arXiv.itsnick.co

an independent field guide to 23 million papers from arXiv & OpenAlex — not affiliated with arXiv.org

Author

Martin Lipscomb

17 papers · 2006–2024

2006: 12007: 22008: 02009: 12010: 32011: 22012: 12013: 02014: 02015: 02016: 02017: 02018: 22019: 12020: 02021: 12022: 22023: 02024: 1
2006peak 3 in 20102024

Frequent co-authors

Papers

showing 1–17 of 17 RSS

Abductive reasoning and qualitative research

Martin Lipscomb

Education · Nursing Philosophy · · cited 151× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Abduction, deduction and induction describe forms of reasoning. Deduction and induction are discussed in the nursing literature. However, abduction has been largely neglected by nurse scholars. In this paper it is proposed that abduction may play a part in qualitative data analysis - specifically, in the identification of themes, codes, and categories. Abduction is not, in research, restricted to or associated with any particular methodology. Nevertheless, situating abduction in qualitative research facilitates the identification of three interlinked issues. First, it is suggested that abductively derived claims require support from deductive and inductively sourced evidence if they are to 'hold' and, yet, in qualitative research this is clearly problematic. Second, difficulties in choosing between alternative plausible hypotheses (i.e. concerning theme, code, and category description)…

Mixed method nursing studies: a critical realist critique

Martin Lipscomb

Sociology and Political Science · Nursing Philosophy · · cited 69× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Mixed method study designs are becoming increasingly popular among nurse researchers. Mixed studies can have advantages over single method or methodological investigative designs. However, these advantages may be squandered where researchers fail to think through and justify their theoretic decisions. This paper argues that nurse researchers do not always pay sufficient heed to the philosophic and theoretic elements of research design and, in consequence, some mixed study reports lack argumentative coherence and validity. It is here suggested that Hempel's concept of equivalence can be stretched to usefully illustrate one of the main threats to argumentative coherence in mixed study design. The critical realist theory of Roy Bhaskar is then introduced and this, it is proposed, offers one means by which Hempel's equivalence dilemma can be overcome. Critical realists recognize the…

Critical Realism and Realist Pragmatism in Mixed Methods: The Problematics of Event Identity and Abductive Inference (Evolving Paradigms in Mixed Methods Research) - presented on Dr Lipscomb's behalf

Martin Lipscomb

Sociology and Political Science · Worcester Research and Publications (University of Worcester) · · cited 5× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Whilst mixed method research is not universally accepted as an appropriate research choice (and in certain situations it is, self evidently, an inappropriate choice), mixed inquiry is now widely embedded in and accepted by many disciplines. Indeed, it might be argued that debates regarding the legitimacy or otherwise of mixed method research have, in some if not all cases, been superseded by detailed discussion about quality or the specific mechanisms by which mixing can best be achieved. Assuming that the ‘paradigm wars’ are, if not ended, then certainly in armistice, controversy nonetheless remains regarding the relationships that exist, if they do, between methods and the research traditions with which they are associated. And mixed method researchers who attempt to elide or conjoin methods (as tools) that invoke or are coupled with divergent epistemologies and ontologies must…

Events and event identity: under‐explored topics in nursing

Martin Lipscomb

Sociology and Political Science · Nursing Philosophy · · cited 5× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Theoretic interest in the nature of events and event identity is apparent across a wide range of fields. However, this interest has not yet made itself known in nursing. In this paper, it is asserted that nurse theoreticians and researchers should consider the problematic of events and event identity. It is suggested that engagement with these issues is important because the manner in which this component of explanation is integrated into argument has concrete implications for our understanding of healthcare practice. Indeed, refusal to engage with such issues may jeopardize explanatory coherence.

Humanistic educational theory and the socialization of preregistration mental health nursing students

Martin Lipscomb, Avril Ishmael

Education · International Journal of Mental Health Nursing · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

In the present study, humanistic educational theory is juxtaposed against forms of socialization that run counter to its precepts and values. It is suggested that, in theory at least, humanistic principles (broadly defined) underpin UK preregistration mental health student training, but that in practice, humanist theory is subverted or destabilized by external social pressures. To support this claim, work by Margaret Archer on the hegemonic role of the state in educational resourcing, planning, and delivery is introduced. This paper questions the integrity and intelligibility of current student experience. It also presents a novel perspective on the theory-practice divide. Although the paper is UK specific, it nonetheless raises questions that are pertinent to nurse training in other countries, where the state plays a dominant coordinating role in service organization and delivery.

Communicative integrity and moral education

Martin Lipscomb

Education · International Journal for Educational Integrity · · cited 4× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This paper suggests that moral education might be advanced where students are granted expressive tolerance in academic work. It is acknowledged that, in some instances, expressive tolerance may result in the disclosure of morally questionable or discriminatory opinions and that this disclosure presents difficulties for educators. However, it is argued that moral education is hampered by any process that blocks open and honest communication/debate and it is suggested that communicative
 integrity between educators and students may be foreclosed when educators from practice-based disciplines that espouse strong moral claims impose non-academic normative or professional values upon debate and/or assignment assessment (marking). It is noted that significant logical and practical problems attend attempts to 'police' moral content and, to illustrate these problems, an argument that might…

Nursing's professional character: A chimera?

Martin Lipscomb

Sociology and Political Science · Nursing Philosophy · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Does nursing possess a character? The idea that professions have characters is hard to sustain, and the possibility that nursing as a collectively or occupation lacks a character is worth considering. To this end it is argued that absent robust theoretical and/or evidential scaffolding it is implausible to suppose that nursing has an objectively real (reality describing) character, and if 'nursing's character' is chimeric or illusory, aspects of our conception of professionalism require reappraisal. Specifically, traits and values that attach to nursing and are implicated in the concept of character are, shorn of their moorings, untethered. This may be significant.

Review essay: Realist theory in research practice - review essay of Making realism work: Realist social theory and empirical research. Edited Carter B and New C. 2004. With response commentary by Carter B and New C

Martin Lipscomb

Sociology and Political Science · Journal of Critical Realism · · cited 3× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

We explored the relationship between T cell activation signals and dendritic cells (DC) in the replication cycle of immunodeficiency viruses. First we analyzed the effect of two cell cycle inhibitors (mimosine and aphidicolin) on SIV reverse transcription, circularization, and integration in macaque resting T cells stimulated with anti-CD3 mAb at the time of infection. The formation of SIV LTR circles was blocked by the G1 inhibitor mimosine. The G1/S inhibitor aphidicolin neither affected circularization nor integration of SIV DNA. Therefore, the induction of SIV LTR circle production is likely to be mediated by signaling events normally regulating the G1 to S transition. We further characterized DC-dependent HIV-expression in human T cells. We examined the effect of ligating two novel receptors, IPO-3 and Bgp95, on DC-dependent HIV-1 expression. Activation of DCs through IPO-3…

Teaching the ideas of others: Is there a problem?

Martin Lipscomb

Education · Journal of Advanced Nursing · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

University nurse educators do not always possess subject expertize in the non-nursing disciplines from which the ideas they use in teaching are derived. This is potentially problematic. Subject expertize can be variously defined. Nonetheless, expertize is associated with education, and education is often assessed by processes culminating in accreditation. Nurse educators, however, do not hold first degrees in every subject they take ideas from (e.g. biology, ethics, pharmacology, philosophy, psychology, sociology, etc.), and in consequence ideas are brought to the attention of students studying for first and higher degrees by educators who lack accreditation at the level at which the ideas they use in teaching are taken. Disjunctures between accredited learning and teaching generate epistemological and other conundrums. Nevertheless, bluntly, absent subject expertize, educators risk…

Politics in the classroom

Martin Lipscomb

Political Science and International Relations · Nursing Philosophy · · cited 2× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

Nursing and midwifery is, in the UK, regulated by the Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC). Regulatory duties include establishing standards for education, and from January 2019, new educational programmes will be approved against standards detailed in the document Future nurse: Standards of proficiency for registered nurses (NMC, 2019-hereafter "the standards"). This publication lists "the knowledge and skills that registered nurses must demonstrate when caring for people" (NMC, 2019, p.3), and from September 2020, registration (licence) will require the successful completion of programmes that have been ratified against these standards. The importance of this document in a UK context cannot be understated. However, less parochially, learning outcomes contained in section 7 of the standards raise questions that require educator attention whenever politically sensitive topics (broadly…

Pain is (or may not be) what the patient says it is — professional commitments: objects of study or sacrosanct givens?

Martin Lipscomb

Sociology and Political Science · · cited 1× · DOI ↗ · more like this ·

This chapter’s focus on pain highlights a problem of general concern. Following Zurn (2021), it is presumed that curiosity (critical thinking/argument) is subject to socio-cultural and political constraints. And, to restate, mindful of these constraints, critical thinking can be blocked or discouraged by nurse educators when this disposition and activity menaces professional values and practices associated with those values.

Abductive inference the research process and mixed method studies

Martin Lipscomb

Education · UWE Research Repository (UWE Bristol) · · cited 1× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Based upon a reading of the work of Charles Sanders Peirce (1839-1914) this presentation introduces and examines the role of abductive inference in the research process. It is proposed that qualitative research employs or embodies abductive forms of inference when generating, during data analysis, the themes, codes and categories that thereafter become study findings and, if this is the case, then the underexplored but problematic nature of abductive inference in belief formation and belief justification must be acknowledged. The implications of this argument for mixed methods research are developed. It is suggested that Peirce’s developed theory of scientific method supports mixed method work but that the nature of abductive inference in such work requires further consideration. The presentation aims to provoke and stimulate discussion in what has hitherto been a neglected subject area.

Nursing Conversations - YouTube videos

Martin Lipscomb

Education · Worcester Research and Publications (University of Worcester) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Conversations about nursing and research (broadly conceived). These videos were created to bring to student attention debates and controversies not comprehensively covered in online teaching materials which, perhaps inevitably, have a strongly instrumental (assignment driven) focus.

Labour, Work, Action

Martin Lipscomb

Political Science and International Relations · Worcester Research and Publications (University of Worcester) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Although the descriptor often carries negative connotations, rationing is, depending on how it is defined, neither ‘good’ nor ‘bad’ in itself. Indeed, if we suppose that rationing describes the controlled or managed allocation of scarce resources, and/or if it designates means or methods of constructing, restricting and channelling demand then – arguably – absent unlimited resources, it is an ever present and inescapable part of everyday real-world decision making. Rationing can be justified on rational, practical, and ethical grounds. And the question is not then ‘do nurses ration care? Rather, it is, ‘do nurses ration care well?’ The IPONS 2018 conference theme speaks about rationing in relation to a dearth of decision making frameworks. No doubt frameworks can be useful, they may help structure and formalise rationing. However, technical solutions (i.e. the use of these sorts of…

Social Theory and Research - A Professional Dilemma

Martin Lipscomb

Education · Worcester Research and Publications (University of Worcester) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Social theory and sociological ideas run through or infuse most if not all humanities research projects. Theory can be overtly recognized and explored or, more frequently, it is implicitly assumed. Researchers who are also professionals (e.g., nurses, teachers, physiotherapists, paramedics etc.) often invoke or reference social theory/sociological ideas without prior training or education. That is, they use and deploy (or overlook) theories/ideas - but - they do so unaware of the full meaning or implications of doing so. This workshop explores some of the problems and issues that are thrown up by this practice.

Events and Event Identity: Underexplored Concepts in Mixed Method Studies

Martin Lipscomb

Sociology and Political Science · Worcester Research and Publications (University of Worcester) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Despite the existence of a diverse and burgeoning specialist literature (see, for example, Casati and Varzi, 2009), theorists and researchers involved or interested in mixed method research have not perhaps attended sufficiently to the problematic nature of ‘events’ and ‘event identity’. In this presentation I draw upon personal experience as a lecturer and researcher to illustrate and outline some of the major arguments and problems regarding event identity. Moreover, I propose that, because different ontological positions or traditions – specifically, Humean empiricism and Roy Bhaskar’s Critical Realism – allow or presume different notions of what an ‘event’ entails, researchers who combine methods that invoke or derive from varied epistemologies and ontologies should ideally consider whether concordant or discordant conceptions of events are being elided. I suggest that if discordant…

Retroduction and retrodiction: Abductive inference in realist practice.

Martin Lipscomb

Sociology and Political Science · UWE Research Repository (UWE Bristol) · · cited 0× · OpenAlex ↗ · more like this ·

Although retroductive and retrodictive inference play a significant role in critical realist theory – indeed, they might reasonably be considered necessary or integral to realist ambition – major challenges attend the use of these forms of abductive reasoning in research practice and, perhaps, these challenges are underplayed by some theorists. This presentation employs examples from realist research to explore the benefits and problems that attend abductive reasoning and, whilst the logic or coherence of all forms of inference may be criticised it is argued that, in the social realm, the robustness of claims grounded on hypothetic retroduction or retrodiction can appear markedly exposed or insecure.