New Public Management (NPM) principles introduced a performance management system in Italian universities. On the basis of the analysis of the documents regarding the performance management system produced by 60 public Italian universities as a result of the reform implementation, the paper investigates the performance management tools in relation to both completeness and use of them. The analysis highlights that the universities have implemented performance management tools in an unstructured and nonhomogeneous way. This allows formulation of hypotheses on the main determinants of this unsatisfactory result.

The new Italian agency for the evaluation of the university system (ANVUR): a need for governance or legitimacy?

Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · Quality in Higher Education · · cited 46× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

After nearly 20 years of evaluation in Italian higher education, a new national agency for the evaluation of the university system (ANVUR) came into being in 2011. This article traces the history of evaluation in Italian universities, discussing the tasks assigned to the national evaluation bodies and their functions within the university system. In order to analyse the evolution of national evaluation systems the article discusses the contribution made by evaluation to the governance system mechanisms and the legitimacy requirements to which the universities are subject. The adoption of quantitative parameters and standards in the evaluation process is one of the elements that contributes most to interpreting the significance and consequences of the evaluation.

Internal quality assurance in universities: does NPM matter?

Tommaso Agasisti, Giovanni Barbato, Martina Dal Molin +1 more

Political Science and International Relations · Studies in Higher Education · · cited 32× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Following the ideas of New Public Management, Quality Assurance (QA) practices have become a relevant concern for public organizations. In the Higher Education sector, QA policies have inspired different reforms, becoming a debated issue for universities’ leaders and policy-makers. This article analyzes the implementation of a newly defined committee for quality assurance (QAC) within Italian universities in order to identify if, as happened in other NPM reforms, it represents a further example of ‘implementation gap’; and to detect the key variables that promote a satisfactory QAC functioning. Based on both the analysis of the composition and the role of QAC in all the Italian public universities and significant case studies, we have identified some core variables that promote the implementation of an effective QAC and ultimately supports the overall QA policy.

Governance in Higher Education: An Analysis of the Italian Experience

Gianfranco Rebora, Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · · cited 25× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The concept of governance has many meanings and there is no scholarly consensus on a definition. This is partly due to changes in governance, making it, to some extent, a “moving target.” In the context of higher education until the 1980s, governance was more or less synonymous with government, but in subsequent decades governance became associated with the idea of networks (Bevir, Rhodes and Weller, 2003), and the introduction of markets and ideas from the corporate world has led to the focus on New Public Management (NPM) as a mode of governance (Dent, 2007). The change in governance has broadened the focus beyond solely governmental policies: current analyses include policies and different ways of influencing other stakeholders and agencies in higher education, as well as incorporating – with the diffusion of the power of the state – strategy and management at the level of higher…

The difficult transition of the Italian university system: growth, underfunding and reforms

Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · Journal of Further and Higher Education · · cited 15× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The evolution of Italian universities in terms of growth, economic sustainability and reforms can be interpreted in the light of the élite, mass and universal access categories defined by Martin Trow. The findings from this analysis show that although the number of enrolled students and funding problems propel the Italian university system towards the universal access stage, activities and functioning mechanisms are lagging far behind, since they are still involved in the transition from the élite to mass stage. Interpretation of the changes since 1980 on the basis of the New Public Management (NPM) paradigm and the notion of diversity allows identification of the reasons for this discrepancy as being mostly related to backwardness in terms of ideas and values rather than a lack of management techniques.

The role of the organisational dimension in university positioning: a case-study approach

Giovanni Barbato, Tatiana Fumasoli, Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · Studies in Higher Education · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper argues that university strategic positioning is influenced by the organisational dimension, operationalised along the variables of organisational structure, identity and centrality. A comparative case study is presented including two English and two Italian universities and drawing on a set of sixty interviews with academic leaders, managers and administrators. The analysis of the trajectory of the four universities from 2004 to 2018 illustrates the articulation of the link between the three organisational variables and positioning and how this has changed over time. Finally, the paper outlines six propositions on the expected impact of the organisational structure, identity and centrality on positioning processes of universities.

What do positioning paths of universities tell about the diversity of higher education systems? An exploratory study

Giovanni Barbato, Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · Studies in Higher Education · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Diversity in Higher Education system has been a central topic for both scholars and policy-makers for decades. Several studies have investigated how to measure diversity and the nature of its determinants so far; however, contradictory empirical evidence has emerged. This paper contributes to this literature by adopting a methodological approach that starts from the analysis of positioning paths of Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) in order to explore the diversity of HE systems. A comprehensive quantitative analysis performed across two HE systems over time shows how detecting the positioning of HEIs can provide information that an analysis of diversity at the level of the entire system might hide, in particular (I) if and how compliant and distinctiveness are concurrently displayed (II) in which dimensions positioning shifts are more likely to occur and (III) which groups of HEIs…

The risk of failure of controls and levers of change: an examination of two Italian public sectors

Eliana Minelli, Gianfranco Rebora, Matteo Turri

Public Administration · Journal of Accounting & Organizational Change · · cited 14× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Purpose The aims of the paper are to: present a theoretical framework for analysing the functioning and consequences of control systems; understand and compare the structure and impact of control systems on two Italian public administrations also in relation to possible situations of crisis and failure; and examine the possible link between the organisational impact of control systems (and their failure if this is the case) and the characteristics of the sectors involved. Design/methodology/approach The proposed theoretical framework (analysis of the concept, methods, bodies, uses, coherence and impact of control) is applied through a parallel examination of two cases: control systems in Italian universities and ministries over the past 15 years. The objective is to understand why similar rules concerning control systems bring about different consequences and results. Findings Analysis…

Is the role of academics as teachers changing? An exploratory analysis in Italian universities

Giovanni Barbato, Roberto Moscati, Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · Tuning Journal for Higher Education · · cited 11× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

University teaching is under pressure to evolve in line with the social, cultural and economic changes of modern society. This process inevitably affects the professional profile of academics since it creates an increasing tension between the traditional modes of teaching and the learning styles and professional expectations of students. This article analyses, both theoretically and empirically, the process of change of university teachers in the face of today’s challenges. The empirical analysis is based on the Italian university system, which has always been characterised by an overall reluctance to reforms. This article presents a theoretical framework based on two dimensions, i.e., the teacher/university relationship and the teacher/student relationship, to investigate the evolution of the professional profile of academics as teachers on the basis of seven teaching practices…

Is merit pay changing ethos in public administration?

Renato Ruffini, Giuseppe Modarelli, Roberta Sferrazzo +1 more

Public Administration · Cogent Business & Management · · cited 10× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article aims to explore the changes in the organizational culture of public administrations following the implementation of performance-related pay—PRP systems. The work explores the switch to an explicit remuneration system through the implementation of incentives and focuses on the effects, positive or negative, this has had on the ethos of public administrations. Data from a survey carried out among private and public employees in a specific area of Southern Italy are used to analyze how the shift from an implicit to an explicit remuneration system has impacted the public servants’ ethos. Due to the application of PRP, public servants are now expected to be compensated based on their performance. The ineffective management of incentives in public administrations affects the intrinsic motivation of public employees and may lead to moral disengagement. While the previous…

The diversity of the English higher education system: a multilevel quantitative analysis

Giovanni Barbato, Aurea Grané, Silvia Salini +1 more

Political Science and International Relations · Studies in Higher Education · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Although the diversity of higher education (HE) systems is a widely debated topic in literature, this has been rarely examined considering multiple levels of analysis. This article adopts both a multilevel and longitudinal perspective to study which dimensions of horizontal diversity diversified the English HE system most. Diversity, and how this has changed over time, is investigated at the level of the HE system (macro-level) at the level of homogeneous groups of universities, i.e. mission groups (meso-level), and at the level of individual universities (micro-level). The comprehensive multivariate quantitative analysis performed across the three levels of analysis shows the polarization between research and teaching orientation emerges as the dimension on which the HE system and universities horizontally diversify most together with the internationalization of the student body. The…

Accountability in Local Public Utilities. Not Only Corporate Governance

Maria Tullia Galanti, Matteo Turri

Public Administration · International Journal of Public Administration · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This study questions the accountability relationship between one Municipality and its different Local Public Utilities (LPUs). On the basis of a case study built on documental analysis and on 21 in-depth interviews with key public officials, top managers and policymakers, a less scholastic view of accountability is proposed based on the consideration of different accountability mechanisms. The case study confirms that corporate governance, albeit central, is only one of the mechanisms available to the municipality to make the LPUs accountable. The dependence on the financial resources and the political salience of the specific public service emerge as factors impacting on the intensity of the accountability relationship.

Leading the Change in Europe: Early Implementation of the ‘Bologna Process’

Giliberto Capano, Marino Regini, Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · Palgrave Macmillan UK eBooks · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

The reforms of the Italian universities implemented during this period were characterized by two unique features that were to condition their outcome. On the one hand, a favourable policy window made it possible to reform the university curricula, following the Bologna Declaration, of which Italy had been one of the promoters. On the other hand, the implementation of that reform suffered significant shortcomings and raised the perception of ineffectiveness and inefficiency. Consequently, governments started to include a number of restrictions on the universities’ autonomy, and to establish standards which the universities were called upon to conform to, while reintroducing a logic of centralized bureaucratic control. Moreover, the universities’ behaviour contributed towards creating mistrust in the academic world, which was to be of key importance as a basis for subsequent legislative…

Policy Design and Institutional Resistance to Reform: The Case of Institutional Governance Reform in Italian Universities

Giovanni Barbato, Giliberto Capano, Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · Higher Education Policy · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This paper examines the implementation of a New Public Management reform aimed at reshaping the internal governance of Italian public universities. It applies a policy design framework to analyse how the reform (Law 240/2010) interacted with the organisational characteristics and the responses of universities during implementation. While the reform sought transform universities into corporate actors, the nature of the policy design allowed universities wide discretion in its implementation. Consequently, many institutions maintained traditional decision-making structures, leading to an imbalance in the distribution of authority and persistent internal fragmentation. The findings show that the incoherent design of the reform allowed for a variety of organisational responses beyond compliance, as selective coupling and manipulation. The study concludes that governance reforms in…

Degree-Level Determinants of University Student Performance

Massimiliano Bratti, Giovanni Barbato, Daniele Biancardi +2 more

Political Science and International Relations · Archivio Istituzionale della Ricerca (Universita Degli Studi Di Milano) · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract Although features of the higher education degree programmes in which students are enrolled are likely to have an impact on their academic careers, primarily because of data limitations, research has mainly focused on individual, household and higher education institution drivers of student performance. To fill this knowledge gap, this chapter presents a study using administrative data on the complete supply of higher education degrees in Italy during 2013–2018 to carry out an analysis of the degree-programme determinants of university student performance, as measured by the National Agency for the Evaluation of the University System and Research (ANVUR) ‘quality’ indicators. After controlling for detailed degree subject–geographic macro-area fixed effects, our analysis uncovers several significant degree-programme predictors of university student performance, including the…

Unpackaging universities’ local economic impact through a systematic literature review: between fragmentation and unclear boundaries

M Capriolo, Giovanni Barbato, Matteo Turri

Safety Research · Science and Public Policy · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abstract This paper systematizes the literature on universities’ local economic impact, using the ‘Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses’ (PRISMA) approach and bibliometric techniques to identify key aspects underlying this concept. Although the analysis identifies three essential dimensions of economic impact—Technology transfer, Human capital, and Local development—it also reveals the literature’s struggle to examine their interrelationships. Furthermore, while most scholars define local impact as regional, the literature finds also challenging to operationally define its boundaries. This paper contributes to this debate by emphasizing the importance of understanding universities’ economic impact as an interplay among various dimensions at multiple interrelated levels. It is crucial to adopt a holistic and multidisciplinary approach to formulate policies…

The Transformation of Systemic and Institutional Governance

Giliberto Capano, Marino Regini, Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · Palgrave Macmillan UK eBooks · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter reviews the dynamics of systemic and institutional governance. Firstly, the features of this dynamics before the introduction of the autonomistic policy – when the Italian case was characterized by a centralized and balkanized system – are summarized. Then it is shown how in the 20 years following the launch of the autonomistic policy structural problems has persisted both in institutional governance and in the systemic one. On the one hand, universities have continued to self-govern themselves by following the inherited template; on the other hand, Italian governments have shown a substantial inability to steer the system at a distance. These features seem to have been only marginally changed by the implementation of the 2010 reform.

Internal quality assurance units: empirical evidence from Italy

Eleonora Erittu, Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · Quality in Higher Education · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This article uses the theoretical framework developed by Elken and Stensaker to examine the characteristics of the quality assurance internal bodies in relation to composition, activities and factors perceived as critical for the success of quality assurance implementation within higher education institutions. The article is based on data collected from a survey sent out to Presidi della Qualità (PQAs), the internal bodies in charge of implementing quality assurance in Italian universities, at the end of the first national accreditation round. Results point out that PQAs’ activities are somewhat homogeneous while organisation solutions are different in relation to the institution’s size and their nature (whether they are state-funded or non-state-funded universities). The results also make it possible to ascertain that the aspect of quality work is central in determining the success of…

Poor Policy Design and Implementation

Giliberto Capano, Marino Regini, Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · Palgrave Macmillan UK eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter presents a theoretical framework to analyse the content of governmental policy design in higher education (HE) policy. By assuming that the political and the technical capacities are the two main dimensions of governmental design, four design spaces are proposed as potentially viable for policy-makers. By focusing on the mechanisms through which these two capacity dimensions work, the authors show how a variable political capacity and a constantly poor technical capacity have affected the Italian reforms of HE governance over time.

Frameworks, Effects and Significance of Research Assessment in the Italian University System

Gianfranco Rebora, Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · SensePublishers eBooks · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In the past decades, growing attention has been paid to the assessment of the quality of university research (Handerson et al., 1990; Genua & Martin 2003; Lange, 2006). Although Italy is traditionally behind other European countries in introducing assessment systems for academic activities, it is now distinguishing itself on the European scene as a country that is adopting large-scale research assessment practices. In 2004, the Committee for the Evaluation of Research (CIVR) launched the Three Year Assessment Exercise (VTR) to analyse research activities carried out in the three year period 2001–2003 which had its origins in the European peer review experience.

University Online Teaching in Italy: Diffusion and Characteristics of Students

Vito Di Santo, Stefano Trancossi, Matteo Turri

Education · European Journal of Education · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

ABSTRACT The paper deals with the complex theme of the online universities in Italy, starting from the phenomenon historical reconstruction and framing the universities on the basis of the main analysis metrics (property, training offer, organic, territorial dislocation). Subsequently, the paper examines the composition and characteristics of the students who choose this type of university, comparing them not only with those of the students of the courses in the presence of state and non ‐state universities that are not online, but also with those of the students of the courses paid at a distance in these universities.

The organization of teaching. A comparative and explorative study

Martino Andreani, Matteo Turri, Cristina Zaggia

Education · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

OECD surveys show that students in Italy take longer to complete their higher education qualifications, access studies at a later stage, and have a high drop-out rate. This paper outlines the main results of a study funded by ANVUR that involved 40 programme study coordinators from different countries (Italy, Switzerland and the UK).The programmes of study involved in the research concerned three fields: philosophy, management and chemistry. Each programme coordinator was interviewed about the organisation; the teaching, learning and assessment methods; and the quality assurance system of the respective undergraduate degrees. Compared with the other countries studied, and recognising the specificities of each discipline, the findings emphasise three critical aspects concerning the Italian way of organising, providing and evaluating the study programmes: the control of the students…

Changes in Funding and Assessment

Giliberto Capano, Marino Regini, Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · Palgrave Macmillan UK eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

There is a parallel, at times convergent, development of the funding and assessment systems in the Italian higher education system. They were initially the instruments by which ample room for autonomous action was given to Italian universities. But they have gradually lost this role, as they are now the instruments by means of which governments try to introduce elements of central control into the university system. Given the difficulty of the Ministry to steer universities at a distance, the funding mechanisms and the assessment activities have changed their functions. Rather than being the key instruments that allow universities to exercise their autonomy, they have led to a return to a centralized system whereby universities are again completely dependent on inputs from governments.

From the Post-Second World War Period to the 1980 Modernization Law

Giliberto Capano, Marino Regini, Matteo Turri

Political Science and International Relations · Palgrave Macmillan UK eBooks · · cited 0× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter presents the historical evolution of the Italian higher education (HE) system from the end of the Second World War to 1980. This reconstruction shows the failure of the reforms that, during the 1960s, attempted to cope with the ‘massification’ of universities. This failure forced the Italian university system to deal with the challenge of universal access to HE and of new societal demands, with old, inadequate organizational and institutional arrangements. Also, the problems of the academic staff’s careers became of central importance to the governance of universities. Finally, during this period, the political debate over the university system became radicalized in ideological terms: in particular, the idea that this system necessarily has to be homogeneous and capable of offering students exactly the same ‘services’ throughout the country became a sort of taboo.